Wednesday, November 18, 2026

How well is the "Welfare State"? (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

(Continued from September issue).

Painting backgrounds to civilised society’s fine facades (backgrounds that invariably turn out to make dismal and sombre sights), merely to show that all is not gold that glitters, and that under varying descriptions like “Welfare State,” “Peoples Democracy,” "Socialism” or “‘Communism,” the basic conditions of the mass of the people are everywhere of only slightly varying ugliness, is not the only purpose of the Socialist's criticism. He never fails to drive home the incongruity and the stupidity of the contrasts and to insist that the conditions which make for the sombre and dreary picture need not continue in our days of automation and electro-brains; in other words that, contrary to the general view, the ugly background can be wiped out The ugly picture painted in this series of articles does not of course, comprise all sectors of modern life. The boasted “undisputed, unalienable and unassailable right and freedom of expression and criticism” in the “free world,” for example, is another deception and illusion.

Freedom on this side of the Iron Curtain
Under the sub-tide "Two sides of the Iron Curtain” (in the September issue of the Socialist Standard) we said: "Politically the iron heel of capitalism crushes the critic and the opponent of the powers that be in the East by deportation to forced labour camps, prison or death; in the West by sacking him from his job, and so exposing him to pauperism.” A recent occurrence in a Vienna automobile works glaringly proved the truth of our contention, if such proof was at all necessary. Three employees at the factory Gräf & Stift were dismissed because they left the "Socialist Party" —controlled Trade Union, and one of the critics propagated another union. A protest lodged by the three dismissed workers under the existing “anti-terror law” placed the S.P.A. in a very embarrassing situation, but how they manoeuvred themselves out of it is too long and too dirty a story to be told here. Suffice to say that if this can happen in a private firm like G. and St, none of the hundreds of thousands of employees eating the bread of the nationalised enterprises can be under any illusion as to the consequences of foolhardily exercising too openly his or her "undisputed and unassailable ” right to freedom of expression and criticism of the powers that be. Since leaders and functionaries of the "Socialist Party of Austria” are now holding about half the key positions in the State and government (including the office of the State President, the Vice-Chancellor, the Minister of Justice and for Home Affairs, etc., with incomes of from 10 to 40 times that of the average citizen), they are more firmly than ever committed to the service of the capitalist class and exercising executive powers on its behalf.

Further deceptions and illusions, notably in the sphere of ideologies, have previously been dealt with. It was pointed out that the big "Socialist” parties, the Labour Party, and the Russian Communist Party have nothing to do with true scientific Socialism (Communism) save the disgracing and misrepresentation and distortion of the great cause, and the particularly impudent and loathsome association of the names and teachings of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels with the monstrous Russian regime and its actions. As an earlier edition of Contemporary Issues put it: "Russia has not the slightest connection with Socialism or Communism, whether in the national or international, ideological or material sense. The nationalisation of the means of production, which (for example, in England) is misrepresented as"Socialism,” does not in the least alter the character of the economy as a private profit economy (it remains irrelevant whether it is managed in the interests of the old owners or of a new bureaucracy). It does not overcome a single one of the devastating consequences of the capitalist system, but rather drives these vehemently towards that point where unrestrained Russian barbarism makes manifest the final outcome of capitalist development.”

Are You Prosperous?
As we said before, the average foreign visitor to the "fair cities of the world” may see little or nothing of their dismal background, nor may he detect any particular signs of depression on average people’s countenances. They may not exactly appear in a mood of desperation, but the overwhelming majority of the people would consider your remarking on their prosperity and happiness as a joke or as trying to pull their leg. And where they profess contentedness, or rather where they do not grouse and grumble or tell their tale of woe, it simply means that they are resigned to, because considering as unalterable, what is, in sober reality, a wretched lot.

In any case, a life of resignation is not one of happiness. Millions of people have learned and are duly learning this bitter truth.

For men and women to see no other way than bearing as unalterable, and eventually getting used to an obviously unsatisfactory and unhappy condition of existence is often a long drawn-out tragedy.

