Monday, November 16, 2026

About socialism (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

1. What is the Socialist Party of Great Britain?

It is a political party, separate from all others, Left, Right or Centre. It stands for the sole aim of establishing a world social system based upon human need instead of private or state profit. The Object and Declaration of Principles printed in this introductory leaflet were adopted by the Socialist Party in 1904 and have been maintained without compromise since then. In other countries there are companion parties sharing the same object and principles, and they too remain independent from all other political parties.


2. What is capitalism?

Capitalism is the social system which now exists in all countries of the world. Under this system, the means of production and distribution (land, factories, offices, transport, media, etc.) are monopolized by a minority, the capitalist class. All wealth is produced by us, the majority working class, who sell our mental and physical energies to the capitalists in return for a price called a wage or salary. The object of wealth production is to create goods and services which can be sold on the market at a profit. Not only do the capitalists live off the profits they obtain from exploiting the working class, but, as a class, they go on accumulating wealth extracted from each generation of workers.


3. Can capitalism be reformed in our interests?

No: as long as capitalism exists, profits will come before needs. Some reforms are welcomed by some workers, but no reform can abolish the fundamental contradiction between profit and need which is built into the present system. No matter whether promises to make capitalism run in the interests of the workers are made sincerely or by opportunist politicians they are bound to fail, for such a promise is like offering to run the slaughter house in the interests of the cattle.


4. Is nationalization an alternative to capitalism?

No: nationalized industries simply mean that workers are exploited by the state, acting on behalf of the capitalists of one country, rather than by an individual capitalist or company. The workers in nationalized Austin Rover are no less the servants of profit than workers in privately-owned Ford. The mines no more belong to "the public" or the miners now than they did before 1947 when they were nationalised. Nationalization is state capitalism.


5. Are there any “socialist countries”?

No: the so-called socialist countries are systems of state capitalism. In Russia and its empire, in China, Cuba, Albania, Yugoslavia and the other countries which call themselves socialist, social power is monopolized by privileged Party bureaucrats. The features of capitalism, as outlined above, are all present. An examination of international commerce shows that the bogus socialist states are part of the world capitalist market and cannot detach themselves from the requirements of profit.


6. What is the meaning of socialism?

Socialism does not yet exist. When it is established it must be on a worldwide basis, as an alternative to the outdated system of world capitalism. In a socialist society there will be common ownership and democratic control of the earth by its inhabitants. No minority class will be in a position to dictate to the majority that production must be geared to profit. There will be no owners: everything will belong to everyone. Production will be solely for use, not for sale. The only questions society will need to ask about wealth production will be: what do people require, and can the needs be met? These questions will be answered on the basis of the resources available to meet such needs. Then, unlike now, modern technology and communications will be able to be used to their fullest extent. The basic socialist principle will be that people give according to their abilities and take according to their self-defined needs. Work will be on the basis of voluntary co-operation: the coercion of wage and salary work will be abolished. There will be no buying or selling and money will not be necessary, in a society of common ownership and free access. For the first time ever the people of the world will have common possession of the planet earth.


7. How will socialism solve the problems of society?

Capitalism, with its constant drive to serve profit before need, throws up an endless stream of problems. Most workers in Britain feel insecure about their future; almost one in four families with children living below the official government poverty line; many old people live in dangerously cold conditions each winter and thousands die; millions of our fellow men and women are dying of starvation — tens of thousands of them each day. A society based on production for use will end those problems because the priority of socialist society will be the fullest possible satisfaction of needs. At the moment houses stand empty and thousands of building workers are unemployed; yet many people are homeless or inhabiting slums. At the moment food is destroyed and farmers are subsidised not to produce more: yet many millions are malnourished. At the moment hospital queues are growing longer and people are dying of curable illnesses; yet it is not "economically viable" to provide decent health treatment for all. In a socialist society nothing short of the best will be good enough for any human being.


8. What about human nature?

Human behaviour is not fixed, but determined by the kind of society people are conditioned to live in. The capitalist jungle produces vicious, competitive ways of thinking and acting. But we humans are able to adapt our behaviour and there is no reason why our rational desire for comfort and human welfare should not allow us to co-operate. Even under capitalism people often obtain pleasure from doing a good turn for others; few people enjoy participating in the "civilised" warfare of the daily rat-race. Think how much better it would be if society was based on co-operation.


9. Are socialists democrats?

Yes: the Socialist Party has no leaders. It is a democratic organisation controlled by its members. It understands that Socialism can only be established by a conscious majority of workers — that workers must liberate themselves and will not be liberated by leaders or parties. Socialism will not be brought about by a dedicated minority "smashing the state", as some left-wingers would have it. Nor do the activities of paid, professional politicians have anything to do with Socialism — the experience of seven Labour governments has shown this. Once a majority of the working class understand and want Socialism, they will take the necessary step to organise consciously for the democratic conquest of political power. There will be no Socialism without a socialist majority.


10. What is the next step?

Many workers know that there is something wrong and want to change society. Some join reform groups in the hope that capitalism can be patched up, but such efforts are futile because you cannot run a system of class exploitation in the interests of the exploited majority. People who fear a nuclear war may join CND. but as long as nation states exist, economic rivalry means that the world will never be safe from the threat of war. There are countless dedicated campaigns and good causes which many sincere people are caught up in, but there is only one solution to the problems of capitalism and that is to get rid of it, and establish Socialism. Before we can do that we need socialists; winning workers to that cause requires knowledge, principles and an enthusiasm for change. These qualities can be developed by anyone — and are essential for anyone who is serious about changing society. Capitalism in the 1980s is still a system of waste, deprivation and frightening insecurity. You owe it to yourself to find out about the one movement which stands for the alternative.


If you agree with some or all of the above, please contact the Socialist Party with your questions and ideas about what you can do to help speed the progress towards Socialism.

Running Commentary: A leaner Spain (1988)

The Running Commentary column from the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

A leaner Spain

Margaret Thatcher recently romped across the continent in her version of the Grand European Tour. Apart from providing those members of the media covering the event with a few duty frees', this exercise in high profile politicking was one that concerned the working class of Europe not one iota. However, one aspect of these theatricals of interest to socialists was the attention devoted to the non-socialist policies of socialist' Spain.

Six years ago the Spanish elected a 'socialist' government on a promise to create 600,000 new jobs. Unemployment has risen by a million since. Spain's unemployment rate of twenty per cent is the highest in the EEC. Only twenty six per cent of those out of work are entitled to unemployment pay. Taking a leaf out of Maggie's book, 'socialist' Prime Minister. Felipe Gonzalez, has eased the restrictive practices resulting from the considerable job security (but little political freedom) enjoyed by Spaniards under General Franco. Gonzalez has made it easier for employers to fire and hire and. again following Maggie's example, has turned Spain into a fitter, leaner society more able to compete in world markets.

By refusing to inject cash into the public sector — health, social services and education — the government has allowed Spanish capitalists to achieve the fastest economic growth rate of any EEC member country. Such growth cannot, of course, be sustained without some sacrifices. Under capitalism these sacrifices always come from the working class.

The situation in Spain provided those paid by the ruling class to mould the ideas and opinions in society with yet another apparent example of the correctness of the capitalist way of life and the failure of socialism. This is utter nonsense. Those political parties calling themselves 'socialist', whether in government or in opposition, are committed to running capitalism for the benefit of capitalists. The Spaniards who are now vociferous in their criticism of a government which, in their view has abandoned all its left-wing ideals in its enthusiasm to run Spanish capitalism, were obviously unaware that any political party calling itself socialist which does not advocate the transition from capitalism to a moneyless, wageless, leaderless, stateless society, is not a socialist party.
Dave Coggan

Running Commentary: Gone for gold (1988)

The Running Commentary column from the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

Gone for gold

Gold medals for hypocrisy must go to the sports journalists for their hysterical indignation about the drug-taking athletes of the Seoul Olympics. Athletes who boosted their performance by taking drugs, we were informed by these experts, debased the Olympic ideal, which is all to do with amateurism — competing for the love of it and not for material reward and with the principle that it is not winning an event which counts but taking part in it.

Putting aside any astonishment that an assembly of media hacks should be concerned about ideals and principles, we can consider this matter of the Olympic ideal. Far from being a gathering of noble amateurs, the Games are riddled with professionalism, some examples of it more blatant than others. For a long time American athletes have survived most comfortably on sporting scholarships to colleges and those from Eastern Europe on generous subsidies from the state. British athletes are reliant on sponsorship and the laundering of income through trust funds. The financial rewards for the likes of Ben Johnson are high enough to justify the risk of being exposed in using banned drugs and stimulants.

It is no less dishonest to pretend that the Olympics are concerned with participating rather than winning. Long before the first starting pistol is fired the likely winners are being hyped by the media; little interest is shown in those who are not expected to bring home any medals. Winners are saluted with a flag-waving, anthem-playing celebration of triumphant nationalism which is not a pretty sight. In Britain Linford Christie and Adrian Moorhouse were worshipped in the media as true-blue British heroes while in Canada Ben Johnson was changed overnight from a superman to a disgrace to the entire Canadian nation.

Indeed, it would be astounding if an event like the Games were excluded from this kind of treatment. Nationalism is one of capitalism's taken-for-granted bigotries; we are all presumed to want "our" armed forces to be the most powerful, "our" exports to be the most competitive, "our" sportspeople to be always first across the line. Such delusions help to persuade workers that they have common interests with their exploiters

A great deal of money is invested in the Olympics. To begin it all there is bitter competition over where the Games should be held not through any pride in being chosen for a great sporting event but through hunger for the spin-off profits available to the host country

Yet amid all this chaos of nationalism and commerce, built up by the media in the interests of selling newspapers or boosting TV ratings, there is a crazy, baseless expectation that the Games' participants will be willing to stand aside, satisfied through their devotion to the Olympic ideal. It is a laughable idea and Ben Johnson, and not a few more, have shown it up for what it is and that capitalism's morality is corrupting everywhere and everything.

Running Commentary: Money (1988)

The Running Commentary column from the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

Money

Love it or hate it, you can't ignore it. It permeates every sphere of human life. More effort goes into the pursuit of it than into any other human activity. From the moment of waking each day it dominates the existence of the vast majority of the worlds population. Without it the basic necessities of life — food, drink, clothing, shelter — are difficult to obtain. Liza Minnelli sang that it makes the world go round. The classic American Depression song echoed the cry of millions: "Buddy, can you spare a dime?" Abba gave us the self-evident truth that it's a rich man's world. Pink Floyd know more about political economy than do the so called expert economists: "Money, it's a crime, share it fairly but don't take a slice of my pie. Money, so they say. is the root of all evil today, but if you ask for a rise it's no surprise that they're giving none away.''

Mr Micawber's maxim still holds true. "Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six. result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six. result misery.

But for those who control capitalism — the minority who own the means of production and distribution money serves a different purpose.
The extent of the power of money is the extent of my power. Money's properties are my — the possessor's — properties and essential powers. Thus, what I am and am capable of is by no means determined by my individuality. I am bad, dishonest, unscrupulous, stupid; but money is honoured, and hence its possessor. Money is the supreme good, therefore its possessor is good. Money, besides, saves me the trouble of being dishonest: I am therefore presumed honest.

I am brainless, but money is the real brain of all things and how then should its possessor be brainless? besides, he can buy clever people for himself, and is he who has power over the clever not more clever than the clever?'
Those who profess concern for the less well-off in society offer myriad schemes for the reform of capitalism: a minimum wage for everyone, a more equal distribution of wealth, more aid for the third world. The obvious solution never seems to occur to them. The replacement of capitalism by socialism a wageless, moneyless society where goods are produced for need, not for profit. So come all you bank clerks, salespeople, tax collectors, bailiffs and credit controllers. Stop wasting your lives handling money for your bosses and investigate socialism. Because until a majority of the working class understand and want socialism, you'll spend the rest of your time on this earth creating wealth for other people.

A security guard was recently knifed to death. During the attempted bank raid, a passer-by who went to his assistance was also seriously injured. The incident received heavy media coverage. The local newspaper headlined the story, 'Hero guard is killed in bank raid.' It reported that, 'He bravely struggled to get the money to safety before collapsing.' A man died for five thousand pounds — a heavy price to pay for defending the boss's profits.
Dave Coggan

Brent: cuts versus needs (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

The people of Brent have every right to be angry. The borough has been thrown as a living sacrifice upon the altar of profit. Basic services have been savagely depleted as the Council is forced to cut £17 million from its expenditure budget in order to please the vandals called economists.

What have these cuts meant in practical terms? One in five home helps has been sacked; let the old look after themselves. Four residential homes for the elderly are closing down. 600 workers in the school meals service are to go: let the kids bring their own food to eat. The refuse collection service has had its budget cut by 20 per cent; in future dustbins will only be emptied fortnightly, if that. There used to be 209 dustmen in Brent. Now there are 116; let the rubbish rot in the streets. The number of road sweepers has been cut from 142 to 96. An increase in street vermin is expected to follow the cuts; but cuts in Brent's environmental health department mean that if they are to be removed it is likely to be in the more affluent streets, where residents can afford to buy the use of private firms. 233 teachers are to be removed from Brent education. This is in a borough where the lack of money for education and the high number of non-English speaking pupils has put a unique strain upon the schools. Last term 162 teaching jobs went as a result of the cuts, and now there are to be efforts to get rid of a further 233 unwanted teachers by voluntary redundancies. 60 primary teachers have so far agreed to go; 94 secondary school posts had to go by the end of October, or else, for the first time in the history of London education, compulsory sackings will take place. Brent's youth and community services are to be cut to the point of virtual extinction. 17 youth and community centres will close down. An 80 per cent cut in this area of social service staffing will mean that 100 full-time jobs will go. and 400 part-time workers will have the task of carrying on with a budget reduced from £4.5 million to £450,000. The number of Brent's social workers has been cut by nearly 20 per cent. In the next round of cuts in January many more jobs will go in the social services department, compulsory redundancies in schools will be inevitable and it is anticipated that several libraries will have to be sold off.

All of this has been carried out. not by Thatcherite monsters with top hats and cigars, but by a Labour Council. Indeed. Brent Labour Party is known as one of the most Leftist in the whole of Britain. It is a Labour Council that has wielded the knife which has hurt so many Brent workers. The leader of Brent Council, who claims to be a socialist, has a picture of Mikhail Gorbachev on the wall of his Town Hall office. The Brent East Labour MP, Ken Livingstone, whose political patronage was provided by the Labour Left who control the Council, has stated that the rulers of Brent reminded him of Pol Pot's regime. Ron Anderson, a Labour councillor and long-standing Brent Leftist, has said that Brent is being ruled like a Stalinist state, with a small caucus of rulers running the finances. Harsh criticisms, but neither Livingstone or Anderson have been quick to explain how Brent could have avoided the mess.

Brent is different from most other London boroughs, and most non-London areas. Firstly, it has the highest number of workers living in it who were not born in Britain. Secondly, the borough has an unusually high number of homeless workers. Thirdly, the number of workers living on or below the poverty line in Brent (particularly in the south and east of the borough, which used to be Willesden before fusion with the more prosperous Wembley area in the north) is much higher than in most parts of Britain. Brent politics has long been dominated by Labour with the Tories having their own stronghold in Brent North, the constituency of the awful Rhodes Boyson. Like most London Labour parties. Brent constituency Labour Party (CLP) is highly factionalised. There has always been a strong hard left in Brent who have argued that the Council should make no compromises with the demands of the profit system for cheap services. Unlike most London CLPs. and more like New York politics, Brent Labour Party has. over the past decade, been divided into several ethnic sections: Afro-Caribbean, Indian Hindu, Muslim, as well as strong Jewish and Irish lobbies. (It is the latter that Ken Livingstone has had to play to in order to win votes with his posturing over the IRA. and the former who have ensured that Livingstone has of late made some uncharacteristically pro-Israeli noises.) These ethnic factions do not correspond in any particular way to ideological divisions. So, for example, five years ago there was the case of a Jamaican-born councillor, given her job with the strong support of the Trotskyist faction, who lost an argument in favour of having segregated education for West Indian children so that they could be taught Christian values and beaten when they misbehaved, and then joined the Tory party. At that time Labour only had a majority of one on the Council and power passed briefly to a Tory-Liberal coalition. Ironically, many of the policies of the mid-1980s which have been dubbed 'loony leftist' were initiated by the Tory rulers during their administration. The reason was that only by pandering to the various local interest groups can any administration retain power in Brent.

The main reason for Brent's financial mess arose out of a failure on the part of its rulers to understand that capitalism cannot be run in such a way as to please workers living under it. Brent Council's futile policy of trying to ignore the profit system, at least in terms of its public image, has resulted in overspending in order to win/buy votes. In a system where profit comes first, needs a distant second, the price to be paid for failing to be economically callous is economic collapse. Now the workers of Brent are having to pay the hard price of the populist antics of the political opportunists whose reformism promised capitalism without the cuts. New managers will be brought in. advised by pinstriped vandals from The London School of Economics and Human Misery, and they will see that the accounts are kept in order. The God of Profit must be fed; to hell with the human cost.

Paul Johnson started out life as a columnist on The New Statesman writing twaddle about how Labour governments could run capitalism well. leaving the workers contented. Experience showed him that he had been as wrong as all other reformist day-dreamers. Johnson's condition deteriorated instead of improving. He became a Tory — an ultra-crazy Tory at that so mad, indeed, that he now writes a regular column for The Daily Mail. On 15 August Johnson wrote an article entitled 'The blight Burma shares with Brent'. Both 'collapsing regimes provide striking proof that the quest for socialist utopias invariably ends in nightmares.' He tells his readers that in both Burma and Brent 'socialist policies have been tested to the destruction.' The reality is quite the opposite. What the current crisis in Brent proves is that you can never run a system of production for sale and profit, however sincere and 'progressive' the rulers, except by hurting the workers whose needs must come second to the profit priority. In neither Brent nor Burma have those who have had power won it on the basis of aiming to produce solely for use. not for the market. Indeed, as Labour's national leader spelt out in Blackpool at the party's conference, speaking of his party's task ahead. 'The kind of economy that we are faced with is going to be a market economy, and we have got to make it work better than the Tories make it work.' In Brent the Council has tried to beat the Tories at the game of running capitalism locally, and they have ended up playing the same game according to the same old, despicable Tory rules. Tories like Johnson have no reasons to gloat: in Conservative-controlled Westminster Council they sold a local cemetery, workers' graves and all, for under a quid to a property company who wanted to build offices on the land. And the only reason that Tory councils like Westminster and Merton are not cutting services as savagely as Brent is because the services were never there in the first place.

Many Brent workers have taken strike action against the Council. Social workers were shocked into striking when the Council cut provisions for dealing with local child abuse and closed down a home for handicapped kids. Teachers have also taken strike action. None of this will change anything. Brent's administrators are being forced to learn the hard lesson that running capitalism in an area of particular poverty and ethnic deprivation is a job for heartless swines, not councillors who listen to the cries of the needy.

In Brent, as everywhere else, the real choice is between a system which puts needs first and one which puts the market profit first. We know from Kinnock's words and Brent Council's actions which side they are on. The alternative is presented by the socialists. Workers may ignore the socialist alternative at their cost — a human cost which in Brent is causing hardship and heartache which should not ever be voted for again.
Steve Coleman

Postscript
Since this article was written, the situation in Brent has deteriorated. The Town Hall and other municipal buildings have been mortgaged to a Japanese bank in order to raise money to maintain basic services. Compulsory redundancies of teachers and social workers have now been ordered. Brent's only home for the part-time care of handicapped children has been closed. Parents have demonstrated against the Labour councillors but the Japanese owners are unlikely to listen.

Danger: capitalism at work (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

Paradoxically, accidents are both avoidable and inevitable. Under certain conditions, accidents will and must happen; the possibility of avoiding an accident can be, and often is, reduced to zero. The avoidable conditions or circumstances which make accidents unavoidable and cause disasters like the King's Cross fire or the capsize of the Herald of Free Enterprise are — like crises and class conflict — by-products of the capitalist way of doing things. They are intrinsic to the system, whose warped priorities consistently put profits before people.

Partly perhaps because of their frequency, we tend to accept accidents as a normal feature of everyday life. A child feels upset and cries after breaking something in the home, but grown-ups say, by way of reassurance. "Never mind, accidents will happen". The TV newsreader reads the news of some horrific disaster with apparent equanimity. Whether such people are hand-picked for callousness, or. more likely, are trained to react in this way to avoid alarming the viewing millions, the effect is to reassure us by suggesting that accidents are normal.

After the first announcement, the media give us bland interviews with responsible-sounding official spokesmen for the rescue authorities. Later on, the probing investigative journalists raise questions focusing on the specific circumstances of the disaster.

For instance, after the King's Cross fire, we heard a great deal about rubbish not being cleared from under wooden escalators. Similarly. it was supposedly the fact that the ferry's bow doors were still open when the Herald of Free Enterprise left harbour which caused it to capsize: a superficial explanation. like saying the ferry sank because it shipped water. It explains nothing.

The journalists do not ask whether such major disasters have general features in common. Yet accidents are a social problem deserving serious analysis: social and economic factors are an essential part of this analysis.

No one can deny the scale of this problem. Year after year, day after day. accidents, large and small, keep on happening. Houses bum down and sleeping children are killed. On the roads accidents are so frequent, so 'normal'' that they are seldom reported: every year thousands of people are killed and injured on Britain's roads by accident.

In the area of "work-related accidents", we do not even know how many accidents occur since, as a RoSPA spokesman told me. "under-reporting is a major problem". However. RoSPA estimate that about half the construction industry's accidents are not reported. Even so. in 1986-87, nearly 20,000 accidents involving personal injury (serious enough to keep a worker at least three days off work) were reported in the construction industry. In energy and water supply, a similar number of serious accidents was reported, amounting to 39 for every 10.000 employees each year, or about one worker in 20. In offices and shops, the statistics are extremely unreliable: possibly two-thirds of these accidents are not reported. RoSPA noticed an increase in under-reporting after the abolition of Industrial Injury Benefit (1982-83): government regulations now only require employers to report fatal and "major" accidents. The statistics are only the tip of the iceberg.

Accidents, then, however startling at first sight, in fact happen frequently and are a normal part of everyday life. We can and should regard them as a social problem, rooted in and illustrating the characteristics of the capitalist system.

Of course, it would be wrong to claim that in some ideal, Utopian world, accidents would never happen. Accidents can be caused by human failing — a moment's inattention, a miscalculation, a safety precaution carelessly overlooked. To some extent then "accidents will happen", since only robots perform their functions at all times with maximum efficiency.

The frequency and scale of accidents is such that they deserve analysis like other regularly recurring social phenomena. Accidents have a place in the history of humanity, as indicators of underlying features of our social and economic system.

Plelchanoy wrote that "accident is something relative . . .  if appears only at the point of intersection of inevitable processes": (The Role of the Individual in History)- The accidental is a part of history. Apart from everyday disasters (fires, road accidents and the like), the accidental plays a part in politics. In the USA. the selection of candidates for political office and a place in the history books has a lot to do with the accidental. Edward Kennedy could have become President, but for Chappaquiddick. Gary Hart's campaign was wrecked by media snooping into his sex life. The point is that there is a pattern, a common theme linking these "accidents", private peccadilloes. which affect the political scene.

Where "democratic" electoral processes are involved, public opinion has to be managed. Image-building is a major feature of election campaigns, interacting with the pollsters and the media for whom a scooped scandal means higher TV ratings and readership figures. Also, the party is identified with the leader: the only major issue discussed is the personality of the candidate. Hence the muckraking, searching for any sign of mortal frailty: a leader must not have feet of clay.

A common theme can be shown, also, when one analyses accidental disasters, such as this recent short list: the fire at Bradford City football stadium, the capsize of the Herald of Free Enterprise, the fires at King's Cross underground station, and on the Piper Alpha oil-rig in the North Sea.

First, the football club: run as a business, it had to economise on staff to keep costs down. As a result, rubbish under the stands was not cleared. When a lighted match was dropped, the rubbish caught fire. The superficial "cause" was the accumulation of rubbish. The underlying cause was saving on labour-costs to balance the books.

Next, the Channel ferry disaster: this did not happen simply because the bow doors were left open as the ferry left harbour. One has to ask why this happened. Any ferry company has to minimise turn-round time in harbour so as to keep costs as low as possible. This way they can carry more cargo and ensure a higher return on capital invested. Also, to maintain high profits, they have to keep to a minimum the number of workers, to save on labour-costs. The result can be seamen tired out from excessively long shifts and half asleep on the job.

Long before this disaster, the design of roll-on,roll-off ferries was criticised. In previous accidents, the lack of internal bulkheads caused extremely rapid capsize but ferry companies resisted the call for the bulkheads. Their view was. and is, that to have a lot of internal bulkheads taking up valuable cargo space, means allowing more time for loading and unloading not being able to get so many lorries, coaches and cars on board. All this would be bad for profits: profits take priority over safety precautions.

London Transport's blatant lack of concern about safety is also related to the need to minimise costs — especially labour costs. At King's Cross, the number of staff had been reduced, consequently cleaning under the escalators was neglected and rubbish accumulated which easily ignited. Other aspects of LRT's cost-cutting included their failure to install smoke detectors, costed at King's Cross in 1966 at only £450. or to train staff in the use of water-sprinklers. (New Scientist, 7 July 1988). This was a classic case of predictable and avoidable accident which happened because costs had to be balanced against revenue.

Lastly, the fire on the Piper Alpha oil-rig was what RoSPA calls a "work-related" accident. The practice of keeping off-duty workers on the rigs, in accommodation directly above the drilling or pumping operation, helped keep down the costs of this very profitable industry. It also ensured a large number of deaths when fire broke out. The North Sea oil industry had been skimping systematically on safety. There was the practice of issuing fake inspection reports on the construction components of North Sea platforms. There was a constant conflict between the requirement to inspect properly and management's insistence that inspection must not hold up the flow of oil (Nick Hughes, Channel 4, 26 July 1988).

And there was the practice of sub-contracting responsibility down a chain of contractors and sub-contractors, insurers and re-insurers. That way, all concerned could spread the risk, as in a game of musical parcels. However. when the music stopped, workers trapped on that oil-rig could only choose between being roasted where they were or to hurl themselves into a sea of flaming oil. The oil companies, shipyards, contractors and sub contractors, if they lost anything, lost money, not lives.

Keep the oil flowing. Keep the ferries to-ing and fro-ing. Don't hold things up for staff training or fire-drills. Have as few people as possible working as fast as possible to produce as much as possible at the lowest possible cost. That is how capitalist businesses have to operate. That is the pressure which helps to bring about accidents.

Although capitalism does not need to operate without concern for safety, there are constraints and pressures on any enterprise to keep down costs in order to raise profitability. These pressures mean that work is done in haste by too few people working too fast: haste and fatigue are inevitable, given these pressures. Tired people working in a hurry are likely to make mistakes.

The solution usually suggested is legislation. However, experience of protective legislation indicates that companies evade inconvenient regulations. In the nuclear industry, for instance, where safety should be of paramount importance and international regulation is elaborate and detailed, it is well known that European organisations practise "flag-swapping" of uranium for commercial convenience to avoid strict safeguards rules” (Environment Now, August 1988).

Regulations do not get at the root cause of accidents. Besides, companies take their business to other countries to avoid restrictions. which are not properly enforced when government-financed watchdogs, like the Health and Safety Executive, are chronically under-resourced.

Accidents highlight the way the capitalist system operates: it inevitably increases risks. It is not feasible to produce as much as possible as fast as possible without having haste and fatigue as inevitable by-products, inherent in the pressure to make profits.

Haste and fatigue makes errors and accidents more likely. But that is not the whole story Workers are often concerned about excessive risks at work. But their objections are typically brushed aside, the "troublemakers" are sacked and blacklisted and union representation is discouraged. Management's priority is to make profits and nothing is to be allowed to get in the way. If management proves to be "not up to the job", another set of managers who are less squeamish will be appointed.

Accidents then do result in part from mistakes but at some point those in position so power will have made conscious decisions which make accidents more likely to happen and so help to cause them. At bottom, almost every accident or disaster is a tribute to the warped, "profits before people ", priorities of the capitalist system.
Charmian Skelton


Blogger's Note:
  • The March 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard carried an article by Clifford Slapper on the Kings Cross fire.
  • The August 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard carried an article by Brian Gardner on the Piper Alpha explosion.

Thatcher: the last Briton (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

"Europe: open for business"
This is the frankly utilitarian, not to say cynical, slogan adopted by the Department of Trade and Industry for its campaign to publicise the so-called Single European Market that is supposed to come into existence in 1992.

Wisely, from their own point of view, this campaign is directed primarily at business people since it would be difficult to interest ordinary wage and salary earners in something that is so obviously irrelevant to our daily lives. We don't export and we don't import. and the only markets we are involved in are the labour market in which we sell our mental and physical energies, and the supermarket where we buy our weekly supplies. All the same, we are obliged to make some attempt to follow what the bosses are up to.

As its name suggests, the European Common Market is an economic and trading arrangement between a number of European states, twelve at present, including Britain and Ireland. It was set up under the Treaty of Rome signed in 1957. which was modified last year by a new Treaty known, for some reason, as the Single European Act.

The original treaty provided for the establishment of a "European Economic Community" (to give the Common Market its somewhat grandiose official title) which would be something more than a mere free trade area in which commodities could circulate free from customs duties and import quotas. It was to be a single economic area in which capital and professional services, as well as goods, could circulate unhindered, not just by customs restrictions but also by other barriers such as those arising from different technical standards and from collecting taxes at frontier posts. The 1987 Single European Act essentially only changed the decision-making procedures so as to make it easier to achieve this goal by the end of 1992.

Customs restrictions between the Common Market countries have long since been removed (since 1968 in fact) and a common external tariff against outside goods has been erected. Customs posts still exist, of course, but they are concerned either with commodities coming into the Common Market from outside or with checking that incoming goods conform to a country's technical standards or with collecting taxes or checking that they have been paid.

The mere abolition of customs duties and quotas between Common Market countries has proved insufficient to ensure the free flow of commodities between them. The member countries still found ways of protecting their home markets from competition even from other member countries. Germany, for instance, used its "purity law” on beer to keep out imports of beer from other Common Market countries on the grounds that they contained banned chemicals and additives (as indeed they did. and as does most German beer produced for consumption outside Germany). The European Court of Justice struck this down as contrary to the Treaty of Rome, as it has done in many similar cases involving nearly all the Common Market countries (Italy over pasta, Britain over UHT milk and so on).

The way in which national technical standards present a barrier to the free flow of commodities is explained in one of the Department of Trade and Industry's factsheets for businesspeople:
Most Member States have their own standards and laws which are important in setting quality and safety requirements for goods sold in their national home market National standards can be a serious barrier to trade when different standards apply in other Member States; or often a bigger obstacle when Member States do not recognise each others' arrangements for testing and certifying products to ensure that they meet national or EC standards.

These 'technical' barriers fragment the market and add to costs by forcing producers to modify their products, or by subjecting them to different national testing and certification procedures. if they wish to sell them in other Member States. All too often the effect is to discourage firms from seeking orders in other parts of the Community National technical barriers will be progressively eliminated as the single market is completed. By then any product which can be sold in the Member State in which it is produced will be freely marketable in other parts of the EC. unimpeded by different national standards and testing and certification practices (DTI Single Market Factsheet 2).
So this is what all the fuss is about, achieving by the end of 1992. besides the completion of the free movement of capital (some Common Market countries still impose exchange control restrictions) and professional services (it is still not possible for all professional people who have qualified in one country to practise freely in the other countries). the removal of the barrier to the free movement of commodities represented by national technical standards. From the end of 1992 health, safety and other technical standards will either be European or mutually acceptable. At the same time ways of collecting and checking on the payment of taxes other than by physically stopping lorries at frontier posts will be found. And. by pure coincidence, the Channel Tunnel linking Britain physically to the rest of Europe, is due to open in 1993.

What then? Some European politicians want to go on to an Economic and Monetary Union, involving a common European currency (which already exists for some accounting purposes) and a European Central Bank. Others want to go even further and look forward to the emergence of a federal United States of Europe. Mrs Thatcher is vehemently opposed to both. In a radio interview with Jimmy Young in July, she said that the first would "never come in my life-time, and I hope never at all". As to the second, it was simply "not possible":
It is not possible to have a United States of Europe. What is possible is for the 12 countries of Europe to work more closely together on things we would do better together, so that we can trade better together
(Independent, 28 July 1988). 
Actually, apart from the narrow-minded British nationalist prejudice that is typical of her attitudes, Thatcher's view of Europe does correspond more accurately to what the Common Market is in practice and to what the Treaty of Rome meant it to be. Despite what she says however, it would be quite possible to have a United States of Europe if the governments and public opinions of the member countries were to agree to this. But this would require a new. political treaty going way beyond the essentially economic aims of the 1957 Treaty that set up the Common Market. It is true that a directly-elected European Parliament (the next elections are due in June), a European Court of Justice making binding decisions and a European civil service headed by an embryo executive composed of politicians already exist, but their powers, such as they are, do not extend beyond the strictly economic field defined by the Treaty of Rome.

The prospect of the disappearance of the kind of petty nationalism peddled by Thatcher and her equivalents in the other European countries is a welcome one, but that does not mean that we socialists are in favour of a federal European State. Certainly we are non-nationalists and we do want to see a world without frontiers, but a single European State would represent the emergence of another capitalist superpower to vie with imperialist America and state capitalist Russia for the domination of the world. This in no way corresponds to the sort of world we want to see established where there would be no states and no national frontiers but, instead, a single democratic World Community based on the common ownership of the Earth's resources, natural and industrial.
Adam Buick

Funds appeal (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

It is a long time since we made an appeal for funds in these columns and we do so only when the work of the Party shows signs of outstripping its finances.

To sell the Socialist Standard at 40p and to try to keep the price-range of our literature as low as possible involves a subsidy from the General Fund which slowly erodes it. Add to this the routine things like electricity, telephone and rates, and it is not long before we have to look round to see what we can cut back on, when we should be expanding our activities for socialism and going forward.

We are well aware that our fellow workers to whom we address this appeal have their own financial worries. If, however, you think it is worth getting rid of the system which produces them, please send as much or as little as you can. Cheques should be crossed, made payable to the Socialist Party of Great Britain and sent to the Treasurer at 52 Clapham High Street, London SW4 7UN.

Alternatively you can transfer any contribution directly to our account no 02823446 at the National Westminster Bank, 145 Clapham High Street, London SW4.

The real world (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

When was the last time that someone accused you of not living in the real world? The definition is a subjective one. What conditions the attitudes, opinions and views of those who are either content to live under the present system of society, or of those who feel the need to modify capitalism to meet their perception of a fairer, more equal society? Leaving aside for the moment the factors which influence the majority into an acceptance of capitalism, (as Marx said, the prevailing ideas in society are those of the ruling class) let us concentrate on the power of the state and its hold over those it governs.

Your attitude towards the state is determined by your position in the political spectrum. The Libertarian Right would like to extend the principle of laissez-faire to Social Services. Education, the National Health Service and Nationalised Industries. This process is already being put into effect by the present government. The "freedom of choice" offered by those who want a free market affecting every aspect of our life is a choice based on the ability to pay for the commodities and services on offer. There is no place in this philosophy for the poor, the weak or the sick. To describe this system of society as envisaged by the Right as the law of the jungle is to libel animals who are incapable of behaving in this manner.

The Leftist view of the state, a view seen through rose-coloured spectacles, is that of the Nanny State. Here the state is perceived as providing care for its citizens from the cradle to the grave. This ideal may have a superficial attractiveness but the underlying supposition is that the capitalist system will continue in its present form. The Left sees the state as providing palliatives to the inherent problems of capitalism. A case of treating the effects and not the cause.

What of the majority of apolitical citizens? Brainwashed from birth into accepting what the ruling class tells them, their view of the functions of the state is an extremely simplistic one. A soap powder commercial once asked. "What is a Mum?" The advertising agency responsible for it then answered its own question with a series of answers designed to elicit the correct emotional response from its audience. Likewise, in order that those who are subject to the power of the state should not look too closely at the prime purpose of the state it utilises whatever means are necessary to ensure that the opinions of the majority mirror those of Auden's Unknown Citizen. "Our researchers into Public Opinion are content that he held the proper opinions for the time of the year; When there was peace, he was for peace; When there was war he went . . . Was he free? Was he happy? The question is absurd: Had anything been wrong, we should certainly have heard".

When the political bosses pull the strings a suitable response occurs — Britain is best; Isn't our monarchy wonderful. It 's all the fault of foreigners; Things were different when we still had an Empire . . .

What is the knowledge about itself that the state tries so hard to keep hidden from those that it governs? The state is the public power of coercion created and maintained in human societies by their division into classes. a power which, being clothed with force, makes laws and levies taxes. The state is not just an administrative machine; its centred feature is force. In class societies the state is used by the ruling class to serve its ends. Today the capitalists are the ruling class so the state serves their ends.

The ordinary citizen, aware that secret intelligence organisations like MI5 and MI6 exist, naively believes that the second oldest profession in the world is there to protect their interests. We may safely assume that the majority of these citizens are unaware of the scope of the activities of these security organisations on behalf of their political masters. M15, set up in 1909 has increasingly been used since the 1970s against domestic targets considered subversive. It works closely with the Special Branch which is estimated to have two million personal files, twice as many as MI5. In 1984 the Home Office published guidelines which describe the function of both the Special Branch and MI5 as gathering information about "threats to public order" and defending the realm against "attempts at espionage and sabotage or from the actions of persons and organisations whether directed from within or without the country which may be judged to be subversive to the state".

Just because you're paranoid it doesn't mean that they're not out to get you. Those of you who are. or have been, members of Left and Right wing radical groups including feminists, pacifists. CND. nationalists and of course socialists will have come to the attention of section F7, a sub-division of MI5’s counter subversion division. Should you believe that you do not fall into any of the categories mentioned, being an upright, sober, patriotic citizen, take heed. Should you believe that all these commies, gays. lesbians. lefties, trade unionists and socialists deserve all they get for daring to question the values of this wonderful society of ours, even a letter to your local rag criticising the state may result in attention from your unfriendly local Special Branch.

Those who believe that it is the plight of others to live under oppressive regimes which practice terror and torture in order to control the working class should perhaps draw a salutary lesson from the fate of Hilda Murrell, an anti-nuclear campaigner and Aunt of Rob Green, an officer aboard the submarine that sank the General Belgrano. during the Falklands War who was murdered at her home. The crime remains unsolved. Issue number 16 of Lobster contains an article by a writer with very close links with government Intelligence Agencies. He points out that before her death Hilda Murrell was the subject of attention by at least five Intelligence Agencies. He concludes. "I am confident beyond any reasonable shadow of a doubt that the death of Miss Murrell was caused by private investigators or security consultants acting on behalf of a government department."

Moral indignation is not enough, reprehensible as these activities are. Although one person's terrorist may be another's freedom fighter the object of the struggle in which they are engaged is likely to be the continuance of capitalism, the system of society which encourages violence, legalised or not. But who carries out these actions on behalf of their respective governments and ultimately the capitalist ruling class? The answer is of course members of the working class. Imbued as they are by notions of misplaced patriotism and devotion to a system of society that exploits them, they continue to gather information for the files on their fellow members of the working class, or even commit murder on behalf of the owning class.

The use of intimidation, torture and coercion is practised worldwide because capitalism is a worldwide system. Mongane Wally Serote of South Africa describes his personal experience of the coercive State in Index On Censorship. May 1988: "Physical torture was extremely intense. I never thought a human being could go to that level, but I saw them do it and they are free men even now, they sleep with their wives, they talk to their children, even now. extremely cruel people, very cruel people. It's a thing I will never forget. I can't forget.”

Despite the considerable power that the state has at its command, emanating from the economic power of the ruling class resulting from their monopoly of the means of production and distribution, its influence holds good merely because the working-class allow it. "One man is king only because other men stand in the relation of subjects to him. They, on the contrary, imagine that they are subjects because he is king." (Footnote, Capital, Volume One). How then may this menacing monster, whose tentacles reach into the lives of everyone, be displaced? Those who believe that the state may be violently overthrown and replaced by a People's State, or believe that the revolution in Russia has led to a half-way house between capitalism and communism are sadly misguided. The destruction and abolition of the state and of the antagonistic class society will only come, through the ballot box. when the majority of the working class, worldwide, understand and accept the case for supplanting the government of people by the administration of things.
Dave Coggan

EETPU: a bosses' union? (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

As expected this year's TUC conference held in Bournemouth at the beginning of September voted to expel the electricians' union (EETPU). Contrary to the impression given by much of the media the expulsion was not for making single union deals or for making no strike agreements. Regarding the former, these are accepted as legitimate by most unions and have a long history. John Edmonds of the General, Municipal and Boilermakers Union (GMB) outlined how the forerunner to this organisation signed its first single union deal 99 years ago at a gas works. The Transport and General Workers Union (TGWU) outlined in a recent memorandum to its members that it had no real objection to single union deals. The reason for the expulsion was that the EETPU broke the rules of the TUC regarding inter-union relations as contained in the Bridlington Agreement which dates back to 1939. The EETPU were in breach of this ruling in two cases. At Orion in Port Talbot the TGWU had members but the company gave the electricians sole negotiating rights in a single union agreement. The second case concerned two Christian Salvensen plants in Warrington and London where the company offered a single union deal to the EETPU without consulting three other unions with whom it also had agreements. Complaints from the other unions involved were investigated by the TUC disputes committee who found the EETPU in the wrong. Consequently the electricians' union were asked to withdraw from these agreements and it was their refusal to do so which led first of all to their suspension and finally to their expulsion.

Hammond's defence of his union s strategy was summed up in his speech to congress. No apology was made or intended for breaking the rules of the movement of which the EETPU had been a part. Instead Hammond outlined how those who were opposed to his way of thinking were out of touch with their members. The EETPU are, he said, the modern face of trade unionism. The union had an open door and any person was free to come in or walk out. Modern trade unionism was about communicating with its members and providing people with individual choice.

Hammond's speech raised many queries. What kind of communication through trade union democracy does the EETPU offer? What does it mean by individual choice? In a society where the majority have to sell their ability to work to the owners of the means of production and distribution and need effective organisation, what sort of trade unionism is the EETPU offering to workers?

A member of SOGAT 82 in a letter to The Guardian, (8 September. 1988) notes how the EETPU's claim that it is one of the more democratic unions is open to question. Of its 150 full-time officers only 15 are subject to election. This number includes the general secretary and the executive council (E.C.) with the remainder of the full-time officers being appointed by the E.C. A rule introduced in 1977 allowing appointed officials to stand for election to the E.C. makes it more difficult for lay members to successfully seek election to that body as full-time officers have more influence and are in a better position to gain support. Motions to the union's conference have to be submitted first to the E.C. for their consideration. The E.C. also have some influence over delegates to the conference. Each branch can elect one delegate only irrespective of its size and additional delegates are elected by industrial conference, the number elected being determined by the executive council.

Hammond's claim about offering workers more individual choice is based on the same type of hypocrisy as the present government's supposed concern for trade union democracy. The EETPU have become renowned for single union deals in recent years. For example the two agreements previously mentioned; the choice of which union was to be given sole representation and negotiating rights was not made by the workers themselves but was decided over their heads by union leaders and the employers concerned. In such circumstances even if workers are given the opportunity to join an alternative union of their own choice, that organisation would not be able to exert any influence within the plant as it will be denied the right to represent its members. Also, single union deals mean that workers seeking a job in a plant which recognises only one union will, if that union is not the one recognised by the company, have to resign from the union of their choice and join the one recognised by the company. The truth is that single union deals, particularly the type pursued by the EETPU, offer workers less choice than multi-union agreements. In a society which offers the majority little choice in any respect it is important that workers should be able to decide which union represents them.

This leads on to perhaps the most important question: just what type of trade unionism is on offer from Hammond's brand of new realism ?

Apart from the fact that it is left to union leaders and employers to decide which union should, in this case, misrepresent workers. this brand of unionism weakens the main weapon workers have in defending themselves their ability to withdraw their labour. Socialists whilst supporting the use of the strike weapon do not do so out of some idealistic belief that the right to strike is a fundamental human right which is the hallmark of any free society. Our experience shows us that such a perspective can only be supported by those with little understanding of the world they live in.

In a truly free and democratic society the means for producing and distributing the things we need to live will be owned in common and subject to democratic control and productive capacity will be used directly to satisfy self determined human need. In such a society the need to strike would not be necessary. However ability to withdraw one's labour is not a right but an absolute necessity for the working class in a society where the majority have to sell their ability to work to those who own and control the productive capacity. Such a society is divided into two antagonistic classes. It is in the interests of the employing class to buy labour power as cheaply as possible and to be able to control it to realise a value from it in excess of that paid out in wages and salaries. On the opposite side of the class divide are the working class whose interest lies in getting as high a price as possible for the sale of their labour power as it is their only means of economic survival.

Workers also need to be organised to be able to resist, where possible, attempts to reorganise production since this may lead to a deterioration of working or economic conditions.

Hammond claims that he can overcome this inherent conflict of interest and forge a partnership between capital and labour. One idea is that instead of resorting to industrial action when a conflict cannot be resolved through the collective bargaining process both sides should agree to the contentious issue being put to pendulum arbitration. Under this method an independent' outside arbitrator will examine the issue in dispute and decide in favour of one side or the other — a compromise solution is ruled out. This system is beneficial to workers, it is claimed, because it prevents management from being able to impose a unilateral decision on the workforce. The point is that providing workers have as a back up to the collective bargaining process the freedom to take industrial action, they will be in a position to prevent unilateral management action and what is more important their ability to do so here rests on independent self-organisation. Under no-strike pendulum arbitration agreements workers are left without the option of putting economic pressure on the arbitrator who is thus more likely to decide in favour of the dominant interests of capital.

Where does the expulsion of the EETPU leave the British trade union movement? A report in The Guardian (10 September, 1988) suggested that Tony Christopher, the new chairperson of the TUC, will be making attempts to get the EETPU back into the TUC. Such a move may include reviewing the Bridlington Rules, the breaking of which led to the expulsion. The fact that a merger between the Amalgamated Engineering Union (AEU). a member of the TUC and the EETPU now a non member, is still set to go ahead will create obvious problems. However the re-entry of the EETPU to the fold seems unlikely to take place smoothly. In reality what lies behind the split goes deeper than the breaking of the rules of the TUC even though that was the reason for the expulsion. Essentially it concerns the face of modern trade unionism. Such disagreements cannot be simply put down to a right-left division. Some unions considered to be right of centre are very much opposed to the methods of the EETPU. For example John Edmonds of the GMB, not renowned for adopting a militant standpoint and. in many respects, a keen supporter of 'new realism', made the following statement at the congress.
I totally reject the hyped up notion that the only way to be a modern trade union is to forget our basic task of looking after people and to accept values handed down by multi-nationals based in Wapping and Detroit. We are not here to do a favour for Lord Hanson or to pout prettily for Rupert Murdoch. We are here to win dignity for working people at work.
(quoted in The Guardian. 6 September. 1988) 
The working class have no need for organisations which in effect are little more than company unions designed to help companies pursue the efficient exploitation of their workforce. Effective, democratically controlled organisations are needed which can be put to use in workers' struggles. There is a dangerous idea being developed, probably not for the first time, that to survive trade unions need to become more involved with company objectives. For example a recent study by David Metcalf. Professor of Industrial Relations at the London School of Economics, indicates that companies are better off without unions. Non-union companies, the study suggests, have both higher productivity and profits than companies operating with trade unions. Socialists wish to inform Professor Metcalf that unions, contrary to the impression he seems to have, do not exist to raise productivity and profits. In fact the study does provide (probably unintentionally) evidence of the usefulness of effective trade unionism in modern capitalist society. Firstly it states that in unionised firms wage differentials by race, sex and occupation are narrower than in non-unionised companies. Secondly it shows that employees belonging to trade unions are paid 7-10 per cent more than those not belonging to unions. The higher the density of union membership the greater is the wage mark up, with closed shops proving best of all. Less skilled and lower paid women and particularly black workers gain from union membership when compared with white male skilled workers in non-unionised firms. Unions have also had some success in protecting the under privileged at work and this has caused problems for the present government in its efforts to encourage more lower paid jobs in the services to mop up the unemployed. The benefit of trade unions to lower paid workers is shown by the fact that employers in the service industries such as hotel and catering are vehemently opposed to unionisation as they rely on imposing extremely low wages and long hours of work on their workforce which contains a high proportion of women and immigrant workers.

Thus the case for all workers belonging to and becoming active in trade unions is as clear today as it ever was. There are indications which suggest that amongst many groups of workers there is the beginnings of a rebirth of militancy', meaning they are getting fed up with being kicked around. This has been notable in recent months amongst car workers, seamen and most recently postal workers. Even though a small sample poll conducted for the Sunday Times found that 42% of trade unionists backed the EETPU whilst only 32 per cent supported the TUC. the same poll, even more significantly, found that almost two thirds objected to a no-strike clause being included in single union deals. As Ian Aitkin, writing in The Guardian (5 September. 1988) suggests "without such a clause a good many employers would find Mr Hammond's single union agreements a good deal less appealing. "

The problems many workers face is the economic cost of taking industrial action in order to defend themselves. This very fact should reveal to workers that under the present organisation of society they are far from free but are. on the contrary, subject to a form of dictatorship — economic dictatorship. It is the organisation of present day worldwide society which makes it necessary for workers to combine to protect themselves. This society has also created a body of women and men who wish to go further than the defensive struggle within capitalism to which trade unionism is confined. Socialists have as their aim the ending of a system of wage slavery by removing the conditions on which it rests. Marx noted how the position of the free labourer under capitalism differs from the slave who sold his or her self to a owner, or a serf who was tied to the land. "The worker". Marx explains.
. . . belongs neither to the owner nor the land, but eight, ten. twelve, fifteen hours of his daily life belong to him who buys them. The worker leaves the capitalist to whom he hires himself whenever he likes, and the capitalist discharges him whenever he thinks fit. as soon as he no longer gets any profit out of him. or not the anticipated profit. But the worker whose sole source of livelihood is the sale of his labour power, cannot leave the whole class of purchasers, that is, the capitalist class, without renouncing his existence. He belongs not to this or that capitalist but to the capitalist class, and moreover. it is his business to dispose of himself, that is to find a purchaser within the capitalist class."
Ray Carr

Burma: a tiger by the tail (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Burmese army is now an occupation force. It holds in power a brutal military regime which itself is the last bastion of the “Socialist” Party of Burma, the BSPP. Since the uprising began three months ago thousands have died and the country now teeters on the brink of a bloody civil war. How can we account for this sudden explosion after twenty six years of silence?

The Burma Socialist Programme Party seized power after a military coup in 1962. At its head stood General Ne Win, who proclaimed that he would follow “the Burmese Road to Socialism”. Needless to say, this had little to do with the common ownership and democratic control of the means of producing and distributing wealth. Instead, it meant State Capitalism in the Stalinist mould. The Party took direct control of all aspects of the economy and suppressed all opposition to its rule. Ne Win also imposed a policy of rigorous isolation from the world market – a direct analogue to Stalin’s untenable notion of “Socialism in One Country”. Foreign investment was ostentatiously shunned, and as late as 1986 foreign businessmen were being expelled for “importing corruption”.

The effects on the economy were catastrophic. Bad planning, fuel shortages, and a lack of foreign currency for spare parts and new equipment soon made a shambles of the distribution system. Despite an extremely fertile agriculture and good harvests, food was simply not getting through to the cities. In the first six months of this year the price of rice rose 400 per cent and growing numbers of people found it difficult to feed themselves and their families.

In July, popular anger finally spilled over into the streets. Mass demonstrations broke out throughout Burma, and a general strike paralysed the country. The state responded by letting the army loose. In the space of one week in August, 3000 unarmed demonstrators were killed. When even this failed to crush the uprising, a shaken Ne Win resigned. Shortly afterwards the army was withdrawn from the streets after several hundred soldiers had refused to fire on crowds. A civilian, Maung Maung, then took over with promises of reform.

It was too little and much too late. The opposition was now demanding not only economic reform, but the abolition of one party rule, freedom of expression and a return to multi-party democracy through free elections. Protests were stepped up and the remaining authority of the BSPP began to disintegrate. In Mandalay, central government ceased to function, and the city was run for several weeks by Buddhist monks.

Although the uprising appeared to be skilfully coordinated, there was no one national opposition group, and no central leadership. Local initiatives appear to have come from clandestine student groups and local committees of Buddhist monks, but the rising has otherwise been entirely spontaneous, taking in a broad cross-section of Burmese society.

With the survival of the Burmese ruling class now in jeopardy, the army stepped into take control on the 22nd of September The new leader was General Saw Maung, a close associate of the former ruler Ne Win. General Maung had already replaced his unreliable troops with soldiers from the minority Chins tribe. These hill people had been used by the British in the past for putting down the “Native” Burmese, and had few inhibitions about gunning down civilians.

Throughout the poorer quarters of true capital Rangoon, barricades went up and workers armed themselves with whatever was to hand – principally sharpened bicycle spokes fired by catapults. The result was never in doubt. According to eye witnesses thousands were killed in “an exercise in calculated brutality” (The Guardian, 23 September 88). On the third of October the general strike was broken after General Maung threatened the half starved workers with mass redundancies.

The Burmese uprising is now entering new and dangerous phase. The time for peaceful protest appears to have passed, and the talk now is of taking up arms. In Rangoon, a student group calling itself the Burma Revolutionary Force has been formed to strike at the military. Its 21 year old leader told a correspondent, “we will fight. We will all die ourselves rather than let the military government continue” (Observer, 2 October 88). And there is plenty of support to hand.

