Showing posts with label Scientific Socialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scientific Socialism. Show all posts

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Idealism v. Socialism. A Critic Answered. (1911)

From the November 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

The following criticism of the third chapter of Engels’ “Socialism, Utopian and Scientific,” raises objections to the fundamental principles of scientific Socialism. And as many others may jump to similar erroneous conclusions through failing first to master the elements of the problem, it will be both interesting and useful (at least to those desirous of understanding the Socialist philosophy) to review the points raised.

The criticism runs as follows :

“Scientific” Socialism.
A criticism of Engels' chapter on the above.

“The Socialist Party of Great Britain is founded upon the economic principles laid down by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, principles which, it must be admitted, are, on the whole, sound and well conceived. But on applying logic to the particular phase of the subject known as “Scientific Socialism,” one comes up against anomalous situations which it is here my purpose to point out.

My first point is this. Engels asserts, on p. 29 of his “Socialism, Utopian and Scientific,” that “the final causes of all social changes and political revolutions are to be sought, not in men’s brains, not in man’s better insight into eternal truth and justice, but in changes in the mode of production and exchange. They are to be sought, not in the philosophy, but in the economics of each particular epoch.”

The only term applicable to such a statement is “economic fatalism,” and such is the creed of Marx. Now if it be true that “ideas are secondary things in the changing or transforming of a society,” a statement that was made in the pamphlet “Socialism and Religion,” and which is the implication of the above Engelian assertion, does it not seem absurd that the S.P.G.B. should strive to educate the proletariat to class-consciousness ? Why educate if the “final causes are to be found not in mens’ brains”? Engels tells us that “society at present contains, in a more or less developed condition, the means of getting rid of the incongruities of capitalism,” and if that be so, how can man control, or can he control at all, these means, which I take to be economic forces ?

Socialism is a deduction from present-day phenomena,—it is not a fact but a theory—a theory based upon logical deduction. Therefore I cannot see how it can be scientific. But that being so, Socialism is not a remedy for poverty, etc., for Engels says “these means” (referred to above) “are not to be invented by deduction from fundamental principles, but are to be discovered in the stubborn facts of the present-day system of production.” (Page 30.)

Following upon the above, one is astounded by the following seeming contradiction : “The present structure of society is the creation of the ruling class of to-day.”

Surely this cannot be, for we have just been told that “changes must not be sought in men’s brains,” therefore to speak of the bourgeois class as the designers and creators of capitalism is obviously contradictory ; if the bourgeois class created capitalism, why cannot we infer that the proletariat will, by combined political action, create the Socialist system ?” The bourgeoisie broke up the feudal system and built upon its ruins the capitalist order of society” (Page 30.)

I defy the S.P.G.B. to disprove the statement that ideas are the predecessors of economic change. Ideas are not of secondary importance as stated in the pamphlet “Socialism and Religion,” but of primary importance. What transformed society in the time of the Revolution but inventions, that is, ideas ? What will abolish capitalism and bring Socialism but ideas ? We must educate the proletariat, must imbue that class with the idea of social ownership, must, in brief, preach Socialism. And then, when the proletariat has reached that point of intellectual impregnability termed class-consciousness, they will not hesitate to capture the political machinery, and utilising that machinery as a lever, will transform the capitalist State into the Socialist regime.

J. H. Lamb.

_______________________________

One’s first care in serious discussion must be correct terminology and accurate quotation. Now it is not correct to say that “economic fatalism” is the creed of Marx. The Socialist is not a fatalist but a determinist. Fatalism (even stripped of its gross superstition) ignores or defies man, and denies him his place among social forces ; thus falsifying sociology by suppressing an important factor. Determinism, on the other hand, gives man his due and recognises him as the vehicle of certain social forces with a part to play in social change that cannot be ignored. This is so even though man’s part is determined by heredity and environment—that is by past and present social conditions—and is ultimately explicable only from the economic basis. As the point has been put by Prof. Pannekoek :
“Not only the moral codes, but also other products of the human mind such as religion, science, arts, philosophy, were then understood to be connected with the actual material conditions of society. The human mind is influenced in all its products by the entire world outside of it. And thus the mind is seen to be a part of nature, and the science of the mind becomes a natural science. The impressions of the outer world determine the experience of man, his wants determine his will, and his general wants his moral will. The world around him determines man’s wants and impressions, but these, on the other hand, determine his will and activity by which he changes the world; this will-directed activity appears in the process of social production. In this manner man by his work is a part, a link in the great chain of natural and social development.” (Preface to Dietzgen’s “Positive Outcome of Philosophy.” Kerr.)
Thus the historic materialism of Marx and Engels (using the word materialism in its broad philosophic sense as opposed to idealism), while recognising the economic as the essential groundwork, embraces the whole of the factors—the reflex as well as the direct—and places them in their true relative positions.

Further, in the pamphlet on Socialism and Religion, issued by the Socialist Party, the statement which our correspondent puts in quotation marks nowhere occurs. As will be seen later, such a statement would convey a false impression. The passage our critic has in his mind is doubtless the following, which occurs in the preface to the second edition, now on sale.
“The Socialist case against religion differs widely from the usual Freethought position. There are Rationalist superstitions as well as Christian. Religion was not the wicked invention of charlatans, nor is the passing of superstition simply to be explained by the ‘triumph of Reason.’ As shown in the following pages the ‘march of mind,’ the development of science, and the decay of religion, are themselves ultimately explicable only from the evolution of economic conditions. Ideas play a secondary part in social development. They are the effects of the material environment on human beings, and are not the creative motive force of social evolution. Consequently, in his worship of the ‘idea’ the bourgeois freethinker is, like the Christian, attributing miraculous powers to the figments of men’s brains.”
Our critic’s misquotation shows that he confuses the gradual economic development with the conscious revolution.

It explains why he is “astounded” at Engels’ statement that the present structure of society is the creation of the bourgeoisie.

Marx has outlined the materialist conception of history in the preface to his “Critique of Political Economy,” and in the course of it he says :
“In considering such revolutions we must always distinguish clearly between the change in the industrial methods of social production on the one hand ; this change takes place unconsciously, according to the laws of natural science, and might properly be called an evolution.

And, on the other hand, the change in the legal, political, religious, artistic, philosophic, in short idealogical institutions ; with reference to these men fight out this battle as a revolution conscious of their opposing interests. This conflict takes the form of a class struggle.”
Hence the truth of Engels’ statement. Economically, capitalism has evolved ; politically it has been created. Ideas play an immediately prominent part in political revolutions, but they are themselves the products of previous conditions mainly economic. To our critic, however, ideas cause, or create, but are not themselves caused ! He calls them creative, and is extremely unwilling to look behind ideas at all lest he should discover them to be determined by social and economic conditions.

It is such an elementary truth that ideas are secondary to material change in the advance of the social organism that it requires all man’s insufferable conceit about his intellect to blind him to its recognition.

Our correspondent fails to give any argument in favour of Idealism, and his “defiance” and mere assertion are in no sense contributions to the discussion. Obviously, before mind could exist the material and forces which form it must have existed. Ideas, further, require the existence of brains, and are generated in the brain by experience, impressions, or sensations; racial or personal. They are the reasserted reflexes of first- and second hand experience, directed to more or less useful ends by the interests, wants and environment of the individual.

The mind, then, is a reflector—one with a highly developed and useful power of focussing and accumulating its reflections—but still a reflector in essence. This, however, is far from minimising the historic and social role of the products of the mind, and the importance of this role, secondary to material conditions though it is, is fully realised by scientific Socialism. Just as capitalist political and legal society is the product of the now dominant class, so will the establishment of Socialism be the work of the proletariat imbued with the Socialist idea. Now, the working class, as such, is a product of capitalism. Its interests, ideas, and aspirations, are the consequences of economic pressure and capitalist environment. Indeed, if it were not for economic development within the present system, Socialism itself would be neither necessary nor possible. It would not even be thinkable. But as it is, the direct effects of economic pressure and the material environment are caught up, reflected, and passed on by the mind, quickening the movement and propagating the idea among the workers.

