Sunday, November 15, 2026

Idealism v. Socialism. A Critic Answered. (1911)

From the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

The following criticism of the third chapter of Engels’ “Socialism, Utopian and Scientific,” raises objections to the fundamental principles of scientific Socialism. And as many others may jump to similar erroneous conclusions through failing first to master the elements of the problem, it will be both interesting and useful (at least to those desirous of understanding the Socialist philosophy) to review the points raised.

The criticism runs as follows :

“Scientific” Socialism.
A criticism of Engels' chapter on the above.

“The Socialist Party of Great Britain is founded upon the economic principles laid down by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, principles which, it must be admitted, are, on the whole, sound and well conceived. But on applying logic to the particular phase of the subject known as “Scientific Socialism,” one comes up against anomalous situations which it is here my purpose to point out.

My first point is this. Engels asserts, on p. 29 of his “Socialism, Utopian and Scientific,” that “the final causes of all social changes and political revolutions are to be sought, not in men’s brains, not in man’s better insight into eternal truth and justice, but in changes in the mode of production and exchange. They are to be sought, not in the philosophy, but in the economics of each particular epoch.”

The only term applicable to such a statement is “economic fatalism,” and such is the creed of Marx. Now if it be true that “ideas are secondary things in the changing or transforming of a society,” a statement that was made in the pamphlet “Socialism and Religion,” and which is the implication of the above Engelian assertion, does it not seem absurd that the S.P.G.B. should strive to educate the proletariat to class-consciousness ? Why educate if the “final causes are to be found not in mens’ brains”? Engels tells us that “society at present contains, in a more or less developed condition, the means of getting rid of the incongruities of capitalism,” and if that be so, how can man control, or can he control at all, these means, which I take to be economic forces ?

Socialism is a deduction from present-day phenomena,—it is not a fact but a theory—a theory based upon logical deduction. Therefore I cannot see how it can be scientific. But that being so, Socialism is not a remedy for poverty, etc., for Engels says “these means” (referred to above) “are not to be invented by deduction from fundamental principles, but are to be discovered in the stubborn facts of the present-day system of production.” (Page 30.)

Following upon the above, one is astounded by the following seeming contradiction : “The present structure of society is the creation of the ruling class of to-day.”

Surely this cannot be, for we have just been told that “changes must not be sought in men’s brains,” therefore to speak of the bourgeois class as the designers and creators of capitalism is obviously contradictory ; if the bourgeois class created capitalism, why cannot we infer that the proletariat will, by combined political action, create the Socialist system ?” The bourgeoisie broke up the feudal system and built upon its ruins the capitalist order of society” (Page 30.)

I defy the S.P.G.B. to disprove the statement that ideas are the predecessors of economic change. Ideas are not of secondary importance as stated in the pamphlet “Socialism and Religion,” but of primary importance. What transformed society in the time of the Revolution but inventions, that is, ideas ? What will abolish capitalism and bring Socialism but ideas ? We must educate the proletariat, must imbue that class with the idea of social ownership, must, in brief, preach Socialism. And then, when the proletariat has reached that point of intellectual impregnability termed class-consciousness, they will not hesitate to capture the political machinery, and utilising that machinery as a lever, will transform the capitalist State into the Socialist regime.

J. H. Lamb.

_______________________________

One’s first care in serious discussion must be correct terminology and accurate quotation. Now it is not correct to say that “economic fatalism” is the creed of Marx. The Socialist is not a fatalist but a determinist. Fatalism (even stripped of its gross superstition) ignores or defies man, and denies him his place among social forces ; thus falsifying sociology by suppressing an important factor. Determinism, on the other hand, gives man his due and recognises him as the vehicle of certain social forces with a part to play in social change that cannot be ignored. This is so even though man’s part is determined by heredity and environment—that is by past and present social conditions—and is ultimately explicable only from the economic basis. As the point has been put by Prof. Pannekoek :
“Not only the moral codes, but also other products of the human mind such as religion, science, arts, philosophy, were then understood to be connected with the actual material conditions of society. The human mind is influenced in all its products by the entire world outside of it. And thus the mind is seen to be a part of nature, and the science of the mind becomes a natural science. The impressions of the outer world determine the experience of man, his wants determine his will, and his general wants his moral will. The world around him determines man’s wants and impressions, but these, on the other hand, determine his will and activity by which he changes the world; this will-directed activity appears in the process of social production. In this manner man by his work is a part, a link in the great chain of natural and social development.” (Preface to Dietzgen’s “Positive Outcome of Philosophy.” Kerr.)
Thus the historic materialism of Marx and Engels (using the word materialism in its broad philosophic sense as opposed to idealism), while recognising the economic as the essential groundwork, embraces the whole of the factors—the reflex as well as the direct—and places them in their true relative positions.

Further, in the pamphlet on Socialism and Religion, issued by the Socialist Party, the statement which our correspondent puts in quotation marks nowhere occurs. As will be seen later, such a statement would convey a false impression. The passage our critic has in his mind is doubtless the following, which occurs in the preface to the second edition, now on sale.
“The Socialist case against religion differs widely from the usual Freethought position. There are Rationalist superstitions as well as Christian. Religion was not the wicked invention of charlatans, nor is the passing of superstition simply to be explained by the ‘triumph of Reason.’ As shown in the following pages the ‘march of mind,’ the development of science, and the decay of religion, are themselves ultimately explicable only from the evolution of economic conditions. Ideas play a secondary part in social development. They are the effects of the material environment on human beings, and are not the creative motive force of social evolution. Consequently, in his worship of the ‘idea’ the bourgeois freethinker is, like the Christian, attributing miraculous powers to the figments of men’s brains.”
Our critic’s misquotation shows that he confuses the gradual economic development with the conscious revolution.

It explains why he is “astounded” at Engels’ statement that the present structure of society is the creation of the bourgeoisie.

Marx has outlined the materialist conception of history in the preface to his “Critique of Political Economy,” and in the course of it he says :
“In considering such revolutions we must always distinguish clearly between the change in the industrial methods of social production on the one hand ; this change takes place unconsciously, according to the laws of natural science, and might properly be called an evolution.

And, on the other hand, the change in the legal, political, religious, artistic, philosophic, in short idealogical institutions ; with reference to these men fight out this battle as a revolution conscious of their opposing interests. This conflict takes the form of a class struggle.”
Hence the truth of Engels’ statement. Economically, capitalism has evolved ; politically it has been created. Ideas play an immediately prominent part in political revolutions, but they are themselves the products of previous conditions mainly economic. To our critic, however, ideas cause, or create, but are not themselves caused ! He calls them creative, and is extremely unwilling to look behind ideas at all lest he should discover them to be determined by social and economic conditions.

It is such an elementary truth that ideas are secondary to material change in the advance of the social organism that it requires all man’s insufferable conceit about his intellect to blind him to its recognition.

Our correspondent fails to give any argument in favour of Idealism, and his “defiance” and mere assertion are in no sense contributions to the discussion. Obviously, before mind could exist the material and forces which form it must have existed. Ideas, further, require the existence of brains, and are generated in the brain by experience, impressions, or sensations; racial or personal. They are the reasserted reflexes of first- and second hand experience, directed to more or less useful ends by the interests, wants and environment of the individual.

The mind, then, is a reflector—one with a highly developed and useful power of focussing and accumulating its reflections—but still a reflector in essence. This, however, is far from minimising the historic and social role of the products of the mind, and the importance of this role, secondary to material conditions though it is, is fully realised by scientific Socialism. Just as capitalist political and legal society is the product of the now dominant class, so will the establishment of Socialism be the work of the proletariat imbued with the Socialist idea. Now, the working class, as such, is a product of capitalism. Its interests, ideas, and aspirations, are the consequences of economic pressure and capitalist environment. Indeed, if it were not for economic development within the present system, Socialism itself would be neither necessary nor possible. It would not even be thinkable. But as it is, the direct effects of economic pressure and the material environment are caught up, reflected, and passed on by the mind, quickening the movement and propagating the idea among the workers.

Consequently ideas are the revivifying force of the working class movement, but only so long as the connection with material conditions is clear, close, and logical. So soon as this ceases to be the case, the faddist, the crank, the charlatan, or the traitor finds congenial soil, and the movement is proportionately retarded. But no ideas, whether sound or distorted, are original creative forces springing independently out of man’s head. All of them, given the antecedents, can be traced to earlier material causes. In short, ideas are not gods, though gods are ideas. They are social products.

Among the capitalist class the propaganda of revolutionary Socialism is utterly useless. Why? Precisely because (pace Mr. Lamb) “the final causes are not to be found in men’s brains,” and because ideas are secondary to the influence of the material environment. That is why we are a class party. That is why Socialism spreads amongst the workers, and propaganda among them is effective, adding definiteness and intensity to the movement.

