Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Letter: A Reader defends the Liberal Party (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

A Reader defends the Liberal Party

Finchley Road, London, N.W.2.

The Secretary, S.P.G.B.

Dear Sir,—Some months ago I wrote to you asking for an explanation of certain statements made about Marxism in the pamphlet Socialist Comment. I never received a reply, although when I sent for “Questions of the Day” it was quickly sent. I will not assume that you are only interested in spreading your ideas and not caring to answer questions on them, but that an administrative hitch was the reason for your silence. I am now writing to ask you why you have deliberately distorted the facts about the Liberal Party in the booklet “Questions of the Day.” As a Liberal I deeply resent the allegation made against the Liberal Party. First, you have deliberately tried to convey the impression that the Liberal Party is composed of capitalists of the High Tory calibre. Nothing could be further than the truth. It is not clever to give accounts of nineteenth century Whig and so-called Liberal administration and then point to the Liberals of today. It is a cheap trick and is completely misleading. The nineteenth century Liberals were in some measure more enlightened than the Tories. This does not mean to say that the present-day Liberal Party follows their doctrines. Far from it; we only accept that which is good; e.g., Repeal of the Com Laws. But why go back in history? Surely it is only the present that counts? But even if you must delve back into the past, at least be honest. Nothing is said about the great Liberal social reforms at the beginning of the twentieth century, and nothing about our Free Trade ideas.

Liberalism is identified with laissez-faire. But not, and this point must be stressed, of the 19th century variety. The Government should merely supervise industry, nationalising only public utilities, and keeping a sharp eye on restrictive practices, inflation, etc. In that way the evils of unfettered capitalism and the evils of bureaucratic Socialism can be avoided.

I am not asking you to share my beliefs [it would be futile in any case] but only to present them in a fair way.
Yours faithfully,
Brian M. Levy.


Reply.
We cannot trace our correspondent’s earlier letter. We certainly have no wish to avoid answering questions, and if he will repeat them a reply will be forthcoming.

The letter goes on make charges about the contents of the S.P.G.B. pamphlet Questions of the Day, but the charges are quite unfounded. It is true that the chapter on the Liberal Party deals to a considerable extent with the actions of that party in the nineteenth century, but it also deals with the programme of the Liberal Party at the 1950 General Election—about which our correspondent says nothing.

Our correspondent asks "Why go back in history?" This would, of course, be a legitimate point for the present-day Liberal Party to make if in fact that party repudiated the policies and actions of the Liberal Party and Liberal governments in the past. Until such repudiation is forthcoming and while the Liberal Party goes on chiming continuity with its own past, it will continue to be pertinent for us to expose what those Liberals were and what they did. And our correspondent does not give any evidence at all of any distortion on our part.

Our correspondent does name one of the "great social reforms” of the Liberal past and explicitly approves it—the repeal of the Com Laws and the support for Free Trade. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Free Trade movement was one conducted by the Liberal factory owners for the purpose of getting cheap food and consequently low wages.

As regards the present-day activities of the Liberals, one of their main concerns is to promote schemes of profit-sharing. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Liberal aim is to get the workers to work harder and thus secure "increased profits,” out of which increase the workers are to receive a share. Yet our correspondent writes indignantly at our charge that the Liberal Party is, as it always was, a party of capitalism.

His last point is equally revealing. He claims that the Liberal Party is in favour of nationalising certain industries. As nationalisation is State capitalism and does not serve the interests of the working class, this too, clearly demonstrates the capitalist character of the Liberal Party.
Editorial Committee.

Letters from readers invited (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Our Annual Conference in April decided that a section of the Socialist Standard be reserved for letters from readers as a regular feature. Readers are invited to send letters of comment and criticism and questions for answer. Letters should be kept as short as possible as space is limited, and the shorter the letters the larger the number that can be printed.
Editorial Committee.

Letter: A Reply to W. Brain (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
S.W.16.

Dear Sir,—In his article “Instructions for M.A.s,” W. Brain asserts that only by breaking the bonds of religion shall we survive, and that “ as Socialists we fight the powers temporal and spiritual.”

True religion divorced from Creedalism, which is man made, embraces all races and colours as brothers and sisters, recognises the Fatherhood of God and personal responsibility towards families and humanity.

I know many staunch Socialists who uphold all these principles, so that W. B. is quite wrong in claiming that “ as Socialists” we shun the things of Spirit.

Anti-Religionism is a Communist doctrine, not Socialist. Man is a Spirit allied to a body, of which I have absolute proof. How then can we fight the things of Spirit?

Man is a Spirit, allied to a body—of this I have indisputable proof. Art, Music, Song, the Dance, Poetry, fine literature and all things of Mother Nature are “things of the Spirit.” How, then, can we overthrow them?

It is the absence of Spirituality in the world which breeds vice, crime, disease and suffering. If we overthrow Religion in the purest sense (and again I do not mean “Creedalism ”) we must become as the beasts of the field.
Sincerely,
(Mme.) Sandra Oland, 
Concert pianist and psychic writer.

Letter: A letter of appreciation (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
Coggeshall, Essex.

Dear Sirs,—

A brief line to record the appreciation of my friends and I for that really unique journal, the S.S. Since the time of reading my first copy nothing seems quite the same—certainly the run-of-the-mill dailies, with their hysterical clamour for this and that cause, have been relegated to their correct status—alongside the horror comics and science fiction. True, masterpieces of bourgeois “culture ” these! The only flaw in this newfound awareness is noticed when one observes fellow-workers avidly soaking up the capitalist sludge in such misused toilet-paper as the Daily Sketch—then I know the real meaning of that overworked word frustration.

Well, I suppose we must accept the old adage re “the toughest stone ”—in the meantime thanks again for a really well appreciated journal from a few enlightened wage-slaves.
—Yours,
G. T. Croxford.

P.S.—Specially appreciated are the razor-sharp commentaries on the “Men of God ’—they are priceless!

Letter: A Reply to Sidney Warr (1957)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard
(Views put in letters in the correspondence column 
do not necessarily represent the Party’s attitude).
Morecambe.