Consequently ideas are the revivifying force of the working class movement, but only so long as the connection with material conditions is clear, close, and logical. So soon as this ceases to be the case, the faddist, the crank, the charlatan, or the traitor finds congenial soil, and the movement is proportionately retarded. But no ideas, whether sound or distorted, are original creative forces springing independently out of man’s head. All of them, given the antecedents, can be traced to earlier material causes. In short, ideas are not gods, though gods are ideas. They are social products.

Among the capitalist class the propaganda of revolutionary Socialism is utterly useless. Why? Precisely because (pace Mr. Lamb) “the final causes are not to be found in men’s brains,” and because ideas are secondary to the influence of the material environment. That is why we are a class party. That is why Socialism spreads amongst the workers, and propaganda among them is effective, adding definiteness and intensity to the movement.

Obviously it is by no means absurd, according to the determinist position, to strive to educate the proletariat to class-consciousness. But the fact of it being so utterly hopeless to convert the capitalist class to Socialism is the reductio ad absurdum of the belief in ideas as creative forces or prime causes of social change.

It is difficult to take quite seriously a correspondent who states, in these days of scientific theory, that a theory “based on logical deduction from present-day phenomena” is therefore not scientific !

Science, as Engels shows, is essentially deduced from stubborn facts in contradistinction to metaphysical philosophy, which vainly endeavoured to construct a complete system of knowledge from a few introspectively obtained principles, ranging from the “I think, therefore I am ” of Descartes to the gibberish of Professor Teufelsdroch of God-knows-where.

Its utter failure is the bankruptcy of Idealism, just as the rise of modern inductive science is the demonstration of the fact that the idea, however fantastic, is but the more or less distorted reflex of the real world. Science, indeed, is directly due, in its modern phase, to economic development, and would be impossible without it. It is under the impulse of the technical necessities of capitalism that the advance of science has been so rapid and so triumphant.

Engels, therefore, in saying that the means of abolishing capitalism are not to be invented by deduction from fundamental principles, but are to be discovered in the stubborn facts of the existing system of production, is simply saying that the Socialist method must be scientific, not metaphysical. Our correspondent has entirely failed to understand the passage in question.

And the inventions of the 18th century of which our correspondent speaks—do they help him? What called them forth ? What gave them their opportunity ? None of them would have been possible in earlier economic circumstances. Every one of them depended on the active cooperation of society and on a given condition of the material to hand, being otherwise impracticable. All arose from, and were dependent on, economic development every inch of the way. The tools, and the arts of working in the many-materials, wood, leather, stone or metals, had previously to have reached a given degree of perfection. The wheels, pulleys, cylinders, pistons had to be present in utilisable form. A social demand had to exist. And a social market that depended on a certain degree of development of a definite social system had also to be available. All these and other prerequisites were the results of the accumulation of human experience and practice through countless years. The inventor, as well as the conditions around him, was the product of economic evolution and untold past social effort. For countless ages mankind had patiently persevered, following the line of nature’s least resistance to their needs, acted upon by, and re-acting upon, nature, be fore social conditions were ripe for thebeginnings of the machine age. And then, the inventions were called forth by the necessities of a particular stage of industry. Once power-driven machines were made possible by the state of one branch of industry they became theoretically possible in. all, and absolutely essential in many. So the problems, narrowed down to definite points by industrial advance, were clearly set down for solution by economic development itself.

So true is this that at a particular period the same thing will be hit upon in several widely distant centres at, the same time. This continually occurs, both in industry and with its hand-maiden science.

Not one of the inventions was the result of one man’s labour. All were the results of many minor improvements. Indeed, the “great man” theory has been exploded by Herbert Spencer, and the inventor, like the genius in other spheres, is the product of his age.

It was the exhaustion of the wood supply in the forests of the South of England, together with the pressing need for iron, that directed men’s energies to the utilisation of coal for smelting ; a process that but slowly approached perfection with accumulated practical experience.

One need, indeed, go no further than the first volume of “Capital” for a masterly expression of this fact.

After pointing out how manufacture (in the old sense) produced the machinery by means of which modern industry abolished the handicraft and manufacturing systems in those spheres of production that it first seized upon. Marx says :
“A radical change in the mode of production in one sphere of industry involves a similar change in other spheres. This happens at fast in such branches as are connected together by being separate phases of a process, and yet are isolated by the social division of labour, in such a way that each of them produces an independent commodity. Thus spinning by machinery made weaving by machinery a necessity, and both together made the mechanical and chemical revolution that took place in bleaching, printing, and dyeing, imperative. So, too, on the other hand, the revolution in cotton spinning called forth the invention of the gin, for separating the seeds from the fibre ; it was only by means of this invention that the production of cotton became possible on the enormous scale at present required, but more especially, the revolution in the modes of production of industry and agriculture made necessary a revolution in the means of communication and of transport.”
The huge masses to be worked demanded huge mechanical instruments for the operation, and power capable of moving them. This, as Marx further shows, led to the invention of the slide rest, a means that was essentially required to produce the straight lines, cylinders, and spheres needed in the construction of the steam engine.

Finally, machinery itself could not be introduced before a certain stage of economic development, because it required for its effective use that a given stage of the social division of labour be already reached. So the classic instances of man’s power of invention are but further proofs of the dependence of man’s ideas upon economic development.

The materialist conception of history is, indeed, an integral part of the Socialist philosophy ; and there is no consistent way of escape from acceptance of the whole when the truth of one of its phases is recognised. Nature—all knowledge, is essentially one. All phenomena, mental and physical, are in the domain of science, and intimately woven together in the universal network of cause and effect. Human brain work, important though it be, is but a email part of nature, and it is still true that the whole is greater than the part.

Industrial processes evolve along lines of least resistance pressed hard by human requirements. With this evolution the internals of society outgrow the social edifice which the ruling class have erected during their run of power. It is the workers who are most affected by this. Their ideas change, and acquire definite form and purpose. The socio-political change begins to show itself, as it were, as a smouldering of ideas. It bursts into light. The flame spreads because of the abundance of combustible material around it. It gathers strength and propagates ever more quickly by the increase of its own internal heat. The rigid structure that would enclose and smother it is at last burst asunder, and the great change is a thing accomplished.

So onr work in the propaganda of Socialism is not only necessary—it is inevitable. And whether the historic mission of the working class be fulfilled sooner or later depends, to a great degree, on the intensity, completeness, and scientific nature of that propaganda.
F. C. Watts


Blogger's Note:
J. H. Lamb, at the time of writing this contribution, was a member of the Manchester Branch of the SPGB. He joined the Party in April 1911, and remained a member until September 1912. Despite his pointed criticism in his letter, he didn't resign from the Party. His membership was lapsed. 

Monday, November 2, 2026

Letter: Science and Ideas (1976)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1976 issue of the Socialist Standard

Science and Ideas

Your recent reply to my letter (“A double bind or two”) involved a total misinterpretation of the argument I presented.

I did not say that the SPGB was wrong because it was small. What I did say, quite simply, was that the SPGB was small — and, as such, virtually unrecognized by the working class.

The misinterpretation continues. I did not say that because working-class interests are known only to the SPGB this “somehow invalidates working-class interests and Socialism”. What I now would say however is that Socialism as an “ideal” should be differentiated from Socialism as a “scientific truth”. The one is undeniable, the other is a lie.

It is possible to prove by experiment that Newton’s First Law of Gravity is a scientific truth. Lift up the apple and it will invariably fall to the ground. Can you prove in the same way the certain formation of a socialist society or the certain collapse of capitalism? The apple falls to the ground by virtue of the force of gravity. A scientific truth. You assert that the workers will fall into socialism by virtue of the force of your ideas. Idealism, pure and simple.