Obviously it is by no means absurd, according to the determinist position, to strive to educate the proletariat to class-consciousness. But the fact of it being so utterly hopeless to convert the capitalist class to Socialism is the reductio ad absurdum of the belief in ideas as creative forces or prime causes of social change.

It is difficult to take quite seriously a correspondent who states, in these days of scientific theory, that a theory “based on logical deduction from present-day phenomena” is therefore not scientific !

Science, as Engels shows, is essentially deduced from stubborn facts in contradistinction to metaphysical philosophy, which vainly endeavoured to construct a complete system of knowledge from a few introspectively obtained principles, ranging from the “I think, therefore I am ” of Descartes to the gibberish of Professor Teufelsdroch of God-knows-where.

Its utter failure is the bankruptcy of Idealism, just as the rise of modern inductive science is the demonstration of the fact that the idea, however fantastic, is but the more or less distorted reflex of the real world. Science, indeed, is directly due, in its modern phase, to economic development, and would be impossible without it. It is under the impulse of the technical necessities of capitalism that the advance of science has been so rapid and so triumphant.

Engels, therefore, in saying that the means of abolishing capitalism are not to be invented by deduction from fundamental principles, but are to be discovered in the stubborn facts of the existing system of production, is simply saying that the Socialist method must be scientific, not metaphysical. Our correspondent has entirely failed to understand the passage in question.

And the inventions of the 18th century of which our correspondent speaks—do they help him? What called them forth ? What gave them their opportunity ? None of them would have been possible in earlier economic circumstances. Every one of them depended on the active cooperation of society and on a given condition of the material to hand, being otherwise impracticable. All arose from, and were dependent on, economic development every inch of the way. The tools, and the arts of working in the many-materials, wood, leather, stone or metals, had previously to have reached a given degree of perfection. The wheels, pulleys, cylinders, pistons had to be present in utilisable form. A social demand had to exist. And a social market that depended on a certain degree of development of a definite social system had also to be available. All these and other prerequisites were the results of the accumulation of human experience and practice through countless years. The inventor, as well as the conditions around him, was the product of economic evolution and untold past social effort. For countless ages mankind had patiently persevered, following the line of nature’s least resistance to their needs, acted upon by, and re-acting upon, nature, be fore social conditions were ripe for thebeginnings of the machine age. And then, the inventions were called forth by the necessities of a particular stage of industry. Once power-driven machines were made possible by the state of one branch of industry they became theoretically possible in. all, and absolutely essential in many. So the problems, narrowed down to definite points by industrial advance, were clearly set down for solution by economic development itself.

So true is this that at a particular period the same thing will be hit upon in several widely distant centres at, the same time. This continually occurs, both in industry and with its hand-maiden science.

Not one of the inventions was the result of one man’s labour. All were the results of many minor improvements. Indeed, the “great man” theory has been exploded by Herbert Spencer, and the inventor, like the genius in other spheres, is the product of his age.

It was the exhaustion of the wood supply in the forests of the South of England, together with the pressing need for iron, that directed men’s energies to the utilisation of coal for smelting ; a process that but slowly approached perfection with accumulated practical experience.

One need, indeed, go no further than the first volume of “Capital” for a masterly expression of this fact.

After pointing out how manufacture (in the old sense) produced the machinery by means of which modern industry abolished the handicraft and manufacturing systems in those spheres of production that it first seized upon. Marx says :
“A radical change in the mode of production in one sphere of industry involves a similar change in other spheres. This happens at fast in such branches as are connected together by being separate phases of a process, and yet are isolated by the social division of labour, in such a way that each of them produces an independent commodity. Thus spinning by machinery made weaving by machinery a necessity, and both together made the mechanical and chemical revolution that took place in bleaching, printing, and dyeing, imperative. So, too, on the other hand, the revolution in cotton spinning called forth the invention of the gin, for separating the seeds from the fibre ; it was only by means of this invention that the production of cotton became possible on the enormous scale at present required, but more especially, the revolution in the modes of production of industry and agriculture made necessary a revolution in the means of communication and of transport.”
The huge masses to be worked demanded huge mechanical instruments for the operation, and power capable of moving them. This, as Marx further shows, led to the invention of the slide rest, a means that was essentially required to produce the straight lines, cylinders, and spheres needed in the construction of the steam engine.

Finally, machinery itself could not be introduced before a certain stage of economic development, because it required for its effective use that a given stage of the social division of labour be already reached. So the classic instances of man’s power of invention are but further proofs of the dependence of man’s ideas upon economic development.

The materialist conception of history is, indeed, an integral part of the Socialist philosophy ; and there is no consistent way of escape from acceptance of the whole when the truth of one of its phases is recognised. Nature—all knowledge, is essentially one. All phenomena, mental and physical, are in the domain of science, and intimately woven together in the universal network of cause and effect. Human brain work, important though it be, is but a email part of nature, and it is still true that the whole is greater than the part.

Industrial processes evolve along lines of least resistance pressed hard by human requirements. With this evolution the internals of society outgrow the social edifice which the ruling class have erected during their run of power. It is the workers who are most affected by this. Their ideas change, and acquire definite form and purpose. The socio-political change begins to show itself, as it were, as a smouldering of ideas. It bursts into light. The flame spreads because of the abundance of combustible material around it. It gathers strength and propagates ever more quickly by the increase of its own internal heat. The rigid structure that would enclose and smother it is at last burst asunder, and the great change is a thing accomplished.

So onr work in the propaganda of Socialism is not only necessary—it is inevitable. And whether the historic mission of the working class be fulfilled sooner or later depends, to a great degree, on the intensity, completeness, and scientific nature of that propaganda.
F. C. Watts


Blogger's Note:
J. H. Lamb, at the time of writing this contribution, was a member of the Manchester Branch of the SPGB. He joined the Party in April 1911, and remained a member until September 1912. Despite his pointed criticism in his letter, he didn't resign from the Party. His membership was lapsed. 

Why Socialists Oppose Anarchism: Part 3 (1911)

From the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

 Its Fallacies and Dangers Exposed.

[continued from October issue.]

One thing is plain : if you reject political action you are left only with individual action — “propaganda by deed.” The Anarchists have tried to find substitutes, and Syndicalism and the General Strike have held the stage — until they have been examined.

They point to France as an example of successful Syndicalism, but France is surely Syndicalism’s grave! It is represented there by the Confederation Generale du Travail — composed of 300,000 members, a small number of whom are Anarchists, though, through lack of democracy, they set the official positions. The small unions have the same, voting power at Congresses as the large ones, and it is well said that
THREE UNITED CHIMNEY SWEEPS
have the same voting power as a union of 10,000 members.

Owing to the tempestuous, excitable nature of the people of southern climes, they are more prone to display and impetuous action than other races. Hence the sudden strikes and the equally sudden and sad collapse of them. The majority of the organised French workers are outside the Confederation, and even the number of organised workers all told is far less than here. Yet with all the lack of organisation and the reactionary politics of the majority of unionists, the Syndicalists keep announcing a great general strike. But these strikes, ordered by the Anarchist minority at the helm, have turned out to be general fiascos.

Even a strike such as the first Paris Postal strike temporarily claimed a victory, but after Government preparations their succeeding strike collapsed amid dismissals and persecution. The Syndicalists preach direct action, but direct action for reform. The Union Label, the Eight Hour Day, the Reduction of High Food Prices—these are some of their ideals. And “sabotage” is their trump card. Known under the English name of ”rattening,” it consists of breaking and making useless machinery, and other such revolutionary (!) deeds.
WRECKING TRAINS
follows, and it promotes wide-spread dissension and lack of sympathy with the strikers.

These methods indicate backward organisation and unscientific conceptions, and are reminiscent of early English trade unionism.

The Anarchists fiercely denounce authority, but they become officials of the trade unions and paid ones at that! They impeach representation and delegation, but have to resort to them ! They condemn political action but vote for the politicians who promise Government subsidies for union premises !

But the criticism from their own side is, perhaps, the most damaging. Said Malatesta (at International Congress) : “He expected some comrades would be surprised to hear him speak against Syndicalism and the General Strike.” He would have nothing to say against it (Syndicalism) if he could believe that Syndicalism could alone, as was claimed for it, destroy Capitalism. But who could expect to overthrow Capitalism while remaining a servant of capitalist production? . . . The fact of the matter was that as the Syndicalist organisations grew nearer and nearer to perfection, the number of unemployed grew greater and greater . . . It is only too obvious that the Syndicalists make a
SERIOUS DIVISION OF THE WORKERS
without harassing the capitalists.” Sighing for a “moral struggle” he said : “We may as well confess that the purely economic struggle is not sufficient.”