It is quite another thing for men and women to see their way out; i.e., to have free and unstinted access to the glorious possibilities of life (working in free and harmonious association with one’s fellow men and women in a world without frontiers and without money) and so seeing their way to escape from, and alter what is or had become an unsatisfactory and unhealthy condition of existence—it has the greatest possible number of elements and chances for enjoying GENUINE HUMAN HAPPINESS.

The Socialist Ideal
The realisation of this latter alternative is the aim of Socialism. To achieve it the present system of society, capitalism must first of all be removed. A Socialist is a person who concentrates his political activity on advocating the abolition of capitalism, to the exclusion of any other scheme or programmes of reforming the present system, and as the only solution for 95 per cent. of the evils of today (poverty, insecurity, universal conflicts and war). Only after the consummation of the social revolution by which the present values and ideology, corresponding to capitalism, will naturally be superseded by the new ideological concept of Socialism, can the building up of the new social order—Socialism—begin. Then, and then only, shall we all be Socialists. It will, of course, involve the disappearance of all coercive machinery, including the armed forces, police, law courts, judges, prisons, and all things appertaining thereto.

As, after the abolition of the capitalist ownership basis (whether private or state capitalism) in favour of COMMON OWNERSHIP and democratic control of the means of life, there will be no more need for money, no more buying and selling, the commerce in human labour power will also have come to an end. The God Capital, who lives and thrives on this vicious traffic of exploiting the disinherited, will have been killed—the evil spirit creating universal conflict and the ever present spectre of war will have been exorcised. The impersonal relationships between man and man, their mere business and cash relations will at last become GENUINE HUMAN relationships. Man will have come into his own. A new chapter of history will open.
Rudolf Frank

(Concluded).

The South African scene (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

The treatment of the non-whites by the whites in South Africa has caused some concern throughout the rest of the world. The application of “Apartheid ” by the Nationalist Government, in power since 1948, runs counter to what the rest of the world is doing with regard to racial relationships. What lies behind this policy?

It is fair to say that most of the development of the country has been undertaken by those who have most recently arrived—the building of the railways, farming development and irrigation, and the industrial growth of the last fifty or sixty years—have largely been earned out by those who went there for the specific purpose of doing certain jobs. They may have settled in the country afterwards, or returned whence they came.

The earlier settlers, and some of the later ones, were farmers. Land was available in abundance, and farms were huge, and incredibly isolated by European standards. Native labour was, and is cheap and the tendency has been to shrink somewhat from the bustling activity of the rest of the world and revert to something that resembles feudalism

The geographical position of South Africa is such that there are no really marked seasonal differences, and the conception of the passage of time is very easily lost The two world wars also made little impact on rural South Africa, certainly insufficient to act as mileposts in the memory. To the rural Nationalist there are only two outstanding dates—1835, the year the Great Trek commenced, and the Boer War of 1899. In both cases the British element were the villains of the piece.

Rural Stagnation
This state of affairs—activity and development in the towns, and isolated quietude in the country—might have gone on indefinitely, but for two things. The soil is generally poor, and soon becomes worked out, unless carefully conserved. Social activities on the farms are few, and children are thus produced in large numbers.

With a poor and inadequate memory of the past, life tends to become concentrated in the present, with little or no thought for the future. Thus, upon the death of a farmer the future of the farm in particular, and the agricultural community in general, would not receive much consideration. The farm would be divided equally amongst the male offspring, who would attempt to carry on in the traditional way.

It is easy to see that, after two or three generations, the original enormous farms would degenerate into small holdings—too small and too barren to support families. Thus South Africa developed its “Poor White” problem.

This problem, like most others in South Africa, was solved by those who had arrived more recently. Factories have been built by the hundred in the last twenty to thirty years and they have been able to absorb the poor whites as they have left their impoverished holdings and trekked to the towns. They have shown themselves capable of carrying out unskilled and semi-skilled tasks, and a few exceptional ones have acquired skilled status. They now form a large part of the town populations, and Afrikaans is heard, and taught, in places where English was the only language a generation ago.