Come back Hegel — at least the SPGB forgive you.
Tim Caulfield
Bury


Reply:
Much of your letter in the June Socialist Standard was given to sarcastic parody of the SPGB’s position — “the working classes [sic] must pay heed to their mentors” — and drawing attention, in similar terms, to “the working classes’ refusal to walk the road Marx laid out for them”. Your conclusion from this was that the SPGB is “doctrinaire” and its case “idealistic utopianism”. We do not think you were misrepresented at all.

You now shift your ground to a different rendering of the Socialist case. Previously you asserted it to be that the working class would become revolutionary through the collapse of capitalism. This was dealt with in our reply: it is a view the SPGB has never held and actively opposes. Your new version is that the workers “will fall into socialism by virtue of the force of [our] ideas”. Again, this is not our position. We contend that ideas are products of the social environment, which is the superstructure on the property basis of society. Many workers “discover” the SPGB because it corresponds to their own conclusions. Our function is to give precision to class-consciousness and to organize for the attainment of Socialism.

Your remarks about the law of gravity do not contribute to the argument; they might be used to invalidate any branch of science which cannot show an equivalent of an apple falling to the ground. We spoke of scientific theory—general conclusions from observation and practice—and opposing interests. This was the case with the theory of evolution, which is still rejected by many religionists. The term “scientific socialism” was used by Marx and Engels to mark a Socialism based on economic and historical analysis, i.e. from observable facts about society past and present. In this analysis, the foundation of society is production; and the dynamic of change from one social form to another is the class structure and the conflicts of economic interests between classes. From it, we assert that the next stage in society can only be Socialism brought about by the conscious action of the working class.
Editors.

Sunday, October 11, 2026

Society and Morals. Part IX — Socialism, its Economic and Theoretical Basis. (1918)

From the July 1918 issue of the Socialist Standard


The Socialist movement is revolutionary ; its object is the establishment of society upon a new basis—that of common ownership by the members of society, of the land and the machinery necessary for production and distribution. The movement seeks, by this means, to solve what it considers the otherwise unsolvable problems raised by the prevailing capitalist society, such problems as, to take that most obvious to everyone, the existence of widespread poverty and drudgery side by side with the most prodigiously efficient means ever known of creating every kind of wealth. The abolition of war, also, is a problem to-day more keenly felt than ever before, which Socialists declare can and will be solved only by the abolition of capitalism and the organisation of that Socialist Commonwealth which is their supreme objective.

The Sociology of Revolutions.
In this series of essays we have had occasion to notice some of the social revolutions of the past. The revolutionary movements of previous ages also undertook to solve the social problems of their time. Such problems and the necessity for social re-organisation arises when the established institutions cease to conform with the actual economic relations of men, forced on them by the industrial conditions obtaining ; when the existing organisation of society hinders rather than facilitates the development of the sources of production.

Mechanical inventions and technical improvements step by step effect changes in the methods of industry, but social institutions tend to linger on and to outlive their usefulness because of men’s reverence for traditions and attachment to custom and convention. Only when the insufficiency of these institutions to meet the newly arisen needs becomes glaring and obvious is social re-adjustment more or less rapidly brought about. But in class-divided communities a potent artificial factor intervenes to retard this necessary social progress, and that is—the self interest of the class which the established order elevates to prominence and maintains in wealth and power.

Under the conservative and reactionary influence of ruling-class activity social contradictions have frequently become chronic and disastrous. When such a condition is reached this class which dominates society and receives the richest share of the wealth produced becomes parasitic by losing every vestige of social function. Conversely, the remainder of the community are afflicted with unnecessary burdens, restrictions, and privations, while society itself is threatened with collapse.

But if class-interest be often a powerful conservative agent it has also been the most virulent incentive in the cause of revolution and progress. Whenever a class existed who for any reason felt the ill effects of the obsolete system, with extreme severity, a class who, for instance, were conscious that their interests were or could be especially administered to by those very industrial forces which were denied expansion, this class became the chief advocate of revolution and played the part of leader and guide to the revolutionary movement.

Thus it was with that series of revolutions which removed the legal restrictions upon the liberty of industry and trade, imposed by the out-worn semi-feudal absolutism, and released for seemingly unbounded expansion the economic forces behind capitalism. These were the work primarily of the capitalist classes themselves, inflamed with revolutionary zeal by the oppressive conditions which so injuriously affected their interests. On the other hand, however, the landed-nobility-well-favoured parasites of the old regime were bitter opponents of, and strove to frustrate the aims of, the bourgeoisie. In this they were typical of all ruling classes, for as indicated above, history shows that every such class has clung to its power and privilege until compelled to abdicate, and never voluntarily assisted any move in social progress which menaced its sovereignty. Moreover, the dominant class of every epoch has never lacked arguments in justification of the position and of their system of exploitation which maintained them in it. Consequently they were ever incapable of being “moralised” into an unresisting acceptance of revolution. It is important to bear this in mind, for it shows how dangerously misleading is the work of those would-be “reformers” who declare their belief in an universally acceptable morality—a point we shall dwell upon later.

Ruling classes, however, have never relied solely on moral justification to safeguard their interests. On the contrary they were always prepared to use the most violent means or take the most extreme, ferocious action against a revolt of the “lower” oppressed classes, whether this was consciously revolutionary or not. Because exploitation and class oppression have underlain all the various forms of social civilisation, class friction and conflict pervades every page of its history. The ruthlessness of these struggles is revealed whether examples be taken from the slave risings of Antiquity, the serf and peasant revolts of the Middle Ages, or from the records of existing bourgeois society. The Paris Commune of 1871 will ever remain a tragic and significant instance of the modern phase of that ages-old war of class against class, oppressors against oppressed.

Utopia or Science.
Many men, often of great genius and learning, have in different ages elaborated schemes of social regeneration, plans to re-organise society upon a “better” basis. Among them may be ranked Plato in ancient Greece, More in mediaeval England, and later St. Simon, Fourier, Godwin, Owen, Compte and Proudhon. Their ideals were, however, never realised, for they all failed to see that every society is an evolutionary product determined by preceeding conditions, and in turn determining what is to follow. They did not recognise economic conditions to be the main foundation of society nor yet in many cases the irreconcilable antagonism between the interests of the existing classes or the effect this had upon their moral opinions.

True, in some cases, the ideas of men of this type, Rousseau, for instance, did assist in bringing about a social transformation, but only when it happened that the conditions for such had been prepared by economic developments and when a class already existed whose needs urged them on to revolutionary ambitions. But even where a social change was thus actually realised the new form of society never corresponded with that depicted by the imagination of such idealistic thinkers ; it was always moulded in accordance with those social needs, impressed upon the revolutionary class in the form of economic interests, and which were determined in the last analysis by the stage reached in industrial development.

In its every phase the modern Socialist movement differs from the Utopianism of the great social idealists, and of their puny, latter-day disciples, the sentimental reformists.

It was, indeed, the founders and pioneer exponents of the Socialist theory, Marx and Engels, who first showed, over seventy years ago, that economic evolution is the mainspring of social and ideological history. Since their time many non-Socialist historians and sociologists have been compelled to recognise the mode of production as the chief determining factor in social growth, and to Lewis H. Morgan, the famous pathologist, belongs the distinction of reaching independently this epoch-making conception. Every advance in historical and sociological research has repeatedly demonstrated the profound truth of the Marxian conception of society, and therefore, because the Socialist movement stands alone in its consistent adherence to this, its guiding principle, it may fairly claim to be in truth a scientific movement, the first to consciously apply social science to social revolution.