Ridiculing the success of French Syndicalism the same speaker said “he did not see why France should consider herself in a novel condition. English trade unionism began in just the same revolutionary way and look at it now . . . What he objected to was the idea freely propagated by some Syndicalists that the General Strike can replace insurrection. Some people fondly cherish the idea that we are going to starve the bourgeoisie. We should starve first. . . . He considered that some of the pamphlets published on the General Strike did nothing but harm. … He had read somewhere that we ought to go and smash the railway bridges ! He wondered whether the advocates of such foolishness ever realised that corn has to come the same way as the cannons come . . . We must face the cannons if we want the corn. … If the Government have perfected the arms of repression we must purfect those of revolution. We need more knowledge ” !

From their own ranks, then, the exposure has come. But we do not adopt the view of another of their delegates who asked : “What was the use of agitating for higher wages when the cost of living automatically rises in price ?” That is capitalist economics.

We recognise that the workers, having only their energy to sell, have to get the best price possible, and therefore must oppose any attempt to beat them down or make them work longer. The present trade unions are not Socialist, but mere alteration in the form is not the remedy.

The workers in and out of the unions must be taught the Socialist position, and when the members become Socialists, they will see that the unions take the class form.
CHANGE THE FORM
how you like while the workers are not revolutionary, they will be misled still and will fail to see the limits of their powers and the remedy.

While we strongly sympathise with all real struggles against the employers’ attacks, we never cease to urge upon the workers the need for class-consciousness for ending this system of society altogether, by political control.

The General Strike as a means of emancipation must surely fail, for the working class are propertyless, and if they cease work even the “short commons” that “work” means cease too. Starvation stares them in the face. All acquainted with proletarian life know the terrible privation that strikes entail; the suffering writ large on the faces of the helpless babes, the toddling children and the struggling wives. Such agonising scenes as were to be witnessed on the hillsides and in the valleys of South Wales during the year-long Cambrian Strike. The stripped homes; the crammed pawnshops; the rising mortality: these remind us that
STRIKES STRIKE THE WORKERS
as well as the masters. This is but a sectional strike; a strike with those at work helping those who are out. But when all the workers strike even that help fails, for they are all in the same boat. Even in sectional strikes we have seen how the workers often appeal to the bourgeoisie for aid for their wives and little ones, and soup kitchens, etc., are opened. Their purchasing power also grows worse as strikes continue, for prices rise.

The masters, strongly entrenched in the economic field, also control the political machine, and when they think the aims of the strikers important enough they use the armed forces to butcher, baton, and cow the strikers. Though always at their command, they do not use the armed forces wantonly. They weigh the pros and cons. “Is massacre necessary?” they ask themselves. “Can’t we arbitrate their demands out of existence? Won’t a Royal Commission do? Shall we give their leaders jobs?” Just as they bought Briand, the pioneer of the General Strike. Only when these other means fail do they risk inflaming the populace by resorting to open and
WIDESPREAD MASSACRE.
But other means generally do not fail.

True, a general strike can paralyse industry. A prolonged General Strike can destroy society. For we depend upon continued production and cessation means death. But death snatches its first victims from the toilers : they are most vulnerable—they have no stores, no reserves. Our masters have.

The General Strike figured largely in speeches 30 years ago, and found its chief exponent in Michael Bakunine. The greater part of his life he was a prominent figure in the reactionary pan-Slavist crusade. He turned his attention to the International founded by Marx, Engels, and others, and in the Latin countries and Switzerland he carried on a bitter campaign against Marx and other members of the London General Council of the International.

Marx believed in effective organisation, strong and well knit, and political action as against street fights. The unscrupulous methods Bakunine used to smash the International from within, together with his past, often laid him under suspicion of being a spy, but against his intrigues the sturdy Socialist pioneer proved too strong.

From the days of the International onward Marx and Engels continued to press the need for the conquest of political supremacy by the workers. Engels incurred the especial hatred of the Anarchists for his condemnation of their General Strike tactics. The Anarchist rising in Spain in 1873 served as an occasion for his pamphlet against them entitled “The Bakunist on Labour,” and he afterwards carried the war into
THE ENEMY’S TERRITORY
with his “Social Conditions in Russia,” a polemic against the Bakunists circulated widely in Russia. W. Tcherkesoff, the Anarchist, bitterly denounces Engels for these pamphlets in his falsified “Pages from Socialist History” and elsewhere.

The last work from Engels’ pen was the introduction he wrote a few months before he died (1895) to Marx’s “The Class Struggles in France.” Of it the writer of the “Life of Engels” says: “With merciless criticism he destroyed the fanciful representation of the all-powerful barricade and destroyed the hope of the European reaction that the labourers could be provoked to a street-fight in which they could be repulsed with decimated ranks. He showed how the revolution in the art of warfare had made the old form of struggle impossible, while a new weapon had been provided for the labouring class in the new political right of suffrage against which the ruling class were helpless. ‘The irony of the world’s history,’ says Engels, ‘ places everything on its head. We, the “revolutionaries,” the “overturners,” we succeed better with the legal means than with illegality and force. The self-named “Party of Order” goes to pieces on the legal conditions created by itself. They despairingly cry with Odillon Barrot
“LEGALITY IS OUR DEATH”
while we from the same legality gain strong muscles, ruddy cheeks, and the appearance of eternal life. If we are not so foolish as to please them by allowing ourselves to be led into street fights there remains nothing for them but to be broken to pieces upon this fatal legality.’ “

Just as Engels shows, we, the revolutionists, are prepared to use legal means in so far as they can be used in the workers’ interest, and ignore them when they cannot. When legal means fail illegal means are justifiable and commendable. Therefore we have no qualms about using the suffrage, enacted by the capitalists. We know that just as the bourgeoisie before us had to be enfranchised for the free and easy development of society an ever wider and more extended suffrage is imperative.

One section or another had sooner or later to pass the Franchise Bill, and it was the Tories who actually did it—to dish the Liberals was their immediate aim. It is with the enlightened use of this weapon they were forced to give us that their graves will be dug. Marx well says : “The capitalists are their own gravediggers.” Enactments they pass to conserve their own interests often have effects they little dream of at the time. They made “education” compulsory the better to compete with other nations, but with even that miserable education the worker’s child may afterwards read the message of Socialism and be converted into a fighter in
THE ONLY CAUSE.
Anarchists and their allies say “Look how the suffrage has been tampered with abroad,” but they forget that even in semi-feudal Prussia, despite stifling of the vote, the candidates it was intended to keep out have still increased, to the dismay of their enemies. In the same way, should a headstrong Government suspend the suffrage, they meet disaster in the resentment they inflame in the masses.

But the Anarchists’ point really shows the value of Parliamentary action, for if the House of Commons is useless against the capitalists, why do they attempt to manipulate the suffrage to prevent the Socialists getting in? Just as their plea that real revolutionists will never be allowed in Parliament brings its fitting answer, if it is the futile institution the Anarchists pretend, why should they raise barriers to prevent their election?

No ! the Anarchists ought to see, just as we do, that the millions spent on elections by our masters to get their nominees returned; the money spent on agents to teach the workers the “virtues” of capitalism and the “vices” of Socialism, signify much. They spent millions to prevent the workers getting the vote, and for forty years brutally illtreated, massacred and persecuted the Chartists fighting for mere manhood suffrage. They evidently know its portent and its value.

While Socialists are in the minority in Parliament they can but use its platform to oppose capitalist villainy; to point the lesson of its daily deeds; to examine the measures brought before them and show their failure and their fraud, and in the long run, by the continued work and criticism of the revolutionists, and the growing number of the Socialists they represent, they will doubtless witness the passing of measures intended to
CONTENT THE TOILERS,
but any grains of good they may contain will be used but as a further foothold in the fight for Socialism, the fight against all the enemies of the Red Flag.

I believe sufficient has been said in this article to show the firm, scientific attitude of the Socialists toward the fallacies and dangers of Anarchism. One by one their so called arguments have been exposed in the light of history and of science. In the area of theory as well as of practice their “case” is seen to be Utopian and futile. Their “direct action” turns out to be direct reaction, for to ignore the political machinery is to play the game of the ruling class.

The final plea of the Anarchists usually is that politicians always have sold out and always will sell, but this cannot apply to our movement, for informed Socialist men and women are not material for the man on-the make. But what is true is that on the economic field the betrayals of the toilers have been frequent and many. From the pioneer of the General Strike in France—Aristide Briand—to John Mitchell and Samuel Gompers of the American Federation of Labour, they illustrate the puerility of the Anarchist view.

