Saturday, November 21, 2026

By The Way. (1913)

The By The Way Column from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Whilst emigration agents and others persist in their endeavours to lure workers with their glowing description of the lands across the seas, the true state of things occasionally leaks out in the most unexpected quarters. In the “Odd­ellows’ Magazine” for October appears a letter from Canada, headed :
“A Warning.” It proceeds :“We, the officers and members of the Order in Ontario, wish to inform the members of the Order in Great Britain that work is very hard to obtain at present in Canada, and to warn them against coming to this country.”
The same old story of unemployment and poverty for those who do the work of the world.

* * *

Two most extraordinary placards were to be seen on the same day side by side. If the printer will oblige, this is how they appeared :

£100,000
ROYAL
WEDDING
PRESENTS.
100,000
STARVING
IN
DUBLIN.

How true is the quotation : “He owns my life who owns the means whereby I live.” When the workers begin to think and to recognise this simple truth, they will commence to act, and to act intelligently. The S.P.G.B. alone points out the way of working-class salvation. Then no longer will our highways and byeways be made hideous with such incongruous specimens of the typographical art.

* * *

Mr. McKenna addressed his constituents a week or so ago, and during his speech he told his audience that “a number of measures advocated by Labour Members were passed by the Liberal Government, and said that those who called themselves the Labour Party were no more the Labour Party than he was. He had represented Labour ever since he sat for North Monmouthshire, and he would represent Labour until the end of his days.” (“Daily Mail,” 9.10.13.)

It is to be hoped that the workers fully appreciate the endeavours of this gent and his official party, including the tail end occasionally known as the Labour Party, on their behalf. In this connection it is worth while to remember that it was this Rt. Hon. gent who stated in the House that:
“There are now at the docks 8,000 men at work under protection, and I observe with some satisfaction that the Chairman of the Dock Committee of the Port Authority stated that the Port Authority had received more protection for labour from the present Home Secretary than they had ever received from any previous Home Secretary.” (“Daily Herald,” 14.6.12.)
It is unnecessary to quote more of the words of Mr. McKenna, to show that he has not represented the workers. All his acts go to show that he is in Parliament in the interests of the capitalist class, and “those who pay the piper call the tune.” Nevertheless, when Mr. Mc­Kenna says he is as much Labour Party as the Labour Party, he is well within the confines of truth. It is a very obvious case of “birds of a feather.”
The Scout



Blogger's Note:
Reginald McKenna was the Liberal government's Home Secretary from 1911-1915, and his quote from the Daily Herald refers to the Liberal Government's response to the Port of London dock workers strike which took place in June 1912. More details are available at the following link.

Letter: Franchise Questions. (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

Franchise Questions.

We have received the following questions from Mr. John Drysdale. Our reply is appended.

(1) Would you kindly let me know your attitude toward Adult Suffrage?

(2) Do you think the working class have a majority at the ballot box with the franchise they have now?

(3) Do you think the working class should use the franchise they have got in their own interests before the Socialist Party should fight for more?

 
Reply:
(1) Our attitude towards Adult Suffrage is as follows :

While Adult Suffrage would be a useful measure for the working class, to enable them to more quickly and completely take control of political power when they understand how to use their votes, yet as the working class have a franchise wide enough for the initial steps of their emancipation, it is not the business of a Socialist Party to spend time and energy in advocating the extension of that franchise, but to educate the workers in how to use the voting power which they already possess; hence the business of a Socialist Party is to advocate Socialism only.

(2) The working class are overwhelmingly in the majority at the ballot box, as is shown by the following figures :

According to “White Paper” No. 478 on ” Parliamentary Constituencies (electors)” for 1913, there are 8,058,025 voters on the Register. Of these 4,895,840 are in the Counties and 3,111,062 in the Boroughs, while the remaining 51,123 are University electors.

In the Counties the Owners number 637,608, the Occupiers 4,086,829, and the Lodgers 171,402.

In the Boroughs the Freeholders and Freemen number 54,854, Occupiers 2,824,923, and Lodgers 231,285.

It may be accepted that the Owners, Freeholders, and University electors are members of the capitalist class. They number 743,585.

The Lodgers may be taken as members of the working class, the few exceptions to the contrary in this case being probably balanced by the few very small property owners in the first case, and they number 402,687.