The Contradictions of Capitalism.
Aided by their materialist conception of history, Marx and Engels examined in detail the economic structure of capitalist society, how it had evolved and to what it was tending. Resulting from their politico-economic study was the demonstration that capitalistic production which had hastened the break-up, and emerged triumphantly above the wreckage of the feudal system, was now itself generating with its development economic and social complications which it was evident would ensure its eventual downfall.

We have already sketched out the salient features of capitalism as revealed by the Marxian analysis, and have also shown some of the colossal problems which the system as it matures rises for solution. The most striking and important are those which we saw lay at the root of modern imperialism.

How to dispose of an ever-growing volume of commodities in a manner profitable to their class is as we have seen, a problem which the capitalists of the world are compelled to face. To-day the attempt at solution results in war on a gigantic scale, bringing devastation and suffering and death to countless millions. In the future this difficulty bids fair to become, with intensified productivity and closing markets, insuperable. Capitalist production and commerce demand war, but production itself is now an international process, and wars, by obstructing commercial intercourse and free access to the world’s markets, threaten capitalist society with collapse, and by blocking the supplies of raw materials, cut at the very foundation of production itself. They thus constitute a terrible menace to social life itself, now that the whole world is one vast workshop. Imperialism is the path which the bourgeoisie are enforced to follow in recognition of the economic fact that modern history has outgrown the bounds of the national State, yet in their attempt to solve the problem they have to ferment a degree of national hate and antagonism never known before.

Allied to the above is the anomaly of over-production, for when, as frequently happens, the available markets are unable to absorb the whole of the vast surplus of commodities, a commercial glut occurs, warehouses remain stocked, factories slacken off or close down and the workers thrown out of employment are faced with starvation because, incredible as it may seem, they have produced too abundantly. Again, the use of more efficient machinery (in order to cheapen production), which, appropriately used, could both lighten the labour of the producers and greatly add to their comfort and wealth, under capitalism promotes unemployment, intensifies the competition for work, and augments both the toil and the poverty of the workers.

Under capitalism, let it be repeated, while the powers of production are greater and the wealth actually created vaster and more so every year, than under any previous system, being easily capable of supplying the whole population with every need and comfort, the great army of workers who use these powers to produce this wealth live in a condition of perpetual poverty and drudgery, and are thus isolated from most of tho real fruits which the science, art, and technical achievments of civilisation have to offer. And when in addition to this it is realised that competent social investigators declare existing economic conditions to be at the root of such evils as child-mortality, prostitution, crime, and a host of pernicious maladies like consumption, the striking force of the indictment which Socialists bring against capitalism will be forced home.
R. W. Housley

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Utopian & Scientific Socialism (1975)

From the October 1975 issue of the Socialist Standard

It is essential for workers to have at least a basic understanding of capitalism before they can hope to become useful in the struggle for Socialism. Whilst one man cannot hope to know everything about society today, he can acquaint himself with the fundamentals. Unfortunately today most workers accept the prevailing ideas of the ruling class and the confused outlook that results from them. When many workers hear the Socialist case for the first time they are apt to dismiss it as utopian or an impossible dream. Socialism is however a materialist conception, that is an idea which has sprung directly from the real conditions and relations in society. Socialism as yet is an idea only but one which is based upon knowledge of the real world and not upon an ideal or religious feeling. The Christian ideas that “Christ died for our sins” or “Christ lives to save” are idealistic and have no basis in fact. (It would take a mist- enveloped religious mind to explain how Christ can be both dead and alive). The Socialist idea that capitalist society is divided into two different classes with mutually opposing interests is a fact. But it is one which the ruling class and their propagandists are always trying to obscure, talking instead of the “National Interest” and playing down class interests. Naturally the ruling class, being in a privileged position, want capitalism to continue ad infinitum, so that they can keep reaping-in the surplus-value produced for them by the working class.

Capitalism will remain as long as the majority of the working class want it to remain and allow it. Historically speaking capitalism is relatively new (about two hundred years) but already it has outlived its useful life. Whilst it was the necessary step for society to develop its productive forces and social production, it is essentially an anarchic and anti-social system. All past private-property societies have resulted in the exploitation of one class by another, but under capitalism it has taken a particular form, i.e. the wage-slave. The worker, owning virtually nothing of the means of life, must sell his abilities to the owners of capital for a wage. He is “free” to approach any potential employer for work, and the employer is free to employ him or not as the case may be.

Capitalist industries are geared to produce vast numbers of commodities which must be sold at a profit if they are to remain in business. That great organ of capitalist ideology the Daily Telegraph (14th June 1975) summed up the purpose of capitalist production very neatly:
Offices and factories will not be built unless it pays people to do so. In the same way there will be no investment in industry unless it is expected to produce a reasonable profit.
The aforesaid profit of course comes from the unpaid labour extracted from the working class at the point of production, and not from the shifting of sums of money by financial wizards from one industry to the next. When the worker goes home at the end of the week he leaves behind him his labour, now embodied in commodities with a certain value. The value of the wage which he takes home is invariably less than the value of the labour he leaves with his employer. The “reasonable profit” of the Daily Telegraph is created by human labour applied to materials; and from the capitalist point of view the larger the profit, the more “reasonable” the investment.

The London Brick Company Ltd. recently announced half yearly profits of about £5m., £2m. higher than expected, and immediately became a more “reasonable” proposition. It is worth pointing out that the housing problem is no less severe because of the profits of the London Brick Company, and for certain types of bricks there is now a three-month waiting period. On the other hand the capitalists are steering well clear of the Norton-Villiers concern at the time of writing because it looks like folding or at least severely curtailing production. Slumps and booms are as natural to capitalism as waves on the sea. At the moment there is a worldwide recession affecting many industries (but not all), and this is because the workers as a class have produced too many commodities for the world market. Because it is no longer profitable to employ them many workers will be laid off or put on short time, and they must suffer the hardships. The very goods that they alone have produced are denied them because they have produced too many! Booms, slumps and unemployment are inherent characteristics of capitalist society because the purpose behind production is the accumulation of profit and not the satisfaction of human needs.

With the abolition of private property (either state or individually owned) there will no longer be any classes in society, and for the first time production can be geared to the needs of society generally and not to the profit motive. All the paraphernalia of capitalism, i.e. money, wages, banks, insurance, armies, police etc., will cease to exist as the reason for their existence disappears. In the opinion of the writer, the only conceivable use for money in Socialist society would be as museum-pieces to show how backward previous societies had been.
Tony D'Arcy


Blogger's Note:
The following quotation from Karl Marx accompanied this article:
". . .  a man who has not understood the present state of society may be expected to understand still less the movement which is tending to overthrow it and the literary expression of this revolutionary movement".
Karl Marx, letter to P. V. Annekov, 28th December 1846.

Wednesday, October 8, 2025

A word of advice to Labour Party supporters (1952)

From the October 1952 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Labour Party is searching for a policy. The nationalisation of the basic industries and the extension of the social services have been brought about and still the position of the working class remains unchanged, the workers must sell their ability to work for a wage that scarcely buys the necessities of life. At the last general election a large number of workers showed their discontent with the Labour Party’s administration by placing the Tories in power. To rally the support of the workers next time, a host of publications have been issued recently by the Labour Party and groups within it. All attempt to find some new solution to the problems of Capitalism, since nationalisation and the welfare state have failed to solve them.

One of these publications, the “New Fabian Essays,” was reviewed in the Economist (May 25th, 1952). The reviewer wrote:—
“Mr. Crosland presents a skilful analysis of the mixed economy, neither Capitalism nor Socialism, that war and six years of Labour rule have created. Mr. Strachey thinks rather well of the result and Mr. Crossman, naturally, dismisses it contemptuously as ‘welfare capitalism.' Neither manages to define the Socialism which he wants to evolve from it. Mr. Crosland himself effectively challenges the stock Left-wing assumption that the mixed economy is naturally transitory and must pass quickly into some sort of Socialism; and he dismisses several of the orthodox lines of advance—more social services, more nationalisation, more controls, more direct taxation—without making the alternatives at all clear . . . 