Have we not in Britain a whole tribe of tricksters from the industrial field ? What of Isaac Mitchell, David Cummings, Richard Bell, and David Shackleton? Trade union leaders all! And the Anarchist reliance upon an intelligent minority as against the Socialist policy of an enlightened whole will give these tricksters
MORE SCOPE THAN EVER.
We appeal to the men and women of our class to take their place in the only revolutionary party in this country—the Socialist Party of Great Britain. All around us are signs of the “fret and fever” of our fellows under the lash of capitalist oppression. Governments are marshalling their forces for attacks upon our class. Surely here is the need for a strong, revolutionary, disciplined movement inspired by the Socialist ideal to battle against the influence of false friends and foul foes. Cease your fruitless wanderings in the desert of Anarchism ere your enthusiasm dies away. Guided by the beacon lit by Marx and Engels and the landmarks on the road travelled by our class, enlist in the only Socialist Party and lift your voice and use your pen to dispel the moonshine of the missionaries of capitalism and help to bring nearer the sunshine of Socialism—the fruitfulness of the co-operative Commonweal.
Adolph Kohn

[CONCLUSION.]

A Socialist Survey. (1911)

From the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

Under the heading “Protection against Socialism” the “Globe” prints the following :
“The management of the Essen Railway, in order to counteract the attempts of Socialists to convert to their cause the employees on the system, have submitted to every man in their service a written communication, warning them that the introduction of Socialistic literature into the places where they work will be punished be dismissal.”

* * *
The capitalist class realise the danger of the spread of Socialism, but such methods of repression will not avail. The “Labour” leader can be dealt with. The trade unions can be silenced through their officials. But the Socialist propaganda and the Socialist Press, insignificant though they may appear, are a growing force that non-plus the “captains of Industry.” They will find that all their lying and suppression will but recoil upon themselves, for what is it we are told about that infinitesimal portion of the “Old Adam” present in each human breast that sets up an insatiable longing for the fruit which is forbidden ?

* * *
At “Labour” leaders the representatives of Capital can readily scoff, because their critisism contains a grain of truth. The following from the “Standard” (24.8.11) can be readily endorsed by the Socialist.
“The Labour Party are great talkers and a due regard to the supply of workmen’s pennies calls for an occasional advertisement of their independence. But a little reflection will probably help the hurt that Labour honour feels, and two months hence Mr. Hardie and his friends will be tamely trooping into the lobby with the men they have described as murderous hirelings of capitalism. Gratitude has little part in the politics of labour, but fear and cupidity have full sway, and even Mr. Churchill’s crimes may be condoned if the Government continues to allow some of the golden shower of patronage to fall upon the flower of the Party.”

* * *
Andrew Carnegie, library purveyor, has offered £15,000 for the building of branch libraries at Cottonopolis, and certain labourists have protested against taking assistance from a man who, as head of the American Steel Trust in in 1892, was responsible for the murder of the strikers at Homestead. Whereat Andrew, writing from Skibo Castle to the Mayor of Manchester, says :
“May I ask you to inform your citizens that I was coaching in the far north of Scotland when the deplorable outbreak at Homestead occurred and did not hear of it for two days after. I received the following cable :

” ‘Kind master, tell us what to do and we will do it for you. Workmen’s Committee.’

“It was too late. Two City Guards had been shot, and the Governor of the State had cald out troops and was in possession of the works. Into the merits of the question we need not enter, tho I must say I found, on my return, that my partners had offered most generous terms.

“The workers of Pittsburg never refused the Libraries and Halls I personally bilt for them at the Carnegie Works, nor others I bilt for the city, nor would the workers of Manchester if they enquired into my relations with labor for 20 odd years during which I was in control.”

* * *
Now we all know Andrew. He has forced himself upon our notice as a philanthropist of the most rabid type, as an economist of a very doubtful order, and as an authority upon morality and “simplified” spelling. But I, for one, did not think he would rush into print with such an absurdity.

A correspondent of the “Manchester Guardian” (12.9.11) writes:
“With respect to the personal responsibility of Mr. Carnegie for the strike at Homestead, of which the Pinkerton riots were the outcome, Mr. J. H. Bridge, at one time Mr. Carnegie’s secretary, reproduces in his book “The Inside History of the Carnegie Steel Company,” a draft of a notice to the Homestead employees written by Andrew Carnegie on April 4, 1892, and sent by him to Frick (a co-director) at Pittsburg. This notice stipulated that the Homestead Works should become non-union after the expiration of the contract then in force, which ran until June 30, 1892. In the same book there is a reproduction of a letter represented as from Mr. Carnegie and dated June 10, 1892, in which the advice is given that conferences should be refused, and that if the union should refuse the scale proposed by the Company the non-union notices should go up on June 25.”

* * *
As to the “kind master” cablegram and the “20 years relations with labor,” the same correspondent quotes Mr. J. A. Fitch, New York State Dept. of Labor, thus :
“In March (1888) the Knights of Labor sent a committee to New York to interview Mr. Carnegie, he received them, and proposed a reduction of 10 per cent. in the steel department and 8 per cent. in the other departments, together with a return to the twelve hour day. These terms were necessary, he told them, to enable the Edgar Thomson plant to compete with the Chicago rail mills, which were nearer the market and where a twelve hour day then prevailed.

“In April Carnegie went to Pittsburg and made a proposition of a sliding scale of wages based on the selling price of steel rails. A committee of working men were appointed who should inspect the books each month to determine the base of wages for the next month. At the same time he announced that the plant would start non-union and the men must sign an agreement not to join nor remain members of any labour union. In May Carnegie refused to meet a committee or hold any further conference, and about the middle of the month, after being out all winter long, the men accepted the terms and went back to work. Thus ended unionism in the Edgar Thomson plant.”

* * *
With all his “gentle Jesus” cant, Saint Andrew is about as clumsy a liar as can be found even among his less pious brethren, and it is rather amusing to note that the champion of “directive ability,” in order to escape from an awkward position, will confess that the workers of America can turn out wealth for him while he is “coaching in the far north of Scotland.”
Twel.

“Blessed are the meek”. (1911)

From the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

Really, when the matter is considered, perhaps one of the strangest and most paradoxical phenomena in the present strange and paradoxical social system is the excessive and irritating humility that pervades the majority of the workers. Here you have a numerous army of men and women engaged in producing all the wealth of society—everything that is necessary to mankind, every article of use, aye, and of luxury, emanates from the working class. And yet, instead of insisting upon reaping the fruits of their sowing, the workers meekly allow a small section in society calmly to appropriate to itself all that is produced; further, meekly; allow themselves to be insulted, mocked and jeered at by the very people in whose interest and for whose benefit they work day after day, year after year, through, a life-time of degrading toil and hopelessness. All their lives through they meet with nothing but covert or open insult.

Take the following instance :
A Labourer, we will say, applies at a mill or factory for a job. He is seen by the manager or some other functionary of capitalism (himself usually a working man, but in this case standing as the embodiment of the employer), and something like the following dialogue ensues :

Manager : Well ?
Labourer : I’ve just called, sir, to see if you’ve got anything for me.
Manager : What’s your name ?
Labourer : John Smith.
Manager : Age ?
Labourer : Forty-two.
Manager : Umph ! You’re rather old for our class of work. We want young, strong men.
Labourer : I’m strong enough, sir. Not afraid of work.
Manager (sceptically) : You don’t look very strong. Married, I suppose?
Labourer : Yes, sir. Any family ? Three children.
Manager : How long have you been out of work?
Labourer : About three months
Manager : What have you been doing in the meantime ? Living with relatives or what ?
Labourer : Well, my wife has done a bit of work and my eldest boy brings in a shilling or two a week.
Manager: I suppose your hands are pretty soft by now ?

The Labourer, without speaking, holds out his hands, palms upwards, and they are looked at critically by the manager.

His references are then examined, and if it is found that he has been honest, sober, industrious, and has left his previous situation through no fault of his own, his name and address are probably taken down. The dialogue ends :

Manager : If we find there is an opening, we will let you know.
Labourer : Thank you, sir. Good morning, sir
Manager : Good day.
An impartial onlooker might perhaps think that the above colloquy would be likely to touch, however softly, some hidden spring of self-respect in the workman. But such, seldom seems to be the case. The treatment meted out to the workers on their applying for situations appears usually to be accepted by them as quite natural and inevitable. For generations past the priest, the politician, and the pressman have done their best—and their best has been wonderfully successful—to instil a self-abasement and a slavish humility into the working-class mind. The brutal and impertinent questions asked are taken as being “all in the day’s work.”

