Showing posts with label CPGB. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CPGB. Show all posts

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The British road to state capitalism (1977)

From the November 1977 issue of the Socialist Standard

There are many, opponents and supporters alike, who believe that the so-called Communist Party wishes to destroy capitalism. At most the Communist Party (CP) is against private capitalism, favouring instead state capitalism where the main means of production would be in the hands of the State, where the working class would continue to work for wages and where goods would continue to be produced for sale with a view to profit, but where (as in Russia) the private capitalists have been replaced as the ruling, privileged group by the leaders of the Communist Party and their hangers-on. Not so many are aware that the Communist Party is not consistently opposed even to private capitalism, but is prepared to take part in government while private capitalism continues — so participating, even by its own standards, in the administration of the capitalist system.

As is made clear in the draft revision of their programme The British Road to Socialism to be discussed at their Congress this month, the immediate aim of the British Communist Party is not the state capitalism it falsely calls socialism, but “democratic advance” to be achieved by a “left Labour government” which will nationalize a few big firms (i.e., convert them into state capitalist enterprises) but will leave the rest of private capitalist industry in private capitalist hands:
For a government to exercise effective control over the operation of the economy, the key firms among the top firms which dominate the economy must be nationalised, while at the same time drastic controls must be instituted over the investment, production and employment policies of those remaining in private hands (which at this stage would still constitute the great majority) (our emphasis).
That the nationalization of these key firms, combined with that of the banks and insurance companies, would give a government effective control over the capitalist economy is an illusion, but is one which derives from the CP’s misunderstanding of the nature of capitalism.

According to CP theory, the present stage of capitalism is “state monopoly capitalism” in which the State is controlled by the monopolies and used to further their interests at the expense of the rest of society. Quite apart from the fact that "monopoly” is an incorrect description to apply to the big capitalist enterprises which dominate production (they are not the sole sellers of the products they offer for sale, which is the strict economic definition of a monopoly), this theory mistakenly suggests that the way capitalism works depends on the policies pursued by the State. In fact, the policies of governments are determined by the workings of capitalism and not vice versa.

Monopoly capitalism
The whole strategy outlined in the new draft of The British Road to Socialism is based on this mistaken view that it is “the big monopolies”, rather than the capitalist system as such, which is responsible for today’s social problems. It is even claimed that the non-monopolist sections of the capitalist class have an interest in joining with the workers to defeat the monopolies:
The capitalist class comprises the owners and controllers of the means of production, distribution and exchange—the factories, banks, shops, land, etc. Even as a whole it constitutes only a small fraction of the population. But within it there is a still smaller minority exercising the dominant power—the very big firms, which not only exploit their workers, but also operate at the expense of many smaller businesses, small shopkeepers, and small farmers. These small enterprises are among the first victims in periods of acute capitalist crisis, many of them going bankrupt, being forced to close down, or being swallowed up by the big firms. When working class standards are cut, small producers, shopkeepers and traders are also adversely affected.

There is therefore an objective basis for an alliance between many in these sections of the capitalist class and the working class against the common enemy — the big capitalists (our emphasis).
So, in place of the class struggle between the working class (all those who have to work for a wage or salary) and the capitalist class (the owners of the means of production) we have a struggle between the "victims of monopoly”, including “parts of the capitalist class”, and the “big monopolists”. And this is supposed to be Marxism!

But the CP goes further: all the victims of monopoly, they say, including the non-monopolist capitalists, should unite in a “broad democratic alliance” with the aim of electing a “new type of Labour Government”, one which instead of simply administering capitalism, will take steps to “weaken the grip of the big monopolists” (not end, but only weaken!). The CP explicitly say that the aim of this government will not be socialism even on their definition: (“It would not be a socialist government carrying out a socialist revolution . . .”).

In fact not only will a large private sector remain, but the non-monopolist capitalists are to be offered “cheap credits, the abolition of VAT, rent controls”. Whether this will encourage small employers like George Ward of Grunwicks to vote for a “left Labour government” remains to be seen.

So the proposed left Labour government would be administering capitalism just like all previous Labour governments. In CP theory it would be a capitalism without private monopolies (or at least only with monopolies with weakened powers), but a capitalism without monopolies is no more in the interests of the working class and can no more be made to work for their benefit than capitalism with monopolies.

Capitalism, including the state capitalism which the CP sets as a longer-term aim, can only work in one way, as a profit-making system based on the exploitation of the working class.

Capitalism is an economic system subject to its own unchangeable economic laws which governments cannot control or overcome. Under capitalism wealth takes the form of commodities, or goods produced with a view to sale at a profit. The aim of capitalist production is the accumulation of more capital out of the profits made from exploiting the wage-labour of the working class. Whenever profits cannot be realized, as occurs periodically because of the unplanned and exploitative nature of production under capitalism, production in some spheres slows down or stops; a crisis occurs.

Reformist illusions
In suggesting that a left Labour government would be able to do something for the working class under capitalism—such as reducing unemployment or improving living standards—the CP is encouraging reformist illusions amongst the workers. But then the CP itself is thoroughly reformist, having a gradualist conception of the establishment of Socialism. What we call Socialism—a society based on “from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs” —the CP calls “communism”. Society will gradually pass, we are asked to believe, from a stage of “democratic advance” to the stage of state capitalism and from the stage of state capitalism to the stage of communism by means of a series of democratic and social reforms passed by Parliament. Just as was imagined by the early Labour Party reformers and gradualists!

Our objection to this strategy is not that it involves using the ballot box or Parliament. This is the only practical way for the working class to win political power—as we have been saying for the past seventy or so years, including the period when from its foundation in 1920 to 1934 the CP preached armed insurrection. What we object to is its gradualist strategy, the suggestion that capitalism can be gradually transformed into Socialism through a series of reform measures.

Socialism can only be established by the conscious political act of a socialist-minded working class. Once a majority of the working class want and understand Socialism they can win control of political power by using the existing electoral machinery to send a majority of mandated socialist delegates to the House of Commons and similar institutions in other countries. Once in control of political power they will immediately abolish capitalism and establish Socialism by the single revolutionary act of making the means of production the common property of society under the democratic control of all the people. This done, the State, as the machinery of political power, is dismantled so that to talk of a “socialist government" is a contradiction in terms. As long as the working class does not want Socialism then capitalism must continue. Which is why gradualists, once elected to power (by a non-socialist working class), have no alternative but to administer capitalism—and that in the only way possible, as a profit-making system in the interests of those who live off profits.

The vital task today is not to try to reform capitalism but, by persistent and effective argument, to win over a majority of the working class to abolishing it. This is the road to Socialism.
Adam Buick

Friday, November 13, 2026

Slings and Arrows: Quick-change Artist (1952)

The Slings and Arrows column from the November 1952 issue of the Socialist Standard

Quick-change Artist

The history of the Labour Party is full of examples of rebels who have, after attaining power and eminence, become just as “Right-wing” as the leaders they displaced. Yet, each time a new ginger group or rabble rouser appears in the political firmament large numbers of people think that it is different. It is always the last lot that were no good, and it is always this lot that will be better. The recent Labour Party conference has resulted in a great victory for the group known as the “Bevanites.” They are going to put more Socialism into the Labour Party. We confidently predict that they will fail, not because we are prophets, but because we know that Bevan and his henchmen are no more socialists and no more backed by socialists, than Attlee, Morrison or R. A. Butler for that matter. We predict that should these rebels gain the leadership of the Labour Party they will prove themselves to be just as “right-wing” as the fallen leaders and just as ready to lend themselves to the conduct of Capitalism, war, or whatever situation arises out of this system. And never will the fundamental interests of the working-class be served. Thus it was with the late Sir Stafford Cripps; thus it will be with Bevan. The transformation from left-wing rebel to right-wing leader is invariably gradual. The process takes a few years so that by the time leadership is attained the indiscretions of the rebellious past are buried and almost forgotten. With the present rebels in the ascendant, however, the cat has been let well and truly out of the bag, even before leadership has been reached.