“. . . . The gross result is certainly not even the beginnings of a new philosophy either of socialist change or of consolidation in the welfare state."
The Glasgow Forward (23rd August, 1952) commented upon another of these publications:—
“The Labour Party's latest policy statement—ironically titled 'Facing the Facts'—has met with all-round criticism. It tries to please everybody in the party and ends of pleasing nobody. At the moment the Labour Party is suffering from too many personalities, too many platitudes—and too few policies."
Another pamphlet published by the Socialist Union, “Socialism—A Restatement of Principles,” is called by the Tribune (11th July, 1952) “ Sunday School Socialism.” According to the Economist (June 28th, 1952), the pamphlet argues that “The Labour movement is not . . . concerned with overthrowing Capitalism and replacing it by something called Socialism . . . All the social and economic changes from the Capitalism of the nineteenth century cannot be seen as part of the transition to some definite socialist system . . .” 

From this the pamphlet goes on to protest against the class war as an instrument of socialist advance: it declares roundly that the programmes and thoughts of socialists “have all grown out of the discontents of the past, and were designed to meet the injustices of a past age it not only objects to the identification of nationalisation with Socialism, but asks whether anyone knows what “socialisation” means. . . .

“All this is, of course, destructive,” wrote the Economist. “Positively, socialist union offers as yet ethical, not political, principles; and the best of ethics can lead men to almost any practical conclusion.”

Over 70 years ago. Frederick Engels had something to say about the relation of ethics to Socialism which was later published as “Socialism: Utopian and Scientific.” Here Engels traced the origin and development of Socialism, its historical conditions and philosophical ideas. He called those who sought to bring about a better society by appealing to ethical principles. Utopians. He wrote:
"The ‘Utopians” mode of thought has for a long time governed the Socialist ideas of the nineteenth century. and still governs some of them. Until very recently all French and English socialists did homage to it. The earlier German Communism, including that of Weitling was of the same school. To all these Socialism is the expression of absolute truth, reason and justice, and has only to be discovered to conquer all the world by virtue of its own power. And as absolute truth is independent of time, space, and of the historical development of man, it is a mere accident when and where it is discovered. With all this, absolute truth, reason, and justice are different with the founder of each different school. And as each one’s special kind of absolute truth, reason, and justice is again conditioned by his subjective understanding. his conditions of existence, the measure of his knowledge and his intellectual training, there is no other ending possible in this conflict of absolute truths than that they shall be mutually exclusive one of the other. Hence from this nothing could come but a kind of eclectic, average Socialism, which, as a matter of fact, has up to the present time dominated the minds of most of the socialist workers in France and England. Hence a mish-mash allowing of the most manifold shades of opinion, a mish-mash of such critical statements, economic theories, pictures of future society by the founders of the different sects, as excite a minimum of opposition, a mish-mash which is the more easily brewed, the more the definite sharp edges of the individual constituents are rubbed down in the stream of debate, like rounded pebbles in a brook.

“To make a science of Socialism, it had first to be placed upon a real basis.” (“Socialism: Utopian and Scientific,” Vol. II, pp. 117-8, Marx Engels' Sel. Works, published by Lawrence & Wishart, Ltd.)
As the foregoing comments on the Labour publications show, Engels’ words also describe the Labourites of the 20th century.

Engels pointed to the working class struggles in the early 19th century and argued that these ’’facts more and more strenuously gave the lie to the teachings of bourgeois economy as to the identity of the interests of capital and labour. As to the universal harmony and universal prosperity that would be the consequence of unbridled competition . . .”
"The new facts made imperative a new examination of all past history. Then it was seen that all past history, with the exception of its primitive stages, was the history of class struggles; that these warring classes of society are always the products of the modes of production and of exchange—in a word, of the economic conditions of their time; that the economic structure of society always furnishes the real basis, starting from which we can alone work out the ultimate explanation of the whole superstructure of juridical and political institutions as well as the religious, philosophical and other ideas of a given historical period. . . .”

"The Socialism of earlier days certainly criticised the existing capitalist mode of production and its consequences. But it could not explain them, and therefore, could not get the mastery of them. It could only simply reject them as bad. The more strongly this earlier Socialism denounced the exploitation of the working class, inevitable under Capitalism, the less able was it clearly to show in what this exploitation consisted and how it arose. But for this it was necessary—(1) to present the capitalistic mode of production in its historical connection and its inevitableness during a particular historical period, and therefore, also, to present its inevitable downfall; and (2) lo lay bare its essential character, which was still a secret. This was done by the discovery of surplus value. It was shown that the appropriation of unpaid labour is the basis of the capitalist mode of production and of the exploitation of the worker that occurs under it; that even if the capitalist buys the labour power of his labourer at its full value as a commodity on the market, he yet extracts more value from it than he paid for; and that in the ultimate analysis this surplus value forms those sums of value from which are heaped up the constantly increasing masses of capital in the hands of possessing classes. The genesis of capitalist production and production of capital were both explained.” (“Socialism: Utopian and Scientific,” Vol. II, M.E.S.W., pp. 123-5.)
After tracing the development of modern social production from small handicraft, Engels wrote:
“The means of production, and production itself, had become in essence socialised. But they were subjected to a form of appropriation which presupposes the private production of individuals, under which, therefore, everyone owns his own product and brings it to the market. The mode of production is subjected to this form of appropriation although it abolishes the conditions upon which the latter rests.

“This contradiction, which gives to the new mode of production its capitalistic character, contains the germ of the whole of the social antagonism of to-day.” (M.E.S.W.. Vol. II. pp. 128-9.)
Engels explained in detail the social antagonisms that follow from this fundamental contradiction and pointed out how it would be eliminated ”with the seizing of the means of production by society.” (P. 140.)

By this Engels didn’t mean nationalisation. He claimed that
"the transformation . . . into state ownership does not do away with the capitalistic nature of the productive forces . . . the modern State . . . is only the organisation that bourgeois society takes on in order to support the external conditions of the capitalist mode of production against the encroachments as well of the workers as the individual capitalists. The modem State, no matter what its form, is essentially a capitalist machine the state of the capitalists, the ideal personification of the total national capital. The more it proceeds to the taking over of productive forces, the more does it actually become the national capitalist, the more citizens does it exploit. The workers remain wage workers—proletarians.” (P. 136.) 
Members and sympathisers of the Labour Party seeking a policy to which they can give their support should lay hold of ”Socialism: Utopian and Scientific,” and read it carefully. They can find it included in “Marx, Engels, Selected Works,” Vol. II. The language may reflect the conditions under which it was written, but as an exposition of the rise and development of capitalist society and the solution to its problems. Socialism, it is right up to date.

We hope that many of them would then realise that the object of their policy should be the common ownership and democratic control of the means and instruments of production and that to ” thoroughly comprehend the historical conditions and thus the very nature of this act, to impart to the now oppressed proletarian class a full knowledge of the conditions and of the meaning of the momentous act it is called upon to accomplish, this is the task of the theoretical expression of the proletarian movement, scientific Socialism.”
J. T.

Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Marx's partner (1983)

From the March 1983 issue of the Socialist Standard

Socialists cannot pay tribute to Marx without at the same time noting the role of his comrade and collaborator, Engels. It was Engels’ financial support which enabled the penurious Marx to carry out his researches into political economy.

But this financial support was not the least of Engels’ contributions. It is reckoned that about 1500 letters passed between Marx and Engels. They thought along the same lines, they spoke the same language, yet their life-experience was different. For Engels, there was the practical world of the Manchester cotton trade, he read widely, keeping himself fully informed of the latest developments in physics, chemistry and other sciences, with a special interest in comparative physiology and the controversies surrounding Darwin’s theory of evolution.