Dear Editors,,—

There is a well-known variant question regarding Socialists not joining larger organisations such as L.P., C.P. I.L.P., etc., so as not to be splitters— see end of Sidney Warr’s letter, S.S. Sept.—the editorial reply does not touch.

Many times I have pointed out that in ordinary matters people seek TRUTH. Anyone who is pointed out an error, falsity or bad fitting part in, say, a machine, immediately seeks to correct it. How many times have Labour folk, C.P-ers and I.L.P-ers, been told their case was wrong; i.e., not Socialism (Marxism): but they still keep harping on the same old reformist note. The only excuse—not logical argument—they make is that the S.P.G.B. is small. So why they do not make a little effort and get right and join us, make us bigger and better; i.e., work for Socialism, I really don’t know, unless it is fear or laziness. May we see thousands of Sidney Warrs filling up forms “A” and not being led by leaders who likewise are not interested in Socialism? The question goes very deep for a short letter.
Yours fraternally.
Maxi Shaw.

Letter: Socialism and Religion (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Socialism and Religion

The existence of religion no more proves the existence of God than does the existence of the rainbow. In the debate I stated that without God’s existence miracles could not occur, prayer would be useless, after life impossible, and the Bible neither holy nor inspired. My opponent agreed to all this and nodded approvingly. Therefore, I continued, since everything depends on God's existence, it is incumbent on you to prove it, for we Socialists deny it. One cannot prove God’s existence by pointing to religious paraphernalia, for there are religions without a personal God, and dozens of gods of a kind who have neither a religion associated with them nor followers who pray to them.

The four quotations from the Bible given by PEN will answer anybody who wants to resurrect the Jesus myth. Not only did Christ say that he came not to bring peace but a sword, but kept his word in this respect (which is more than he did about his return), but the sword has been wet with religious and Christian blood ever since. Socialism does not need this contradictory fantastic rubbish, which is the product of primitive man’s childhood.
Horace Jarvis.

Letter: "Who owns? Who controls? Who manages, etc". (1957)

Letters to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

N.W.2.

Dear Comrades,—

If I may make some observations on Comrade Wilmott’s article in last month’s Socialist Standard, it occurs to me that the main problem to deal with in analysing the approach of people such as Burnham is to isolate the focal point of their approach to present-day society. What exactly is it they regard as the determining factor which makes society capitalist? My experience has been that all judgments seem to be made on the organisation at the top: Who owns? Who controls? Who manages, etc., and how? The position of the working class in all this is apparently of little consequence. It never occurs to them to base their judgments on the totality of social relationships and the basic common factors. The question “what is capitalism”? is that answered from one standpoint, but by laying bare the mechanism as a whole. The arrangement of the working parts may vary, but we are able to recognise in each case the same machine, with the same function. 
I. D. Jones.

50 Years Ago: A Travesty of Socialism (1957)

The 50 Years Ago column from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Undoubtedly one of the greatest hindrances to a clear understanding of Socialism is the misrepresentation to which it is subject, not only from opponents, but also from those who, at times, call themselves Socialists. Here, for example, is Mr. Jas. Parker, Labour M.P. For Halifax, which position he secured by making a compact with the Liberal Party, assuring an audience at Swadlincote Town Hall (on October 8th) that the Army, Navy, and Post Office are Socialistic institutions, and that the last Government decided to socialise the telephones. Did anyone ever hear such twaddle ? What is Socialism ? It is the ownership and control by all the people of all the means of production and distribution of wealth. It is thus the very antithesis of capitalism. How, then, can you have Socialistic institutions in the midst of capitalism ? The Army and the Navy exist for the purpose of protecting the British capitalist class against the capitalist class of other countries and to enable them to extend their spheres of exploitation. Yet these according to our I.L.P. oracle, are Socialistic ! And the Post Office is admittedly an institution where the lower grade of workers are abominably sweated in order to provide a huge profit, which the P.M.G. (Tory or Liberal) may apply to the reduction of taxation. And as taxes do not affect the working class in the least, as their exploitation takes place in the factory—they are robbed at the pay-box—what does it matter to them whether taxes are high or low ?

There is all the difference in the world between State Capitalism and Socialism . . . To argue that certain capitalist institutions are Socialist ones is misleading and those who so argue are either ignorant or fraudulent.

[From the unsigned article, 'A Travesty of Socialism', the Socialist Standard, November, 1907].

Party News Briefs (1957)

Party News from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

The London Propaganda Programme has gone according to plan, the meetings have been successful in every way. The last meeting of the series is in the form of a debate which is being held at Lambeth Town Hall on Monday 4th November. This debate is with the Union Movement—details of time, speakers and title are in the “ notices ” columns.


The Speakers’ Study Class continues its excellent work. The members are actually punctual on every occasion, and are keen and hardworking, so much so that file tutors are confident that our speaking strength will be augmented next year by several “graduates” from the class.


Comrade Gilmac is back in London after his trip to Canada and America. In this, issue he has written a brief report of his experiences. He was certainly afforded a very warm welcome by our comrades in the West, and in Gilmac’s brief report to the E.C. he modestly suggested that his visit had stimulated the Comrades into planning more propaganda drives. It is to be hoped that his trip will pave the way for others to be able to visit our Comrades across the Atlantic.


The Central Literature Sales Committee again appeal for the utmost support for an all out drive to sell the S.S. during the month of November. Arrangements are similar to previous drives, and branches will have received our circular by the time you read this. It is an uphill climb—this selling of our journal (like all Socialist propaganda), but we ask members not to let this deter them and to keep on climbing. Contact your branch and give them a hand; they certainly need it.


Documentary Films at Head Office are now being run every Sunday evening at Head Office. These proved most successful last year, and there is always time for questions and discussion after the showing of the film. The titles for this month are listed in this issue and they cover a wide variety of subjects.


The Autumn Delegate Meeting was not so well attended as could be wished, but the agenda was completed in good time; in fact, the meeting finished at 4 p.m. on Sunday afternoon. Despite a smaller attendance over £8 was collected towards Party funds.


