Friday, November 20, 2026

Free trade, profits and the environment (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard
Capitalism is, first and foremost, a system in which the making of profits overrides every other consideration — including damage to our environment. Socialists have been pointing this out for a long time now, yet most of those involved in environmental issues still think you can have capitalism without its problems.
The environmental movement present us with such devastating evidence of the effects of the profit system that it is surprising they fail to touch upon the root cause of the problems they highlight. This is nowhere more striking than in their attacks against the current global trading system which they blame for many social and environmental problems.

World trade has certainly been “liberalised” in many areas in the past forty or fifty years. “Distortions” of the free market price of goods, such as tariffs (which force importers to increase the price of goods), import quotas (restrictions on the amount a state will import) and export subsidies (selling exports at a deliberately low price) have all been cut back. Environmentalists are right to point out that this leaves little or no room for restrictions on the exchange of goods produced by environmentally or socially damaging means. Still, capitalism never left much room for considering the harmful consequences of the production methods used, such as causing pollution or paying low wages, when trade was more restricted. Their call for restricting trade to somehow prevent these harmful consequences overlooks the profit-driven motives that have shaped the current world trading system.

Multinationals
It is not hard to see the benefits of free trade to the hugely powerful transnational corporations. These now account for one third of global output and their global annual sales have reached 4.8 trillion dollars (which is, incidentally, greater than the total level of international trade). The largest 100 multinational corporations alone control about one-third of all foreign direct investment. The world trading system can be seen as having adapted itself to meet their needs, particularly in the last forty or fifty years.

There was, in the aftermath of the Second World War, an especially concerted effort by the US and Europe to establish freer world-wide trade. The liberalisation of capital and goods markets was an integral part of their strategy, and had indeed been a key war aim given the autarkic regional trading blocs pre-war Germany and Japan had built up.

The USA and Britain agreed to start cutting down on tariffs in 1944 as part of the famous Bretton Woods agreements. Further measures were then taken such as in 1949 when 30 percent of European trade was freed from restrictions.

Capitalism Since 1945 (edited by P. Armstrong, 1991) takes up the story:
“The reduction of tariff barriers after the formation of the EEC in 1958 increased trade by the order of 25-35%. Within EFTA, (the free trade zone formed by seven of the non-EEC European countries, including at that time the United Kingdom) lower barriers resulted in extra imports of around 10-15% for the countries concerned . . .

"Very high rates of tariff covering about 7% of goods in the United States and United Kingdom almost disappeared, and the proportion of trade (excluding agriculture and fuels) which attracted tariffs of 15 per cent or less rose from 54% to 85% in the USA, from 37% to 85% in the United Kingdom and from 71% to 97% for the EEC. "
World trade grew by an average of 8.7 percent between 1963-72. This growth then slowed sharply from 1973 (it averaged 3.8 percent per year from 1973-88).

In 1973 the Trilateral Commission was founded, to continue the work of building what Holly Sklar in her book Trilateralism (1980) called the “new economic order”.

The Trilateral Commission, she wrote, “planned and encouraged an utter restructuring of the world’s political and economic agenda with much of its new power arrangements built to favour transnational corporate activity.”

The objectives of the Commission were evident in their various reports and policy documents such as this call for the lifting of restrictions on capital mobility made in their publication Towards a Regenerated Economic System, “countries that want economic development would be well-advised to welcome foreign firms on appropriate terms”.

You do not need a degree in economics to work out what was meant by “appropriate” in this context. It is made abundantly clear in the following statement by David Rockcrfeller, one of the leading US politicians and business representatives on the Trilateral Commission: 
"international bankers, corporations, and investors have little need for tariffs and other trade barriers. Their interest lies in finding the most efficient, profitable, productive, and convenient spot for their investment".
George Ball, Under-secretary of State for Economic Affairs in the Kennedy Administration and a director of Lehman brothers Kuhn Loeb, a large investment house, told the British National Committee of the International Chamber of Commerce in 1967:
“In these twenty postwar years, we have come to recognise in action, though not always in words, that the political boundaries of nation-states are too narrow and constituted to define the scope and activities of modern business".
No place for environmentalism
GATT (now called the World Trade Organisations WTO), an institution which has been the focus of much hostility from environmentalists, also had an important role in the move towards trade liberalisation:
"Six rounds of General Agreements on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) negotiations, from 1947 to 1967, for example, brought tariffs on all dutiable US imports downfrom their 1932 high of 59.0% to 9.9% in 1970 n (Capitalism Since 1945).
GATT was founded after the Second World War as an institution to regulate world trade. The original GATT articles contained the basic free trade principles that were gradually put into practice: 
"Article One establishes the rule of 'Most Favoured Nation ’— one country cannot discriminate between domestic products and ‘like products’ imported from another GATT country. 'Like products' were defined in 1971 to be limited to consideration of product characteristics; does not allow consideration of how product is produced or harvested" (Lori Wallach in The Case Against Free Trade, Earth Island Press, 1993).
Environmentalists had hoped that Article 20, which allowed “measures necessary to protect human, animal and plant health or life”, would permit exceptions to the above principles in the case of environmental protection. The well-publicised tuna-dolphin ease, in which the Mexican government appealed against the US Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, put the hopes of environmentalists to the test. Wallach records what happened:
“In August 1991, a three-person, secret GATT dispute panel in Geneva ruled that the (1972 act) was an illegal barrier to trade because it restricts importing tuna into the United States that are caught using techniques that kill large numbers of dolphins”.
This was one of many such judgements that put paid to the environmentalists’ misplaced faith in international law to protect the environment. As Ralph Nader put it, “GATT and NAFTA set out rules limiting countries’ ability to exclude imports on the basis of labour, human rights, or environmental conditions in the country of production”. The Agreements allow one country to challenge as infringing trade another country's environmental, health or safety laws. They therefore have the effect of “harmonising” environmental and safely standards, a euphemism for bringing those states with more stringent regulations down to the level of the least stringent. In other words, the law could only be relied upon when it worked in the other direction.

The move towards free trade can be clearly seen as an outcome of the drive for profits, as companies increasingly operate on a global basis and expect to be able to import and export goods at their free market price.

The anti-free trade lobby are right to point to the conflict between the drive towards free trade and environmental and social needs. After all, if the purpose of free trade is to increase profits, such a conclusion is quite predictable. As Larry Elliott puts it, writing in the Guardian (27 May):
“In reality, globalisation . . . represents the final triumph of capital over labour, since the corollary of the deregulation of finance is the shackling of trade unions. It means the national governments are left powerless in the face of multinationals who will relocate at the first whiff of interventionist policies."
Environmentalists do not usually dispute that the drive for profit underlies the move towards free trade. What they want instead is a “fairer” system of world trade in which environmental and social needs are taken into account. For example, Wallach refers to a “Group of 250” NGOs who wrote a letter to the US government, calling for sanctions to ensure compliance with regulations, funding for their enforcement, taxes and duties on environmentally damaging practices and so on.

In other words, they unreasonably expected that the goal of increasing profitability (which is what GAIT, the WTO and NAFTA are all about) can be compromised under the profit-system. But it can’t. The profit system demands a trading system that allows profits to be maximised. To protect the environment it is the whole global profit system itself that must go.
Dan Greenwood

No comments: