Wednesday, October 7, 2026

“Profit-sharing plans that increase efficiency”. (1911)

From the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

The above title appears over an article in the July issue of “System and Modern Business,” a journal published expressly to review and suggest ways and means of running business concerns at a minimum of cost, and, consequently, at a maximum of profit.

The article in question deals with the various co-partnership and bonus systems which have been very successful from the employers’ point of view, taking first the system inaugurated by the late Sir George Livesey at the South Metropolitan Gas Works.

The basis of the South Metropolitan Gas Co.’s system is an agreement with each workman entitling him to a share in the business, and at the same time, security of occupation for a certain period.

When the co-partnership scheme first came into use every man in regular employment was permitted to sign an agreement on the assumption that he was a good man ; but afterwards discretion was used.

The usual period is 12 months, but if a man shows little regard for his work, or is wasteful and neglectful of the Company’s interest, he may find that his agreement is not renewed at the end of the period, or, in some cases, it may be renewed for three, or even six months, to give him an opportunity to improve. If he does not improve he gets no agreement, and his ultimate fate is discharge.

The bonus is paid half in the ordinary shares of the Company and half in cash. The latter is payable at any time at a weeks’ notice, or may be left with the Company at, 3 or 4 percent. interest.

There is, however, a regulation which, to some extent, protects the men from themselves, in that it impresses upon the employees the fact that, while one half is withdrawable, the success of the scheme depends on them saving some part of it ; and in consequence, any employee who regularly draws all his cash moiety will in time find that his agreement is not renewed.

While the cost of carbonising labour to the South Metropolitan Gas Co. was less than the mean of the two other metropolitan companies in 1888, the formation of the Gas Workers Union in the following year caused it to increase until it passed the mean, where it stayed for two years.

In the second year, however, the first co-partnership or “profit sharing” bonus was distributed, and costs fell sufficiently to reduce the excess above mean by two thirds. The following year it dropped well below the mean again, and from that time gradually grew less, until it nearly halved the high cost of labour during the dispute.

In eight years £820,000 was paid for carbonising labour-power, which was £260,000 (or nearly 25 per cent.) less than it cost the two other companies chosen for comparison to make the same quantity of gas.

All this, of course, was not the direct result of co-partnership; but, directly or indirectly, the changed labour conditions had by far the most to do with it.

This very interesting information, coming whence it does, ought to show the working class that the employers, when floating bonus schemes, are not influenced in the least by any philanthropic notions. They are on a good thing and they know it. They sugar coat the pill for the workers to swallow, but the end in view, despite the sweet verbiage under which it is hidden, is always the same, i.e., to increase production and reduce the cost of it.

The co-partnership scheme of Lever Bros., of Port Sunlight, is also reviewed. Mr. W. H. Lever, M.P., who may well claim to be one of the pioneers of “profit-sharing,” holds strong views on this subject.

He held that while in many industries wages remained stationary, capital increased output and raised the value of the product, building up colossal fortunes without in any way giving extra remuneration to labour, through which the success of many of the great enterprises was due—to the volume of labour employed without which the money-earning capacity of machinery would have been nil. Profit-sharing was, he thought, the best way of drawing out intelligent labour.

On the initiation of the scheme Mr. Lever invited his new co-partners, who would receive the same rate of wages as before, and work the regular hours, to join hands with him in making the profits of the business sure and increasing. He held up as a motto “Waste not want not,” recommending them to work for the business, aiming at increasing the quantity and quality of the product. When working with machine and tool they should remember that they were handling, economically or otherwise, their own property ! The inefficient worker would cause his fellow co-partners to suffer, as well as his employers.

The foregoing are the salient points of the two schemes mentioned. The workers will find on examination that the underlying motives of co-partnership are always to increase his output, to weed him out like cattle breeders weed out their stock, and to make him more than ever a slave by giving him an infinitesimal holding in the shares of the firm which exploits him—shares which, by the way, he cannot sell, and which he forfeits if he leaves voluntarily.