Since the 1939-45 War the demand for labour has been in excess of the white supply, and non-whites have been taken on in increasing numbers. They have proved themselves, in general, no less able to learn new activities than did the poor whites at an earlier, date.

Cheap Labour
This is the basis of apartheid. The South African capitalists would probably prefer to hire workers of their own colour, and who spoke their own language, other things being equal. But they have found that the poor white will work for less money than the man who was born and educated in the town; and that the non-white, with an even more frugal background, will work for only a small fraction of what the poor white will demand. They will, if unrestricted employ the cheapest labour that can do the job.

The South African franchise is restricted mainly to the white population, with a constituency delimitation that permits of considerable “loading” either way. This has kept the Nationalists, who mainly represent the poor whites, in power for nearly ten years, although they cannot claim an actual majority of the votes cast at the last two general elections.

They have dressed the simple economic needs of their followers in suitable national and religious dress, and have been quite successful in safeguarding their interests. This is sometimes carried to farcical extremes, as reported by the Johannesburg Star on the 18th March, 1957.

“White" Jobs
“The dividing line between white men’s work and non-Europeans' work—in other words, the industrial colour bar—is for the first time being given a precise definition in South Africa. The Minister of Transport, Mr. Schoeman, revealed that the management of the railways bad been corresponding with the Artisan Staff Association about the possibility of assigning certain tasks, particularly in the signals section, to non-Europeans. The Association had replied that the following were white men’s jobs and could not be banded over to non-whites.
“Finishing wire joints started by a fitter; putting on wire pulleys under supervision; using a spanner for dismantling purposes; i.e. loosening bolts and nuts of not less than ⅝in. diameter; canning wires through pulleys under supervision; putting on and finger-tightening bolts and all types of fastening; inserting and opening split pins.”
Future Problems
Probably the most striking thing about the South Africa political set-up is the fact that the political power is not at present held by those who own the bulk of the wealth. The Nationalists, however, have not made any far-reaching attempts to interfere with the normal workings of capitalism, to date. Their plans for the future, however, as far as they can be ascertained, involve compulsory migration and re-settlement of large sections of the population, and the consequent removal and re-establishment of industry.

The entry of investment capital into the country has practically ceased, causing some concern among the less irresponsible of the Nationalist leaders. Another General Election is due there in 1958, and it will be interesting to note whether they produce a policy in line with the needs of capitalism, or whether they press on regardless with new developments of Apartheid.

Whatever the result of the election, one thing is clear from the Socialist point of view—it will be very difficult to convince the many and diverse sections of the South African working class that they have a common interest and a common enemy—capitalism. The best thing we can do to help is to intensify our efforts to spread Socialist knowledge wherever we may happen to be.

The Nationalists impose a rigorous censorship on incoming publications, but they will not be able to shut out the knowledge that the more advanced nations are becoming Socialist if, indeed, they remain in power that long.
J. O. B.

Letter: A Reader defends the Liberal Party (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

A Reader defends the Liberal Party

Finchley Road, London, N.W.2.

The Secretary, S.P.G.B.

Dear Sir,—Some months ago I wrote to you asking for an explanation of certain statements made about Marxism in the pamphlet Socialist Comment. I never received a reply, although when I sent for “Questions of the Day” it was quickly sent. I will not assume that you are only interested in spreading your ideas and not caring to answer questions on them, but that an administrative hitch was the reason for your silence. I am now writing to ask you why you have deliberately distorted the facts about the Liberal Party in the booklet “Questions of the Day.” As a Liberal I deeply resent the allegation made against the Liberal Party. First, you have deliberately tried to convey the impression that the Liberal Party is composed of capitalists of the High Tory calibre. Nothing could be further than the truth. It is not clever to give accounts of nineteenth century Whig and so-called Liberal administration and then point to the Liberals of today. It is a cheap trick and is completely misleading. The nineteenth century Liberals were in some measure more enlightened than the Tories. This does not mean to say that the present-day Liberal Party follows their doctrines. Far from it; we only accept that which is good; e.g., Repeal of the Com Laws. But why go back in history? Surely it is only the present that counts? But even if you must delve back into the past, at least be honest. Nothing is said about the great Liberal social reforms at the beginning of the twentieth century, and nothing about our Free Trade ideas.

