Saturday, November 21, 2026

Lloyd George’s Land Campaign. Another Liberal Swindle. (1913)

From the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

At long last the Right Honourable Lloyd Jaws, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, has made his “great” speech on the Land Question. Many of his followers are disturbed and there is murmuring in the camp, for the promised programme has not been brought forward, and the foolish hopes of those who can learn nothing even from the bitterest of bitter experience have not been realised.

A great and rousing campaign is, however, foreshadowed, and once again Labour is to be bamboozled. Four years ago the Budget was trailed before the workers’ eyes, and since then both the Lords’ Veto and Home Rule have been dexterously exploited to draw the attention of the workers from the real causes and the only remedy for their poverty-stricken and miserable condition.

But these two wheezes have lost, or soon will lose, their efficacy, while the need for a political red-herring, with the workers’ miseries steadily increasing and with the line of class cleavage being so frequently illuminated by police bru­tality and military massacres, and even more vividly by the wholesale slaughter in prevent­able mine disasters, was never greater than it is to-day. And apart from this there are other reasons, and even more important ones, perhaps, from the Lloyd-Georgian point of view, for embarking upon this campaign.

In the first place, when the fructification of the Home Rule measure takes from the Liberal camp the bulk of the Irish support it has for so many years ranged behind them, it will be necessary for the Liberal party to find other allies. They can hardly expect the old decoy duck—the Labour Party—to rise to the occasion, for their impotence in the great Railway and Transport strikes, and their cowardly silence and indifference in the face of working-class butchery at Llanelly, Belfast, Dublin, the Rand, and other places, have opened the workers’ eyes thoroughly to the fact that the “Labour” representative is nothing but a sneak Liberal. Therefore they must try and turn the scale in the country constituencies by appealing to the farmer and the agricultural labourer.

One more reason. The Liberal party is pre-­eminently the political party of the manufacturing capitalists. They play their part well in labour disputes, as history from Featherstone to Dublin shows. Their legislation is in the direction of cheaper and more efficient labour-power, as witness their Free Trade policy and their Unemployment Insurance, Labour Exchanges, and other reform measures.

To the industrial capitalist the landowner is a useless parasite. He sits idly by and waits for unearned increment. If the old aristocrat had an overwhelming contempt for “trade,” the plutocrats of the factory return that contempt wholeheartedly upon the aristocrat in his capacity as landowner. And if the lords of the land at one time thought it nothing less than Divine justice that all the expenses of running the State should fall upon “trade,” the manufacturing section of the master class are wide awake to the desirability and the opportunity of imposing the whole burden of taxation upon “the land” to-day.

The present campaign, therefore, besides being a counter-attraction to keep the workers in confusion, and a red-herring to catch the votes of the man on the land, is another blow at land-ownership, not in the interest of the agricultural labourer, or even of the farmer, but of the industrial capitalist. It is an incident in the struggle between rent on the one hand, and profit and interest on the other—and Lloyd George speaks, as he did at the railway “settlement” and elsewhere, for Profit, and Interest.

Gradually the Liberal party is getting their followers familiar with the manufacturing capitalists’ view of the “land monopoly” and land­lordism, the diabolical wickedness of “unearned increment,” and the parasitism of the landowner as such. Gradually they are preparing the way for the final triumph of the industrial capitalists—the placing of all taxes on land.

It is quite clear, however, that as the workers are neither land-owners nor capitalists, as far as the “Land Campaign” is a struggle between these two, they are not interested in it in the slightest degree.

The actual details of the Cabinet’s proposals, as far as anything definite has been said, seem to centre around two main points—security for the farmer and a minimum wage for the labourer. There are minor points, such as housing the workers, “fair rents,” etc. It is no part of our task to go into the question of security for the farmer, but it is quite easy to see that when the large landowner sees agriculture advancing, the land yielding more, and himself unable to reap the benefit, compensation or no compensation, the farmers will have to go. Bailiffs will take their places, and the landowner will farm the land himself through them.

It is admitted that tenant farmers have only been suffered because the landowner could, in general, rob them of all they produced beyond their living (the statement of Mr. Chiozza Money that “nearly the whole of the farmers of the United Kingdom earn less than £160 per annum.” [“Riches and Poverty,” p. 17] supports this), and to attempt to deprive landowners of this power of robbery, so far from giving the farmer security, will simply turn him into the landlord’s bailiff.

Even if the land were municipalised the rents would be maintained, for the industrial capitalists, who are the power in the land, are deter­mined that as far as possible, and as soon as possible, the land shall bear the burden of the State expenses, either through taxation under private ownership, or through rent under land nationalisation. If the Liberals cared about the “man on the land,” and especially about the small “man on the land,” they have had ample opportunity of showing it as the landlords of thousands of acres of Crown land. But instead, it is the constant boast of Liberal Ministers, that since their Allotments and Small-holdings Acts have come into force, since, that is, a portion of these lands have been parcelled out to small men, the rent derived from the Crown lands has considerably increased.

Much of the Chancellor’s verbiage has been expended upon the old, old cry of increasing the fertility of the soil—making “two blades of grass to grow where one grew before.” Of course, if food can be produced with less expenditure of human energy the price would fall, and the immediate effect of this would he to re­lieve the pressure of the “labour unrest” which is so sorely troubling the capitalists at present, and must do so until wages readjust themselves to the high, prices of necessaries, or until these prices fall.

As all that is left of the worker’s product after he has met the expenses of living, becomes rent, profit, and interest, passes, that is, into the poc­kets of the exploiting class, it is easy to see how desirable it is, to those Lloyd George speaks for, for the farmers to produce cheaper food for the workers. To get the farmers “out of the hands of the landowners” (which means, eventually, land nationalisation) and to speed them up (the real purport of the wily Welshman’s remarks on what will done with the had farmer) is just to remove the exploitation of the farmer from the landed gentry to the factory lords. Instead of slaving to swell a noble’s rent-roll, he is to toil to enable factory lords to feed their human cattle more cheaply.

But does more abundant and therefore cheaper food supplies in the markets mean more food for the workers ? If other things remain con­stant it certainly does. But other things do not remain constant. As Lloyd George himself used to point out (to the masters—he had a different tale for the workers) when he was prosecuting his campaign for National Insurance, the better nourished the workers are, the more can be got out of them—the greater that is, becomes their efficiency and the possibility of intensifying their labour.