Mr. R. H. Crossman, reputed “expert” on foreign affairs and destined to be Foreign Secretary if ever Bevan gets the call to the premiership, well and truly, yet inadvertently, gave the whole show away. Called to speak to a resolution on foreign policy, a day or so after being elected to the Party Executive, he admitted that the speech he was originally going to make, which would have been “lively and fiery,” was to be scrapped in favour of one “less controversial.” The transformation in his case seems to have taken place overnight. The responsibilities of office affected him more quickly than most other “poachers turned gamekeepers.” To the credit of the delegates of the Labour Party Conference this example of political opportunism was solidly booed, and we can only hope that the incident will leave the delegates with some doubts as to the value of leadership, whether “right- wing,” “left-wing,” or “centre.”


What do they do?

Francis Bacon, alleged by some to be the real author of Shakespeare’s plays, wrote in his essay on Justice: "a much talking judge is like an ill-tuned cymbal.” If he were alive to-day he would have no cause to revise his opinions. Magistrates and Judges are fond of hearing themselves talk, and often betray the most abysmal ignorance of things outside their legal experience. Thus we have a magistrate roundly condemning a working-class woman who had the temerity to spend some of her children’s allowance on going to the pictures once a week. Another legal luminary on being told that a Czech refugee charged with theft could not be deported because his life would be in danger, retorted “So our lives must be endangered.” An apt comment, for to the capitalist and his henchmen property is life.

The magistrate of an East-end Court recently had before him a sixteen year old boy who was earning £8 10s. per week. So astounded was the magistrate that he pondered aloud over this phenomenon and produced the remark, “What on earth can he do to deserve such pay?” The answer, of course, is obvious. Work! It appears from this consternation which fills the breast of the magistrate, that boys of sixteen should not have £8 10s. per week given to them as wages. But this opens up a wide field of investigation. If the Magistrate is perturbed at this state of affairs, he should broaden his horizon and enquire what, for instance, anybody does which is worth, say, £30,000 per annum. He could enquire into the fact that people are getting far more than £8 10s. for doing nothing except clipping dividend coupons off Share Certificates, or paying somebody else to clip the coupons for them. This aspect would not of course perturb the learned Magistrate. What he really objects to is not the sum involved. He would certainly not have said it concerning an Eton schoolboy brought before him for some college “ rag.” He is perturbed by the fact that a working-class boy should get more money than he thinks is proper. It is commonplace to hear of people receiving enormous incomes, complaining that miners or dockers are earning “too much.” They feel that they are the only ones entitled to be affluent, safe, and secure. Socialists who object to the system which produces such inequalities are dubbed "selfish” and "jealous.” So of the magistrate and those who think with him we ask this question: “ If it is wrong for a boy to receive £8 10s. per week for his work, is it not wrong for people to get infinitely more for not working? ” We feel sure that the question will remain unanswered by those who have set themselves up as arbiters of what workers should have.


Misdirected efforts

The explosion of the new British Atomic Bomb off the coast of Australia has been hailed with rapture by every section of the press—the Daily Worker, of course, excepted. The Daily Mirror informs us that this bomb puts the word “Great” in front of Britain, and expects us all to rejoice that Britain has attained at least parity with Russia and America in the development of atomic weapons. It enables "us” to defend ourselves and others. It would be amusing, if the occasion were not so melancholy, to observe that each and every country always has weapons for defence, never for attack. Indeed, the cry of "Defence” which rings out all over the world, makes us wonder why wars ever occur.

The Daily Worker, reporting a statement of an organisation known as "Science for Peace” (a crypto- communist outfit) tells us that the spending of £200,000,000 on this atomic experiment is "anti-social and wholly destructive,” and a "misdirection of scientific effort.” It finds it particularly so at a time when "Britain's economic difficulties are unprecedented and unsolved.” Is then, the expenditure of such a sum on such a project in order if Britain’s economic difficulties were not unprecedented? Do we assume that if Britain did not have a “dollar gap,” and shortage of raw materials (with which the Daily Worker is concerned) the Daily Worker would not frown on Atomic development? Of course we do not. The only time the Daily Worker or the Science for Peace Organisation would approve would be when Britain and Russia were allies. Not one word has ever been published in the Daily Worker condemning the “misdirection of scientific effort ” in the Soviet Union. For remember the Soviet Union also has its Atom bomb. Not only do they not condemn Russia for this but they offered no word of protest at the use of the bomb on Hiroshima when thousands of men, women and children were destroyed in one night, and those who were left alive remain living monuments of the ruthless, predatory nature of that Capitalism which both the Daily Mirror and the Daily Worker support.

The development of Atomic weapons is just one more reason why Capitalism should be swept away and Socialism instituted. But protests at their development in England and America and acquiescence in their production in the Soviet Union is “misdirection of scientific effor ” indeed.

To quote Longfellow:—
“Were half the power that fills the world with tenor.
Were half the wealth bestowed on camps and courts,
Given to redeem the human mind from error.
There were no need for arsenals and forts.”
S.A.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Editorial: Russian Foreign Policy and Communist Somersaults (1938)

Editorial from the November 1938 issue of the Socialist Standard

Ten years ago, when Germany was disarmed and Russia was particularly fearful of France and her allies in Central and South-Eastern Europe, the Russian Government cultivated friendly relations with Germany and Italy. In line with this policy, the Communist Parties all over the world were ordered to denounce the Versailles Treaty, seek the break-up of the British Empire and hold up Great Britain, America and France and her allies as the enemies of peace and democracy.

The Russian policy changed with the recovery of German armed strength. Russia joined the League of Nations and sought alliances with France, Czechoslovakia and Great Britain. A corresponding change had to take place in the policy of the Communist Parties, and they proceeded to eat their own words and preach all of the doctrines they had formerly derided. The League of Nations, instead of being to them a League of Britain and France to hold the spoils of the last war, became overnight the only bulwark of peace and democracy. The Lenin of 1918 would have poured scorn on the puerile arguments the Communists now put forward. 

The extent of the gulf between the old and the new Communist doctrines can be measured by comparing the present attitude with that contained in “The Struggle Against War," published by the Communist Party of Great Britain ten years ago. (It is undated, but reveals its date of publication by the opening words: “Ten years after the world war.")

On page 31 it deals with the “numerous oppressed nationalities and national minorities existing in a number of the States in Europe, set up by the Versailles Treaty." It denounces Poland and Rumania, who “cruelly oppress with a bloody hand the White Russian and Ukrainian and Bessarabian populations in their territories," and goes on as follows : —
In Czechoslovakia and in the Balkan countries, in Italy in France, Spain, Belgium and Great Britain (Ireland) there are also oppressed nationalities. The Communist Party will support the liberation movement of the oppressed nations and national minorities in all these countries, lead them in the revolutionary struggle against Imperialism and unreservedly champion their right to self-determination, which must include the right to complete separation.
But in 1938 Russia had treaties with Czechoslovakia and Rumania and France, and any Communist who dared to champion the right of their minorities to separation would have found himself in trouble, denounced as a Fascist.

Then there is the question of the cunning way in which capitalist governments lure their workers into supporting wars. In 1928 it was a fundamental task of the loyal Communist to expose the “sophistries and catchwords by which the bourgeoisie and Social-Democracy try to justify war" (page 14). The Communists were to expose the slogan of “national defence,” and, above all, the workers must be warned against the trick of pretending that the war is a war against Fascism. The pamphlet goes on: —
In the last Imperialist war, the Allies made use of the slogan, “Fight Against Prussian Militarism," while the Central Powers used the slogan “Fight Against Tsarism”; both sides using the respective slogans to mobilise the masses for the war. In a future war between Italy and France, or Yugo Slavia, the same purpose will be served by the slogan “ Fight Against Reactionary Fascism," for the Bourgeoisie in the latter countries will take advantage of the anti-Fascist sentiments of the masses of the people to justify Imperialist war.
The paragraph ends with the remark that “The Communist Parties have hitherto paid insufficient attention to the duty of refuting these sophistries.”