Isolated Members and Sympathisers are invited to act as contact secretaries for the establishment of Socialist discussion groups in their locality. A directory will be published in these columns. All who are interested in this task should first contact the Groups Secretary at Head Office, who will keep them posted with any activities which may result.
Phyllis Howard

SPGB Meetings (1957)

Party News from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard









Blogger's Note:
"E. J. Ham" was better known as Jeffrey Hamm. He was a leading figure in the British Fascist movement after World War Two. According to his wiki page, Hamm was, for a time, associated with Eleonora Tennant, which is interesting as the SPGB debated Tennant in the early 1930s when she was a parliamentary candidate for the Conservative Party.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Socialism versus Christianity. Are They Mortal Enemies? (1909)

From the November 1909 issue of the Socialist Standard

The perturbation of the Church at the spread of Socialism was reflected in the predominance of that topic among the subjects discussed at the Church Congress at Swansea ; and the very full report of its proceedings in the Standard newspaper was interesting reading to Socialists in consequence. Early in the first session
A SIGNIFICANT NOTE
was struck, and the identity upon fundamentals of the two great sections of Christians in this country was indicated. A return deputation from the Welsh and English Free Church councils of Swansea came with words of welcome and expressions of gratitude, and, amid the bandying of compliments, the president of the Congress gave voice to their fundamental unity. As between the Liberal and Tory sections of the capitalist class in frankly political matters, so between the religious reflexes of the two sections, there is nothing vital at stake ; and the attitude of the clergy of the Church of England toward Socialism differs in no essential from that of the clergy of Nonconformity.

At the Church Congress, as at other Christian conferences, the acuteness of the conflict between the mission of the workers and that of the churches showed itself as an instinctive feeling, expressed in different ways by all the speakers, that between Socialism and Christianity something fundamental is at stake. Frankness, however, is not characteristic of the prelate, and toward Socialism his antagonism is often
MASKED UNDER A VERBAL SYMPATHY
with everything, except, of course, that which is material. So soon, indeed, as the material interests of the workers are dealt with, or the need of a radical change in economic conditions is mentioned, and particularly whenever the indubitable necessity for deposing the class whose interests and aims require the maintenance of the present hellish conditions is expressed, all this Christian sympathy vanishes amid mutterings of “Materialism,” “Atheism,” and assertions of the utter unimportance of all material things as compared with things spiritual. If by their simulated sympathy the clergy can succeed in diverting a section of the working-class movement from its genuine material aims into a futile chasing of spiritual will-o’-the-wisps, they will deserve well of their capitalist paymasters. And that such aim underlies the so-called Socialistic leanings of many Christians is made plain by the hope they constantly profess, of ridding
THE SOCIALIST MOVEMENT
of its materialism and of its hostility to the capitalist class; and this means ridding the Socialist movement of its Socialism.

Thus Dr. Ingram, Bishop of London, in a most conciliatory speech, nevertheless found it needful to “denounce many advocates of the social movement for the unchristian setting of class against class in public speaking. It was absurd to say that Capital and Labour were enemies,” etc., etc. So also the Bishop of Truro, who opened, pleaded for “Socialism” the while that he severely reproved materialism and revolution. Thus Christian “Socialism” is a term emptied of all meaning, and on this ground one can understand the Bishop’s emphasised remark that “we might all quite safely be Socialists to-morrow if we and the rest of the world were sincerely Christians to-day.” On the same lines doubtless the worthy Bishop might safely obey the scriptural injunction tomorrow to sell all he has and give it to the poor if the term “poor” could be so Christianised to-day as to mean a company that would pay him 20%.

There was, however, at least one speech at the Congress that rang true and was not a mere juggling of words. Dr. Shadwell clearly and vigorously emphasised the
IRRECONCILABLE ANTAGONISM
that exists between the Christian and the Socialist concepts of life, and with much of what he said we are in agreement. He denounced the loose and unjustifiable use of the word “Socialism” as a misuse of language and a source of confusion, and proceeded to call a spade a spade. He traced the term to an early definition and said :
“It stood for a movement having a practical aim in view. It was not a theory, or a doctrine, or an idealistic sketch like the Utopias, but an essentially practical policy. Its object was to abolish poverty by doing away with the unequal distribution of wealth, to which all evils are attributed. The means were a reconstruction of the economic framework of society, whereby the working classes, who alone produce all wealth, should become its owners, and all private property, except that actually earned, should be abolished. . . . The only changes effected in the three-quarters of a century since elapsed are the demarcation of several varieties ot Socialism, distinguished by differences of detail in the methods they would adopt, a more concise definition of the predominant policy, and the discovery of a so-called scientific basis for it. But they all come under this description—a movement for preventing the present unequal distribution of wealth and abolishing poverty by the economic reorganisation of society. This, and this alone is Socialism. The ultimate end is the universal happiness of mankind, the extinction of strife, and the establishment of brotherly love.”
Dr. Shadwell further added, with quite unconscious irony, that ‘”this would involve the disappearance of Kings, Lords and Priests— especially Bishops.” One can quite understand that if the
“ESTABLISHMENT OF BROTHERLY LOVE”
has as a consequence the disappearance of his profession, it is not what he is looking for.