Now greater efficiency and intensification means fewer required for production and more unemployment. More unemployment means less food as a first result and greater competition for work and falling wages as a second. Lower wages again means reduced purchasing power and less food. So it is demonstrated that in the long run the cost of food is a question that no more concerns the worker than does the cost of fodder concerns the horse. In both cases efficiency is necessary to the master, and it is he who must provision it. He will not provide for more than he requires, be food never so cheap or never so dear.

As regards the promised minimum wage Act for farm labourers. We have had samples of Liberal Minimum Wage enactments, and know exactly what value to place upon such promises. But really a Minimum Wage Act in regard to agricultural workers would be no bad stroke for the factory capitalists, and doubtless they know it. Consider the difference between Colonial and English farming—the advanced machinery in use in the former countries compared with the latter. Why are not these perfect machines in common use in this country ? Simply because the agricultural worker is so cheap.

To raise agricultural wages, therefore, would but enforce the adoption of more economical machinery. The agricultural worker would be speeded up. He would, by means of improved machinery and methods, be made to produce more in a given time, and since value, and therefore prices in the long run, are not determined by the amount of wages paid to the producer, but by the amount of labour-time needed to produce the goods, food being produced with less labour, will be cheaper—which is what our masters want.

Then, with our rulers straining every nerve to stop the “haemorrhage,” to prevent the depletion of the rural population, and even to increase it, the agricultural labourer will find himself, with his “reasonable hours” and “Minimum Wage” (if he gets them) in very much the same stew of competition as his fellows of the factory—made redundant by machinery, and thus made to suffer the hardships of increased unemployment and insecurity.

There is neither allieviation nor remedy for the poverty and misery of the workers of the farm, factory, or workshop in the proposals of this Liberal hack, and the working class are earnestly exhorted by us, their fellow workers and fellow sufferers, to refuse to be led into any enthusiasm for them. The only remedy for the evils which afflict the workers in common—you as well as us—is Socialism. The rich, who are rich because you are poor, and can only be rich so long as they keep you poor, tell you Socialism is wrong ; but we, who have nothing to gain ex­cept we gain it with you, and who must be poor while you are poor, tell you Socialism is right, and ask you to study it.
A. E. Jacomb

Editorial: An Infamous Lie. (1913)

Editorial from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Many of our readers no doubt will recollect that, after the inquiry into the loss of the “North Briton” with her crew, we unequivocably and without reserve charged the murder of those seamen upon those responsible for the raising of the load line of ships. We need not repeat the facts in the case, for they were such as haunt the memory for many a long day. That emblem of Radical treachery, deceit, and humbug, to wit, “Reynolds’s Newspaper,” on September 28 recalled the tragedy in the following paragraph:
“Mr. J. M. Robertson, M.P., Parliamentary Secretary of the Board of Trade, referring at South Shields to the load-line question, said the latest figures regarding loss of life at sea decisively refuted the gross charge that a great Government department and political party had heartlessly been a party to a dangerous change in order to meet the commercial interests of the ship-owning class. Mr. Robertson added that it was, moreover, a libel on the ship-owning class. The whole thing was due to the remark of a Magistrate with regard to one particular vessel. The Board of Trade was now having a thorough enquiry into the matter, and on the conclusion of that enquiry the question of the load-line would be reconsidered. He thought it a disgraceful thing that they should be called upon to repudiate such calumnies as these.”
Of course it is a disgraceful thing to be called upon to repudiate such charges, and what adds to the disgrace is that they should so signally fail to refute them when called upon to do so. Strange, is it not, that no account of the “latest figures” that purport to “prove black white, and red no colour at all,” has been given to the world ? Are we to take the word of this bought mouth-piece of “a great Government department and political party” that those figures do refute the terrible charge we have openly laid at their door ? Are we to be expected to be impressed with the assumed indignation of this hireling of “a great Government department and political parts ?” Are we to forget the records of this “great Government department and political party” in particular, as exposed at the enquiry into the tragedy of the “Titanic,” and the Whitehaven and other mining disasters? Are we to suppose that a “great Government department” which neglects to provide for the safety of passengers at sea, which permits mine-owners to flaunt with impunity the provisions of its own mining Acts, which supinely watches the butchery of hundreds of railway workers every year who could be saved by imposing automatic couplings upon the companies, is above suspicion of being the tool of powerful capitalist interests, and on Mr. J. M. Robertson’s bare word and simulated indignation ? Are we to believe, also, that the shipowners (whom we are supposed to have libelled) are any better than the railway-owners, who cannot refute the charge that they prefer to see their men slaughtered rather than submit to the expense of means of safety, or better than mine-owners who refuse to ventilate their mines even in accordance with the requirements of the law, and so refusing, hurl hundreds of bread winners into eternity ? No, something more is required from the instrument of such a “great Government department and political party,” and the tool of such a skull and cross-bones class, with all their gory horrors so peculiarly fresh upon them, to induce us to modify the charge we have laid at their doors.

Mr. Robertson himself proves the case against himself and his paymasters when he says “the whole thing was due to the remark of a Magistrate with regard to one particular vessel.” He does not deny the facts in that particular case, therefore, since he handles it, he admits it. He tries to escape on the question of degree, on the argument, that is, that the magnitude of the danger is exaggerated. This is showing the cloven hoof with a vengeance. It is capitalist calculation. It is the argument that the forty-odd men who went down in the “particular vessel” (the “North Briton”) were not so important as the “1,000,000 tons added to the carrying capacity of our merchant fleet.”

That is the argument of “a great Government department and political party,” as blandly expressed by the Parliamentary Secretary of the Board of Trade. It is not merely a coincidence that it is the argument also of the mine owners and the railway companies. They all admit that men are killed who could be saved by the means of safety at hand, and they all claim that it is the consideration of expense that prevents them adopting those means.

The question of how many working men’s lives those 1,000,000 tons of added carrying capacity are worth we utterly refuse to discuss. We leave that to the “great Government department” who are going to “reconsider” the question of the load-line when it knows exactly what the toll of working-class life amounts to. The principle of murder is not a nice thing to discuss, but the price of it is a particularly odious subject. Before we leave the matter to the “great Government department” whose business it is, however, and which is as well-qualified to appraise working class life according to the capitalist standpoint, we would challenge the “latest figures regarding the loss of life at sea” now stewing on the hob in the “great Government [cooking] department.” When the cooking process is completed will they explain away the statements made in “Everyman” for August 29th to the effect that “out of 62 vessels foundered or missing between January 1911 and May 1912, 30 had had their load-line altered”? And will it lessen the significance of the fact that, in reply to a question, in the House of Commons, the President of the Board of Trade agreed that “last year 3,000 seamen lost their lives in British ships, this being equal to 1 in 76 as compared with 1 in 106 and 1 in 112 for the two preceding years” ? And are these “latest figures,” when they are done to a turn, going to explain what has become of the “Amana” (left Leith Dec. 1911), the “Archton” (of London), the “Wingrove” (left Plymouth Dec. 1911), the “Cargo Largo” (sailed from Swansea April 16, 1911), the “Gulf Stream,” “Solway,” and “Bellwer.” All these were ships which had had their freeboard altered, and are either known to have foundered or have not been heard of.