So you see, fellow workers, that it is not to give that “extra remuneration to labour through which the success of many of the great enterprises was due,” but to make the worker work harder, and to make each man a spy upon his fellow “co-pards,” so that “discrimination may be used” and the inefficient may be weeded out. |

Another great boon is held out to the employee “shareholders” — voting power and eligibility for election as “employee director,” with a seat on the board. It would, indeed, be a picture for a post-card to see the “employee director” at a board meeting demanding a bigger dividend for the “co-paids” who do the work. It would look comical if it happened so, but it doesn’t. The “employee director” learns better manners and behaves himself like a good boy.

Let it be clearly understood that co-partnership precludes all possibility of a strike, for, say the employer partners to the employee “partners,” “You are members of the firm and you cannot strike against yourselves. You must work harder and waste less, and then we can increase your bonus 3d. a week, which bonus you can leave with us at 3 or 4 percent, interest. So, in the course of time, you will get enough to build a house.”

The Socialist does not regard the intelligent and economical application of brain and muscle as something to be condemned in itself, but he points out that so long as the means of life are owned and controlled by the capitalist class, the application of greater effort is of no avail in the bettering of the material position of the working class as a whole, notwithstanding all the honied words of the apostles of co-partnership and bonus systems.
A. J. G.

A Socialist Survey. (1911)

From the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

Mr. F. Townsend Martin, a wealthy member of American society, and a brother of Mr. Bradley Martin, the multi-millionaire, has written a book entitled : “The Passing of the Idle Rich,” in which he says : “I know society, I was born in it and have lived in it all my life both here and in the capitals of Europe.” Further on he tells us that:
“Somewhere there is something wrong. I speak as a rich man. I speak as a representative of the class of which I write and to which, in particular I address myself. We can no longer blind ourselves with idle phrases or drug our consciences with the outworn boast that the working man of America is to-day the highest-paid artizan in the world. We know those lying figures well. Many a time I myself in personal argument, have shown that the American workman receives from one and a half to three times as much as his English cousin at the same trade ; but we know now that it means nothing. . . .

We are learning, too, that what we give our workers is wages we take back from them in the higher cost of necessities, in food, in clothing, in medicine, in insurance—in a hundred devious ways, all with one tendency—to keep the living margin down.”
“O most learned judge,” there is something wrong, and the only curious factor in the above is its source. The determined stand made, for a time, by the workers of different parts of the world, has forced upon the notice of others besides our worthy American, the fact that while the great mass of the working class are prepared to suffer in silence, there is yet a little spirit remaining which may burst into a blaze at some inconvenient moment, to the detriment of that superstructure of society which gives to the “idle rich” so good a living for so little exertion.

                                                                            * * *

Dr. Gore, late Bishop of Birmingham, in a letter to the “clergy and laity” of that city, informs us that “the profound sense of unrest and dissatisfaction among the workers” is genuine.

“We are not justified,” he says, “in tolerating the conditions of life and labour under which the vast mass of our population is living. We have no right to say that these conditions are not remediable. Preventible lack of equipment among the young, and later the insecurity of employment and inadequacy of remuneration, and consequent destitution and semi-starvation among so many of our people, ought to inspire in all Christians a profound and passionate determination to devote themselves to the reform of our industrial system.”

That eminently respectable organ, the “Pall Mall Gazette,” tells us that
“Unrest among large bodies of men is not scientifically explained by ascribing it all to the depravity or agitators, and in the case of the railwaymen, as we have repeatedly affirmed, there are deeper causes in the general economic condition of the country which it is futile to ignore. British working men would not surrender themselves to the irrational and discreditable impulses which have had such free play during the last few weeks, unless there were forces at work to throw them off their balance, and those forces can easily be discerned in the rise of prices and the consequent fall in ‘real’ wages.”
and if the testimony of the “democratic” “Star” can add weight to that of so respectable a witness, it tells us (20.9.11) that we have certain facts to face.
“Just as France and Germany, Austria and Spain have got to face them. All over Europe the people are in revolt against the lowness of wages and the dearness of food. It is foolish to imagine that unrest which is caused by permanent and deep-seated economic causes can be allayed by harsh words and stern discipline.

“The Labor problem is a problem of flesh and blood. It is producing riots in France, in Austria, and in Spain. Everywhere the people are in rebellion against the conditions of their existence.”
The “Morning Leader” (same date) says :
“That labor is grossly ill-organised and under-paid ; that the conditions under which great masses of laborers live are a disgrace to our civilisation ; that industrialism, which has opened to the wealthier classes endless sources of pleasure and luxury never dreamt of by their grandfathers, has robbed the worker’s life for the most part even of the little patches of color and brightness it had in slower, easier days, and even where he gets more money has made him pay for it dearly in the drab monotony of his toil—all these things are very well known. No one questions them.”
* * *

The cause of the unrest so candidly admitted is that the wage of the worker does not rise in correspondence to the increased price of necessaries, and the increased cost of production of the worker, who, toiling under high pressure and producing more and more rapidly, requires a greater amount of food, both physical and mental, to maintain him in the requisite condition for the modern wage slave.

To again quote Mr, Martin :
“I cannot go down through the crowded tenement settlement sections of our great cities without having it borne in upon me that we, as a nation, pay a fearful price in human blood and tears for our industrial triumphs. For the grim fact stands out beyond denial that the men who are the workers of the nation, and the women and the children dependent upon them, are not to day given the opportunities that are their proper birthright in free America ; and that, struggle as they will, save as they may, lift their voices in protest as they dare, they cannot obtain from our industrial hierarchy much more than a living wage.”

* * *
When will the workers recognise that they are but merchandise ? When will they see those stubborn facts with which they are faced ? They can but get a bare sufficiency to enable them to produce wealth for the “idle rich,” who, with all their “good intentions,” are impelled by necessity, in order to maintain their supremacy, to keep down wages and to prevent the toiling masses from raising their standard of comfort. In every branch of industry the same effect is being felt: the necessity on the part of the workers to strike and of the masters to resist their demands. That nationalisation is a cure is easily refuted. Mr. Cheesman, Secretary of the Fawcett Association, seen by a representative of the “Daily News,” said :
“The discontent is very general, and arises primarily from the refusal of the Postmaster General to reopen the question of the improvement of the conditions in regard to wages, especially in view of the increased cost of living and the great length of lime that has elapsed since the wages were last adjusted. The National Committee is forced to take action owing to the general discontent, and not from any desire on their part to take advantage of the present unrest in the labour world.”
These men are working in an industry that has been nationalised, and to add force to the argument that conditions there are at least as bad as in any private concern, Mr. Cheesmsn adds :
“The seriousness of the situation i.e. emphasised by the speeding-up that has taken place during recent years in the various departments. Indeed, the conditions in many cases have become almost unbearable, and the great plague of the postal service, consumption, is being replaced by an even greater evil, nervous breakdown.”
So the postman’s reward—bunions and consumption—is increased by the sporting chance of a padded cell as a rest cure.

The “Daily News” (5.9.11) contains “An Interview with a typical Barman,” who, after describing his daily “life” (which is, according to the scribe, a “dismal, soul-destroying round of duty”) says:
“We want to establish a sixty-hour week and one compulsory day’s holiday in seven. We also demand an increase in the rate of pay, since we receive at present about 1½d. per hour for labour.”