Speaking of the materialistic basis of Socialism Dr. Shadwell said :
“In the first place Socialism deals solely with material or economic conditions—the distribution of wealth. All evil and unhappiness are traced to its mal-distribution, which divides mankind into rich and poor; and its redistribution is relied on to abolish them and establish the ideal “state.” If any one thinks that view of life compatible with Christianity, then I am afraid he is not a person with whom I can discuss anything seriously, for however estimable he may be, words evidently have for him no particular meaning. . . The purely materialistic view on which Socialism is based is absolutely opposed to Christian teaching and false to life.”
It is, however, the Christian concept that is false to life in that it denies the primary importance of material things and is in perennial conflict with science. Moreover, that this conflict with science is the condemnation of Christianity, is recognised by the clergy ; as is shown by their strenuous but futile endeavours to reconcile religion with science. In this matter they attempt to
SIT BETWEEN TWO STOOLS
and cannot help but come to grief inconsequence. This is illustrated in the discussion at the Church Congress, for Dr. Shadwell’s stand on behalf of Christianity and free will as opposed to Socialism and economic determinism, was cut from beneath his feet by two of his confreres. The Archdeacon of Ely said :
“Evidence has been brought under my notice which shows that the tone of morality in some Cambridgeshire villages is deplorably low, and that no external change would do more to remedy this than the building of sufficient cottage accommodation.”
while the Bishop of London said :
“As he wended his way to some slum church, he felt almost ashamed of the comfortable condition of his life as contrasted with the awful life of people in the slums. Therefore he could not agree with Dr. Shadwell that circumstances did not affect character, and that there were not children born damned into the world.”
Now can these priests be ignorant of the fact that they have, by their evidence, knocked the bottom out of the Christian position ? If children are born into the world damned for life, as they undoubtedly are, what remains of the doctrine of free will and the whole religious superstructure raised upon it ? Admit the influence of economic conditions on character and conduct and the whole Christian scheme of reward and and punishment, fall and redemption,
TUMBLES TO THE GROUND
as a logical consequence ; for where is the reason for reward or punishment hereafter if man is what heredity and environment have made him ? Fundamentally, indeed, the supernatural is totally excluded from the whole of the known, universe by the interminable warp and woof of cause and effect. As Leibnitz said, “As knowledge takes a step forward God takes a step backward.” The height of man’s superstition is the depth of his ignorance. Socialism is science applied to society, and is the child of experience and light, just as Christianity is the offspring of ignorance and darkness. The one reflects the development and perfecting of the social forces under man’s control, while the other reflects their imperfection, insufficiency, and lack of control by man. In his “Jewish Question,” Karl Marx said : “For us religion is not the cause of social imperfection but its result. We explain the religious subjection of citizens by their social subjection. We do not pretend that they must shake off their religious chains in order to get rid of their social chains; we say, on the contrary, that they will get rid of their religious chains by disengaging themselves from their social chains.

“We do not transform questions of this world into questions of theology, we transform the questions of theology into questions of this world. History has
BEEN EXPLAINED BY RELIGION
long enough, let us explain religion by history The question of the relations between political emancipation and religion become for us a question of the relations between political emancipation and human emancipation.”

Thus does Dr. Shadwell’s assertion that “Socialism is the mortal enemy of Christianity” obtain a deeper meaning. As the Bishop of Truro said : “Individualism is of the very essence of Christianity.” And modern Christianity is at once the reflex and faithful ally of capitalism, doomed to disappear with the system that it supports.

As a political ally, indeed, the ruling class make use of it to the full. They value it as a working-class soporific, or, in other words, as a means of directing the energy of the worker away from his material aims to the pursuit of things utterly immaterial, in order that the security, property, and profits of the parasites may be undisturbed. At the very Congress in question the Rev. John Wakefield was moved to remark that:
“The Church has in a large measure forfeited her right to condemn and denounce by her inexplicable cowardice and culpable silence when commons have been enclosed and peasant holdings have been swept away, and fetid slums have been made to yield swollen profits to ground landlords and property and property jobbers.”
But in truth it is not that the Church has been passive in all this, but that it has been
AN ACTIVE AGENT
in the robbery and oppression of the toilers. It has long been the servile tool of the ruling class and the hypocritical enemy of those who produce, always ready to bless war of oppression and to oppose the resistance of the workers to oppression, or lull them into submission. To quote a pregnant sentence from Marx’s criticism of Hegal, “Religion is the opium of the people.” The slave is enjoined to resist not evil, to despise earthly things, and to regard this world as a vale of tears, a toilsome preparation for a reward in eternal life. Socialism on the contrary is the recognition of the supreme importance of material things, while Christianity is their negation. Socialism is part of that scientific conception of life which excludes the supernatural by tracing all things to natural sources. It indicates the natural genesis and modern decay of religion, and exposes its role as an agent of class oppression.

That Christianity still retains its ancient Inquisitional characteristics wherever it is strong enough, may be seen from
THE RECENT MURDER OF
the educationist Ferrer by the clerical party in Spain. Its comparative harmlessness in most countries in these latter days can be attributed directly to its growing weakness and  fissiparous nature. It is the development of economic forces, and man’s consequent growing control over nature and increasing knowledge of her working, that provides a wider and firmer basis for science, and leaves less room for superstition in the minds of working men. Indeed, science itself is the outcome of economic developement. It is the torch which, as its greater circle. It therefore, occasions no surprise that one of the sessions of the Church Congress was devoted to discussing that inevitable Christian conference subject: “Neglect of public worship; its causes and remedies.” The great decline of religion among the workers has been attested in every field, but none of the clergy put his finger on the cause, as was, indeed, to be expected. And in point of remedies : revision and readaptation were the keynotes of the discussion. Revise and readapt how she may, however, the Church, is
IRREVOCABLY DOOMED.
She persists and is supported to-day because she is useful as the handmaiden of class government, and because of the confusion and ignorance that remain owing to the disorder, parasitism, and and oppression of capitalist society. As Marx says, religion will only finally disappear through Socialism, wherein alone the relations between men in society and their relations with nature will become reasonable, orderly, and completely intelligible, leaving no mysterious or obscure nook or cranny for superstition. Nevertheless the growth of the social forces of production within modern society, and the increasing knowledge of the workers of their true relations to each other and to nature, while they form the basis of Socialism materially and intellectually, will also loosen the chains of ghost worship and mysticism from their limbs, and lessen the power of religion as a political weapon in the hands of their masters. Thus one by one the weapons of the enemy will lose their effectiveness.