These tragic names nail down the interested lie that the “whole thing was due to the remark of a Magistrate with regard to one particular vessel”—a lie chanced upon the old, old (but not entirely true) murderer’s axiom that “dead men tell no tales.” We, at all events, shall welcome Mr. Robertson’s figures, confident that the more they are cooked the more easily we shall digest them, and certain that they will confirm everything we said a year ago under the heading: “Lloyd George’s Permit to Murder.”

The chapter of accidents. (1913)

From the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

As things are, peace is an ideal greatly beloved by those who do not understand the cause of war. As usual, love proceeds from ignorance. For years the Liberal party has had emblazoned on its banner the motto “Peace, Retrenchment, and Reform,” and its inflated armaments expenditure should not be taken as indicative of inconsistency, but rather must be regarded as a portion of its peace programme in as much as it at least temporarily satisfies the armaments manufacturers. The giving of pieces procures peace (but not perfect peace).

This year the centenary of peace between England and America will be celebrated by the establishment of a fund known as the “British and American Centenary Appeal.” A list of subscribers published in the “Daily Chronicle” of October 10th makes interesting reading. The treasurer is Earl Grey, who, strange to tell, is a debenture trustee in Armstrong, Whitworth, & Co., Ltd. The donors include Messrs. N. M. Rothschild and Sons (whose efforts toward peace by financing war are well known), the Rt. Hon. Lord Glenconner (chairman of a branch of the National Service League and shareholder in the Nobel Dynamite Trust), Lord Revelstoke (shareholder in Armstrong, Whitworth, & Co., Ltd.), Rt. Hon. Lord Kinnaird (Vice-President of the British and Foreign Bible Association and shareholder in Vickers, Ltd.)

According to Mr. Asquith (Featherstone peacemaker) the objects of the committee have the support of the Government. How beautiful ! Supporting peace and drawing dividends from the manufacture of the implements and munitions of war ! It is a striking application (especially by Lord Kinnaird) of the precept of not letting your right hand know what your left hand does. Their attitude in this case could be paralleled by the Rev. F. B. Mayer opening an emporium for the sale of boxing gloves, or by the Socialist Party instituting a provident fund for the succour of impecunious capitalists.

—0—
October of this year will go down to posterity (according to the pictures in the “Daily Mir­ror”) as a chapter of accidents culminating in a royal wedding and a speech by Mr. Lloyd George at Bedford. Mr. George had been boomed for months, and the Liberal Press had forecasted the remedies he was going to propound for the evils inflicted by the terrible curse of landlordism. Enthusiasm (in Liberal editorials) was at fever heat. A terrible secret committee had been pursuing its ruthless investigations for months, and at long, long last the day of salvation had arrived.

Before an audience of 3,000 agricultural labourers (especially unearthed from the various Metropolitan Radical Clubs) Mr. Liar George’s philippic was delivered on October 11th at Bedford. He said : :”The time has come”—for what ? For nationalising land ?—no ; for abolishing landlords ?—no ; for providing houses for labourers?—no; but “the time has come to enquire into that” (the reason why landlordism is the least controlled of all monopolies).

To enquire ! O ! what a fail was there, my countrymen ! How invigorating must an en­quiry be to land-starved men ! Truly the Liberals were ever a party of going to do.

Mr. Lloyd George also answered his own party on their record of reforms when he let fall this gem. “The labourer, if anything, is worse off than he was 150 years ago.” This under Free Trade and ontop of a trade boom !

The reason for the existence of the Georges etc. was shown by Marx in his “Poverty of Philosophy,” and our Marconi muddler was answered before he made his speech. Said the Socialist pioneer:
“We can understand Mill, Cherbulliez, Hilditch, and others, demanding that rent should be handed over to the State to be used for the remission of taxation. That is only the frank expression of the hate which the industrial capitalist feels for the landed proprietor, who appears to him as a useless encumbrance, a su­perfluity in the otherwise harmonious whole of bourgeois production.”
And if that were not sufficient, then Mr. Harry Verney (landowner and Liberal M.P.) adds the finishing touch when (according to the “Daily Chronicle” of October 18th) he said, speaking to landlords, that a revision of our land system would produce a more plentiful and more efficient supply of labour. That is the crux of the whole position—greater efficiency and the smoother working of capitalism. More out of the workers’ bodies and more into the masters’ pockets. And that is where the accident lies for the working class.

—0—

As regards lives, a more serious accident took place at Senghenydd, which has now become famous throughout the world owing to the fact that about 430 miners were murdered there in the interests of the mine-owners. According to the “Daily News and Leader” of October 15th, in one portion of the pit men were unable to work owing to its gassy nature. The “Daily Chronicle” of the same date says editorially :
“There can be no doubt that many explosions are preventable, in the sense that they would not have occurred if the colliery equipment had been on a level with that of the best collieries. … It is, we fear, only too true that the equipment of many collieries for averting explosions lags far behind what the best scientific experience dictates.”
That is, men are murdered for profits. The miners are regarded as dirt, and as such are cheaper than coal-dust. It is a capitalist truism that “men must work and women must weep,” and so the men are free to choose between a lightning exit by explosion and a “South Eastern” departure by starvation.

—0—
It takes a lot to please a parson, but it is not often that a holy Joe has the graceless temerity to express open dissatisfaction with the way God does his work. The following extract from the “Western Mail” (South Wales) of October 20th is therefore the more interesting as showing that some among the clergy think that God has such good reason to be ashamed of some of his handiwork that it should offend his eyes.

“The harrowing, heartrending tale of death at Senghenydd, said the Rev. Gwilym Francis at St. John’s Parish Church, Cardiff, was lightened by stories of noble deeds, which one was proud to think inevitably accompanied such tragic scenes. He had officiated on Saturday at the last sacred rites over the grave of one of the victims, amid the heartrending grief of the widowed wife and children. Next to this man had been working his unmarried brother, with no ties and no responsibilities, and he had been spared. Why ? Again, from the English Church at Senghenydd had been swept away a church­ warden, an organist, a superintendent of the Sunday School, and several sidesmen—all good men, earnest workers. Why did God permit such things ? Religious Pharisees, humbugs, might say that a tragedy was a Devine visitation for sin, but they knew that it was not so, that it was part of a higher, deeper mystery held from their eyes and soluble only to a Divine Providence. . . . He (the preacher) liked to think of a God who could permit such wastage of life doing so with averted eyes.”