Pity the poor Communist who kept his pamphlet by him and dutifully tried to pay more attention to refuting them.

How the Churchills and Edens must laugh when they see the Communists walking right into the trap against which, ten years ago, they were warning other people.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Letter: Ourselves and the CP (1974)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1974 issue of the Socialist Standard

Ourselves and the CP

I am writing to protest at your waste of good Socialist space in the S.S. I refer to your continual obsessive carping on the misguided thinking of the CP in comparison to yours. Surely, with all the futile waste, almost criminal of the capitalist system, this includes state capitalism masquerading as communism, you could leave the CP to its usual smearers in the Labour and Conservative parties. After all there must be something wrong with the CP to warrant this continuous smearing — apart from yours.

A member of the CP can never expect honours from the establishment while still an active member. In order to attain these he must leave and get control of a Union if possible, and duckshove his way to the top, to manipulate its business in capitalism’s favour. A case in point is the ETU where three communists with the help of the present Lord Feather secured controlling positions in that key Union. One became Sir Leslie Cannon — if that was any consolation to him. The establishment know how to reward working-class treachery in their favour.
J. Maryon
Hornchurch.

Reply
We have never gone in for the “smearing” of other political parties. Our criticisms are always based on verifiable fact and never on smear, guilt by association or any of the other tactics employed by capitalist parties.

Our criticism of the so called “Communist" Party is quite different to those used by the Labour and Conservative Parties. We are unique in attacking the CP on the grounds that they are, whatever their proclamations may be, an anti-working class party. The CP advocates not Communism or Socialism (the terms are the same thing although the CP confuse the issue by differentiating them) but State Capitalism.

Nothing that the CP advocates can change the economic position of the working class. When they contest elections they do so on a reform platform talking nonsense such as “The British Road to Socialism” or more nationalization. The suggestion that they want a fundamental change in the basis of society can easily be refuted. For example John Mathews writing in their fortnightly review was full of “criticism” for Labour chancellor Denis Healey’s recent mini-budget because it failed to deal adequately with the problems facing British capitalism. Mathews suggested that Britain should go in for selective import controls, planned investment and that self contradiction in terms “planned trade”. And what did he have to say about capitalism?
  There is much wailing and gnashing of teeth over the size of the [trade] deficit, and the interest charges to be paid on loans, but no solution — only appeals to make a "national effort”, etc. It needs to be said that the British economy is running down not because of shoddy workmanship, or absenteeism, or any of the pseudo-explanations advanced but because of the economic sabotage of the owners of capital. It is the management of the economy which is at fault, not the economy itself. (Comment August 10, 1974 — emphasis in the original.)
Our unmasking of these political frauds masquerading as revolutionaries is fully justified. The fact that some ex-CPers seek places of privilege and power in the capitalist establishment is not surprising but does not alter the case. Once in power Communists pursue anti-working-class policies. Ken Gill, newly elected to the TUC general council brags that “. . . this mighty Congress has committed itself to wage restraint . . . we hated restraint under Heath but we welcome it under Wilson” (Daily Telegraph 5 September 1974.) 

Need we say more?
Editors.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Marching backwards (2026)

Book Review from the November 2026 issue of the Socialist Standard

How I’ve Tried To Change The World. By Alexei Sayle. Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2026. £16.99

This is the third of Sayle’s entertaining autobiographical meanders and is subtitled ‘… By Walking Down The Middle of the Street Shouting’. Instead of a straight autobiographical approach to the more recent decades of his career, stand-up comedy’s greatest ever shouter has instead chosen to focus on his political activity and this is the thread everything else revolves around. To an extent it works, though it is also a catalogue of failure and frustration, as he largely admits.

His parents were stalwarts of the old Communist Party of Great Britain but the young Alexei moved on to the Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist), a Maoist outfit he tired of over time and whose internal atmosphere and membership behaviours he has bemoaned, arguing they could learn a lot from some of the practices of Alcoholics Anonymous. Since then, he has been a supporter of most leftist causes from the late 60s, often prominently so. In recent times he has been especially animated by the atrocity in Gaza and appears to have fallen out with a number of friends over it, including others – like him – of Jewish heritage.

As he recognises, ultimately much of this political activity has been futile, though he clearly had his hopes of something bigger and more successful rekindled by the rise of Jeremy Corbyn when he was Labour leader. This soon went the same way of course, though he seems to downplay the inherent contradictions in the Corbynite position (which was always focused on delivering rhetoric on behalf of the oppressed – while never really challenging the capitalist system of markets, profits and competing nation states that creates the oppressed in the first place). As a great supporter of the Palestinian cause, Sayle also underplays the tendency of Corbyn and his allies to focus on single-issues and rely on the belief that an enemy of an enemy must somehow be a friend, often in a way that has demonstrated a huge degree of political naiveté.

Sayle, however, does show some real lucidity at times which is memorable (as he always does in his stand-up and radio shows). Here he is writing about the Arab Spring when mass movements threatened to topple – and often did topple – a series of Middle East dictatorships:
‘There is no greater argument than the failure of the Arab Spring for leaders of protests needing to understand that they absolutely have to possess a political ideology. For them to have adopted socialism or Marxism or anarchism, this providing a way to bring structure to the act of rebelling. For them, in fact, to have a code. Otherwise, you risk your protest ending up like the Black Lives Matter rallies which went from a visceral outcry against state brutality to players occasionally kneeling before a football match for fuck knows what reason’ (p.147).
Elsewhere Sayle also says that he regards Marxism as the best way available of understanding the world around us … even if it won’t necessarily make you happy! Cheers, Alexei.
DAP

Sunday, October 25, 2026

To the brink in Vietnam (1965)

From the September 1965 issue of the Socialist Standard

When the Second World War broke out the Socialist Party of Great Britain had no hesitation in declaring its opposition. We maintained throughout that war the same position as we had taken in 1914. We based our attitude on the Socialist principle of International working-class unity and argued that the war resulted from the commercial rivalry between capitalist nations over such things as world markets, spheres of influence and investments, and mineral resources, etc. From the Socialist viewpoint workers do not own countries, empires or vested interests, they do not own the wealth which they alone produce nor the factories and so on where production takes place. Therefore, when rival capitalists fall out, as they constantly do, over the division of the wealth they have plundered from the workers, no working-class interest can be involved. Further, the workers in every country have a common interest in uniting together to get rid of their common enemy, the world’s capitalist class, by bringing to an end the system that exploits and degrades them.

This attitude brought us much scorn and bitterness from the war-supporting members of the Labour and so-called Communist Parties. These and other self-appointed champions of the working-class had joined forces with the avowedly capitalist parties to win the war. They argued that democracy was at stake and therefore the interest of the workers was involved in defeating Fascism and dictatorship. There is always some plausible sounding get-out to make it appear that this war “is a just war”; the readiness of workers to accept such stories is what makes war a continuing possibility.

For the “Communists” however, this new found love of democracy only came after the Daily Worker (23/8/1939) had hailed the Russian pact with Hitler as a “Victory for Peace and Socialism,” and completely ignored the fact that Russia was itself a dictatorship where no vestige of democracy existed. The “Communists” having survived their former friend Hitler, are still suffering from political double-vision concerning democracy. The Socialist Party of Great Britain maintained that war could not be used as a means of defending democracy or of maintaining freedom. We pointed out that talk of freedom and democracy was just an ideological cover-up for the commercial ambitions of the rival capitalist classes, and that peace could never be other than an illusion as long as capitalism remained. There would always be new line-ups, new power-blocks as enemies became allies in the continuous quest for markets and profits. Throughout our existence we have insisted in face of all the clamourings for “something now” that the thing for world workers to do “now” is to recognise their identity of interests and unite for Socialism. Thus ending in one move the foul system which produces and reproduces all the day-to-day issues they clamour about.

There are countless examples from capitalism to prove our position to be the only sound one and, conversely, that all the arguments of our opponents are dangerous nonsense.

The most blatant current example is provided by the war in Vietnam. American capitalism is embroiled in a blood¬bath which, as usual, the propaganda machine describes as a fight for freedom. The double-talk and hypocrisy have failed to hide the real nature of the regime in South Vietnam, which is openly referred to in the British newspapers as a dictatorship. On July 4th the Sunday Mirror published an interview with a self-confessed murderer named Nguyá»…n Cao Kỳ. Under American patronage this thug became the tenth Prime Minister of South Vietnam in 20 months. In the interview he declared that his only hero is Adolf Hitler and boasted about shooting anyone who got in the way. The interview sparked off a chain of reactions, but the Sunday Mirror (formerly the Sunday Pictorial which supported the Second World War did not condemn this American stooge. The situation emerges where America, having fought the Second World War allegedly “to make the world safe for democracy” against Hitlerism is now backing up a Hitlerite in the name of “freedom.” The politicians of capitalism are, however, nothing if not thick-skinned. The embarrassment does not seem to have been too much for the British Government or the House of Commons. The day after the interview appeared, Mr. William Warbey, a Labour M.P., raised the matter in the House, but the Speaker, Sir Harry Hylton Foster, refused a debate. Another Labour member, Mr. Frank Allaun, tabled a question for the Foreign Secretary, seeking to break off diplomatic relations with the Government of South Vietnam “whose Prime Minister has declared the policy of following Hitlerian principles.” But as the Sunday Mirror points out, “Mr. Stewart is unlikely to agree.” The Labour Government cannot afford to be squeamish about supporting a dictatorship, they are committed to running British capitalism and they need the goodwill of American capitalism economically and militarily. Just as capitalism once made bed-fellows of Russia and Nazi Germany, it now does the same for the Labour Government and Hitler’s latest admirer. Cynicism and hypocrisy are inescapable for all who would retain capitalism. Democracy and freedom are ruthlessly trodden under foot and become empty words in the battle for propaganda advantage.

We seize the opportunity to again affirm —
“That the machinery of government, including the armed forces of the nation, exists only to conserve the monopoly by the capitalist class of the wealth taken from the workers.

“The Socialist Party of Great Britain pledges itself to keep the issue clear by expounding the CLASS STRUGGLE, and whilst placing on record its abhorrence of this latest manifestation of the callous, sordid and mercenary nature of the international capitalist class, and declaring that no interests are at stake justifying the shedding of a single drop of working-class blood …”  (Extract from SPGB Statement on War, August, 1914)
Harry Baldwin

Friday, October 23, 2026

Obituary: Nat Posner (1962)

Obituary from the August 1962 issue of the Socialist Standard

Bloomsbury Branch have sadly learned of the death of Nat Posner, who had been ill for some time. A member for over twenty years, he had known and supported the Party a long time and had interested workers in Socialism for more than forty years. Some of these joined the Party thirty years ago becoming very active in propaganda work. Originally working as a group at their place of work they sold thousands of Socialist Standards and pamphlets and took regular weekly collections for the Party from sympathizers over a period of years. Thus, our comrade Posner by quietly and patiently convincing others, set off a chain of socialist activity. He was a frequent chairman at outdoor meetings especially at Hyde Park; a consistent and staunch member, he will be missed.
P. H.


Blogger's Note:
This obituary notice was already on the blog. It was part of a News from the Branches column that was originally posted on the blog back in 2014 but it was somehow lost in the mix. Comrade Posner's obituary deserves its own post. Nat Posner originally joined the Bloomsbury Branch of the SPGB in February 1940, and his Form A tells us that before he joined the SPGB, he was a member of the Communist Party, He wrote a handful of articles for the Socialist Standard in the late 1940s and early 1950s, and they are well worth checking out.

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Letter: A Communist Leader and the Right to Strike (1937)

Letter to the Editors from the October 1937 issue of the Socialist Standard

A Communist Leader and the Right to Strike

To the Editorial Board,                                                                                                                                                          
The Socialist Standard.
 
Woolwich, S.E.18.

Dear Comrade,

I have been invited as a member of the Communist Party to express my opinion on your article, “ A Communist Leader and the Right to Strike.” (See July The Socialist Standard.)

Your article, in the first place, does not examine the economic history and the relation of the class forces leading up to the agreement, but takes part of the agreement, without regard to the situation, and then condemns Arthur Homer and the Communist Party. You are content merely to repeat what a capitalist paper says, instead of as Marxists examining the whole question in the light of its relationship, taking into account as many facts as possible. Had this been done you would have been in a position to express an opinion.

Although not in any way connected with the mining industry, I submit the following facts:—

In 1933 the Bedwas Lodge was driven off the colliery it had controlled for many years. Under police protection the pit was filled with blacklegs and two thousand men were out. From 1933 to 1936 things were relatively quiet, but in 1934 Emlyn, Parc and Dare had been won back to the S.W.M.F. and Taff Merthyr had been weakened, but Bedwas was still 100 per cent. Miners’ Industrial Union. This had cost the Union money and funds were low. It was obvious that the strength of the Industrial Union was at Bedwas. In 1936 the attack on Bedwas started, and eventually 900 men signed revocation cards. Provisional strike notices were handed in. Ninety per cent. of the coalfield supported them. The Bedwas owners left the Coalowners' Association in order to fight. The huts were ready at the pithead to house the blacklegs.

On the last day of the expiry of the notices the owners said they would be willing to meet the Union if they withdrew the notices. There were stay-in strikes.

The owners met the Union. It now became clear that there would not be a strike. If a strike took place the Company would be smashed, the Company was carrying a million pounds of debt and not another penny was available. If the output did not provide the wages, the wages could not be paid. It was easy to close the colliery and destroy the men’s employment as the price for wiping out the Company Union. Therefore the Bedwas agreement was entered into.

In most instances the agreement is the same as that covering the coalfield agreement, and in some instances there are advantages in the Bedwas agreement. Double shift and new machinery are dealt with in the same manner as the coalfield agreement. Wages differ very little from that in the coalfield agreement.

It is Clause 13—machinery for settling disputes —which has caused uneasiness, but after consultation with the men and the old Bedwas Committee, it was agreed to. Either the agreement or close the fit.

The Independent Arbitrator takes the place of the Finality Committee now functioning in the coalfield, but whereas in the cases of dispute 99 per cent. of the cases of “failure to agree" implied defeat for the appellants, every dispute must now reach a conclusion.

If there is a coalfield fight, Bedwas can do as every other colliery, each individual can terminate his contract and secure release from the agreement. In the event of the Company failing to carry out the agreement there can, and probably will be, strikes.

The Bedwas agreement has not endangered coalfield agreement, although it contains formulations agreed to under duress.

Finally, the agreement has paved the way in a period of relative weakness for die final elimination of Company Unionism in the coalfield. Then is your article justified—you must make the choice—is this an advance from the 100 per cent. Company Unionism and the isolation of the Federation from Bedwas or not? You say that “at best it could be described as compromising and dangerous." Do you understand that the class struggle is full of compromises and dangers for the working class? It is a question whether you will face up to them or not. 
Yours fraternally, 
S. Rodgers.


Reply.
Our correspondent’s letter criticising the article, “A Communist Leader and the Right to Strike," is not very convincing. He says that the alternative to the Bedwas Agreement, signed by Arthur Horner, was closing the pit and throwing the miners out of employment. Such situations can indeed arise, but when faced with a demand by the employers that the Union shall sign a degrading agreement, the workers at least have the alternative of refusing to give their officials authority to sign— in other words, of giving up official recognition of the Union for the time being. The employers would enforce the terms, whether the Union signed or not, but there would be a certain value in the workers refraining from giving collective endorsement to them.

Our correspondent’s letter is, however, hardly consistent with itself. Having stated that the Bedwas workers had to accept the agreement or lose their employment through the closing down of the colliery, our correspondent goes on to say that, in the event of a coalfield fight, the Bedwas workers can individually terminate the agreement and come out on strike. Surely in that case they will be again faced with the closing down of the colliery and the loss of their employment: if it applies in one case so, it will in the other. This “right" of individually terminating his agreement is possessed by every worker, organised or not, but what a right ! It is an admission that real trade union organisation is for the time being impossible.
Ed. Comm.

Sunday, October 18, 2026

This Right is Wrong! (1976)

From the October 1976 issue of the Socialist Standard

Work is a nature—imposed necessity. If society wishes to sustain itself then it has got to wrestle with nature and produce and distribute food, clothing and shelter in order for its survival. That is general, but now the particular.

Because the machinery of wealth production is in the hands of an owning class, most of us who don’t own this capital are compelled to seek employment from the owners. They are the employers, we are the employees. The employers’ privileges and riches are based on the exploitation of the employees, namely the amount of surplus-value which they (the capitalists) can extract from workers during production. It is in fact on this condition that jobs are provided. So for the workers to insist on their exploitation being made a “right” is blandly perpetuating the system of master and slave.

“Fight for the right to work” is the current bandwagon for the Communist Party and the International Socialists. They have been busy holding demonstrations urging workers to claim their entitlement to a lifelong toil. Their leaders have been anxious to explain how this can be done. Warning the Labour government “no cuts in public expenditure”. That British capitalists should be made to invest their capital in dear ol' Britain, and not export it abroad in search of bigger profits. And that import controls should be imposed in order to save the capitalists who own the home industries from going bankrupt. Most important of all, more state ownership. All done, according to the CP and IS, with the workers’ jobs at heart.

If that isn’t confusing enough, what about this? In America the “right to work” campaign is a completely different kettle of fish. Its main bind is against the power of the trade unions. The National Right to Work Committee which is led by a former electrical engineer, Reed Lawson from Kansas, has upped its membership in the last two years from 30,000 to 330,000. It’s against the trade unions’ closed shop policies; harassment of non-trade-unionists; strikes and picketing which affect the jobs of many people unconnected with the particular dispute. It’s against the compulsory unionization of the teachers and public employees. Last year the NRWC launched a campaign against the Common Sites Picketing Bill. After an inflow of 700,000 letters demanding its removal President Ford finally vetoed the bill. The British and American crusades for the “right to work” are almost opposites and as far as the workers are concerned neither provides much sense.

Society has a need to work. But today society is divided into Capital and Labour, each with its own different interests: Capital with its need to make as much profit as possible at the expense of wages, Labour its need to get as much in wages and as good conditions as possible. There is no place for “rights”. There is a need for Labour to seek independence from Capital and that comes about not by seeking phoney “rights” but only through the emancipation of the working class from the domination of the master class. The emancipation of the working class means the emancipation of all mankind.

Society’s need to produce everything for a full life requires converting the means of production from private or state-ownership into common ownership. By doing this we will have production for use with free access.

“Fight for the right to work” is pathetic and has no place beside the Socialist principle “From each according to his ability to each according to his need.”
Joe McGuinness

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Letters: Anonymous letters (1934)

Letters to the Editors from the September 1934 issue of the Socialist Standard

“COMMUNIST."—We have your letter in which you argue that the Communists “are going the right way, but cannot explain themselves very well." If you give your name and address (not necessarily for publication) we will reply to your letter. We do not answer anonymous letters.
Ed. Comm.

* * * * *
 
Answers held over.
Several Answers to Correspondents are held over owing to lack of space. Ed. Comm.

Friday, October 9, 2026

Scapegoats for the Labour leaders (1950)

From the October 1950 issue of the Socialist Standard

For five years the Labour voters were very loyal to the government of their choice. Through a series of “crises” they patiently worked and waited for the better times they were told would soon be here. Then just as they were preparing to reap the reward they expected when they had delivered the stipulated production and “closed the dollar gap” they received an icy shock that changed their political outlook more than anything that had gone before. This was the Prime Minister’s curt announcement that a new round of austerity is on the way to provide for re-armament, the Korean war and the other wars that it is feared may follow. The new blow has brought to a head the cumulative effect of past disappointments, showing itself in a wave of wage demands and “unofficial ” strikes in disregard of the appeals of Ministers and Trade Union officials.

Workers are asking themselves whether the Labour Party is any better at keeping its pledges than were the Conservatives. Those who looked on the Labour Party as the enemy of conscription and armaments find themselves heading for a third world war. Those who wanted higher wages and lower prices are asked to be content with wage-restraint, a rising cost of living and demands for more sacrifices. Those workers who thought that nationalisation would solve their problems find that it makes no difference to them. Labourism has been tried and has failed but politicians do not easily reconcile themselves to losing office and power. The leaders are bewildered at the failure of their plans, and frightened as they find themselves caught up in capitalism’s swift descent towards war; but they do not yet despair. Like many a government before them they hope to be able to turn a critical situation to their own advantage. If the workers at home dislike the increase of fares, the rising cost of food, the extension of conscription to two years, the entry into the Korean War, the refusal to grant wage increases, perhaps their resentment can be turned away from its natural targets of capitalism and the Government that administers capitalism, and turned in another direction by a campaign against Russia and Communist agents.

It is all so easy—just as it was when the Tory Government worked it to the full during and after the first world war, and used it again to unseat the Labour Government in 1924.

Of course Russian State capitalism and Russian imperialism are evil things but so is capitalism and capitalist imperialism in Western Europe, Britain and America. And the Western Governments’ real objection to the Russian Government’s actions is only that of rival concerns in the same line of business. As Mr. Sefton Delmer, Daily Express correspondent, said in an interview with the Indian Prime Minister, Nehru;—
“We objected to Communism because the countries where it had established—itself mostly by force of arms or terrorism—had been closed to Western trade. This deprived both them and us of commodities essential to our prosperity and progress." (Daily Express, 19-9-50).
The other side of the picture is given by an article in the journal of the Czeckoslovak Ministry of Foreign Trade. (Quoted by the Manchester Guardian, 16-9-50). The Czeckoslovak Ministry’s article discloses that while they encourage the Russian move to promote strikes of dockers in the countries allied to America, on the ground of alleged sympathy with the dockers, at the same time the Ministry is urging foreign business men to send their cargoes through the strike-free ports of Poland and thus avoid hold-ups and consequent loss of profits. Under the East European capitalist dictatorship the dockers strike at their peril.

The British Labour leaders profess to be very much opposed to governmental regimentation of the workers as practised in these countries. Yet at the same time we have Mr. Deakin, General Secretary of the Transport and General Workers Union demanding the suppression of the Communist Party and the Daily Worker (Manchester Guardian 18-9-50), Mr. Isaacs, Minister of Labour threatening legal action and if necessary legislation against the “promoters of illegal strikes” (Daily Herald 16-9-50). Meanwhile Scotland Yard are studying the activities of “Communist agitators”—“Blue print for the arrest of dangerous communists within a few hours, if empowered by legislation, is ready.” (Evening Standard, 18-9-50).