The acceptance of the gospel of Socialism, indeed, logically implies the rejection of supernatural religion, although this will not in all cases be at once clearly recognised, and cannot therefore be made a test question for Socialist recruits. But the bulk of the workers are in point of fact already indifferent to religion, and no harm to the cause of Socialism can possibly result from intellectual honesty and plain speaking on religion and the implications of Socialism. To adopt any other policy, indeed, is to play the confusionist game of the enemy, as is done by such organisations as the Labour Party, those hangers on and preachers for the Nonconformist section of the capitalist party. It is science, not religion, that is the theoretic basis of our policy, and to attempt to base the working-class movement on religion is to build upon the shifting sands. Argument from the basis of religion can only add to the confusion that impedes our path. It can lend no support or inspiration to the working class in its mission, while it provides the opportunity for the charlatan, the mystery monger, and the political trickster, and buttresses the powers of oppression and robbery. We are, therefore, thankful for the speech of one who frankly opposes us, and can testify to the profound truth of his dictum that “Socialism is the mortal enemy of religion.”
F. C. Watts

Editorial: The Outlook. (1909)

Editorial from the November 1909 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Liberal Argument.
The present political situation, with the possibility of a General Election looming in the foreground, cannot fail to be of exceptional interest, and in the circumstances may prove to be fraught with importance to the working class. The Liberal Party is diligently digging its own grave by using arguments against landowners that are every bit as applicable to the capitalists, while the Labour Party have all they can manage to demonstrate to the plain man the reason for their separate existence.

In the event of an early Geueral Election brought about by the Lords rejecting the Finance Bill, this must be the immediate subject of the appeal to the country. To this will he tacked, according to the apostles of the “Newest Liberalism,” the abolition of the Lords’ veto. The Liberals in such a case are confident of success, apparently sure that the enthusiasm for the Budget exists in sufficient force and depth to carry with it the greater constitutional question. But, without the Lords, what will the Liberal Party do for an excuse for their own procrastination in the matter of reform ? Up to now the standing argument has been that the Lords block the way. It would indeed be interesting to see the sincerity of the Liberals tested by them having, beyond possibility of cloaking, that free hand in legislative matters they have hitherto denied. To conduct their present campaign the George-cum-Churchill combination has been arguing against the landed interest that the land, rendered useful and valuable by social occupation, should not be exclusively enjoyed by a class of monopolists, but should contribute to the upkeep of the State. These great Parliamentary debaters, if they are as logical as debaters should he, must know that they are forging a double-edged weapon which must inevitably he turned against them when the working class, to whom the appeal is particularly directed, recognise that capital likewise owes its quality as a means of production to social activities, and is no less monopolised than the land itself.

The income derived from an investment in industrial stock is no more defensible on those lines than is the income from an investment in land.

Nor will it serve to quote the privileges attaching to land ownership ; the essential nature to society of access to the land ; nor the flimsy nature of the right by which land is held. From the working-class point of view, exactly the same applies to that preponderating category of wealth, the instruments of production. Its possessors and monopolists are privileged to receive the bulk of the wealth accruing from its use : it is absolutely essential to the existence of modern society, while the right of the capitalist is really at one with that of the landholder. Neither produced his property, while with the capitalist the whole process is dependent upon the skill and the service of the workers. More than that, the very evolution of both of the actual instruments and of the processes in which, and by which, they are employed, has been a social one, based upon the experience of the workers in their use. The capitalist, as such, has long ceased to perform any useful or necessary functions either in direction or organisation in industry. He is approaching, where he has not already reached, the position of the financial manipulator of the results of the wealth producers’ efforts. To speculate with wealth produces nothing. The capitalist class generally is equally as parasitic to-day as its landlord section, and to draw a distinction between them from a test of social utility would be as impossible as it would be destructive to both.

The Tory Opposition.
On the other hand it must be recognised that the opposition they have to face is lamentably weak. The Tory Party is not only deficient in men of outstanding ability, so far, of course, as parliamentary leadership is concerned, but even on the question of Tariff Reform—to which, apparently, they have pinned their faith—there seems an extraordinary indefiniteness as to just what this central point of their creed means, with the result that there is nothing for the rank and file to enthuse over.

The Labour Party.
The Labour Party and the position it can take up, may furnish some interesting speculations. At present they are tumbling over one another to support the Liberal Budget—which renders their identity with the Liberals too obvious to justify the Trade Unions paying for their separate existence : in which connection it is well to remember that Trade Union contributions to Labour Party funds must now be very largely voluntary. The more they become “advanced” to keep their identity clear, the farther they get from that Liberal support which, in no small measure, is responsible for their presence in the House.

Electoral Reform.
If the Constitutional question is raised in an appeal to the country, the Premier has practically promised that the question of the Franchise will be raised, especially as it affects women, and this would probably be included. One of the few things for which we may give credit to the Government is the way in which its head opposed the hysteric demands of women for the enfranchisement of the propertied ones among them. In that case we may see a bid for popularity by the Liberals with a democratised Suffrage.

The Dark Horse.
The uncertain and unsettling element in the situation is the President of the Local Government Board. Three years ago he was the populariser of the Government, the testimony to the democratic ideals that actuate “the Great Liberal Party.” Not many months ago an important London Liberal paper was urging that John Burns should be used more on the party stump—if the term may be allowed—because he more than any other man in the Liberal ranks could get to the heart of the people. Now John Burns is dumb. The national appeals, the propagandist speeches, are left to Mr. Lloyd George or Mr. Winston Churchill, with an occasional endorsement in the leader. This is unlike the Burns we know. When the Liberal Party is attacking the “hereditary principle” why is Mr. Burns silent, when the abolition of that principle found a place in his election programme in 1906 ? When the Liberal Government is “penalising property” with the “predatory Socialism” of its Budget (according to the Tory Press) why is the “Socialist” member of the Cabinet, which we are assured by the Liberal Press is perfectly united, not lending his most powerful aid ?

The Socialist Attitude.
We are not in a position perhaps at this stage to prophecy, but Mr. Burns is probably contemplating some means of gaining the public ear and the public attention with something of wider importance and interest than Town Planning Bills.