Liberalism is identified with laissez-faire. But not, and this point must be stressed, of the 19th century variety. The Government should merely supervise industry, nationalising only public utilities, and keeping a sharp eye on restrictive practices, inflation, etc. In that way the evils of unfettered capitalism and the evils of bureaucratic Socialism can be avoided.

I am not asking you to share my beliefs [it would be futile in any case] but only to present them in a fair way.
Yours faithfully,
Brian M. Levy.


Reply.
We cannot trace our correspondent’s earlier letter. We certainly have no wish to avoid answering questions, and if he will repeat them a reply will be forthcoming.

The letter goes on make charges about the contents of the S.P.G.B. pamphlet Questions of the Day, but the charges are quite unfounded. It is true that the chapter on the Liberal Party deals to a considerable extent with the actions of that party in the nineteenth century, but it also deals with the programme of the Liberal Party at the 1950 General Election—about which our correspondent says nothing.

Our correspondent asks "Why go back in history?" This would, of course, be a legitimate point for the present-day Liberal Party to make if in fact that party repudiated the policies and actions of the Liberal Party and Liberal governments in the past. Until such repudiation is forthcoming and while the Liberal Party goes on chiming continuity with its own past, it will continue to be pertinent for us to expose what those Liberals were and what they did. And our correspondent does not give any evidence at all of any distortion on our part.

Our correspondent does name one of the "great social reforms” of the Liberal past and explicitly approves it—the repeal of the Com Laws and the support for Free Trade. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Free Trade movement was one conducted by the Liberal factory owners for the purpose of getting cheap food and consequently low wages.

As regards the present-day activities of the Liberals, one of their main concerns is to promote schemes of profit-sharing. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Liberal aim is to get the workers to work harder and thus secure "increased profits,” out of which increase the workers are to receive a share. Yet our correspondent writes indignantly at our charge that the Liberal Party is, as it always was, a party of capitalism.

His last point is equally revealing. He claims that the Liberal Party is in favour of nationalising certain industries. As nationalisation is State capitalism and does not serve the interests of the working class, this too, clearly demonstrates the capitalist character of the Liberal Party.
Editorial Committee.

Letters from readers invited (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Our Annual Conference in April decided that a section of the Socialist Standard be reserved for letters from readers as a regular feature. Readers are invited to send letters of comment and criticism and questions for answer. Letters should be kept as short as possible as space is limited, and the shorter the letters the larger the number that can be printed.
Editorial Committee.

Letter: A Reply to W. Brain (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
S.W.16.

Dear Sir,—In his article “Instructions for M.A.s,” W. Brain asserts that only by breaking the bonds of religion shall we survive, and that “ as Socialists we fight the powers temporal and spiritual.”

True religion divorced from Creedalism, which is man made, embraces all races and colours as brothers and sisters, recognises the Fatherhood of God and personal responsibility towards families and humanity.

I know many staunch Socialists who uphold all these principles, so that W. B. is quite wrong in claiming that “ as Socialists” we shun the things of Spirit.

Anti-Religionism is a Communist doctrine, not Socialist. Man is a Spirit allied to a body, of which I have absolute proof. How then can we fight the things of Spirit?

Man is a Spirit, allied to a body—of this I have indisputable proof. Art, Music, Song, the Dance, Poetry, fine literature and all things of Mother Nature are “things of the Spirit.” How, then, can we overthrow them?