Yes, but the religious Pharisee and humbug whose words I have just quoted, if he were not more afraid of his earthly masters than he is of his “divine” one, would tell what he knows to be the truth, and instead of saddling God with the blame for this odious crime, would declare that the mine-owners alone, in their ghoulish thirst for profits, were the murderers of these 430 or more miners. But when do you get the truth from a parson ?

The Senghenydd holocaust is another incident of criminal capitalism which will not be forgotten when the Revolution arrives.

—0—
Another accident (still they come). A capitalist newspaper has stumbled on the truth. One wonders if the “age of miracles” is really past. From the “County and City of London Observer” for September 27th the following is culled. It is written in reference to the fifty million pounds indemnity fund proposed to safeguard innocuous employers against brutal agitators who are always inflaming the working class:
“The working classes (sic) undoubtedly hold the balance of political power, and they would resort to political action, which no conceivable union of employers could control. Our Constitution is so framed that Parliament is supreme, and the working classes could elect a Socialist Parliament to make short work of both property owners and employers.”
Comment is superfluous.

—0—
But there is one more “accident” to which reference should be made, and that is the “accident” to the employing class implied in the Revolution. How long will it take the working class to consummate it ? It rests with them. Let them speed the day.
A. L. Cox

Who said War? (1913)

From the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

I suppose the readers of the SOCIALIST STANDARD, without exception, understand the object of its publication. A perusal of its pages leaves no doubt. The position of the “Daily Chronicle” toward the workers, however, is not so clear. The “Daily Chronicle” represents, faithfully and consistently, that section of the capitalist class known as the Liberal party. It supports the present Government’s every action, even to the shooting of strikers and bludgeoning of women and children. Its function in the political game of make believe is to kid the workers into thinking that their interests are identical with those of the capitalists.

The point I wish to explain, however, is this. The ” D.C.” has been telling the workers what the Socialist Party have been hammering home for years, but the article to which I am going to refer was certainly never seriously intended for working-class digestion. But a paper that aspires to run with the hare and hunt with the hounds finds itself in no enviable position when hare and hounds meet—as in the case of a strike or a lock-out.

The “D.C.” tells us that a new organisation has been, formed, called, “The United Kingdom Employers’ Defence Union,” the object of which is to raise a fund of £50,000,000 for the purpose of resisting strikes, and, if possible, of forcing the repeal of the Trade Union Dispute Act. Commenting on this the “Daily Chronicle” said (Sept. 26):
“The specious phraseology in which the inspired announcement of the Union’s formation is couched, does not conceal its real object, which is to fight trade unionism. From that point of view we regard the formation of the Union as an ill omened move. It looks very like a deliberate challenge to the trade unions.”
Now, if Capital and Labour are on such terms of affection as we are led to believe, will the “D.C.” tell us whatever made the idea enter the heads of our masters that it was necessary to form a union to fight its “closest friend and ally, Labour ?” And also why working men should find it necessary to band themselves into a union for the purpose of fighting the masters. Talk of affection and unity of interests ! Why are workers willing to take the risk of being starved, batoned, butchered, by the minions of a merciless master class, if it is not because of warring interests ?

Hear what the “Daily Chronicle” says regarding the new organisation :
“For what does its formation mean ? It means in the eyes of those who support it, that the normal terms between Capital and Labour in this country are relations of bitter hostility, war, not peace. Most happily, this is not true.”
Evidently Thorold Rogers was wrong when he wrote: “Of all the wars that have been waged, none has been so bitter and long as that between Capital and Labour.” The trouble is, with the “D.C.,” that the adoption of a definitely antagonistic policy by the masters would cause the workers to become class-conscious. Arbitration, or in other words, bluff and bunkum, is the favourite method of the “Chronicle,” and the Liberal party generally.

Commenting upon the workers’ unions the “D.C.” said:
“Trade Unionism has helped to make for appeasement and reconciliation. It has enabled Labour to meet Capital on something like equal terms.”
Something like equal terms ! Again :
“Capital has an equal right with Labour to protect its own interests. An equal right, yes, but not an equal need. Trade unionism is simply the banding together of workmen in an association that serves as a counterpoise to the loose but effective combination of Capital. In recent years combinations of employers have become more precise and rigid, and the power of capital has enormously increased. What rubbish it is to talk of an ‘Employers Defence Union’ ! Defence against what ? In nearly every great industry in the land the employers are already united in compact organisations, and act together in arranging wages and conditions of work with trade union officials. These employers welcome the co-operation of trade union leaders. They do not want a ‘Defence Union’ : they are well able to defend themselves.”
“Something like equal terms” ! Very rich, this. With regard to the collective bargaining with the trade union leaders, this gives to the masters a degree of security, and enables them to keep the function of the political machine in the background. Quoting Adam Smith, the “Chronicle” proves conclusively the helplessness of the workers to strike effectually against the masters.
“A landlord, a farmer, a manufacturer or merchant, though they don’t employ a single workman, could generally live a year or two on stocks which they have already acquired. Many workmen could not subsist a week : few could subsist a month, and scarce any a year without employment.”
I do not know, of course, but that certainly reads like a taunt at Syndicalist and Anarchist action. Starvation certainly seems a serious stumbling block in the path of the Syndicalist movement. The only hope of victory lies in the capture of the political machine, and through that the control of the forces by which the system is maintained. Join with us, then, in the Socialist Party—whose object it is to educate the workers to class-consciousness, and to organise them for the overthrow of the system of wage slavery, and the establishment of the Socialist, Commonwealth.
J. R.

Marx and his traducers. (1913)

Book Review from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Nothing hurts the master class more than the truth. This is not to be wondered at when we consider that for the upkeep of the present system of society, lying, cant, and hypocrisy are almost as important as force itself. How the master class will spend their money on political, religious, and philanthropic movements, which exist for the purpose of misleading the workers ! Capitalist society would not last long if the people understood their social position in the true light.

None knew this better than Karl Marx, the pioneer of modern Socialism. By his analysis of the methods of capitalist production, and his exposition of the law of social development, he gave capitalist philosophy and criticism their death-blow.