For the Socialist Party, and the working class for whose interest it stands, the position is clear. Convinced that no gerrymandering of the franchise or the Constitution, no readjustment of fiscal burdens, no amount of social or political or fiscal reform, from wheresoever it emanates, can touch the economic position of the workers, while they are bound by the conditions of the labour market and excluded from ownership in and control over tins machinery they operate and the wealth they produce : they will keep steadily plugging on in the heavy preliminary work of converting their fellows to the importance of the bread-and-butter question and the insignificance of’ anything else their masters may wish to bring before their notice. To the capture of the political machinery for the purpose of establishing Socialism the Socialist can only work. When he works for anything else he ceases to be a Socialist and is lost in the dust of the political contest for party, place, and power.


Blogger's Note:
There was a General Election in January 1910. A constitutional crisis had arisen because of a political stalemate between the Liberal Party dominated House of Commons and the Tory dominated House of Lords.

Radical Rodomontade. (1909)

From the November 1909 issue of the Socialist Standard

Whom the Gods would destroy—
The gods seem to have designs upon my life. Through the medium of humble instruments in the shape of “Budget Leaguers” they have been assailing me with much drivel. Than such drivel there is nothing quite so calculated to make a man mad. Only the specially case-hardened are proof against the madness. And it is written ”Whom the ‘gods would destroy they first make mad.” Hence my suspicion of the intention of the gods to me-ward.

Unfortunately for the gods, however, they are at least a baker’s dozen of years too late—which hardly seems to connote godly prescience. But that by the way. Quite that number of years ago I left off being maddened by the packet of dry bones labelled argument that the Liberal apologist, with much introductory loquacity, was for ever solemnly unwrapping and presenting to me and my class to allay our doubts of the divine inspiration of the Liberal policy, and to ensure our continued support of the Liberal Party.

The Budget League gentlemen are playing the old game. They have hardly a new trick in their bag. Their lack of originality is amazing. On any other stage they would be boo’d off incontinently. Only on the political stage are they still able to secure applause—which is even more amazing than the effrontery of their frowsy and thread-bare performance.

The effrontery of Liberal pretension.
When I discovered the emptiness of their precious show, I used to get mad. I thought it an unpardonable thing that a piteous appeal for bread should be answered with a stone—wrapped up in a baker’s bag. It seemed an intolerable thing that they who shot the workers down in protection of capitalist interests should come to us with protestations of friendship. It was an utterly unholy thing that they who asked for our support on the ground that they were “giving” us certain ameliorative reforms were in point of fact only “giving” something out of fear and then only giving that which they knew quite well beforehand would not have the beneficial effect represented. I was very young then, and these things angered me. If the gods wanted to demonstrate the truth of the aphorism they should have destroyed me then, for verily I was mad, or at any rate, jumping wild. They have lost their chance to-day. These things merely make me sleepy, and arouse a certain mild wonderment at the credulity of the people unfortunately of my own class, who are still prepared to swallow the gilded pill.

I’m afraid I’ve mixed my metaphors somewhat. But the metaphors are not nearly so mixed as the honest Budget Leaguer. There is probably a large number of that sort about—honest, but oh, so stupid. There is certainly another number not so stupid, but very—hardworking, let us say. You will find the latter on the platform doing the prestigitateur business. The former are generally in the audience, with their mouths open.

Budget League Blarney.
I came into conflict with one of the platform sort recently. He was old enough to know better, and probably did. He had the support of the local Liberal organisation, and presumably set out the official Liberal case. And a gorgeous mess he made of it. As his arguments are typical they may perhaps be followed (or chased) with advantage. He was for the Budget, the great, democratic Budget (cheers), and was concerned to explain and defend the Finance Bill.

The extra expenditure which the Bill covered had been incurred, first by Social Reforms, secondly by Dreadnaughts. It may be noted in passing that although the cost of “Social Reform” bears to the cost of Dreadnaughts something of the relation of a drop to a bucket full, “Social Reform” is always mouthed first. The idea is palpable. It serves to obscure the comparative immensity of the cost of Dreadnaughts. The same idea dominates the grocer who makes earnest and voluble enquiries about little Willie’s health to divert attention from the fact that the grocer’s hand is being weighed with the butter. The Nonconformist conscience is dominated by the retired grocer person, and the Government is dominated by the Nonconformist conscience. Q.E.D.

Dreadnaughts for the working ‘classes’.
However, my Budget Leaguer dealt with the Dreadnaught question later. I will deal with it here. Dreadnaughts were required for the protection of property. It was the Dukes of Portlands who owned most of the property, yet it was the Dukes of Portlands who were howling most about the burden of taxation. (The cheers here were heartrending. Like the jokes of Jack Point, that were “always much admired,” it is always good business to pillory the House of Lords that Liberal Governments have been largely instrumental in building up.)

But the workers had no property, went on the B. L. (B. L., it must be clearly understood, stands for Budget Leaguer, not for what you may quite properly think it ought to stand for.) That left the conclusion that most of the Liberal Government’s expenditure (on Dreadnaughts) was of no interest to the working class. This was dangerous. So the B. L. went on to explain that nevertheless the workers had much that needed protection, even more than property. There were his food, his work and his family. Dreadnaughts protected these things by keeping the trade routes open. That let imports in and kept him at work.

Unfortunately for the B. L. it doesn’t do anything of the kind. And even those in work are in large measure on the poverty line. Asked to explain he replied that remuneration depended upon supply and demand. The workers produced all the wealth, but “with the economic factors at work to-day,” etc., etc. In short the workers didn’t get it, and the Dreadnaughts didn’t help them to get it. Dreadnaughts only helped the worker to go to work—supply and demand did the rest.

The haunting horror of Invasion.
With the eye of Faith the gentle reader will now easily discern the connection between Dreadnaughts and working-class prosperity. Dreaduaughts help the worker to go to work producing the wealth he doesn’t get. Who gets it ? The B. L.’s dukes and the capitalist class. The Dreadnaughts ensure that the process will go on so far as possible. They also ensure that when the worker kicks up a row about it and looks ugly, he will be kept in his place. If he is inland and can’t be intimidated with sea guns, there’s the other arm of the force (kept in existence to protect the worker’s food, work and family, of course), the military.