We have left, the Occupiers, who number 6,911,752. Who are the Occupiers? An answer is found by looking at the rent of private houses is given in the In. Rev. Report. Of the 1,473,214 houses that come under their survey only 1,088,631 are of the yearly rental of £25 and upwards. It is a poor capitalist whose house is not estimated at more than £25 per annum, while plenty of slum property is rented above his amount. In addition, many houses that are let out in tenements are returning a total rental of £60 or £70 a year. Still others are Occupiers under the Service Franchise who are servants.

We will, however, suppose that all the occupiers of Houses of £25 and upwards are members of the capitalist class, even then we get:

Total Electorate …… 8,058,025

Owners, Freeholders, University Electors and Capitalist Occupiers 1,832,216

Working-class Occupiers & Lodgers 6,225,809 Or more than 3 to 1.

(3) Certainly. In whose interest should they use it if not in their own ? It would be absurd to urge them to use it in anyone else’s interest.
Jack Fitzgerald

The Forum: “The Return of God”. (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

[To the Editor.]

Dear Sir,—After reading the interesting article under the above striking heading in the October “S.S.,” I venture to question whether it is quite fair to speak of the “return of God,” and to say that “the materialism of a former generation of scientists is in the melting pot.” I admit that the fact of Sir Oliver Lodge delivering the presidential address gives some colour to the statement, but one swallow does not make a summer. Sir Oliver Lodge can hardly be taken as a representative scientist in any sense of the term. He is more akin to the sloppy journalists who are busy writing soothing twaddle for the sophistication of the popular mind. Moreover, one has only to remember Professor Schäfer’s address of last year in contrast with that of Lodge, and to note the hostile criticism aroused among scientists by the address of this year’s president, to realise that Sir Oliver’s superstitious suppositions are not necessarily shared by representative scientists. At all events, one can get no correct idea of what scientists are doing and thinking from the newspapers.

Regarding the “former generation of scientists,” even the few great fighters were not keen on boasting of their materialism, to say nothing of the ruck. Then, as now, they gave it fancy names. Herbert Spencer had his cult of the unknowable, and wrote wordily about the reconciliation of Religion and Science—probably for economic reasons, it is true.

The “Agnosticism” of the old school was, as aptly hit off by Engels, only a shame-faced materialism ; but the point is that it helped the enemy by emphasising the ignorance of scientists, when it was necessary to insist on their knowledge. All along, indeed, the generality of scientists have avoided pushing their tenets to their logical conclusion. They have refrained, as far as practicable, from applying them to human social activity, and their text books to this day for the most part carefully leave the superstition of man’s free will untouched. The fact is, of course, that scientists as a rule are but the hacks of the monied class. They helped capitalists to break down the last few barriers to their triumph, and are now prepared to fortify the ruling class by dosing the now threatening subject class with soothing syrup.

Nevertheless, science as science and scientists as such cannot be other than materialistic in method and result. They deal only with ascertainable phenomena. There is nothing ascertainable about the “beyond” except error.

This is, at bottom, the position taken up by the eminent biologist, Sir Ray Lankester in the “Daily Telegraph” for Sept. 30. He said :
“Our forefathers, the founders of the “Royal Society for the Promotion of Natural Knowledge, would have asked Sir Oliver Lodge to “bring in” an experiment or a specimen in proof of his beliefs, his phrases, and suppositions about “discarnate intelligences,” and in their absence would have declined to let him occupy their time. And they would have done this, and did so act, in regard to similar talkers of their day, such as Sir Kenelm Digby, not because they denied the possibility of the existence of ghosts and “such wild fowl?” (many of them firmly believed in such existences), but because they had discovered that the great principle of investigation and the building up of knowledge is the requirement of demonstrative evidence of things asserted, and the rejection of mere statements of belief or fancy, whosoever may proffer them.