At first capitalist representatives, together with the pseudo-Socialists, treated Marx, if not with silent contempt, at all events with dumb respect. But when it was seen that his teachings were being spread broadcast amongst the class who had everything to gain from their dissemination, these misrepresenters of the truth had to abandon their policy of silence, and bestir themselves to promulgate a false, perverted Marxism.

One of the sycophants engaged in this business of misrepresentation is John Spargo, who has written a work entitled : “Karl Marx, his Life and Work.” He opens out by discrediting a work on Marx by the man who, next to Engels, was most intimate with the great Socialist philosopher—a work, moreover, which Spargo quotes more often than any other in his own book. The work referred to is Liebknecht’s “Biographical Memoirs of Marx.”

Spargo’s objections to this book are two-fold. Firstly, he contends that Liebknecht errs when he says that Marx’s father left the Hebrew faith for the Christian for the sake of official position. Secondly he asserts that Liebknecht is wrong when he claims that Karl Marx’s life was a revenge against his father’s act in renouncing Judaism.

As regards the first point, although it is attested by those most qualified to judge, including Karl Marx’s daughter (as Spargo admits) yet our bold author, to reconcile his views with those of the Christian “Socialists,” says that Marx’s father, who was previously of the Hebrew persuasion, became a disciple of Rousseau and Liebnitz, changed his religion, because he sincerely believed in the Christian faith.

How well it speaks for Christianity that a man of the intellect and calibre of Marx’s father should see the noble purity of the Christian religion ! Yet how remarkable it is that he changed his religion at the very opportune time when a law was passed that none but Christians could hold official positions !

Mr. Spargo’s next point is really too absurd. Leibknecht certainly meant that Marx’s teaching is the deadly enemy of religion—and none but perverters can say otherwise.

The main idea of Spargo in writing the book—and of the capitalists in booming it—is to make an idol of Karl Marx by proving that he stood for the policy of opportunism. Because Marx endeavoured to get the workers of all lands together through an international organisation, so that they might discuss matters and formulate schemes, and because, with such an object in view, and the circumstances and conditions of the time, when his views were known to very few indeed, he acted in a manner such as those circumstances demanded, Spargo affects to believe that a similar course of action is needed at the present day, and would be advocated by Marx were he now living.

How singular it is, though, that at a later date than the “International,” this same Marx fought so sternly against the amalgamation of the Eisenachers with the Lassallians—in which his unerring judgment has been confirmed by the lapse of years ! The so-called German Social-Democratic Party is re-actionary, and all its votes don’t make it otherwise.

Marx’s work with the International Workingmen’s Association was glorious. It gave emphasis to the idea that the workers, to bring their battle to a successful issue, must be orga­nised internationally. And to-day, with the development of the capitalist system, society has reached the stage where it is rotten to the core. Reforms cannot help. Opportunist methods are false and useless. Years of opportunism have not bettered the condition of the workers, have not brought the toilers any nearer to their emancipation. Nothing but opposition to the capitalist class everywhere and at all times can ensure success.

Perhaps the most amusing part of the book is that portion in which it is claimed that Marx was the most misrepresented and misunderstood of men. When it is considered how utterly unscrupulously he is misrepresented in the book under notice the delicious irony of this is fully appreciated. John Spargo’s own words will best serve to illustrate this.

On page 14 we read : “No man has been more grievously misunderstood and misrepre­sented than Karl Marx,” while on page 331 we have : “Marx was, in fact, a good deal of an opportunist, and of the two wings of the present day Socialist movement, popularly denoted as ‘Opportunist’ and ‘Impossibilist’ respectively, the former is much more truly Marxian than the latter, at least in its fundamental principles. In its application of these principles the opportu­nist wing of the present-day Socialist movement may at times cease to be Marxist, or even Social­ist of any description, being scarcely or not at all distinguishable from bourgeois reformers. Theoretically they are Marxists as regards political tactics, but Marx, opportunist as he was, never ceased to be first and foremost a Socialist and a revolutionist.”

But whilst Marx “never ceased to be first and foremost a Socialist and a revolutionist,” the opportunist wing of the “present-day Socialist movement,” Mr. Spargo tells us, “may cease to be Marxist, or even Socialist of any description, being scarcely or not at all distinguishable from bourgeois reformers.” Truly, the man who at­tempts to reconcile these two attitudes has good ground to complain of other people misrepre­senting Marx.

Again our author says on page 121 : “Many shallow-minded Socialists claim that the more the workers are oppressed the more likely are they to revolt, and the sooner they are reduced to abject misery the sooner will they rise and overthrow the existing social order.”

Now if anyone depends for success upon the poverty of the people more than others it is the opportunists and sentimentalists. Instead of educating the workers in Socialism they are always appealing on behalf of the starving children, the crippled, the unemployed, etc. “Send us to Parliament and we shall see them right !” they plead, thinking of themselves and the flesh-pots all the time.

Only the Socialist Party of Great Britain realise the situation. Despite reforms the con­dition of the mass of the people tends to become worse, and it is up to us to teach them now, not when it is too late, their status in society, so that the workers may consciously organise to overthrow capitalist society and introduce in its stead the Socialist regime.

Spargo has a knack of quoting private letters written by Marx to his friends as if they were meant to have public importance, and as if they stood for all time as well-thought out theories. It seems necessary to remind our author that it is essential to know exactly the other side of the correspondence, as well as the whole nature of the argument, before it is possible for one to give a correct judgment en the matter. For instance, letters from Kugelman are quoted without us knowing what the latter had said. This is a pretty method of putting into Marx’s mouth words to support the opportunist policy.

Speaking about Hyndman Spargo says in effect that we “should not drag Hyndman’s actions of the past into consideration ; if Marx could only see the splendid work that Hyndman has done on behalf of the Socialist movement he would be sorry for what he had said about him.” The present writer thinks different. The fact re­mains that Hyndman is no Socialist. He thinks too much of the safety of capitalist England and capitalist heroes to be of any value to the work­ing-class movement.

In placing Marx in the Ricardian school Spargo’s sole object is to twist him into a sup­porter of the false, futile, and distinctly reaction­ary and anti-Marxian policy of opportunism.
L. M.

Jottings. (1913)

The Jottings Column from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Another “useful” member of the class which “provides the capital with which to employ labour” (to use a favourite expression of the anties) has just passed away in the person of Mr. Peter Coats, of the well known cotton-thread combine. According to “Reynolds’s,” “Mr. Coats was a model millionaire. He indulged in no lavish display. He was a courteous and kind-hearted gentleman. He did not gain his wealth by grinding down his workers. And he has left a third of his estate to charitable purposes.”