But, pleads the B. L., suppose we had a weak navy and a strong enemy at our gates—why, we should starve. Horror ! what a prospect for those whom “supply and demand” have reduced already to starvation. But the enemy would conquer us, and then—why then, my poor, dear B. L., we should perhaps get the same working-class conditions that obtain in our conquerors’ country, which are approximately the same as our own. We should at the worst swop masters, and that’s all there is to it. So let the enemy come if he wants to.

The “hungry forties” once more.
The B. L. is nobly shocked. At any rate we are better off than we were. Why, in Bolton in the “hungry forties” nine people died of starvation in a day. Good old “hungry forties.” The perennial stand-by of the political bankrupt. Why did nine people die of starvation ? Vast fortunes were being piled up in those “hungry forties”—by whom ? By Liberal manufacturers largely; the same lot (snow-white and God-fearing progenitors of the Liberals of to-day) who fought so splendidly for the Free Trade that would give the starving people food and still keep wages low. The people would have to have food or the manufacturers would soon be without the labour required for profit making. It was a case of increased (relative) wages and consequent reduction of profits, or cheaper food. Free Trade meant cheaper food but a reduction in the profits of the land-owning class. The latter fought the Free Traders desperately on the issue. But the Free Traders were strongest and won. So Virtue triumphed and the people got food (of a kind) and the manufacturers profits.

That’s the reason people died of starvation in Bolton. But we have advanced enormously since then, says the B. L. We have. The wealth of the country has increased enormously—stupendously. The wealth of the working class has also increased—to the point where 21 people die of starvation in London (1905). And just to show how much we are still improving, 46 die of starvation in 1907. And in 1909 according to the B.L., a beneficient Liberal Government has concentrated its whole soul upon Social Reforms (and Dreadnaughts) designed to alleviate a little of the distress amongst those who have produced all the wealth and can’t get it.

Progress ? I should just think it is progress. If it isn’t progress what is it ?

The Liberal way of Salvation.
However, let us have a sympathetic look at the “Social Reforms” of our friend the B. L. He had only just time to mention them in passing—with one exception. There were quite a lot—unemployment insurance, labour exchanges, national development schemes, provision against invalidity, sickness, widow and orphan, wants, and old age pensions. In point of fact, excepting old age pensions, most of these things are in the air, with a few thousand other projects of the Liberal Party. Assuming they came to earth, not one of them would touch more than a ravelled thread of the fringe of the condition of the people. Unemployment insurance is at best a device to save some of the poor rate. Labour exchanges are transparent mockeries. National development schemes are ambiguities that, to the extent to which they provide useful work for some unemployed, displace employed elsewhere. Provision against invalidity and the rest are in the category of unemployment insurance. Frauds, every one—and the Liberal Party know it. They dare not deal with unemployment; dare not deal with the insecurity of working-class existence; dare not interfere with the liberty of capitalism to do what it likes with its own ; dare not touch the property basis upon which the whole social superstructure is erected and from which all the evil flows. Even if they dared they could not. The working class alone can do that—when understanding comes. And until the wealth producers themselves own their product by virtue of the ownership of the machinery of production, which they manipulate to-day, but do not possess, all the “good intentions” in the world will do no more than pave the floor of the red hell of misery and insecurity and want that the worker must tread every age-long day of life

Social Reform Fore-damned.
The Liberal Party no more than any other crowd of capital’s political hucksters, will deal with the ownership of the means of living. Challenge them individually and severally. Fix them to a yea or nay (they will shuffle and hedge and throw off clouds of words, but fix them) and the answer will be always and ever nay. Yet while the workers do not own the means of living no change can effect their general condition ; all changes are no more than good or bad hearted fooling. Social Reforms so-called are mere leather and prunella—when they are not deliberately administered antidotes to Socialism. Socialism is the thing that is feared. Socialism must be kept at bay at all hazards. And the only known medium is Social Reform—the reform, that is, that will give the shadow of amelioration without the substance ; something that will palliate discontent; something that will throw a barrier across the path down which relentless Revolution comes striding. Balfour, Asquith, Churchill, Smith—from either side and from both sides comes the fiat “Social Reform is the antidote to Socialism.” That in itself should be all the evidence required against Social Reform. The fuglemen of Capitalism administer Social Reform in the interests of the Capitalism that connotes wage slavery. Social Reform is fore-damned.

The Budget League’s Ewe Lamb.
However, I’m forgetting the B. L. He had not time to talk of the others because in fact he hadn’t the others to talk about. But he had Old Age Pensions—”the scheme for making the last years of the worker and the poor brighter and by which the brand of pauperism shall be swept away.” The dear man, only the more dear because he saved me the trouble of doing what better writers in the SOCIALIST STANDARD have done better than I can do—riddle its ridiculously inflated importance. For my B. L. set himself presently to defend the Liberal Party against the charge of extravagance and unbusinesslike method, urged by Tory job-hunters. And in doing it the B. L. cuts his own throat in a ghastly way.

This old age pension scheme, quoth he, is not all expenditure—not by any means. Why, at the present time it costs 4s. 1½d. per head per week for the keep of inmates of the union and 5s. 1d. per head for administration, or twice as much as the maximum old age pension. Extravagance ? Why, Mr. Lloyd George expected to save £1,600,000 per annum on the deal in this particular connection !

So there you have it. Instead of the people going into the workhouse to cost 10s., they will stay outside and cost only 5s.! Is that not a veritable triumph of statesmanship ? Is it not also a desperate swindle—a typical Liberal fraud ?

I can only add to that at the risk of spoiling it: let it rest so. And presently we may return to our B. L., perhaps after many days, to see how much more truth he has managed to wind up from the depths of his well. Meanwhile I cast him as bread upon the waters. And I hope for my fellows of the working class there will be enough in the foregoing to cause them to at least rub their eyes and turn out the disused thinking cap.
James Alexander

SPGB Snippets: Fancy some chips? (2026)

From the Socialist Party of Great Britain website 

November 11, 2026
EU potato growers that supply the frozen chip industry are likely to see a drop of around 25% in this season’s harvest. Whilst weather has been a contributory factor, the lower yield is also due to a deliberate decision to reduce the planted acreage. The 2025 season saw a bumper crop that resulted in up to 25% lower contract prices for growers this season.