In the mountainous border regions, seven: secessionist groups have been fighting for over forty years. At least 3000 students have already fled the cities to join them, and attempts are being made to form some sort of alliance. The army is clearly over-extended, and already reports are circulating of major rebel victories in outlying provinces.

There is no shortage of weapons either Firearms can be freely bought on the border; AK47 rifles cost a mere $100 each and grenades are going for £10 a dozen. In the cities, hundreds of police stations have already been stripped of their arms, and these are now mostly in the hands of the monks.

The Burmese ruling class – those whose position in the Party entitles them to live off the labour of the majority – clearly have a tiger by the tail. On the one hand, they cannot give in to the oppositions’ demands for political power without threatening their own survival. On the other hand, the economy which supports them lies in ruins. From being a leading producer of rice, teak and jade, Burma is now the seventh poorest country in the world, with a per capita income of £100.

Economic recovery demands that the notoriously inefficient and rigid centralised economy be dismantled – and here lies the rub. As we have seen in Russia, economic modernisation requires political change to accommodate more flexible market mechanisms. In other words it demands (very limited) moves towards more representative forms of government.

General Sein Lwin, who ran the country for three short weeks in July, expressed these contradictions. The party should “widen the scope for private enterprise in agriculture, mining and transport”, he said, and “liberalise foreign trade to encourage foreign investment”. (Economist, 20 July 1988). Yet the party is clearly not prepared to concede the more democratic structures which would allow such economic change to work. Thus General Maung has pledged to hold elections, but only under the “supervision”, of the BSPP and the army. The opposition parties have refused to participate until the BSPP is disbanded and a neutral transitional regime is in place.

There are other economic drawbacks to naked military control. Despite Ne Win’s rhetoric, no state can cut itself off from the world market for long without suffering rapid economic decline. The architect of the “Burmese Road to Socialism” bowed to this iron law when Burma’s huge foreign debt forced him to go cap in hand to the United Nations last year.

Burma was than granted “Least Developed Nation” status, which entitled it to “soft” loans and development grants. This alone has kept the economy from total collapse. Now foreign governments are threatening to suspend their aid programmes until the army returns to barracks and an accommodation is reached with the opposition.

And what of the opposition? All their remarkable bravery cannot disguise the fact that it is senseless to take on the armed power of the state on the streets. Furthermore, a long drawn out and barbaric guerrilla war will simply result in the brutalisation of all the participants. The Burmese people can see examples in the world today. Even where the guerrillas are “successful”, as in Cambodia or Vietnam, the resulting regime is as likely to be even more brutal than the regime it replaced. Otherwise the prospect is of a bitter and protracted struggle such as that being fought with increasing savagery and little prospect of success by the Sendero Lumo in Peru or the NPA in the Phillippines.

According to latest reports, Burmese workers are waging a more covert form of struggle in their workplaces – go slows, sabotage, turning up to get paid then going straight home. No modern economy can function without at least the grudging support of its workforce, and while the present situation continues, the Burmese ruling class can expect only stagnation or collapse. Their only long term option is to concede some measure of democratic control to the opposition. Economic imperatives may yet achieve what bullets and barricades cannot.
Andrew Thomas

Between the Lines: The Fuhrer speaks backwards (1988)

The Between the Lines Column from the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Fuhrer speaks backwards

Wogan (5 October 88. BBC1. 7 pm) had as a guest a man called David Fuhrer whose talent' is the remarkable ability to pronounce words back to front. It must have taken him years to become such a krej — sorry, I meant jerk — One can imagine Mother Fuhrer standing over the little child prodigy telling him to go upstairs and practice his talking backward or he wouldn't grow up to get his £500 Nagow Eef.

A day earlier Neil Kconnik had given his Leader's speech in what might well be described as Fuhrer-Speak. As ever, it was hard to know quite what the gas emanating from Kinnock was supposed to signify, but one heard fragments of back-to-front shouting about how a future Labour government would have to face reality if it was going to use power for the people who are in need. This meant, said Kinnock. without even the remotest consciousness of its implication, that "We must understand that our rôle is to manage the market better than the Tories." Forget socialism, or even the pretense of it; Kinnock is a self-declared candidate to administer the capitalist system, for only under that social arrangement can the market, with its buying and selling for profit, exist. The following day Nor Ddot of the UWGT (otherwise known as Ron Todd of the TGWU when he is inspired to rise above the language of mumbo-jumbo) complained bitterly that Young Lien was betraying the principles (sic) of the great old Labour Party. So confident had Old Nor been that the Leader would not act like all previous Labour leaders and tell his supporters to toe the line or og ot Heh that Nor had cast over a million T&G votes the day before in the election to keep Kinnock as leader. Terry Wogan was evidently delighted to have as a guest a man whose accomplishment in the art of reversing the sounds of words was so sophisticated. Fuhrer is doubtlessly teaching Tel the party trick at this very moment. Also, other fuhrers are practising other party tricks, with meanings, not sounds, being distorted out of all recognition.


The loony right tells it like it ain’t

On the night when BBC showed a fascinating drama documentary on the 1888 match girls' strike (5 October 88. 8.10 pm), two other programmes reminded us that some workers have not travelled far in the last century Revelations (BBC1. 9.30 pm) was about a family of fundamentalist American right-wingers. People who watch Christian TV and send big cheques to it each month; people who 'hate' workers receiving food stamps in West Virginia, the state where they live and where one quarter of the children are existing below the official poverty line; people who admit that they jumped for joy when American bombers raided Tripoli; people who think that guns represent the American way of life; people who would be dangerous if they were not pathetic, and mere subjects of psychological investigation were it not the case that votes like theirs will be helping to decide who will preside over the White House after this month's election. These are workers whose minds have been screwed up by a belief that the world is a jungle in which they, as Christian sinners and human-nature afflicted criminals, need the utmost repression to defend themselves from their own freedom. That they are screwed up in a homely, naive, almost endearing way is not the point; while there are workers as politically ignorant as them around socialists have a major task of education to pursue.

Of course, there is screwed up and screwed up. as was demonstrated by the other documentary on the same night Dispatches (C4. 8 30 pm) presented an investigation into the neo-fascist National Front. It was alleged that the NF is a terrorist organisation. linked to violent groups in Italy and Northern Ireland. The latter crowd shot a Belfast journalist called Jim Campbell, but, compared to the real murderers on the political stage — the armies, and particularly the power blocs such as NATO and the Warsaw Pact — these skinhead bootboys hardly amount to a threat to the political establishment, or. conversely, to decent values.

The new NF policy is based upon what they call 'the third way' — a claimed rejection of both capitalism and socialism. As part of the new philosophical thinking, the Front has fallen badly for Gaddafi's Green Book (a collection of half-baked Islamic rubbish) and asserts that the IRA is not a terrorist organisation because it does not kill civilians. We can ignore that kind of nonsense, but we would be pleased to learn exactly what the NF imagines the third way', which is neither capitalism (production for profit) nor socialism (production for use), actually means. The knee-jerk Left state that there is no point in communicating in any way with the NF. (This despite the fact that more than a few Leninists also think that Gaddafi has got it right and the IRA are misunderstood philanthropists. and despite the fact that the Leninist Left is just as leader-crazed and supportive of violent rhetoric as the NF.)

The Socialist Party/s willing to give a hearing to the case of the National Front. We will examine it, consider whether this 'third way' amounts to more than a fantasy for running capitalism, and, if. as we strongly suspect, it is nonsense we shall expose it as precisely that — a more worthwhile exercise than making documentaries showing that members of the NF are criminal types. If it is criminality that needs to be exposed, then the City of London is a worthier subject for investigation than a cloak-and-dagger sect which spends most of its time fighting over who will be Hitler and who will be Himmler, 'Come The Day’.
Steve Coleman