It is the absence of Spirituality in the world which breeds vice, crime, disease and suffering. If we overthrow Religion in the purest sense (and again I do not mean “Creedalism ”) we must become as the beasts of the field.
Sincerely,
(Mme.) Sandra Oland, 
Concert pianist and psychic writer.

Letter: A letter of appreciation (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
Coggeshall, Essex.

Dear Sirs,—

A brief line to record the appreciation of my friends and I for that really unique journal, the S.S. Since the time of reading my first copy nothing seems quite the same—certainly the run-of-the-mill dailies, with their hysterical clamour for this and that cause, have been relegated to their correct status—alongside the horror comics and science fiction. True, masterpieces of bourgeois “culture ” these! The only flaw in this newfound awareness is noticed when one observes fellow-workers avidly soaking up the capitalist sludge in such misused toilet-paper as the Daily Sketch—then I know the real meaning of that overworked word frustration.

Well, I suppose we must accept the old adage re “the toughest stone ”—in the meantime thanks again for a really well appreciated journal from a few enlightened wage-slaves.
—Yours,
G. T. Croxford.

P.S.—Specially appreciated are the razor-sharp commentaries on the “Men of God ’—they are priceless!

Letter: A Reply to Sidney Warr (1957)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
Morecambe.

Dear Editors,,—

There is a well-known variant question regarding Socialists not joining larger organisations such as L.P., C.P. I.L.P., etc., so as not to be splitters— see end of Sidney Warr’s letter, S.S. Sept.—the editorial reply does not touch.

Many times I have pointed out that in ordinary matters people seek TRUTH. Anyone who is pointed out an error, falsity or bad fitting part in, say, a machine, immediately seeks to correct it. How many times have Labour folk, C.P-ers and I.L.P-ers, been told their case was wrong; i.e., not Socialism (Marxism): but they still keep harping on the same old reformist note. The only excuse—not logical argument—they make is that the S.P.G.B. is small. So why they do not make a little effort and get right and join us, make us bigger and better; i.e., work for Socialism, I really don’t know, unless it is fear or laziness. May we see thousands of Sidney Warrs filling up forms “A” and not being led by leaders who likewise are not interested in Socialism? The question goes very deep for a short letter.
Yours fraternally.
Maxi Shaw.

Letter: Socialism and Religion (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Socialism and Religion

The existence of religion no more proves the existence of God than does the existence of the rainbow. In the debate I stated that without God’s existence miracles could not occur, prayer would be useless, after life impossible, and the Bible neither holy nor inspired. My opponent agreed to all this and nodded approvingly. Therefore, I continued, since everything depends on God's existence, it is incumbent on you to prove it, for we Socialists deny it. One cannot prove God’s existence by pointing to religious paraphernalia, for there are religions without a personal God, and dozens of gods of a kind who have neither a religion associated with them nor followers who pray to them.

The four quotations from the Bible given by PEN will answer anybody who wants to resurrect the Jesus myth. Not only did Christ say that he came not to bring peace but a sword, but kept his word in this respect (which is more than he did about his return), but the sword has been wet with religious and Christian blood ever since. Socialism does not need this contradictory fantastic rubbish, which is the product of primitive man’s childhood.
Horace Jarvis.

Letter: "Who owns? Who controls? Who manages, etc". (1957)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

N.W.2.

Dear Comrades,—

If I may make some observations on Comrade Wilmott’s article in last month’s Socialist Standard, it occurs to me that the main problem to deal with in analysing the approach of people such as Burnham is to isolate the focal point of their approach to present-day society. What exactly is it they regard as the determining factor which makes society capitalist? My experience has been that all judgments seem to be made on the organisation at the top: Who owns? Who controls? Who manages, etc., and how? The position of the working class in all this is apparently of little consequence. It never occurs to them to base their judgments on the totality of social relationships and the basic common factors. The question “what is capitalism”? is that answered from one standpoint, but by laying bare the mechanism as a whole. The arrangement of the working parts may vary, but we are able to recognise in each case the same machine, with the same function. 
I. D. Jones.