The capitalist solution? Reduce the amount of land given over to spuds by between 15 and 25%, which, given the hot weather, turned out not to be such a great idea. This is the efficient (!) market system in operation, a system that precludes a rational approach to production, be it agricultural or industrial.

Jottings. (1909)

The Jottings Column from the November 1909 issue of the Socialist Standard

The presence of Mr. A. Henderson, M.P., at a P.S.A. conference leads one to imagine him a Christian, but when we read that only when Christians “learned to vote as they preyed”—beg pardon—”prayed” could they convince the world that Christianity was the only answer to the problems pressing for solution.

If Christianity is true, then there’s no need of the vote for Labour or Socialism. Are we not told to “ask and it shall be given,” etc. ? But Mr. Henderson does not want to rely too much on prayer. £200 a year only comes through people voting certain persons into Parliament.

* * *

The eighth conference of the Municipal Tramways Association was held in London on Sept. 22nd. A certain Councillor A. W. Chapman of Manchester, read a paper setting forth the advantages of medical examination of tramway employees. The system was to affect the employers, the employees, and the ratepayers, beneficially. Let us see the advantages to the municipal employees under this system of medical examination, as they are the only class whose interests concern us.

(1) The medical examination itself is only a means of procuring a physically better wage-slave, to endure the “speeding up” due to the electrification of the urban tramway systems to day. The position of the worker unable to pass the medical test was not (according to my report) dealt with.

The speaker gave the chief reason when, he “cited a number of cases that had arisen under the Workmen’s Compensation Act which would have been avoided had a proper system of medical examination been in existence earlier,” because, explained another speaker hailing from Manchester, “If an accident happened to an employee they had to pay half his wages whilst he was off work.”

* * *

It will be recognised by even the tyro in Socialist thought that profit-making is an anti-Socialist process, therefore it should be clear that the ratepayers interests and those of the employers (i.e., the exploiting interests of the stockholders) are not the interests of the tramway employees, for Councillor Chapman stated that “The ratepayers expected the undertakings to be run on business lines and make a profit in relief of the rates,” which latter we have often shown the workers do not pay.

* * *

The Archbishop of Westminster speaking before the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, in Manchester, on Sept. 19th, deplored “the terrible cleavage between class and class which unhappily existed in this country.”

“Here in England we were face to face with terrible social difficulties,” Dr. Bourne declared, and in order that the people should not be carried away by their sympathies into the adoption of Socialist principles, he advised the teaching of the Catholic Church as “a real bulwark against those theories which are undoubtedly gaining ground in this country.”

* * *

Dr. Bourne appears to recognise the significance of the class cleavage in this country—a distinction the I.L.P. does not share.

* * *

The appeal to the working men and women to remain in or join the Catholic (or any other) Church on account of charitable doles accruing from membership of such church will lose its force to a greater degree as economic evolution proceeds. It seems to me that the accumulation of capital into fewer hands will eliminate even those people whose business is “charity.” Finding the source from whence they formerly received assistance (?) dried up, people will look more to themselves to achieve a change in their economic conditions. It may be, however, that our Archbishop’s appeal is really to the exploiters to not throw his particular brand of religion overboard because it may yet prove useful.

* * *

“No social conditions, no legislation, could ever affect the Commandments of God.”—Archbishop Bourne at Salford Cathedral, 19.9.09.

* * *

Social conditions to-day compel men, be they capitalists or workers, to sink much of their better qualities or sink themselves. In the existing struggle for life some Biblical injunctions are daily, aye, hourly, broken. “Thou shalt not kill,” “thou shalt not steal,” are only two. The Right Rev. Doctor probably never heard of a wage slave being done to death by the conditions of production now prevalent, and he is, one must suppose, quite ignorant of the fact that the working class are robbed of their labour’s product every day.

“Six days shalt thou labour and do all that thou hast to do” is another reputed Commandment of God that, owing to social conditions, is seldom fulfilled. If it means that every man shall work six days each week then it seems very few fulfil it. Don’t people go about demanding the “right to work” ? If it means all a man’s work shall be done within six days, then I wish God would exercise his omnipotence and put it into effect. There are not many working men who would not be absolved, and very many parsons would have their six days to complete.

* * *

A Mr. A. H. Watson, S.D.P., in debating the possibility of Socialism with a representative of the Young England Patriotic Association, is reported as saying “Social Reform was merely palliation, it was fiddling with the disease. Socialism would stamp the disease out altogether.” Daily Chronicle, Sept 25.

* * *

Whilst Mr. Watson himself may not advocate reforms, the organisation of which he is a member does. (Incidentally, if neither he nor his organisation support reforms there is no reason to refuse questions from S.P.G.B. Members.)

Proof, however, that the S.D.P. does play the part of “fiddling with the disease,” is shown by the following extract from that Party’s programme.
“4. That in order to ensure greater material and moral facilities for the working class to organise itself and carry on the class war, the following reforms must immediately be carried through.”
Then follows the “Transitional Programme,” formerly headed “Immediate Reforms.” Not many of the original number have been removed, but these are re-stated in the new Rules (1909). And has not Mr. E. C. Fairchild written a pamphlet defending the reforms advocated by the S.D.P.—in which he shows their futility ?

* * *

Councillor A. A. Purcell is to come before the West Salford electors as an avowed Socialist for Parliamentary honours. He is not prepared to sign the Labour Party programme.

I wonder if the Amalgamated Society of French Polishers will agree to their Secretary contesting a seat at which a nominee of the Labour Party is also to seek election ? And how does Councillor Purcell stand as a delegate to the Manchester and Salford Trades Council (which is affiliated to the Labour Party) ?

Further, why does the Amalgamated Society of French Polishers pay £7 10s. to the Parliamentary Fund and 15s. affiliation fee to the Labour Party if their delegates to the appointing body don’t agree with the national policy ?

I don’t ask in order to “queer the pitch,” but because, like Rosa Dartle, I want to know.
JAYBEE