How was his wealth gained, then? “Rey­nolds’s” does not say. Are we to assume that the Paisley workers were equally kind-hearted, and that they allowed this “model millionaire” to retain their share for them, secure in the belief that they would get it back some day in the shape of charity? To the writer, from his knowledge of wealth production under capitalism, it would appear that he had been kindest of all to himself.

* * *
Wherever increases of pay have been granted, from whatever circumstances, it is safe to affirm that the first thought of the masters has been : “How to get it back.” Whilst all are agreed on the process known as “squeezing,” they differ, of course, in method. How it is done may be seen by citing the case of the Standard Mill Go. at Oldham, who were prosecuted quite recently. Their speciality was “time-cribbing,” and operated as follows :

Instead of stopping the machinery at the proper time each day at the dinner hour, it was allowed to run for four minutes longer. Carried on to this extent, it meant that the wage earners worked two weeks in the year for nothing ! It was pointed out that in a case like this, if they could get two weeks a year in “time-cribbing,” it would mean a special profit of £600 a year !

And this is only one way of getting it back !

* * *
“Reynolds’s” (21.9.13) announces that “Mr. Lloyd George has just refused an offer of £20,000 to visit Australia and deliver ten speeches on the progress of social reform in England.”

The “Daily Citizen” thinks that “the Chancellor is far too busy a man to undertake a trip of this distance.”

Yes ! Mr. Lloyd George must be busy indeed if twenty thousand jimmy o’goblins won’t tempt him. Are there greater incentives to remain on this side ? or is it that the Labour Party can’t spare him now that Ramsay has gone to India again ? I have known far smaller sums than that tempt many people—labour “leaders,” too ! Who does not remember our beautiful “Socialist” countess taking a trip to America last year in order to deliver a series of lectures, for each of which, according to the Press, she was to receive no less a sum than £300 ?

Other instances could be quoted.

Though there may have been no truth in the rumour that went round the Press recently to the effect that “a well-known Socialist had netted £12,000" (!) by selling stock on inside information, yet it is plainly apparent that it pays some people to be in the “movement.”

* * *
An informal conference has been held in London between Emile Vandervelde and Camille Huysmans, of the International Socialist Bureau, and representatives of the I.L.P., the Fabian Society, and the B.S.P. for the purpose of inaugurating a scheme for amalgamating those bodies so as to bring about “Socialist” unity in this country.

The B.S.P. welcomed this, to the surprise of those in the I.L.P. But what was the alternative if it wished to save its face ?

Itself the result of a project of “Socialist Unity,” it has been a failure ever since it was launched two years ago. It was stated then that the B.S.P. would be formed of I.L.P., S.D.P., Fabians, and Church Socialist Leaguers (the “Clarion,” 18.8.11)—the same elements that are now seeking co-operation !

They can’t quite stomach having to affiliate with the Labour Party, but “needs must when the devil drives.” And all this confabulation in order to determine just who stands for Socialism in this country !

Of course the joke is that there has been a Socialist Party in existence for some years. It was formed in 1904, and bears the same name that it bore at its formation—The Socialist Party of Great Britain. Standing definitely for Socialism, and imbued only with those principles which correctly determine the attitude of an organised working class, it contains none of the discordant elements which go to make up what is known as Fabianism, I.L.P.isrn, or B.S.P.ism.

So far in the proceedings toward “unity,” its co-operation has not been solicited. To avoid possible misunderstanding, however, allow me to state that we are not open to invitation.

* * *
That was a good point against his own case that Ben Tillett made when he declared at the recent Syndicalist Congress that “Sir Edward Carson is a legal, political and economical, and racial Syndicalist.” It destroys the theory that Syndicalism can be a working-class weapon in the fight for emancipation by making the capitalist class themselves eligible for membership. It is a complete negation of the economic fact that the interests of the capitalist class and the working class are diametrically opposed.

The fact that Tillett is also a member of the B.S.P., and thereby committed to Parliamentary action, only adds to the confusion caused by this Cinquevalli of the workers’ movement.

* * *
“We ought never to take subscriptions from people who make their money out of the life-blood of poor girls.” So says the Bishop of London to the Fulham Ladies Association.

But does the bishop really mean what he says ? For the day that the Church refuses to accept contributions from the exploiting class that day the Church goes out of business.

Parsons, as a rule, argue “up in the air.” Whenever they elect to make a pronouncement bearing on the “social problem,” they assume such a profound knowledge of the subject that papers of the “Daily Citizen” are kidded into giving prominence to the rubbish they talk and write.

The Vicar of Burtonwood, Lancashire, has been letting himself go. He knows something about economics. Here is some: “There is none other landowner but God” (Lloyd George please take note). “Land monopoly, from the Scripture standpoint, is robbery of God.”

From the Socialist standpoint land (and every other) monopoly, implies robbery of the producers. The holy “problem” solvers will not have that, however. It means disaster and extinction for them.

* * *
What is a workman ? Whether it was a lack of knowledge of capitalist development, or a feeling that he was a budding capitalist, that prompted a Stratford engineer named Turner to refuse to take out an unemployment book under the Insurance Act, passes me to under­stand, But whatever the cause, it landed him in the Police Court, where the magistrate set­tled the question of his place in society for him to the tune of £1 and costs.

It seems that Turner had some money of his own, and this, along with the fact that he was in charge of an engineering department, evi­dently created the impression in his mind that he should not be classed as a workman. So he refused to take out a book under the Act, with the aforesaid result.

Though he apparently did not know it, he was as much a workman as the lowest paid labourer under him. He belonged to what Marx would call “a special kind of wage-labourer”—that section of the working class known as managers, foremen, supervisors, etc., but workers, nevertheless.

Suppose an accident had happened to any process under his charge, would the masters have taken the blame ? Not likely ! Who but he ? And who is it but the workers take the blame on almost every occasion ? Simply be­ cause they are right on the job. A passage from Marx’s “Capital” will clinch the point.
“All combined labour on a large scale requires more or less a directing activity in order to se­cure the harmonious working of the individual activities, and to perform the general functions that have their origin in the action of the combined organism, as distinguished from the action of its separate organs.”
So that we see it matters not whether a man is a low-paid labourer or a highly paid manager: he is a worker, and as such is useful to the capitalist for the purpose of exploitation.
Tom Sala


Blogger's Note:
The September 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard carried an article by T. W. Lobb on the newly formed British Socialist Party.