So, in the blessed name of freedom and democracy, the Labour Government prepare to bring British legislation and suppressive measures more closely into line with those of the dictatorship countries.

The position is so fantastic that we have Mr. Deakin, the servant of union members who pay their contributions to support an organisation for the purpose of making wage claims, denouncing Communists on the ground that “they were out to create and encourage wage claims and to use every possible opportunity to cause dislocation.” (At a Press Conference. Daily Telegraph, 19/9/50).

It is true that those who direct Communist policy are not interested in the welfare of the working class being concerned to exploit discontent in order to help Russia, but the discontent exists and will go on expressing itself no matter what the Communists do and even if they are suppressed.

Past experience should warn the Labour leaders of the likely outcome of the policy they contemplate. From 1917 onwards the charge of being pro-German or “Red Agents” was made against all who were critical of the war and all who took part in strikes, and among the results was that more and more workers gave their support to Ramsay MacDonald and Snowden and to trade unionists like Smillie, Williams and Arthur Cook who were thus enabled to gain popularity at the expense of the old leaders. Eventually the workers discontent exploded in the General Strike of 1926. Since the rise of the new men did not mean progress towards the only solution—the replacement of capitalism by Socialism—it only led to further disillusionment and in that respect also a repetition of the process now will be merely another phase of misdirected work and purposeless suffering by the working class.

The Socialist Party of Great Britain will continue to urge the workers of the need to rid themselves of the delusion that Labour Party or Communist Party administered capitalism can solve their problems; also of the need to retain their trade union weapon, the strike, and above all of the need to recognise that only through a world wide movement to establish Socialism can their emancipation be brought about.

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Letter: Who did what in the war? (1975)

Letter to the Editors from the October 1975 issue of the Socialist Standard

Who did what in the war?

Going back to the year after the war I lived in London and used to come along to your meetings and debates with other parties. I used to come to Leicester Square to one on a Sunday evening. In London recently I bought one of the SPGB books, on war, and I must say I enjoyed reading it.

You state that the Communist Party supported the war at first, then in October 1939 they were against it. Well, didn’t the Communist Party give Harry Pollitt the sack during the changeover? I think I am right when I say that later on in the war Harry Pollitt put up in a by-election at Silvertown as a “Stop the War” candidate. And when did the Labour Party join Churchill’s government? They opposed them.

Now in your book Questions of the Day you write about Parliament and the elections. Well, does the ruling class go to the country when it suits them? From 1931 to 1945 the Tories only had two elections, and in 1910 and 1974 there were two elections in one year.

I must say there have been a lot of wars since the SPGB published the book War and the Working Class in 1936: all the killings going on in Ireland at the moment.

With best wishes to the SPGB.
L. J. Taylor 
Peterborough.


Reply:
The answer to your question about the Communist Party is as follows. In March 1939 the Daily Worker published an appeal to Attlee and Sinclair, the leaders of the Labour and Liberal parties, and Churchill for the Conservatives, to get together and form a “Popular Front” government to oppose Germany. On 2nd September this demand was affirmed in a manifesto issued by the Central Committee of the CP for success in the war about to start. Harry Pollitt wrote a pamphlet How to Win the War, in which he said: “The Communist Party supports the war, believing it to be a just war”.

A month later the CP changed its mind and issued a fresh manifesto published in the Daily Worker on the 12th. It said: “The manifesto of October 7th corrects the declaration issued on September 2nd. The present war is not a just war, but an unjust and imperialist one.” Pollitt was relieved of his job as General Secretary of the CP, but continued as its leading propagandist after he had made an abject confession of error. The CP continued to oppose the war and, when the coalition government it had asked for was formed in May 1940, yelled indignantly: “What a man [Churchill] to take under the wing of the Labour Party!”

The reason for the change was, of course, keeping up with Russian foreign policy. Pollitt assumed that the CP would support a war against Germany without taking into account the Russo-German pact of August 1939. When Germany invaded Russia in May 1941 the CP again became vigorous supporters of the war and the Churchill government.

On your second question, the frequency with which governments “go to the country” depends on their assessment of the need to have the support of the working class demonstrated or reaffirmed. The chief reason why there was no general election from 1935 to 1945 was the war, in which the coalition government (not the Tories alone) assumed itself to have general support with a desire for as little disruption as possible.


Blogger's Note:
A later version of the Questions of the Day pamphlet is online on the SPGB website.

Monday, October 5, 2026

The Trades Union Congress (1936)

From the October 1936 issue of the Socialist Standard

The sixty-eighth annual Trades Union Congress was held at Plymouth in September, under the presidency of Mr. A. A. H. Findlay, General Secretary of the United Pattern-Makers' Union.

It is an indication of the trend of trade unionism in this country that, in recent years, the time of Congress has been taken up, to an increasingly larger extent, in debate and discussion on political affairs and international questions. This year’s conference was similarly occupied. The dominant issues were Spain, national defence, dictatorship, and the Communist demand for a united front.

The Spanish Civil War
The President, in his opening speech, referred to the present struggle in Spain, and said: —
“Our hearts,” he continued, “ go out in honour and respect to our comrades in Spain, who are making their magnificent fight in defence of constitutional government.”— (Manchester Guardian, August 9th, 1936.)
A telegram, approved by Congress, and sent to the Spanish Premier, read: —
This congress, representing the organised workers of Great Britain, profoundly moved by the heroic struggle of the Spanish people for the maintenance of freedom and democracy . . . In the confident assurance that they embody the unconquerable will of the Spanish nation to defeat the forces of Fascism and tyranny, we pledge afresh our utmost support to the Spanish people.
Such is the sentiment. But when it came to a showdown, to a question of translating sentimental platitudes into practical assistance, Congress showed its helplessness and complete inability to give any
material help to the Spanish workers. What the Spanish Government needs is arms, in the shape of battleships, aeroplanes and guns, with which to fight the rebel military forces. Congress could not provide these. However, to be consistent with its resolution of “utmost support," it might have adopted a policy of supporting the demand that the British Government supply arms to the Government in Spain. It did not do so, but carried, by 595 votes to 7, a resolution supporting the Government’s policy of neutrality, that is, of withholding the supply of arms. An amendment favouring a policy of intervention was defeated on a card vote by 3,029,000 votes to 51,000. Intervention here meant supplying the Spanish Government with arms.

In the discussion that followed, Sir Walter Citrine said that the great need of the Spanish Government was to be supplied as rapidly as possible with war material to which it was entitled under international law. That it was felt that action should be taken to restrain Italy and Germany from supplying munitions to the Spanish military rebels. This could only be effected by placing a naval blockade round the coast of Spain. He continued : “ . . . I could not say ‘yes' to that.” (Daily Herald, September 11th, 1936.) Nevertheless, Sir Walter did say “yes" to the stupid telegram which pledged “utmost support" to the Spanish people, and which could only be dangerously misleading to the Spanish workers and Government. He also stated that the policy of neutrality was initiated by the Popular Front Government of France, and that the French Government had had a long-standing agreement with the Spanish Government to supply munitions, yet on July 25th (which was only one week after the civil war broke out) it decided it could no longer do so. He expressed the view that the overriding motive was clearly that the French Government was convinced that if it went on supplying Spain in the emergency with the munitions that the Spanish Government needed, there would in all probability be an outbreak of war in Europe.

Certain aspects of the question had apparently escaped Sir Walter Citrine’s notice. Were Congress or the “neutral” powers able to exert sufficient pressure to compel the Fascist powers to observe neutrality, then that pressure could have been exerted to have prevented them from supplying arms to the rebels in the first place. There was, in fact, no essential difference in the policy of neutrality embodied in the resolution which he supported and the policy of intervention in the amendment which he opposed. There would be as much “danger to the peace of Europe" if the policy of neutrality had to be made effective as there would be in the policy of intervention. The neutral powers, Great Britain and France, are not willing to risk war whilst there is “no direct threat to their interests. The enormous cost of war and the possibility of loss in markets and colonies induce an attitude of caution in international affairs and an anxiety to avoid doing anything that would provoke war. Which is quite unlike the swashbuckling sentiment of the British Governments when Empire building was in its heyday. Germany and Italy have less to lose and can afford to take advantage of the weakness, temporary or otherwise, of the other great powers, and with less fear of retaliation. Nobody believes that if Germany and Italy accepted the neutrality agreement that they would keep it. It is doubtful whether Sir Walter Citrine does.

A Recruiting Speech
In the debate Mr. Bevin scored as a jingo. “We are satisfied,” he said, “ that we are not going to meet the Fascist menace by mere resolutions. . . . We are not going to meet it by pure Pacifism . . . the whole of the democratic powers had to say to Hitler and Mussolini * Don’t take us too cheaply.’ ”

And during the discussion on foreign affairs he said: —
“We have been on the retreat as democratic powers.

“We have weakened our prestige. There has been an assumption that we would never defend ourselves.

“ That is not true. 
“ Fascism is not going to saddle itself on the whole earth, either by intrigue or the methods employed in Spain.”—(Daily Herald, 11.9.36.)
The Government has probably noted that speech for use in future recruiting literature.

The Communists and Spain
Other interesting facts which came out were: That the British Communist Party had not raised its voice to demand that Russia should send munitions to Spain. That the fact that the Russian Government had accepted the neutrality agreement and had operated it had never been mentioned by the French Communist Party. That the Russian trade unions had ceased collections for the Spanish workers on the instructions of the Russian Government. That the international fund for relief amounted to £45,000, of which £13,381 came from Britain. This represents a fraction of a penny per head of the trade union membership of Great Britain. (Daily Herald, September 11th, 1936.)

Future Labour Government. Mr. Bevin’s Boast
Resolutions favouring the abolition of the means test, the forty-hour week, the raising of the school-leaving age to sixteen, the abolition of the six-day waiting period for unemployed workers applying for insurance benefit, were approved. Congress knew that the passing of these, resolutions anticipated the policy of a possible future Labour Government. In fact, speaking to the resolution in favour of a forty-hour week, Mr. Bevin said: —
“The resolution did imply that if after the next election they secured the return of a Labour Government they would expect that Government to introduce the 40-hour week.”—(Daily Herald, 10.9.36.) 
And later: —
“ Never again must a Labour Minister be sent into office without all his plans prepared.”
The latter statement is in the nature of an ultimatum or a threat. As Mr. Bevin gave it as his opinion that the Labour Party lacks the virility of the trade unions, perhaps he considered the threat necessary. The statement certainly gives ammunition to the opponents of the Labour Party, who maintain that it was the Trade Union "caucus” who insisted upon the Labour Party not entering the National Government in 1931, against that party’s own wishes.

It is to be hoped that workers will remember Mr. Bevin’s words when the next Labour Government is elected—particularly if he is in the Cabinet. The last Labour Government found its pledges embarrassing, and said so, and asked the workers not to press their claims. The bill to raise the school-leaving age, which was introduced by the last Labour Government, particularly showed that lack of “virility” to which Mr. Bevin referred. It was wrecked because of the dissensions between the rival religious factions within the Parliamentary Labour Party. The waiting period for the unemployed worker and the means test were then in operation and were justified by Labour Government spokesmen. Mr. Lansbury stated that he was not in favour of an unemployed man having assistance unless some kind of means test were applied.

Trade Union Soul-Saving
However, the fear of losing its members, votes, and trade union financial backing, might induce an effort in a future Labour Government to attempt to carry out its pledges. In the opinion of Sir Walter Citrine, the trade union movement “saved the soul of the.Labour movement in 1931,” when the Labour Government fell. However, having said it, it is to be hoped that Sir Walter will be as successful in keeping it unsullied in the future. Incidentally, his statement is a tacit admission that members of the Labour Government were in favour of entering the National Government in 1931, and only refrained from doing so because of pressure from the trade unions.

Trade Union and Co-Operative Societies
Discussion, on the General Council’s report dealing with employment of trade union labour by co-operative societies and firms working on cooperative society contracts was interesting. Some of the discussion, as reported by the Manchester Guardian (September 11th, 1936), is as follows: —
Mr. A. G. Tomkins, of the Furnishing Trades’ Association, said it was not correct to say that with the exception of a few small societies the goods sold were made under fair conditions; it would be more correct to say that the larger the co-operative society the bigger difficulty they nad in preventing “ rat ” furniture from being sold.

Mr. W. Birch, of the Distributive and Allied Workers, Hyde, urged the General Council to take an active part in negotiations for conciliation machinery between the C.W.S. and the unions having members employed by it. It would be a great achievement if they could establish a fifty-shilling minimum for the men concerned. 
“ Rat ” furniture is furniture made under sweated conditions of labour. In this case in workshops which contract for the co-operative societies. The Daily Herald reported Mr. Tomkins as having spoken on the General Council’s report, but completely omitted the statements reproduced from the Manchester Guardian's report above. The Herald also omitted from its report of Mr. Birch’s speech the statement that “it would be a great achievement if they could establish a fifty-shilling minimum for the men concerned.”

Communists and the United Front
When Congress discussed the General Council’s report opposing a united front with the Communists, Sir Walter Citrine made a scathing speech. He said that one of the most amusing spectacles which contemporary political history would reveal was the attempt made by the Communist movement to ingratiate itself with the Trades Union Congress and Labour Party.
“After years of derision of the principles of the Labour movement, after using gallons of ink in denunciation of Labour’s leaders, after abuse of its unions as pillars of capitalism and reformist organisations, after denouncing its puny attempts to capture Parliament—regarded by the Communists as entirely ineffective as a means of emancipation of the people—after all the years that we have experienced since 1925, now we have the curiously incongruous spectacle of the Communist organisations wanting to come into our midst and be part of the movement they have so derided.

“The Communist party in Great Britain, as in every other country in Europe, is the mouthpiece of the Soviet Government. Everything that the Soviet Government decides will be repeated, parrot-like, by the Communists.

" . . . And when they speak here they are expressing the Russian Government’s point of view.”
Membership
The Council’s report showed an increase in trade union membership by approximately 300,000, but London, while it has 2,500,000 industrial workers, has only 350,000 trade unionists.

One last thing about the Congress. No Socialist voice was heard to penetrate the confused ideas and oratory, shedding light with the Socialist explanation of events. 
Harry Waite

Friday, October 2, 2026

Notes of the Month: Labour Party Problems (1935)

The Notes of the Month column from the October 1935 issue of the Socialist Standard

Labour Party Problems
 
Whilst the Labour Party has officially declared for sanctions against Italy should the latter carry out its threat of attacking Abyssinia, this attitude has met with disapproval from many of its own members, including several prominent officials. Mr. Lansbury has threatened to resign his position as Leader because the application of sanctions may involve the use of armed force. He is now opposed to all wars, because "they are against the teachings of Christianity.” He has now evolved a plan which will, in his opinion, put an end to all possibilities of wars in the future. This is nothing less than the “sharing of all the raw materials, markets and unoccupied territory of the world.” He wants the League of Nations to appoint a commission of economic and scientific experts to draw up a scheme for carrying out these proposals.” They could quite easily tell us how to meet the insistent demands of Italy, Germany and other nations for expansion, and how to pool natural resources, develop the markets, and satisfy the demands of the millions of people starving and sick in Asia, Africa and Europe.” (Daily Herald, September 16th, 1935. Italics ours.)