“Sir Oliver makes an urgent appeal in favour of the plausibility of ghosts. He omits to state or consider the real objection which all reasonable men entertain to a belief in the existence of ghosts—namely, that the President of the British Association has not, any more than have other such believers, brought forward a particle of experimental evidence in favour of it. The best evidence forthcoming is not sufficient to induce a normal man to bet five pounds on the successful demonstration of a ghost’s existence against five thousand offered on the other side.”
With the complete domination of capitalist industry the need for the British Association, or its equivalent, as a fighting unit against religious or feudal antagonism has passed, and reconciliation is in the air. But the chief point I wish to make is that this supposed conciliation is with a different religion to the old. Religious advocates now plume themselves on their science, and endeavour to nourish their superstitions on the barren nothingness of the regions where scientific knowledge ends, and this is well brought out by D.K. Moreover, among healthy humans with scientific education, such religion as they profess is in the main sheer hypocrisy. The university-educated clergyman will—to his equals, and in expensive reviews—embrace science, discard miracles, deny the six day legend, and even the divinity of Christ, and will praise the Bible solely as a store of moral lessons from early human history ; but to the ignorant and unscientific majority the same man will preach, pray, chant, bless and thunder as though all the old superstitions were strong and hot within him, and will try to maintain these superstitions undiminished in his flock. Despite however, this widespread hypocrisy, it is really religion that has weakened, not science.

Capitalist industrial processes breed knowledge. Competition and profit-hunger make education inevitable ; and this education, particularly when coupled with class interest, drives religion further into the clouds, and determines capitalist philosophy. The ruling class is verily between the devil and the deep, blue sea. It wishes (and tries) to maintain religion as an aid to its domination, but is compelled to take a hand in its destruction by the spread of an education that is essential to industrial progress and profit. With most of this D.K., as indicated in his article, agrees. But I do not fully agree with his suggestion that it is the scientists who have gone back. The religious crowd have come forward ; as to the scientist—well, he “never was !” On many points the economic position of the scientists compels them to be stagnant, but I think it is, to say the least, a debatable point whether they are less materialistic than formerly. Certainly all biologists of eminence have completely abandoned the vitalistic or ghost theory of life so pathetically dressed up in modern phraseology by Rip Van Winkle Lodge. Like Laplace, when asked by Napoleon where God came in according to his theory, the biologists also say they have no need for that hypothesis.

It is scarcely necessary to say that on most points I am in complete agreement with the writer of the article. If the economists are taken as representative of scientists in general, I must grant D.K. his whole case. Indeed, on reading again what I have written, I perceive that on my own showing respecting the protagonists of physical science he has not at all a bad case ; but I send this contribution to the discussion nevertheless in the hope of evoking further evidence from D.K.’s point of view on what is an interesting and useful point of Socialist knowledge.
Yours fraternally,
“CRAFTSMAN”

The Forum: Rates and Taxes again (1913)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1913 issue of the Socialist Standard

J. Hurle (Walthamstow)—

(1) Your quotation from Philip Snowden only adds to the mass of evidence proving him to be a charlatan. Whilst here he states that the “food taxes” are a pressing burden on the workers, he enthusiastically referred to Lloyd George’s 1909 Budget as “my Budget.” Apart from this, his statement is worthless, as food prices are governed, like those of all other commodities, by the amount of labour embodied in the articles, modified by supply and demand.

(2) The recent Board of Trade Report is eloquent of the great rise in prices, even though, as contemporary politics show, taxes have been continuously reduced in the same period.

(3) Your quotation from Prof. Ashley’s “Economic History of England” is certainly useful evidence of the truth of our position, and as you say, serves to show the bourgeois nature of the Labour Party’s agitation.

(4) Competition would doubtless reduce the price of tea if the tax was removed, and it is quite true that an inflated price and profit in the tea industry would attract more capital, with the inevitable result of over-supply and consequent reduction in price.

(5) The Railway Companies’ 4 per cent. in­crease in goods traffic rates subsequent to the strike proves rather than disposes of our state­ment. Prior to the strike the railway companies were sternly opposed to any increase of wages, but when they made a tardy and well-manipu­lated “concession,” they immediately demanded Parliamentary sanction, for an increase in. freight rates. In other words the increased wages bill was the excuse and not the reason.

The workers are not interested in freight rates, as can be verified by recalling the heated attack by manufacturers in Parliament upon the Railway Rates Bill. They felt the pinch, hence they yelped.

(6) Your extract from “Justice” is quite contrary to the position maintained by E. Belfort Bax and H. Quelch in the “Socialist Catechism” and elsewhere : viz., that rates are of interest to the propertied class alone. It illustrates the confusion that is created by the B.S.P. The idea that every increase can be “passed on” to the workers is ridiculous. The workers buy back but one-third of their produce, hence even the “pass on” theory, if there were anything in it, would affect the masters most.

(7) Tattler’s advice to a correspondent that the incidence of taxes is of little importance to our class is, after the cry about the railway rates in “Justice,” just about the limit. Mystification, not education, is evidently their policy.
Adolph Kohn