By The Way. (1913)

The By The Way Column from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Whilst emigration agents and others persist in their endeavours to lure workers with their glowing description of the lands across the seas, the true state of things occasionally leaks out in the most unexpected quarters. In the “Odd­ellows’ Magazine” for October appears a letter from Canada, headed :
“A Warning.” It proceeds :“We, the officers and members of the Order in Ontario, wish to inform the members of the Order in Great Britain that work is very hard to obtain at present in Canada, and to warn them against coming to this country.”
The same old story of unemployment and poverty for those who do the work of the world.

* * *

Two most extraordinary placards were to be seen on the same day side by side. If the printer will oblige, this is how they appeared :

£100,000
ROYAL
WEDDING
PRESENTS.
100,000
STARVING
IN
DUBLIN.

How true is the quotation : “He owns my life who owns the means whereby I live.” When the workers begin to think and to recognise this simple truth, they will commence to act, and to act intelligently. The S.P.G.B. alone points out the way of working-class salvation. Then no longer will our highways and byeways be made hideous with such incongruous specimens of the typographical art.

* * *

Mr. McKenna addressed his constituents a week or so ago, and during his speech he told his audience that “a number of measures advocated by Labour Members were passed by the Liberal Government, and said that those who called themselves the Labour Party were no more the Labour Party than he was. He had represented Labour ever since he sat for North Monmouthshire, and he would represent Labour until the end of his days.” (“Daily Mail,” 9.10.13.)

It is to be hoped that the workers fully appreciate the endeavours of this gent and his official party, including the tail end occasionally known as the Labour Party, on their behalf. In this connection it is worth while to remember that it was this Rt. Hon. gent who stated in the House that:
“There are now at the docks 8,000 men at work under protection, and I observe with some satisfaction that the Chairman of the Dock Committee of the Port Authority stated that the Port Authority had received more protection for labour from the present Home Secretary than they had ever received from any previous Home Secretary.” (“Daily Herald,” 14.6.12.)
It is unnecessary to quote more of the words of Mr. McKenna, to show that he has not represented the workers. All his acts go to show that he is in Parliament in the interests of the capitalist class, and “those who pay the piper call the tune.” Nevertheless, when Mr. Mc­Kenna says he is as much Labour Party as the Labour Party, he is well within the confines of truth. It is a very obvious case of “birds of a feather.”
The Scout



Blogger's Note:
Reginald McKenna was the Liberal government's Home Secretary from 1911-1915, and his quote from the Daily Herald refers to the Liberal Government's response to the Port of London dock workers strike which took place in June 1912. More details are available at the following link.

Letter: Franchise Questions. (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Franchise Questions.

We have received the following questions from Mr. John Drysdale. Our reply is appended.

(1) Would you kindly let me know your attitude toward Adult Suffrage?

(2) Do you think the working class have a majority at the ballot box with the franchise they have now?

(3) Do you think the working class should use the franchise they have got in their own interests before the Socialist Party should fight for more?

 
Reply:
(1) Our attitude towards Adult Suffrage is as follows :

While Adult Suffrage would be a useful measure for the working class, to enable them to more quickly and completely take control of political power when they understand how to use their votes, yet as the working class have a franchise wide enough for the initial steps of their emancipation, it is not the business of a Socialist Party to spend time and energy in advocating the extension of that franchise, but to educate the workers in how to use the voting power which they already possess; hence the business of a Socialist Party is to advocate Socialism only.

(2) The working class are overwhelmingly in the majority at the ballot box, as is shown by the following figures :

According to “White Paper” No. 478 on ” Parliamentary Constituencies (electors)” for 1913, there are 8,058,025 voters on the Register. Of these 4,895,840 are in the Counties and 3,111,062 in the Boroughs, while the remaining 51,123 are University electors.

In the Counties the Owners number 637,608, the Occupiers 4,086,829, and the Lodgers 171,402.

In the Boroughs the Freeholders and Freemen number 54,854, Occupiers 2,824,923, and Lodgers 231,285.

It may be accepted that the Owners, Freeholders, and University electors are members of the capitalist class. They number 743,585.

The Lodgers may be taken as members of the working class, the few exceptions to the contrary in this case being probably balanced by the few very small property owners in the first case, and they number 402,687.

We have left, the Occupiers, who number 6,911,752. Who are the Occupiers? An answer is found by looking at the rent of private houses is given in the In. Rev. Report. Of the 1,473,214 houses that come under their survey only 1,088,631 are of the yearly rental of £25 and upwards. It is a poor capitalist whose house is not estimated at more than £25 per annum, while plenty of slum property is rented above his amount. In addition, many houses that are let out in tenements are returning a total rental of £60 or £70 a year. Still others are Occupiers under the Service Franchise who are servants.

We will, however, suppose that all the occupiers of Houses of £25 and upwards are members of the capitalist class, even then we get:

Total Electorate …… 8,058,025

Owners, Freeholders, University Electors and Capitalist Occupiers 1,832,216

Working-class Occupiers & Lodgers 6,225,809 Or more than 3 to 1.

(3) Certainly. In whose interest should they use it if not in their own ? It would be absurd to urge them to use it in anyone else’s interest.
Jack Fitzgerald

The Forum: “The Return of God”. (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

[To the Editor.]

Dear Sir,—After reading the interesting article under the above striking heading in the October “S.S.,” I venture to question whether it is quite fair to speak of the “return of God,” and to say that “the materialism of a former generation of scientists is in the melting pot.” I admit that the fact of Sir Oliver Lodge delivering the presidential address gives some colour to the statement, but one swallow does not make a summer. Sir Oliver Lodge can hardly be taken as a representative scientist in any sense of the term. He is more akin to the sloppy journalists who are busy writing soothing twaddle for the sophistication of the popular mind. Moreover, one has only to remember Professor Schäfer’s address of last year in contrast with that of Lodge, and to note the hostile criticism aroused among scientists by the address of this year’s president, to realise that Sir Oliver’s superstitious suppositions are not necessarily shared by representative scientists. At all events, one can get no correct idea of what scientists are doing and thinking from the newspapers.

Regarding the “former generation of scientists,” even the few great fighters were not keen on boasting of their materialism, to say nothing of the ruck. Then, as now, they gave it fancy names. Herbert Spencer had his cult of the unknowable, and wrote wordily about the reconciliation of Religion and Science—probably for economic reasons, it is true.