But what would happen, one wonders, if the tables were suddenly turned and the workman began to ask similar questions of potential employers—such, for instance, as to the financial stability of the firm, the social standing and the domestic affairs of the shareholder or owners of the company, or as to whether the morals of the chairman of the board (if, as is now generally the case, the company should be a joint stock company) were as irreproachable as his linen.

It is not, however, only within the actual industrial portion of capitalism that this kind of thing obtains. All over our present vicious system there is this same contempt on the one hand and humility on the other. Take the following instance, chosen at random :

Dr. Jansen, of the Charity Hospital in Stockholm, reported as follows on the 12th of May, 1891, in a lecture to the Medical Society at Stockholm :
“When I began my experiments with black small-pox, I should, perhaps, have chosen animals for the purpose. But the most fit subjects, calves, were obtainable only at a considerable cost. There was, besides, the cost of their keep, so I concluded to make my experiments upon the children of the Foundlings’ House, and obtained, kind permission to do so from the head physician, Professor Medin.

“I selected fourteen children, who were inoculated day after day. Afterwards I discontinued them and used calves. … I did not continue my experiments on calves long, once because I despaired of gaining my ends within a limited period, and again because the calves were so expensive. I intend, however, to go back to my experiments in the Foundling Asylum at some future time.”
Any working man or woman of a mathematical turn of mind, who happens to be a father or a mother, may perhaps from, the above be able to calculate the value of his or her children—in the eyes of the kindly Dr. Jensen and his confreres—in comparison with the calves, which “were obtainable only at a considerable cost.”

Or take the case of the notorious Dr. Neisser. This distinguished member of the medical profession, who in June of this year was invited by the West London Medico-Cherurgical Society to deliver the Cavendish Lecture on the Evolution of the Modern Treatment of Syphilis, at Kenington Town Hall, London, and presented with the gold medal of the society for “distinguished work in medical science,” has openly boasted of the fact that at the University Hospital of Breslau, he has frequently experimented upon children with the virus of syphilis. Several young girls of the poorer class were inoculated under his instructions, some of whom were admittedly known to have contracted this loathsome disease in consequence. Neither the parents nor the patients themselves were aware that they were being experimented upon. But even had they known, would they have dared to raise a protest ?

In a certain book very much in vogue among theologians we are told that: “Blessed are the meek : for they shall inherit the earth.” But so far from this being true, so far from any blessings accruing by reason of the exercise of this Christian virtue, the workers, if anyone, should know by now that their lot under capitalism is not the inheritance of the earth, or any portion of it, but rather of life-long toil and degradation and suffering. The above aphorism might very well, from a working-class standpoint, be revised to read: “Blessed are the strong and those who have pride in the realisation of their strength, for they shall inherit all the glorious intellectual and physical possibilities of life which only freedom from wage-slavery can give.”
F. J. Webb

Asked & Answered. (1911)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

Answer to Tom Grew.

Marx says : “Commodities are sold at their real values.” Now that being so, why is it that in countries where the productivity of labour is high, gold has not so great a buying power as in countries where labour is not so productive ? Take America and England. America is the highest of all, I think, yet commodities exchange for more gold there than in England. This cannot be due to protection as Germany shows.
Tom Grew.
________________________________

Marx says prices deviate from values for varying periods and various reasons.

Thus monopolies are often able to push up and hold up prices above values for a considerable time, while cutthroat competition will sometimes drive prices down below values.

The high stage of trust development in America is one of the factors behind the high prices ruling there.

But this statement needs an important qualification. Many factory products—where the productivity of labour-power is greatest—are cheaper there than here, and it is mostly in foodstuffs that the high prices reign.

The reason is not far to seek. Agriculture lags far behind manufacture in economic development. The soft soils suitable for agriculture do not lend themselves to the easy manipulation of ponderous machinery and prime movers, so that at present a limit in their application has been reached.

Moreover, the farmer if burdened with the monopolist charges of Railway and Elevator Companies, and this fact finds some reflection in higher prices. The result is to retard the spread of agriculture, so that it is not expanding, either extensively or intensively, at the same rate as the population. Hence the relative demand for the farmer’s products is increasing, adding another factor to those given above in maintaining high prices.
J. F.

Answers to Correspondents. (1911)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

Will the correspondent signing himself “A Reader of Your Paper” (Philadelphia) send his name and address ?

D. Conroy (London, N.)—You give your whole case away when you assert that “the workers have already sufficient legal power do whatever they will. The law points the way, but the law cannot give them the intelligence to accomplish their emancipation.” Whatever you might have urged in support of your other points, the illegality of any attack upon private property is quite beyond dispute.

A Fifth Edition. (1911)

Party News from the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

We have to announce the publication of the Fifth Edition of the Party Manifesto. The Manifesto itself remains unchanged, but the preface has been brought up to date necessitating the enlargement of the brochure to 24 pages. The price is still 1s., post free 1½d.



Blogger's Note:
Unfortunately, the fifth edition - with the expanded preface - is not on the SPGB website but the first and sixth editions are online.


S.P.G.B. Lecture List For November, 1911. T. W. Allen

A brief interlude. 

I've been here before with Frederick S. Leigh and A. Barker, and now it's the turn of another SPGB founder member, T. W. Allen. Just looking at the SPGB Lecture List for November 1911, Allen's name appears on SEVEN separate occasions. And that was back in the day when platform speakers would speak for hours at a time. For example, on the 5th November he was speaking in the morning at Ridley Road in Dalston and, then, later that same day, he was scheduled to speak early evening at the Wood Green Corner speaking pitch in Tottenham.

The details below about T. W. Allen are from Keith Scholey's unpublished document 'The Founding Members of the Socialist Party of Great Britain'.

Allen, TW
   Paddington (later Islington) branch.  TW Allen was a very active early member, both as a propagandist, speaking for the party throughout the pre-war era, and as an administrator, being on the EC from 1904 to 1906 and from 1908 to 1912. At a local level he was briefly secretary of the Paddington branch in 1904. In the SDF he had been secretary of the Marylebone branch in 1901-2. Like many early members his activity ceased during the First World War although he was again on the EC briefly in 1922-3. By the time of the outbreak of the Second World War Allen was in Islington branch, many of whose members, including Allen, had adopted a pro-war stance regarding it as a war for democracy. In accordance with this TW Allen resigned on 1st January 1941. 

S.P.G.B. Lecture List For November. (London District) (1911)

Party News from the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard





Blogger's Note:
Once again, I don't have enough room in the label section to include all the listed speakers, so some brief information on some of the speakers missing from the sidebar. Some of these names (and details) you have seen before:
  • T. W. Allen. See this separate post.
  • A. Barker. See this previous post.
  • H. Cooper was H.J. Cooper. He joined Earlsfield Branch of the SPGB in September 1908, and his membership was lapsed in December 1915.
  • R. Fox was R. M. Fox. He joined the SPGB in Tottenham in September 1906. Better known after he left the SPGB, his 1937 autobiography, Smoky Crusade, sticks the boot into his old SPGB comrades. He should the offending excerpts from his book on the blog some time.
  • C. Ginger: Another member of Tottenham Branch. Charles Ginger was one of those SPGB members who joined the Party more than once. There's a suggestion that C. Ginger could also be Frank Grainger, who had originally left the SPGB to join the Herald League. (See Ken Weller's book). Frank Grainger eventually rejoined the SPGB in the 1930s, and was actually selected as the Party's parliamentary candidate for the East Ham North constituency, which the Party was planning to contest at the probable 1940 General Election. (WW2 intervened.) According to Ken Weller, after he resigned from the SPGB, he later worked for the Economic League.
  • J. Halls was John H. Halls, who joined Paddington Branch of the SPGB in June 1907 (a Mrs Eleanor B. Halls joined Paddington Branch in July 1907). A regular writer and translator for the Socialist Standard in the Edwardian period, he eventually resigned his membership when he moved abroad (Paris).
  • J. Holmes. See this separate post.
  • A. Hoskyns was Ambrose Hoskyns. He joined the Islington Branch of the SPGB in August 1910. He was an occasional writer for the Socialist Standard in the Pre-War 1914 period. There are no details of when he left the SPGB. A flavour of his writing (and the early history of the SPGB) is contained within his April 1911 article, 'The Attempted Suppression of Free Speech in Islington'.
  • A. Jacobs was Alf Jacobs. There is more detailed background on him in this feature which appeared in the September 1954 issue of the Socialist Standard.
  • H. Joy was a member of the Tooting Branch of the SPGB. They joined the SPGB in October 1907.
  • C. Parker was a member of West Ham Branch. They joined the SPGB in May 1906, and was lapsed from membership in October 1929.
  • J. E. Roe. Jonathan Roe's obituary appeared in the August 1972 issue of the Socialist Standard.
  • F. J. Rourke was a member of the Tottenham Branch, originally joining the SPGB in June 1909. Their membership was lapsed in February 1914. ("Moved away".)
  • F. W. Stearn was a member of the Tottenham Branch. There were actually two 'F. Stearn's in the branch at the time - possibly father and son - so I don't know which one was a listed speaker for this month.
  • F. Vickers.  Frank Vickers joined the SPGB in August 1911. There is no mention of when he left the Party. However, he is mentioned in this article from the February 1976 issue of the Socialist Standard. Harry Young encountered him in the Communist Party in the 1920s: ". . . At the Communists' 5th Congress there was an almost unique specimen—an SPGB-er who had joined the Communist Party, Frank Vickers from Tooting."

