Both on the same day, two decisions were taken by this year's Labour Party conference which were—how do we put this in a publication designed for quiet family reading?—somewhat inconsistent. First there was the pledge to ban the ownership and possession of some handguns. This was Labour’s reaction to Dunblane; the conference heard an impressive speech from the organiser of the Dunblane Snowdrop petition (who happens to be a life-long supporter of the Conservative Party). After that Tony Blair and the leadership composed their faces into suitably pious expressions and the conference stood in silent tribute to the children killed in the massacre.
Well that’s right and proper, isn’t it? It’s right that a party which is pretty certain it will be running the country in a few months’ time should be concerned about mass murder and the grief and anguish it leaves in its wake. But what’s this? On the same day the delegates wept about Dunblane they also voted in favour of Britain keeping the Trident missile. And what else is Trident, if not a weapon designed to wipe out lots of people, apart from laying waste to huge areas and leaving much of it uninhabitable for a very long time? A bit worse, in other words, than a handgun.
Votes
Except that when we look at it more closely we can see a disreputable consistency about these two decisions. Making handguns illegal—and getting a Tory to come to urge you to do it in an emotional speech—is likely to win votes. Promising to ban Trident—or any other nuclear weapon—is likely to lose them. As Labour’s shadow defence secretary David Clark put it: ’’British people won’t elect a government that they do not trust with the defence of our country." And getting elected as the government is what Labour is basically concerned with and this year, as the prospect of electoral victory looms closer and closer, the conference was in no mood to put any obstacle in the way. No mood to miss exploiting any chance to win a few votes, even over a poignant tragedy like Dunblane.
Buck stops here
This was the setting for Blair's craftily composed speech on the Tuesday, when he made his pledges for a “new age of achievement" (as if we haven’t heard that before) on education, crime, employment, handguns . . . And said, in case anyone had any doubts on the issue, that he would be responsible for getting Labour’s programme to work, for a "great, radical, reforming" experience for us all. The buck, he said, would stop with him.
Perhaps this impressed enough people to make it worthwhile. If so, they were people with seriously defective memories because if Blair meant what he said he would be unique among prime ministers. Political leaders are not famous for standing up and confessing that they have made a mess of things or that their promises were false or that they are not in control of the situation. Quite simply, when reality comes home and their election pledges are exposed they try to pass the buck. Like Attlee blaming the dominance of American capitalism just after the war. Like Wilson and the gnomes of Zurich. And always, whatever other excuses they make, they blame workers who are allegedly bringing the economy to its knees through extravagant and irresponsible wage claims, strikes, restrictive practices and so on.
Iron Chancellor
To some extent, in spite of Blair’s bluster about where the buck stops, the Labour Party arc getting in a sort of pre-emptive strike. In the person of Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown they are already warning us, before Blair has even got to the doorstep of Number Ten. that life in the new age of achievement might be hard for some. Certainly all those wishy-washy Labour veterans who cut their political teeth on the idea that a Labour government would spend their way out of unemployment, slums, deficient medical services, got short shrift from Brown. Labour’s chancellor-to-be told the conference his policies will be " . . . costed, hard headed." There will be "iron discipline . . . no magic wand solutions by cooking the books. . . no wish-list spending solutions . . .”
This must have gone down a treat in the City; it attracted the sobriquet Iron Chancellor and comparisons with Denis Healey, the last Labour chancellor to carry such a message to their conference (with the difference that he was actually in charge of the Treasury at the time). At the 1976 conference Healey told the delegates that he brought news from the battlefront the government were applying for a loan from the IMF and there must be " . . . very painful cuts in public expenditure . . . sticking to the pay policy . . .” Healey then proceeded to impose those policies right up to the infamous Winter of Discontent and the Tory victory in 1979.
Unnecessary
But Brown should be wary of the comparisons. The original Iron Chancellor—Bismarck—got the sack and Healey admitted, years after the event, that the crisis in the mid-1970s was more a matter of the ‘‘experts’’ in the Treasury getting it wrong. ". . . In a sense," he wrote in his memoirs The Time of My Life, "The whole affair was unnecessary. The Treasury had grossly overestimated the PSBR, which would have fallen with the IMF’s limit without any of the measures they prescribed.” Unnecessary? All those cuts? All that pressure on living standards? All those speeches condemning workers who tried to resist?
Labour is gearing itself up now to be the next government their conference, said Gordon Brown, was “the launch pad for the General Election." How will he describe next year’s event when, if Labour win, the pledges will have been subjected to a rather more rigorous examination than they got from the nervous delegates of 1996—the examination of reality and the actual experience behind the fine words? Watch this space.
Ivan

I don't really get the title of this month's Greasy Pole column.
ReplyDelete