The “Agnosticism” of the old school was, as aptly hit off by Engels, only a shame-faced materialism ; but the point is that it helped the enemy by emphasising the ignorance of scientists, when it was necessary to insist on their knowledge. All along, indeed, the generality of scientists have avoided pushing their tenets to their logical conclusion. They have refrained, as far as practicable, from applying them to human social activity, and their text books to this day for the most part carefully leave the superstition of man’s free will untouched. The fact is, of course, that scientists as a rule are but the hacks of the monied class. They helped capitalists to break down the last few barriers to their triumph, and are now prepared to fortify the ruling class by dosing the now threatening subject class with soothing syrup.

Nevertheless, science as science and scientists as such cannot be other than materialistic in method and result. They deal only with ascertainable phenomena. There is nothing ascertainable about the “beyond” except error.

This is, at bottom, the position taken up by the eminent biologist, Sir Ray Lankester in the “Daily Telegraph” for Sept. 30. He said :
“Our forefathers, the founders of the “Royal Society for the Promotion of Natural Knowledge, would have asked Sir Oliver Lodge to “bring in” an experiment or a specimen in proof of his beliefs, his phrases, and suppositions about “discarnate intelligences,” and in their absence would have declined to let him occupy their time. And they would have done this, and did so act, in regard to similar talkers of their day, such as Sir Kenelm Digby, not because they denied the possibility of the existence of ghosts and “such wild fowl?” (many of them firmly believed in such existences), but because they had discovered that the great principle of investigation and the building up of knowledge is the requirement of demonstrative evidence of things asserted, and the rejection of mere statements of belief or fancy, whosoever may proffer them.

“Sir Oliver makes an urgent appeal in favour of the plausibility of ghosts. He omits to state or consider the real objection which all reasonable men entertain to a belief in the existence of ghosts—namely, that the President of the British Association has not, any more than have other such believers, brought forward a particle of experimental evidence in favour of it. The best evidence forthcoming is not sufficient to induce a normal man to bet five pounds on the successful demonstration of a ghost’s existence against five thousand offered on the other side.”
With the complete domination of capitalist industry the need for the British Association, or its equivalent, as a fighting unit against religious or feudal antagonism has passed, and reconciliation is in the air. But the chief point I wish to make is that this supposed conciliation is with a different religion to the old. Religious advocates now plume themselves on their science, and endeavour to nourish their superstitions on the barren nothingness of the regions where scientific knowledge ends, and this is well brought out by D.K. Moreover, among healthy humans with scientific education, such religion as they profess is in the main sheer hypocrisy. The university-educated clergyman will—to his equals, and in expensive reviews—embrace science, discard miracles, deny the six day legend, and even the divinity of Christ, and will praise the Bible solely as a store of moral lessons from early human history ; but to the ignorant and unscientific majority the same man will preach, pray, chant, bless and thunder as though all the old superstitions were strong and hot within him, and will try to maintain these superstitions undiminished in his flock. Despite however, this widespread hypocrisy, it is really religion that has weakened, not science.

Capitalist industrial processes breed knowledge. Competition and profit-hunger make education inevitable ; and this education, particularly when coupled with class interest, drives religion further into the clouds, and determines capitalist philosophy. The ruling class is verily between the devil and the deep, blue sea. It wishes (and tries) to maintain religion as an aid to its domination, but is compelled to take a hand in its destruction by the spread of an education that is essential to industrial progress and profit. With most of this D.K., as indicated in his article, agrees. But I do not fully agree with his suggestion that it is the scientists who have gone back. The religious crowd have come forward ; as to the scientist—well, he “never was !” On many points the economic position of the scientists compels them to be stagnant, but I think it is, to say the least, a debatable point whether they are less materialistic than formerly. Certainly all biologists of eminence have completely abandoned the vitalistic or ghost theory of life so pathetically dressed up in modern phraseology by Rip Van Winkle Lodge. Like Laplace, when asked by Napoleon where God came in according to his theory, the biologists also say they have no need for that hypothesis.

It is scarcely necessary to say that on most points I am in complete agreement with the writer of the article. If the economists are taken as representative of scientists in general, I must grant D.K. his whole case. Indeed, on reading again what I have written, I perceive that on my own showing respecting the protagonists of physical science he has not at all a bad case ; but I send this contribution to the discussion nevertheless in the hope of evoking further evidence from D.K.’s point of view on what is an interesting and useful point of Socialist knowledge.
Yours fraternally,
“CRAFTSMAN”

The Forum: Rates and Taxes again (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

J. Hurle (Walthamstow)—

(1) Your quotation from Philip Snowden only adds to the mass of evidence proving him to be a charlatan. Whilst here he states that the “food taxes” are a pressing burden on the workers, he enthusiastically referred to Lloyd George’s 1909 Budget as “my Budget.” Apart from this, his statement is worthless, as food prices are governed, like those of all other commodities, by the amount of labour embodied in the articles, modified by supply and demand.

(2) The recent Board of Trade Report is eloquent of the great rise in prices, even though, as contemporary politics show, taxes have been continuously reduced in the same period.

(3) Your quotation from Prof. Ashley’s “Economic History of England” is certainly useful evidence of the truth of our position, and as you say, serves to show the bourgeois nature of the Labour Party’s agitation.

(4) Competition would doubtless reduce the price of tea if the tax was removed, and it is quite true that an inflated price and profit in the tea industry would attract more capital, with the inevitable result of over-supply and consequent reduction in price.

(5) The Railway Companies’ 4 per cent. in­crease in goods traffic rates subsequent to the strike proves rather than disposes of our state­ment. Prior to the strike the railway companies were sternly opposed to any increase of wages, but when they made a tardy and well-manipu­lated “concession,” they immediately demanded Parliamentary sanction, for an increase in. freight rates. In other words the increased wages bill was the excuse and not the reason.

The workers are not interested in freight rates, as can be verified by recalling the heated attack by manufacturers in Parliament upon the Railway Rates Bill. They felt the pinch, hence they yelped.

(6) Your extract from “Justice” is quite contrary to the position maintained by E. Belfort Bax and H. Quelch in the “Socialist Catechism” and elsewhere : viz., that rates are of interest to the propertied class alone. It illustrates the confusion that is created by the B.S.P. The idea that every increase can be “passed on” to the workers is ridiculous. The workers buy back but one-third of their produce, hence even the “pass on” theory, if there were anything in it, would affect the masters most.

(7) Tattler’s advice to a correspondent that the incidence of taxes is of little importance to our class is, after the cry about the railway rates in “Justice,” just about the limit. Mystification, not education, is evidently their policy.
Adolph Kohn