Gunboats Off Guiana (1953)

From the November 1953 issue of the Socialist Standard

In his biography of the late Earl Baldwin, Mr. G. M. Young recalls the ageing Prime Minister, weary of the eternal rounds of diplomacy, crying out for the days when the sight of a British gunboat was enough to quell any disturbance in a foreign land. One wonders what Baldwin would have said of the events in British Guiana which have aroused such interest over the past few weeks, and where not a gunboat but a cruiser, two frigates, an aircraft-carrier and over seven hundred troops are involved.

The first hint of the recent trouble in the colony appeared in the newspapers of Sunday, 4th October, which reported the movement of the cruiser H.M.S. Superb and connected it with the events in British Guiana. After the usual denials the Colonial Office admitted that the cruiser, carrying five hundred troops, was bound for Georgetown and that the expedition was planned as a result of the activities of the People’s Progressive Party (P.P.P.) —an organisation with alleged Communist Party sympathies—which had easily won the elections in April of this year. These elections were the first to be held under the colony’s new constitution, which gave the right of universal suffrage whilst leaving the Governor, Sir Alfred Savage, a large measure of reserve powers. But the roots of the trouble go deeper than any electoral victory.

South America, the Caribbean and the West Indies have for a long time been a source of frustration to British commerce. Up to the beginning of the 20th century the area was virtually under the control of Great Britain: since then, British power and influence have steadily declined. Markets which were once dominated by British goods are now largely exploited by American, French, German, Japanese, Dutch and other interests, British investment has fallen away seriously.

In many South American countries independent capitalist groups have arisen to gain freedom from foreign domination. There is a demand for capital, as opposed to consumer, goods. The resultant native industries are producing commodities which compete with, and finally close the markets to, those from overseas. In South America this process has been assisted by stern import tariffs.

This situation has caused concern to many British governments. In May of this year a government commission reported on the development of economic independence in Latin America. The Queen’s speech to the opening of Parliament in November, 1952, had already promised measures to strengthen economic ties with the area.

Thus British Guiana, as the only British colony in South America, and one containing rich sources of sugar, bauxite (aluminium ore), gold and silver, assumes a considerable importance in the efforts of British industry to re-establish itself in an area in which it was once pre-dominant.

But with its economic development, and particularly with the industrialisation which has accompanied the exploiting of the bauxite deposits, there has arisen in British Guiana the familiar demand for independence from British rule. The return to power of the P.P.P. with their programme aimed at ultimately making British Guiana a republic was a triumph for them that has proved short-lived.

In pursuance of this policy and in opposition to the traditional ruling class of sugar planters and business men the P.P.P. took up the cause of the recognition of the Guiana Industrial Workers’ Union. A strike was called, with the support of the P.P.P. After a period of negotiation and attempted appeasement of the P.P.P., the colony’s economy was deemed to be seriously threatened by the stoppage. Then it was that the British government acted: troops were landed and the constitution of British Guiana was suspended. In amongst Whitehall's allegations of disturbance and violence the colony’s inhabitants went happily to watch the cricket match against Trinidad.

The suspension of the constitution seems to have been rather hasty and has met some opposition— already the Manchester Guardian and (before the event) the Economist have expressed doubts on the wisdom of such a policy. The commission of inquiry which is to be sent out with instructions to frame a new constitution can, presumably, only recommend a form which will exclude the possibility of the P.P.P.—or any similar party—again achieving power: the British government is apparently determined that only administrations of which it approves will be allowed in the colonies. Mr. Oliver Lyttelton, the Colonial Secretary, has said (Manchester Guardian, 10/10/53) that “ Her Majesty’s Government are not going to allow a Communist State to be organised within the British Commonwealth. Our friends can take that as a definite statement, and our enemies can attach to it all the importance that I think they should.” Thus it seems that, if further elections are allowed to take place in British Guiana, they will be rigged to ensure a result favourable to British interests. This, together with the expulsion from the colony of the correspondent of the Daily Worker shows the outlook of the British ruling class when their interests are threatened.

It is little wonder that the workers of British Guiana, poorly paid and wretchedly housed, have no love for British rule and have fallen for the appeal of the P.P.P. The case for independence must seem overwhelming to them. Doubtless they are unimpressed by the attack made on the P.P.P., that it has failed in six months to carry out reforms of living conditions which the British administration has neglected for over 150 years. But the experience of Eire, India and other countries should have had its lesson for them. National independence will not abolish workers’ poverty.

The P.P.P., as the expression of the desire of a potential British Guianese capitalist class to exploit for itself the mineral wealth and workers of the colony, free from British interference, follows a familiar pattern. Its methods, such as the playing upon the sugar workers’ grievances, the extremes of poverty and wealth and other causes of discontent, are also well known. Certainly the British Guianese workers have nothing to gain by supporting the P.P.P. in its struggle to replace one set of masters by another.

But whatever the outcome of this struggle, it seems fairly certain that more trouble is in store for the sunny lands of the Caribbean. The neighbouring country of Venezuela has for some time claimed British Guiana for its own: a wartime agreement entitles the U.S.A. to keep an aeroplane and seaplane base in the colony: and much capital investment will be needed soon, as the Guianese industry finds its feet. This conflict of interests could, as in so many other cases, cause British Guiana to become yet another sore spot in a sick world.
Ivan.

The Passing Show: British Guiana (1953)

The Passing Show Column from the November 1953 issue of the Socialist Standard

British Guiana

Recent events in British Guiana have shown us how feeble is our rulers’ real attachment to democracy. The Guianese workers are not to be allowed to support a party which might try to end the present dependance of Guianese capitalism on British capitalism, and to make Guiana instead an associate of the Soviet Union—that is to say, a party which might try to take Guiana out of one capitalist bloc and into another. There is no question at present, unfortunately, of a struggle in British Guiana between Capitalism and Socialism. According to reports from the colony, the “People’s Progressive Party,” the leaders of which have been dismissed from their positions as ministers by the Governor, is, in the terms of British politics, a cross between the Labour Party and the Communist Party; and neither of these parties is a supporter of Socialism. The policy of the “People’s Progressive Party” is the usual ragbag of reforms and improvements in capitalism: it promises better wages and housing, and is known to favour some measure of state-control over the sugar estates. Nothing in its propaganda, its policies or its activities gives it any claim to be a Socialist Party.


Reforms

Now if the “People’s Progressive Party” had kept to its reforms, it would probably have been left alone. British capitalism, and the subsidiary capitalist systems in the colonial empire, will tolerate a limited amount of reformism; in fact they work all the better for a few reforms. In the Gold Coast the Convention People’s Party is in office, in the eastern region of Nigeria the National Council of Nigeria and the Cameroons, and in the western region the Action Group. The People’s Progressive Party differs from these simply in the Communist affiliations of some of its leaders.


Risk of Bloodshed

It has been alleged that the action of the British Government in sending troops and warships to British Guiana, and suspending the Constitution, were prompted by a danger to life and limb within the colony. For example, the statement issued by the Colonial Office on October 6th said that there was a “risk of bloodshed” (The Times 7-10-53; following quotations are also from The Times unless otherwise stated). But this seems to be highly improbable. On October 5th, just before the troops were sent, the Times correspondent reported not the beginning but the end of a crisis; he said “the threatened constitutional crisis ended last week when the House of Assembly met . . . Elected ministers who had previously walked out from the House returned after consultation between the leader of the House, the Speaker, and the Governor.” (5-10-53). Two days later the correspondent was even more emphatic:
“Georgetown is perfectly normal and quiet to-day, and the excitement in London and elsewhere is not comprehended. There are no signs of impending crisis such as would justify a revocation of the constitution, nor of any disorder necessitating additional troops. An influx of newspaper correspondents is expected in the next few days, but they are likely to be disappointed at the absence of colourful events" (7-10-53).
The Times correspondent was even afraid that the sending of troops into a peaceful colony might alienate “moderate” opinion:
“Thoughtful observers feel that, unless the show of force is justified by the subsequent revelation of an imminent plot, it may well alienate public opinion that was turning from the P.P.P.” (8-10-53).
Thus it seems clear that there was no immediate fear of bloodshed; the ministers were sacked, the verdict of the Guianese voters was overturned, and the troops marched in solely because of the fear of the defection of the colony to another capitalist bloc.