To Engels we owe volumes II and III of Marx's unfinished Capital, which he completed with difficulty from quantities of rough drafts and notes. After Marx’s death. Engels continued to publish translations and new editions of Marx’s works, providing prefaces in many languages. Yet it would be wrong to regard Engels only as Marx's editor, publisher and lifelong friend. His contributions to the socialist movement stand in their own right.

Many of the issues he discussed in his early work, The Condition of the Working Class in England in 1844, were taken up again by Marx in volume 1 of Capital. Engels' passionate indictment of slums, and the diseases and deformities of children at sweated labour (as in his analysis of the real cost of lace for fashionable ladies), such themes permeate his book. Yet there is more in it than indignation at the social evils of industrial capitalism.

Engels described how new technology and the division of labour were accompanied by the emergence of a new class, the urban proletariat. He posed the fundamental question: "What is to become of these propertyless millions who own nothing and consume today what they earned yesterday?’’ Industry, he wrote. ". . . regards its workers not as human beings but simply as so much capital for the use of which the industrialist has to pay interest under the name of wages”. Describing how competition affected the level of wages, he also emphasised the "cycles of boom and slump”; the Malthusian "surplus population” was the reserve army of the unemployed, available for industry's booms, and condemned to destitution and the Poor Law workhouses between-times.

Discussing both the value and the limitations of trade unionism (a theme to which he returned in some later writings [1]), and the main working class movements of the time. Engels criticised the English socialists for being metaphysical, lacking awareness of the significance of historical development. It seemed to him that they preached "philanthropy and universal love . . . the improvement of humanity in the abstract". He reiterated this criticism in his preface to the 1892 edition:
And today, the very people who. from the ’impartiality' of their superior standpoint, preach to the workers a Socialism soaring high above their class interests and class struggles, and tending to reconcile in a higher humanity the interests of both the contending classes — these people are either neophytes, who have still to learn a great deal, or they are the worst enemies of the workers — wolves in sheep’s clothing.
This first socialist examination of the effects of industrial capitalism, written from the standpoint of historical materialism, touched on many issues later developed in other works by Marx and Engels. Written in Germany on Engels’ return from two years in Manchester, The Condition of the Working Class has some faults. He was not able to check all of his quotations, and some are inaccurate; later, he acknowledged that his prediction that with the next crisis would come the revolution was “youthful ardour”.

Although the Communist Manifesto was published as their joint work, Engels himself expressly stated:
The basic thought running through the Manifesto — that economic production and the structure of society of every historical epoch necessarily arising therefrom constitute the foundation for the political and intellectual history of that epoch; that consequently (ever since the dissolution of the primeval communal ownership of land) all history has been a history of class struggles, of struggles between exploited and exploiting, between dominated and dominating classes at various stages of social development; that this struggle, however, has now reached a stage where the exploited and oppressed class (the proletariat) can no longer emancipate itself from the class which exploits and oppresses it (the bourgeoisie), without at the same time forever freeing the w'hole of society from exploitation, oppression and class struggle — this basic thought belongs solely and exclusively to Marx. [2]
One persistent criticism of Marx is that human behaviour is said to be influenced exclusively by class interests and material factors and nothing else. This is a gross distortion and Engels explicitly argued against such nonsense:
According to the materialist conception of history, the ultimately determining element in history is the production and reproduction of real life. More than this neither Marx nor I has ever asserted. Hence if somebody twists this into saying that the economic role is the only determining one he transforms that proposition into a meaningless, abstract, senseless phrase. [3]
In much of Engels' writing, we find the dialectical method explained. He considered phenomena as evolving through often complex interactions. His conception of history was not a simplistic model of a superstructure of laws, religions, ideologies and dogmas perched on top of a separate economic base, with something like a damp course separating one from another. On the contrary, the various elements of the superstructure "also exercise their influence upon the course of historical struggles and in many cases preponderate in determining their form"'. [3]

Criticisms of Marx as an "economic determinist” arise from "the common undialectical conception of cause and effect as rigidly opposite poles, the total disregarding of interaction. These gentlemen often almost deliberately forget that once a historic element has been brought into the world by other, ultimately economic causes it reacts, can react upon its environment and even on the causes that have given rise to it" [4]. In Anti-Dühring Engels showed that science had revealed just such a dialectical process in nature. There are no absolute truths, everything is changing: "motion is the mode of existence of matter".

Anti-Dühring supplies a thorough grounding in dialectical materialism, applied not only to science and philosophy (attacking with gusto the nonsense about "eternal truths" propounded by metaphysical thinkers), but also to the development of socialist theory from "Utopian" socialism to "scientific” socialism. Some chapters from Anti-Dühring were soon republished as a pamphlet, Socialism, Utopian and Scientific, and the central section of the book ("Political Economy”) serves as a helpful introduction to Marx’s Capital. Both the book and the pamphlet had an immediate and lasting influence in many countries.

In his next book, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884). based on Lewis H. Morgan’s Ancient Society, Engels analysed the way civilised, class-divided society had evolved from barbaric and savage societies, and how property relationships changed family relationships. Engels also showed how the changing division of labour, with the introduction of herding, "forced women into second place": mother-right gave place to father-right. He showed how the state arose from the need to hold class antagonisms in check, so that the state "is, as a rule, the state of the most powerful, dominant class, which, through the medium of the state, becomes also the politically dominant class". It follows that the socialist has no choice but to emphasise that every class struggle is a political one.

The superficial objection to socialism — that it is against "human nature” — is based on ignorance of the fact that civilised society, with its class divisions and state coercive institutions, "has not existed from all eternity. There have been societies that did without it (the state), that had no conception of the state and state power". Engels described primitive societies which managed their affairs democratically and without the coercion that is considered right and natural today. Such societies demonstrate that it is not "human nature" which requires humanity to be divided into nation-states and opposing classes, or which would make socialism impossible.

This article has only discussed Engels's main works. There were others which are both readable and helpful. How far was the theory of "Marxism” his work? His own view was emphatic and consistent:
What I contributed — at any rate with the exception of a few special studies — Marx could very well have done without me. What Marx accomplished I would not have achieved . . . Marx was a genius; we others were at best talented. Without him the theory would not be what it is today. It therefore rightly bears his name. [5]
Charmian Skelton


References:
1. Cf. The Wages System (Progress Publishers)
2. Preface to the German edition. 1883
3. Letter to Bloch, 1890 (Marx and Engels — basic writings ed. Feuer, Fontana)
4. Letter to Mehring, 1893 (Feuer)
5. Ludwig Feuerbach, 1886 (Chap. IV. footnote)

Sunday, December 8, 2024

Socialism or Utopia? (1915)

From the December 1915 issue of the Socialist Standard

From the present writer’s experience there still appears to be a considerable number of people who regard the Socialist as a Utopian—a kind of mystic idealist who spends his time dreaming about a beautiful New World, weaving all manner of fanciful details from that ethereal entity, imagination. Yet why ?

If we turn to the official Declaration of Principles of the Socialist Party we find no trace of this fantastic frame of mind. It expresses nothing but the relations of forces actually existent at the present time, and only asserts anything concerning the future as the direct outcome of these relations. To the “genuine idealist” this attitude must appear “grossly materialistic,” while even the “practical man” is invariably found criticising it for the very reason that it is devoid of any detailed elaboration.

Seeing, however, that all erroneous notions must reflect some facts albeit in a distorted out-of-focus fashion, it is well to discover such modicum of truth as may exist in anti-Socialist criticism before considering the case settled. While the modern Socialist, following the scientific method of Marx and Engels, can effectually clear himself of the charge of Utopianism, so much cannot be said of the forerunners of the movement such as Owen, St. Simon and Fourier. Our opponents are welcome to all the satisfaction they can get out of this, considering that we now-a-days recognise the efforts of the above named thinkers to be getting on for a century out of date so far as their ideal reconstruction of society is concerned. Their criticisms of existing society, however, still hold good, and have been preserved by the analysis of Marx and placed upon “the solid rock” as Engels terms it.