That Mr. Lansbury can hope that the present owners of territory, mineral resources, etc., will relinquish or share their property unless forced to do so is sheer madness. That he expects such a scheme, even if carried out to “satisfy the demands of the sick and starving millions,” is equally illusory. The “sick and starving millions” are the propertyless workers and peasants, and they are as much a feature of the countries already in possession of raw materials, territory and markets such as Britain, France and the U.S.A. as they are of Germany, Italy Abyssinia, or any other country. The world now belongs to the capitalists and not to the workers, and if it is parcelled out in different proportions or pooled among the present owners, how can that benefit the proletariat?

* * *
 
“Pious ” Enemy No. 2.

The Archbishop of Canterbury is also a Christian. Nevertheless, he can foresee circumstances in which a war may become “Christian." In his broadcast on September 1st he made it clear that, in his opinion, a war fought with the blessing of the League of Nations had also the blessing of the Church. We would add that history does not tell us of many wars in which the Church has withheld its “blessing.”

* * *

Where Does he Stand?

Sir Stafford Cripps is the Chairman of the Socialist League, an organisation affiliated to the Labour Party. He is opposed to Labour’s policy of sanctions, and does not agree with its support of the League of Nations. In an article in the Sunday Referee (September 15th, 1935), entitled ”Where I Stand,” he says: “While capitalism controls our national, and imperialism our international life, the actions of our Government will be determined by capitalist and imperialist interests.” Correct, Sir Stafford, but how do you square that statement with your membership of the Labour Party, which plainly holds the opposite point of view?

* * *

United Front at Last

The Communists seem to have achieved their hearts' desire, that much-sought-after "United Front." And it is of a magnitude that must exceed their most sanguine hopes. For on the Italian-Abyssinian dispute they are solidly behind the National Government (or should we say in front of them?). "The League's Covenant must be upheld by all means at our disposal," declared Sir Samuel Hoare, British Foreign Minister, in a speech at Geneva. And he has the solid support of the bulk of the Labour Party, the whole of the Liberal Party, and most certainly the Communist Party, who have issued impressive-looking proclamations, urging the public to support the League. As their sponsors at Moscow are now members of the League this is not surprising. But their attempts to explain their "policy" are ludicrous. Lenin's condemnation of the League as a “Thieves' Kitchen" still holds good with us, though the disciples of Lenin grace its functions. And what has become of their erstwhile boast, to "turn every imperialist war into a civil war " ?

* * *

Where we Stand

"The people who do not own a country and its resources have nothing to fight for excepting Socialism "! That is our policy. The workers of Abyssinia, many of whom are still chattel-slaves, should not be inveigled into fighting for the property of Abyssinian princes. The workers of Italy have nothing to gain by fighting to secure more territory and raw materials for their masters. And the business of the workers the world over is not to take sides with either of the two Governments, or any other Government or League of Governments. Their business is to take the world out of the hands of the present owners and make it the possession of all. That is not the attitude of any other political party in this country.

* * *

Another Mining Disaster

Seventeen miners died as a result of an explosion in a coal mine near Barnsley (Yorks.) on September 12th. There have now been three big mining disasters this year, all claiming a heavy toll of life. These tragedies emphasise the conditions of workers who, for a pittance of less than £2 per week, have to risk their lives. And we often have to answer questions like: "Do not the capitalists have to risk their money in order to make a profit?" The miners are now preparing to struggle for an increase in their wages. Whilst we commend such struggles, we must at the same time point out that such a struggle, even if successful, will only mean a few more shillings a week. And we ask you miners: "How can you be satisfied with that when, by organising into the S.P.G.B., you can help obtain the Means of Life, including the mines, for society as a whole." Then the risk to human life would be lessened and, in return for less arduous and unpleasant work, all the comforts of life would be yours.

* * *

A “ Corrective ” for Capitalism

"Capitalism is your servant and must never be your master—but it must be treated fairly. When it goes wrong, as it has gone wrong, it must be corrected." (Mr. Bennett, Canadian Premier, Daily Herald, September 13th, 1935.) We propose that the working class makes itself "master" of the political machine, and then administer one stroke—the appropriation of the land, factories, means of transport, etc., in the name of society.

* * *

“Men of Action ” at Work

The German "Men of Action," Hitler and Co., assembled at Nuremberg, where the German Reichstag was called to deal with problems alleged to be of vital importance to the German workers. General Goering presented the first Bill, which provides that the Swastika flag shall become the State flag of Germany. Thus a tremendous victory was won for the German working population! Further evidence of the Nazi Government's concern for the conditions of the German workers was shown by the following new laws (Daily Herald, September 16th): —
For the protection of the German blood and honour, this law forbids the marriage between Jews and Germans or related lines.

Jews cannot hire German maid's in their household under the age of 45.
The joy of German working people should be boundless. How different from Socialists, who are merely concerned with the solution of the problem of poverty!

* * *

Without Trimmings

The agenda of the Labour Party Conference, held at Brighton this month, contains several interesting items. A resolution submitted by the Southport Trades Council and Labour Party reads as follows: "That the next General Election be fought without trimmings, on the policy outlined at the Southport Conference, under the title of ‘For Socialism and Peace,' special stress being laid upon:—
  1. The immediate nationalisation of the land and all minerals.
  2. The immediate establishment of a 40-hour week, with no reduction in economic circumstances.
  3. The immediate raising of the school-leaving age to 15 years, with full maintenance during the last year at school.
  4. General retirement from industry at the age of 60, with pension, such pension to be raised to £1 per week for a single person and £2 per week for married couples.
“ It is urged that this general and specific policy be a ‘Stand or Fall' programme, and declares that it is the lowest minimum of policy as Socialists this Conference is prepared to tolerate.”

So now you can “stand or fall” for “Socialism and Peace” with or without “trimmings”—and get “trimmed". 

A further resolution submitted by the Warrington T.C. and L.P. reads as follows: —

“That this Conference, believing that there is a limit to the possibility of Social Reform legislation within the capitalist system, and realising definitely that the Labour Movement of this country has declared for a Socialist policy, agrees that the Movement should centre the whole of its propaganda and educational activities on making Socialism and Socialist Policy its only objective” 

”The Conference further declares that the concentration of the Party on the support of the policy of doles and palliatives has become inimical to its Socialist objective, and that the next Labour Government should set out immediately to adopt such Socialist measures as will render such doles and palliatives unnecessary.”

Everything depends upon what the people at Warrington mean by “Socialism” and "Socialist measures.” But if they mean to change the Labour Party from a reformist organisation to a Socialist one their task is hopeless. The bulk of the Labour Party membership is not Socialist, and the job of converting them cannot be done from within. And why trouble to change the Labour Party if there is already a party in existence whose only objective is Socialism, namely, the S.P.G.B.

Labour Party headquarters have shown what they think of the above resolutions by putting it at the tail-end of the agenda, under the heading of “Miscellaneous.”

* * *

S.P.G.B. and the B.B.C.

Last year we approached the B.B.C. with a view to obtaining permission to put our case over the radio. We received a polite letter, informing us that arrangements had already been made for a representative of “Left-Wing Socialism” to broadcast. As we are not “Left-Wing,” but Socialists, as, in fact, we belong to “no wing” of the Reformist Movement we repudiated the right of anyone to speak on our behalf, unless appointed by ourselves. Now we have again approached the B.B.C. and hope that these gentlemen will grant us the privilege that has not been denied to the other political organisations. If and when we get our turn we hope to be able to make it quite clear to the listeners that as the S.P.G.B. is the only party in this country that does not recruit support on questions of day-to-day legislation under capitalism but gets its backing solely on the issue of Socialism versus Capitalism, we have nothing in common with those who, calling themselves “Socialists,” are, in fact, nothing of the kind. Scientific, revolutionary Socialism in Great Britain is represented by the S.P.G.B.
Sid Rubin