Truth

The events in British Guiana have been instructive from another point of view. For many years "Truth” has been equalled as an object for lip-service in political speeches only by “Freedom" and “Democracy.” But to run a capitalist system without telling lies is to do the impossible. The sending of troops to British Guiana followed this approximate timetable:
October 2nd: The cruiser Superb left Bermuda for an 
undisclosed destination.
October 4th: The Sunday papers said that the cruiser was bound for British Guiana.
The Superb left Jamaica after taking on troops and refuelling. British Caribbean headquarters announced that it was to take part in manoeuvres off Jamaica on October 8th. Caribbean Area Forces headquarters denied the rumour that it had been diverted for emergency duty in the South Atlantic (6-10-53)—that is, that it had been sent to British Guiana. 
October 7th: The cruiser Superb arrived in British Guiana.
It might, of course, be said that it was impossible in the circumstances to reveal the destination of the cruiser in advance. But this is to admit the argument that the telling of lies is an essential part of the running of the capitalist system.


Trieste

In this connection, consider also the question of Trieste. The Western Powers—Britain, the United States and France—made a joint declaration in 1948 that the whole territory should go to Italy. Now, these Powers say that this declaration was made solely because of the difficulty in arranging to set up a Free Territory of Trieste, as agreed in the Italian peace-treaty (14-10-53). But this is very far from the truth, and is alleged only to conceal the history of opportunism which lies behind the attitude of the Western Powers to the whole Trieste question. At the Italian peace-treaty, the already strained relations between the West and the Soviet bloc ruled out the possibility of the West agreeing to hand over the whole disputed area to Yugoslavia, then a member of that bloc. The solution found was to create a Free Territory, with its own Governor. But shortly after the 1948 Declaration, Tito broke with the Cominform. This put the Western powers in a quandary. For while they have insisted all along that their intention was merely to do justice to all parties and to do what was best for the people of Trieste, in fact their attitude has always been ruled by expediency. They were not concerned with any minute advantages one way or the other which might accrue to the workers of Trieste by their being exploited by Italian or by Yugoslav capitalism; they wished to award the prize of the strategic and economic advantages which lay in the port of Trieste and its environs in such a way as to secure maximum advantage for themselves. Since 1948 this attitude has led them into much difficulty, since both Italy and Yugoslavia are either allies or potential allies of the Western bloc, and either would take great offence if the whole area were not given to it.


Opportunism

The attitude of the Soviet Union has been equally opportunist. When Yugoslavia was apparently firmly fixed in its alliance with Russia, the latter made every effort to secure Trieste for its protege; but since Tito’s break with the Cominform, Russia has strongly supported making the area a free territory, thus preventing the access of strength which would come to either country if it were given Trieste.

In such a game of power politics, with each great Power fighting unashamedly for its own hand, the interests of the Triestine workers are ignored. Both Italy and Yugoslavia seem to be prepared to go to war over Trieste, with all that that would entail in suffering to the people of both countries and of Trieste itself, rather than let the other country obtain undisputed control of Trieste and its immediate hinterland.

The Socialist Party’s position is clear. In a Socialist system of society such a situation could not arise. National boundaries would disappear, since they are only maintained by the necessities of a property-owning system. No States would wrangle and threaten over Trieste, since States would have dissolved along with the property system of society which alone gives rise to and maintains them.


Negotiate from Strength

The Labour Government initiated a large programme of rearmament, and the Conservative Government has continued it, under the slogan of “negotiating from strength.” The workers were assured that, although it might be thought that heavy re-armament would probably lead to a third world war, this was not so; peace would best be secured by piling up the munitions of war, until this country and its allies were so strong that its potential enemies would not dare to attack it. In advocating this solution, our politicians showed that they were still hankering after the conditions of the mid-nineteenth century; then, because Britain had embarked upon its Industrial Revolution decades before any other country, it was by far the strongest country in the world. There were no “big” or long-lasting wars because no other country could for long dispute the supremacy of Britain. But this was merely an ephemeral phase, a phase which could only arise where there was one giant and a number of pigmies; in the modern world, where there are a number of giants, to hope to restore the conditions of a hundred years ago is to be doomed to disappointment.


Increased Strength—on both sides

What has now happened to the "Negotiating from strength” argument? The Western bloc thought that if it had the atomic bomb it would be secure from attack; but then Russian scientists also evolved the atom bomb. The Western bloc thought that if it had the hydrogen bomb it would be secure from attack; but now Russia has exploded the hydrogen bomb also.

As President Eisenhower said on October 8th:
“The Soviets now have the capability of atomic attack on us, and such capability will increase with the passage of time . . , The Soviets now possess a stockpile of atomic weapons of conventional types and we must furthermore conclude that the powerful explosion of August 12 last was produced by a weapon, or the forerunner of a weapon, of power far in excess of conventional type ” (9-10-53).
So where do we go from here?


The march to war

The moral is simple. In a capitalist world there is no security against war. If one state tries to build up such a strength in armaments that other states would not dare to attack her, the other states will be afraid that the first country plans aggression, and will in their turn build up armaments. And although an armaments race does not make war inevitable, it creates an atmosphere of fear and suspicion in which the unavoidable disputes between capitalist states can more easily cause war. Thus a heavy armament programme adopted in an effort to find security by one capitalist state among many, in fact leads not to security but to a greater likelihood of war.
Alwyn Edgar


Blogger's Note:
The Declassified UK website gives more background on events in British Guiana in 1953.

Socialism and the class struggle (1953)

From the November 1953 issue of the Socialist Standard

The object of the S.P.G.B. is Socialism, a definition of which is given in every issue of the Socialist Standard, together with a Declaration of Principles, which show how society is constituted and how the working class must organise to overthrow the capitalist system and introduce Socialism.

As shown in the Declaration of Principles, the class struggle originates out of economic conditions; all workers take part in the class struggle, whether they are conscious of it or not and whether they like it or not

It is always necessary to remember that the class struggle is two-sided, that it is not only the workers who organise to try and maintain and improve their position, but the capitalist class at all times do likewise and so far they have done it more successfully than the working class. W. Liebknecht, in his pamphlet, “No Compromise,” recognised the class struggle carried on by the capitalists when he wrote: “The class struggle which the proletariat carries on is only a counter struggle in self-defence to resist the class struggle of the bourgeoisie against the proletariat; and the end of this struggle by the victory of the proletariat will be the abolition of the class struggle in every form.”

Victory over capitalism will never be attained by being on the defensive; the class struggle carried on by non-Socialist workers on the economic field in Trade Unions, etc., will never lead to Socialism, indeed, that is not the aim of non-Socialists. They struggle to maintain and improve their conditions under capitalism and the capitalist class struggle to maintain and improve theirs, but history has proved that on the economic field the capitalist class has most of the advantages.

Socialists, by taking political action against the capitalist class, switch from the defensive to the offensive. The class struggle is both industrial and political, the latter its revolutionary form. On the political field the workers of all countries have but one interest, and that involves winning political power and dispossessing the master class. Tie supreme conflict with that class leaves no room for sectional antagonisms between workers.

The Declaration of Principles of the Socialist Party were drafted by Socialists with a great deal of thought and knowledge of the development of society. The Declaration of Principles allow for no compromise with the capitalist class, and offers no reforms for improving capitalism.

The strength of the Socialist Party rests on acceptance of the class struggle, that the working class is exploited and oppressed by the capitalist class, and that within capitalist society effectual reforms which will put an end to class government and class exploitation are impossible. As Marx so correctly stated, “When the class struggle is pushed on one side as a disagreeable 'crude’ phenomenon, nothing remains as a basis for Socialism but ‘true love of humanity' and empty phraseology about 'justice',"  Pity for poverty, enthusiasm for equality and freedom, recognition of social injustice and a desire to remove it, are not Socialism.

The basis of society to-day is the class ownership of the land, factories and other means of living. The central point of our attack is this social base, the class ownership of the means of life. The possessors must be dispossessed.

To Socialists, political action is the action aimed at getting control of the governmental machinery for the purpose of introducing Socialism. In other words, the prosecution of the class struggle in a revolutionary way.
D.W. Lock

Women's weekly magazines (1953)

From the November 1953 issue of the Socialist Standard
“ Avaunt this vile abuse of pictured page!
. . . Heaven save us from a lower stage.”
Thus the aged Wordsworth on illustrated books and newspapers. His tetchy complaint was uttered in 1846, when developments in printing technology and the growth of railway travel were creating both the demand and the technical means for cheap, bright periodicals. W. H. Smith opened his first bookstall in 1848; “light reading” became the popular—and, after the Education Acts, the universal—means of passing time. Wordsworth saw only the beginning of it all.