The law of evolution holds good in the realm of theory no less than in the physical world ; consequently Socialism could hardly be expected to spring itself on the world full-fledged and complete. Its germ came into being as the result of certain definite historical events, and has developed alongside of the full fruition of other results of these events.

About the middle of the eighteenth century mechanical industry took its rise, seized upon trade after trade until by now it has revolutionised the entire character of the production of wealth, converting isolated groups of workers into a vast economic network, and replacing competition between a large number of small manufacturers by that between a small number of Titanic concerns.

Early on it commenced to intensify the poverty of the workers and widen the gulf between them and their employers, and it was these facts, following on an increase of wealth produced, that gave the Utopists the data for their criticisms. Hard on the heels of the industrial revolution in England followed the political upheaval in France which, in its turn, left the workers there worse off than before. Thus almost simultaneously the application of science to production and the establishment of “liberal institutions,” so far from improving the condition of the majority of the people, brought increased misery for them.

This glaring contradiction could hardly fail to arouse the curiosity of such members of he educated class as had not completely prostituted their intellectual faculties to the service to the new capitalist order of society, and out of the genuine research thus developed arose certain definite critical opinions which extended to the conventionalities of society, religion, the state, marriage, etc., in addition to its economic basis, i e private property.

As yet, however, the class antagonism had only manifested itself in spasmodic conflicts such as the machine smashing riots, consequently these original critics of society had nothing to point to as the factor which was to supplant the existing structure by a new one. The organised revolt of the workers against exploitation was quite foreign to their notions. Hence they had to imagine some way out and started experiments according to elaborate schemes for the regulation of communal affairs. They ignored the fact that it was the new industrial change that made a social change possible, and cut themselves off from that change by forming small groups of co-operators and endeavouring to be independent of the rest of society. Such ventures were foredoomed to failure, not because of some imaginary innate individualism of mankind as some self-styled “practical people” insist, but by reason of their insufficient economic basis. To these ideal fantasies the term “Utopian” can correctly be applied. Curiously enough, however it was the further development of industry and the growth of the class-war which simultaneously scotched them and gave birth to the scientific Socialism of the Communist Manifesto.

In the early half of the nineteenth century the workers commenced to organise for the conflict with capital. Trades Unions sprang up and the movement for political rights, Chartism, came into being. The fact that these first efforts did not realise the sanguine aspirations prompting them rendered necessary a scientific analysis of the conditions of the field of battle, in other words, the pressing of critical research to fundamental issues. This led to the discovery of the method by which the workers are exploited and condemned to poverty, and of the necessary outcome of the consequent struggle, i.e., the conquest of political power by the workers and the abolition of exploitation by the conversion of the implements of social production into common property.

The key to the future was obtained not by imagination but by science. The class-war, which is the basic fact upon which modern Socialism as a theory rests, is no mere fantasy but bitter truth.

Socialism, i.e., the criticism of existing society and speculations concerning the future was only Utopian so long as the class-war between wage-earners and capitalists was in its rudimentary stages. No sooner did this struggle develop into the most vital and glaring phenomenon of social life than Socialism became a science. On the other hand, Utopianism, i.e., the deliberate attempt to plan beforehand a social ideal, while it became obsolete, nevertheless persisted in a new form. Instead of being part of an honest criticism of society it became a phase of capitalist politics. The more the workers commenced to chafe against their fetters, the more necessary it became from the capitalist view-point to provide them with visions of economic improvement. The “practical” class, which had scorned the earlier Utopists’ plea for social harmony on the ground that struggle was the law of life, now became anxious that the workers should not put this notion into practice. Hence the “brotherhood of capital and labour” became a most respectable doctrine, and all capitalist legislation took on the form of measures for “the amelioration of the lot of the masses.” Every blessed section of the ruling class developed its own special kind of social policy. The Tory landowners boomed factory legislation, the Radical manufacturers went in for anti-Corn-Law agitation, all apparently for the benefit of the class they were mutually plundering, i.e., the working class. All the latter had to do was to allow the masters to continue to wield the political machine.

So soon as the workers acquired the franchise (as a result of the competition of different sections of the masters for their support) a new aspect of the question arose. In spite of all the promises of Tory and Radical, the onward march of machine industry rendered life ever more burdensome to the workers and the class conflict more acute. The science of revolution spread, much to the rulers’ dismay. A more elaborate Utopia became necessary to play the will-o’-the wisp; and the more nearly it caricatured the revolutionary policy the better.

“Advanced wings” of the capitalist parties composed of “middle-class” parasites, journalists, lawyers, parsons, professional intellectuals of every description arose with a “new Socialism” which had the advantage of not being revolutionary—oh! dear no !—while it appeared on the surface to grant all that the “extremists” asked for. All that was done was to substitute the capitalist “State” for the “community” in the revolutionary formula.

From the standpoint of the capitalist, of course, there is no difference between the words. What community does he know of other than the organisation of his class ? A community of organised workers is to him something outside the realm of “practical politics.”

To the genuine Socialist, however, the gradual purchase by the State of various concerns is but a phase of capitalist evolution. There is in it nothing more Socialistic than in the transformation of “private firms” into joint stock companies. In each case the transaction is conducted on approved business lines, the nominal ownership of material things being exchanged for interest hearing credit. Which means, for the worker, continued exploitation. Practical—isn’t it?

Parties whose political prestige is based on the boosting of this sham Utopia can never be anything but the catspaw of the master class;—of this the compromise-stained records of the I.L.P. and B.S.P. are sufficient proof.

They may pretend to be building the future “step by step,” but their imaginations, like everyone else’s, are limited to the experience of the past and present. To try and project a detailed castle in the air as “the ideal State” is, therefore, nothing more than wandering round in a circle, for their “details” are all derived from the capitalist system itself, and can, therefore, never get them out of it, and the Socialist Party of Great Britain is following the only scientific course in opposing their endeavour to get the workers to indulge in such peregrinations.

We are not keen on drawing pictures of the future. Shall slaves imagine freedom they have not known ? We are concerned with the vital present—the oppression of our class and our struggle to end it. There is only one way—to unite and seize the actual means whereby we live.

There is nothing Utopian about this. All that is lacking is the consciously revolutionary organisation powerful enough to effect the change ; and this is growing, slowly, maybe, but surely, as the results of the present relations between the workers and the tools they use, force themselves upon our attention, along with the means by which these relations are maintained, i.e., the forces of government.

Every Socialist principle is but the actual reflection of existing circumstances which, when correctly analysed and grasped in their entirety, provide us with the essential programme of a working-class political party.
Eric Boden

Wednesday, December 4, 2024

Unscientific emotionalism. (1914)

From the December 1914 issue of the Socialist Standard

The widespread misery of workers in modern times has brought forward two main classes of people claiming to hold the remedy for the social evil. On the one side you have those who, horrified at the miserable conditions everywhere, preach brotherly love, a return to Feudalism, and similar things as a solution for the problem; on the other hand you have the scientific Socialists who, studying societies from the point of view of modern science, regard them as undergoing a process of growth and decay. Thus, instead of attacking the superficial relations in society, the Socialists concern themselves with the centre, the pivot on which the system turns, i.e., the method of producing and distributing wealth, the relation between the masters and the workers, because from this relation springs all the other relations that appear so prominently and make such a show.

Socialists recognise that the technical development (development of the tools) in society has made it possible for small groups to operate large masses of machinery and turn out vast quantities of wealth with a small expenditure of energy ; and that these powerful means of production, if commonly owned, could be economically used for the turning out of only just that amount of wealth required for the needs of all the members of society, and to provide the necessary new means of production for the future. This would necessitate a comparatively insignificant expenditure of energy on the part of each, and leave a great deal of leisure for the cultivation of Science, Art, and so on.