50 Years Ago: A Travesty of Socialism (1957)

The 50 Years Ago column from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Undoubtedly one of the greatest hindrances to a clear understanding of Socialism is the misrepresentation to which it is subject, not only from opponents, but also from those who, at times, call themselves Socialists. Here, for example, is Mr. Jas. Parker, Labour M.P. For Halifax, which position he secured by making a compact with the Liberal Party, assuring an audience at Swadlincote Town Hall (on October 8th) that the Army, Navy, and Post Office are Socialistic institutions, and that the last Government decided to socialise the telephones. Did anyone ever hear such twaddle ? What is Socialism ? It is the ownership and control by all the people of all the means of production and distribution of wealth. It is thus the very antithesis of capitalism. How, then, can you have Socialistic institutions in the midst of capitalism ? The Army and the Navy exist for the purpose of protecting the British capitalist class against the capitalist class of other countries and to enable them to extend their spheres of exploitation. Yet these according to our I.L.P. oracle, are Socialistic ! And the Post Office is admittedly an institution where the lower grade of workers are abominably sweated in order to provide a huge profit, which the P.M.G. (Tory or Liberal) may apply to the reduction of taxation. And as taxes do not affect the working class in the least, as their exploitation takes place in the factory—they are robbed at the pay-box—what does it matter to them whether taxes are high or low ?

There is all the difference in the world between State Capitalism and Socialism . . . To argue that certain capitalist institutions are Socialist ones is misleading and those who so argue are either ignorant or fraudulent.

[From the unsigned article, 'A Travesty of Socialism', the Socialist Standard, November, 1907].

Party News Briefs (1957)

Party News from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

The London Propaganda Programme has gone according to plan, the meetings have been successful in every way. The last meeting of the series is in the form of a debate which is being held at Lambeth Town Hall on Monday 4th November. This debate is with the Union Movement—details of time, speakers and title are in the “ notices ” columns.


The Speakers’ Study Class continues its excellent work. The members are actually punctual on every occasion, and are keen and hardworking, so much so that file tutors are confident that our speaking strength will be augmented next year by several “graduates” from the class.


Comrade Gilmac is back in London after his trip to Canada and America. In this, issue he has written a brief report of his experiences. He was certainly afforded a very warm welcome by our comrades in the West, and in Gilmac’s brief report to the E.C. he modestly suggested that his visit had stimulated the Comrades into planning more propaganda drives. It is to be hoped that his trip will pave the way for others to be able to visit our Comrades across the Atlantic.


The Central Literature Sales Committee again appeal for the utmost support for an all out drive to sell the S.S. during the month of November. Arrangements are similar to previous drives, and branches will have received our circular by the time you read this. It is an uphill climb—this selling of our journal (like all Socialist propaganda), but we ask members not to let this deter them and to keep on climbing. Contact your branch and give them a hand; they certainly need it.


Documentary Films at Head Office are now being run every Sunday evening at Head Office. These proved most successful last year, and there is always time for questions and discussion after the showing of the film. The titles for this month are listed in this issue and they cover a wide variety of subjects.


The Autumn Delegate Meeting was not so well attended as could be wished, but the agenda was completed in good time; in fact, the meeting finished at 4 p.m. on Sunday afternoon. Despite a smaller attendance over £8 was collected towards Party funds.


Isolated Members and Sympathisers are invited to act as contact secretaries for the establishment of Socialist discussion groups in their locality. A directory will be published in these columns. All who are interested in this task should first contact the Groups Secretary at Head Office, who will keep them posted with any activities which may result.
Phyllis Howard

SPGB Meetings (1957)

Party News from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard









Blogger's Note:
"E. J. Ham" was better known as Jeffrey Hamm. He was a leading figure in the British Fascist movement after World War Two. According to his wiki page, Hamm was, for a time, associated with Eleonora Tennant, which is interesting as the SPGB debated Tennant in the early 1930s when she was a parliamentary candidate for the Conservative Party.