Something like nine hundred magazines are published in this country at the present time. The most popular is “Reveille,” which is bought every week-end by three and a half million people; next are “Woman” and “Woman’s Own,” each with over two million readers, and there are half a dozen other weeklies with circulations of more than a million.

Fashions in popular reading change from generation to generation. The most successful and the most ephemeral magazine is the one which measures most accurately what the general public wants; you can please quite a lot of the people for quite a lot of the time, but you must be prepared for a drop in circulation when the nature of public consciousness alters. On the other hand, the longest-lived magazines are those with restricted appeal; “The Countryman,” “The Sporting and Dramatic News” and “The Spectator” are examples. Women’s magazines have the best of both worlds. Their appeal is limited, but limited to half the community; they have the certainty of a known field of interest, and the field is large enough to necessitate the devices and techniques that make for mammoth circulation.

There are nineteen weekly magazines for women. “Home Notes,” the oldest, first appeared in 1894, and the foundation dates of the others are fairly evenly spread between then and 1937, when “Woman” was first published. Looking at them over the years—or even at their predecessors of Wordsworth’s day—one is mildly surprised at how little they have altered. Here is “Woman’s Weekly,” 1912, price a penny: “Great New Year’s Gift Number,” with a Gibson girl on the cover. Patterns; a powerful new serial by Annie S. Swan; readers’ best recipes; lace work; home nursing; . health and beauty page; Dainty Cupid Leap Year Charm given free to subscribers; “Ethel” replying to girls’ problems and my-dearing them for all she is worth.

The difference between the weekly and the monthly magazines is chiefly of pretentiousness and price. If any feature can be said to mark the frontiers, however, it is the “help page.” The monthlies try to do without it; to the weeklies, it is life’s blood. A lot of people believe that the problems are made up by the magazine’s editorial staff. In fact, “human problems” is the busiest of all the advice services—legal, child-care, beauty and furnishing are others—which are offered by the women’s magazines. A weekly of average popularity receives anything up to two hundred letters a week; most are answered by post, and only a selection is printed. The confidantes are all homely women with homely-sounding names; Mrs. Jim, Mary Grant, Evelyn Home. It is easy enough to snigger at the help page with its jealousies and frustrations and frailties, its girls in trouble, possessive mothers and lonely virgins. The problems are real enough to those who have them, and the answers, for the most part, are sensible and to the point.

Every magazine devotes at least one other page to letters. Readers write about their romances, their hobbies, their families, their jobs, their favourite food, their hopes and ambitions. Half-a-guinea or a guinea is paid for each published letter; as a link with readers' consciousness, they are probably cheap at the price—they may even explain why a women’s magazine seldom goes out of business.

It is on this pabulum of everyday life that the stories thrive. The “Garden of Allah” type of escape- story, best-selling between the wars, was never really the stuff for women’s magazines, though occasionally it appeared. The great bulk of the stories have workaday and domestic life as their settings. There is no obvious fantasy, no escapism into past, future or distant worlds, and the harshest realities of this world—war and unemployment—come in as often as they are topical. It takes some time to realize that this realism is an illusion; that the ordinary life of the stories is not ordinary at all, that the hard facts are not hard at all, and that the whole is a fantasy-world into which most of its readers can easily project themselves.

The domestic life of these stories is life on the fifteen-pounds-a-week level—what most people consider to be “middle-class” life. Nice houses with bathrooms and telephones, plenty of good clothes, tasteful furniture and the rest. True, the heroines sometimes are shop assistants or married to clerks; the only possible conclusion is that they are living above their incomes. Nobody wears Marks-and-Spencer dresses, lives with shoddy furniture, lacks elementary education or becomes unattractive from continual child-bearing. It is the daydream world of “if-only"; if only we won a few thousand on the pools, if only Henry’s firm promoted him, etc.

Unemployment and war never really make much difference. The most terrible thing about unemployment in real life is that the wolf does not just howl at the door, but comes right in and stays; in the women’s magazine story, Henry always finds another job and a new day dawns bright and clear. War puts the hero in uniform as a pilot or a commando officer (never a private in the Pay Corps); coming home wounded, he leans on a stick or has one arm in a sling. The atmosphere is that of a fancy-dress party where the guests have nothing to declare but their ingenuousness.

The world of women’s magazine stories can be summarized as something like this. You are an attractive, smartly-dressed woman of your own age, sitting in the lounge of a sizeable semi-detached house. There are flowers on the sideboard and “Vogue” on the coffee table. If you are single, in a little while you will bath and put on your new evening frock because a handsome young man in well-cut clothes and a Jaguar is going to call to take you out to the theatre. If you are married, your two nicely-spoken children are playing hide-and-seek in the garden; Henry—tender, wise and patient—will soon be home from the City; you will never become a worn-out drudge because your home has all the labour-saving gadgets advertized in the women’s magazines.

That is approximately the nature of the make-believe. There are two things which must be noted about it. The first is that it is a mistake to assume, as many people do, that the writers who create and populate this world are bad writers. Actually, theirs is one of the most highly skilled branches of journalism in the world; it is a trade, not an art, and they are first-class practitioners of it. The second thing is that the make-believe obviously feeds a real and continuous hunger. A well-to-do person in urban society has access to variety of experience, a member of a healthy primitive community has depth of experience; a working-class woman usually knows neither. The craving for romance is the craving for either or both of those filings. James Joyce’s “Ulysses” contains a remarkable passage in which a working girl named Gerty MacDowell has a romantic daydream; the dream is a series of images and phrases straight from the pages of innumerable women’s stories.

Roughly one-sixth of the space in an average magazine is taken up by stories. Advertisements cover something like half the total space, and most of the remainder is occupied by articles on female and domestic affairs—cookery, dress-making, health and beauty, fashion, make-do-and-mend, child care, plus one or two items such as a sentimental verse and a horoscope ("Your financial position will improve about next Friday”). Reading these columns of advice on how to bring up baby, how to stay good-looking and what to cook for supper, one sees how vastly public consciousness has altered in the past half-century. The outsize family, with its yearly childbirth, its unkempt, fagged-out mother and its bread-and-jam diet is nearly non-existent today in Britain (except in areas with large Catholic populations, where ignorance and fear keep it going). Most people nowadays really care about their standard of living and really want to bring up their children well; the findings of nutrition experts and child psychologists make their way to, and to some degree are acted upon by, working people. The convention of “what was good enough for my father is good enough for me” has largely disappeared. In 1903, women’s magazines offered cheap patterns for dust-caps and aprons; in 1953, they explain how to make dresses which, from a short distance and for a short time, look as if they came from Norman Hartnell. A great deal of ignorance and dirt and superstition (in spite of the horoscopes) has disappeared; people of all ages are more humane, more responsible, and more conscious of their environment.

Popular reading matter always has a good deal to tell us about the social life and attitudes of its time. What springs most irresistibly from a study of women’s magazines is how unchanged are the basic concerns of life for working-class women. In spite of suffrage, admission to almost every career and profession, and the consequent thirty-year clamour over equality of the sexes, the fundamentals are still the same: finding husbands, rearing children and managing homes. Going to work is not an exchange for these concerns, it is an addition to them, and married women who go to work do so mostly to help finance their homes. “Woman’s place is in the home,” which is usually put forward as an arguable proposition, is really nothing of the sort, but a simple statement of fact.

Living in a working-class home means being involved in the perennial problem of insufficient money. For the single woman, it limits severely the probable area for finding a husband; for the married woman, it means having to make the money go round, and leading an extremely flat and unvaried life in the process. It is this economic blockade from the real world of experience that leads to escape into a fantasy-world, where domesticity is bliss, every cloud has a silver lining and there is true romance for all except the bad girls.

The moral obviously is not to pooh-pooh or condemn women’s magazines as purveyors of baby talk and life-by-proxy. They pass on fairly necessary information and advice about domestic matters, and have probably been influential in spreading more responsible social attitudes. Most people of today want things to be better; “good enough for the likes of us” is a sentiment that no longer has much share in working-class consciousness. As for the stories, possibly they are bilge. That does not, however, answer the question why the majority of working-class women need to have a fantasy-world created for them, and a large number need to have decisions on the management of their lives made for them by a completely unknown Mrs. Jim or Evelyn Home. The truth obviously is that there is something fundamentally wrong with a society in which such needs are so widespread.
Robert Barltrop