The private ownership of wealth is not only uneconomical, but, owing to the fact that the ruling idea is the enriching of the owners regardless of the consequences to the rest, so soon as the wealth of the owners does not continue to increase, production slackens down, even though this slackening down is the cause of untold misery among the workers. When the ruling idea will be the comfort of all, production will be regulated accordingly.

This view of the “social question” has been forced into the minds of Socialists by the every¬day facts of working-class life which they meet when performing their particular functions in the various industries of the world.

When our method of reasoning is applied back through history, we find that man’s thoughts have always been governed by his inherited notions and the material conditions surrounding him ; and as these conditions have centred around the obtaining of food, clothing, and shelter, so at each period of social history the more or less clear relations that were built up on this basis (the particular relations that existed at the particular time, between the various producers and distributors, of the social wealth) have been reflected in the mind in a correspondingly more or less clear manner. After the break up of the early tribal communities society was split into various classes, and history since then has been the record of the struggles of each class in its turn to control society for its own advantage. When the progress of the method of producing wealth had reached a certain point the class in society that was taking the principal part in production, found the old laws (that were suitable to the existing governing class) placed a restriction on their further development. The problem of the removal of all these restrictions therefore constantly occupies them, and it is then forced home to their minds that the only solution to the problem of the removal of these restrictions is the control of society by themselves, and the alteration of existing laws to suit the new conditions. Just as at present the spectacle of the workers doing all the work of the world forces home to the minds of men the Socialist view that, if the workers produce and distribute all the wealth of society they therefore should own it, and reap the benefit of their work themselves, instead of supporting a group of idlers and good-for-nothings. The solution of the problem is constrained within the problem itself. “Therefore mankind always takes up only such problems as it can solve” (Marx).

This matter of fact view of the question is not palatable to the “Red Revolutionists,” who like a great deal of noise (“Full of sound and fury, signifying—nothing”) ; and the soft-hearted and soft-headed, who think the problem can be solved by reverting to antiquated, out of date societies, and whose views of brotherly love cause them to raise their hands in pious horror at the misery they see among workers, and—thank God for his loving kindness in not placing them in a similar position.

The thinking human mind reasons from particular facts to general conclusions. That is to say, we form in our minds abstract pictures drawn from practical experience. The thinking faculty is an instrument for separating the world of things into groups and sub groups, according to likenesses and differences, in order to gain as complete a picture of the world as possible. For instance, the general picture we have in our minds of a horse (the idea of a horse) is derived from practical experiences of different kinds and colours of horses. Abstract ideas of all kinds are produced in the same way, by everyday experience. The difference between the scientific and the unscientific (who are typified by the emotionalists) is that the former recognise this fact and act upon their knowledge, while the latter (owing to the fact that this reasoning is done partly subconsciously in ordinary affairs) imagine the general conclusions existed first and from all time—that the “Idea” is the thing par excellence. The Socialists reason from the practical affairs of everyday life to general conclusions, while the emotionalists set out with a plan formed in accordance with certain abstract ideas true for all time (!) without taking account of the historical development of society. They try to organise society according to the Idea instead of recognising that the shape their particular ideas take has been formed by society.

The emotionalists and their followers play upon those latent ideas of equality that have lain dormant in the minds of human beings since tribal communism disappeared. Thousands of years of life under this form of society fixed in the mind of man these views of equality, and the development that followed, through Patriarchalism, Feudalism, and Capitalism, although it has driven these ideas into the background, has not eradicated them. During periods of revolution these equalitarian views are used as a bait to entice the mass of the oppressed to the side of the particular class that is struggling for supremacy. During the French Revolution these ideas gave the rising commercial class the slogan with which to arouse the down-trodden serfs to assist them in their battle. Their much-vaunted pleas for equality, however, were afterwards shewn to be the equal right to oppress, the freedom of capitalist enterprise from Feudal bonds, and the liberty of the wage workers to starve.

The emotional school, who come forth with their battle-cry of freedom and equality, are merely reproducing the old ideas of primitive tribal equality, instead of examining the constitution of present society and its historical tendencies, and thus arriving at the correct scientific standpoint. The introduction of private property broke up the old societies ; with the abolition of private property, therefore, and the advent of Socialism, these ideas of equality will again have a chance to appear on the stage—but in fact, and not merely in imagination, and in a much higher form than in the ancient societies, owing to the marvellous development in the control of natural forces, or rather, the knowledge of nature’s laws, that has taken place since those societies broke up.

The forerunners of scientific Socialism : Fourier, St. Simon, and Robert Owen—the first who attempted a scientific explanation of social problems—failed in their constructive efforts, and gave merely Utopian solutions, because (as Engels has so clearly shewn in “Socialism, Utopian and Scientific”) society had not yet advanced to that stage when it could exhibit its historical tendency, machinery being in its infancy, and steam not having yet shown its potencies for revolutionising production.

Once our way of looking at the matter (reasoning from facts and not fantasies) is recognised by the workers, they will no longer be prey for the supporters of capitalism with their metaphysical notions, but will see that there is only one hell about which to worry and that is the hell in reality, the hell of capitalist production in which the wealth producers of the world already find themselves.

Those who adopt the sentimental attitude are of all types, and their views generally are of a very noisy character. The individuals of the Industrial Workers of the World, the Anarchist, the Syndicalist, the “Daily Herald” League (or Leagues !), and similar varieties, believe that the Social Revolution will come along to-morrow or the day after, if you will only kick up a row and run your nose up against police batons, bullets, maxim guns, and such “harmless” instruments of coercion. Others follow the showy method in other directions, as, for instance, the Party that at present goes under the name of the British Socialist Party. This party, not making a great show of numbers, followed the method of changing its name, thinking to emulate the proceedings of a conjuror. This same party recently came to the conclusion (after the failure of its policy of “Swell the ranks and never mind who enters ! Let ’em all come, Syndicalists, Political Actionists, Anarchists, and any old rubbish, what matters so long as we get a crowd”) that they had better consider the advisability of joining the Labour Party (very sound conclusion !) whom they have been denouncing for so many years.

Thus do the emotionalists gain a following and safely pilot them over to the enemy.

As for us who are members of the Socialist Party of Great Britain, our ranks may not appear to grow so fast, we do not lay out our stock in fantastic and alluring drapery, but we deal with the hard facts of working-class life from the scientific standpoint banded down to us by previous workers in the same field. We know that in spite of the apparent slowness of our growth, underneath the surface our work is creating among the members of our class, the working class, a growing knowledge of their position in society, and the line along which to act to achieve their freedom. Only those who build, as we do, on the solid rock, can expect the edifice to stand. Those who build on sand will see their work continually obliterated. In any case we have every reason to be satisfied with, our work up to the present, and that knowledge,, combined with the spectacle of the continual downfalls (the re-actionary attitude of all the self-styled “Revolutionaries” on the present capitalist war in Europe is the latest manifestation) of those who sneer at our attitude, will nerve us to still greater exertions in the future.
“For while the tired waves vainly breaking,
Seem here no painful inch to gain,
Far back, through creeks and inlets making,
Comes silent flooding in the main.

“And not by Eastern windows only,
When daylight comes, comes in the light ;
In front, the sun climbs slow, how slowly,
But Westward, look, the land is bright !”
G. McC.

Blogger's Notes:
'G.Mc.' was Gilbert McClatchie. For the majority of his writing life in the Standard he used 'Gilmac' as his pen-name, but like his close comrade, Edgar Hardcastle, ('H.' in the Standard), he didn't not settle on his better known pen-name for a couple of years.

The poem quoted at the end of this article is 'Say Not the Struggle Naught Availeth' by Arthur Hugh Clough. It must have been a popular poem in socialist circles in the early days of the SPGB, as this is not the first time I've seen it quoted in the Standard. See here and here.