* * *
I can fittingly conclude with the final statement of Mr. Martin in the book above mentioned :
“It cannot be for long. The days of the idle rich in America are as a tale that is told. Idleness is doomed as a vocation. We in America are fast moving toward social revolution. Conflicts between labour and capital are assuming the proportions of civil war. The once powerful middle class, which is the safety of every nation, is to day weak, and is every day declining. Soon, politically it will be a memory, and the battle-field will be cleared for conflict. . . . Instead of being the roof and crown of things, the wealthy class in America to-day has sunk to the level of the parasite. The time has come when the producing classes are about to bring it to judgment.”
Let the workers of Great Britain determine that when that day comes they will not be far behind their American cousins.
Twel.

Law and Property. (1911)

From the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

It is often thought that the existence of the “law” is a providential thing, and that its maintenance (usually expressed in the term “preservation of law and order”) is an aim worthy of the greatest effort of every citizen.

But history proves that the law is closely linked with property, that is that the first exists for the protection of the latter.

Now does the working class possess property? If so, then to that extent the law protects the interests of the working class, even though that law is framed and exercised by the capitalist class. But such is not the case, for the proletariat is propertyless, and possesses but one commodity, viz., labour power.

But what about his clothes, his furniture, etc., do not these constitute the worker’s property ? The answer is, no. For by what are these necessities procured ?

They are procured with the wages of the worker, and if we read Karl Marx carefully, what do we find on this particular point ?

This—that wages (in the hands of the capitalist) are a part of capital, and that the capitalist ultimately receives again that particular portion known as wages.

By attending to his physical needs the labourer reproduces labour-power, which labour-power is given back to the capitalist for the accumulation of more capital—the production of surplus-value.

Therefore it is obvious that the working class have no property, and to speak of the “preservation of law and order” is synonymous with the phrase “perpetuation of capitalism.”

The law is the safeguard of the class in power; its function is the suppression of the voice and claims of the subordinate class and the monopoly of the means of life by the ruling class. The Socialist recognises that the economic basis of any society determines the nature and functions of the institutions built upon that basis. Law is a capitalist institution, and therefore works for the benefit of the capitalist class.
J. H. Lamb

Answers to Correspondents: The ‘Middle Class’. (1911)

Letters to the Editors from the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

G. P. S. Bonner (Philadelphia).—Cutting received, but do not think same would interest our readers.

T. Downey (Plumstead).—Your score or so of questions received. Some of them are answered by others. We have dealt with many in this journal before, but you will find most of them answered in the articles on Anarchism now appearing in these pages. The words “middle class” should always be in quotes.

Second Edition of “Socialism and Religion”. (1911)

Party News from the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Second Edition of “Socialism and Religion” contains a useful preface. All opponents of Socialism should read the brochure ; all workers for Socialism should have a supply at all times on hand. It is a splendid little worker for the cause, and does its business effectually, though silently.

Now Ready, A New Pamphlet. (1911)

Party News from the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard




Blogger's Note:
The text of this pamphlet is available at the following link.

S.P.G.B. Lecture List For October 1911. Johnny Holmes

Unlike the posts for A. Barker and Frederick S. Leigh, this October 1911 Socialist Standard adjacent post is not connected to Keith Scholey's founding members document.

Johnny Holmes was not a founding member of the SPGB. He first joined the SPGB via its short lived Earlsfield Branch in August 1909. A regular outdoor speaker for the Party in the period of 1910-1911, he primarily spoke at outdoor meetings in South and West London (Battersea, Tooting, Paddington and Peckham). There is no record of when he lapsed his membership, but we do know that he rejoined the Tooting Branch of the SPGB in April 1921. Sadly, there's no record of when he left the Party for the second time. 

'John Henry Holmes' is briefly mentioned in a couple of books I have encountered on my political reading travels. His son, Len Holmes, speaks of his father in the Hugh Jenkins' 1980 book, 'Rank and File'. Jenkins was the Labour MP for Putney from 1964 until 1979 (defeated by David Mellor at the 1979 General Election) and was firmly on the left-wing of the Labour Party. 

'Rank and File' was a collection of interviews with Labour Party members in his Putney Constituency Labour Party, and the purpose of the book was to give a human face to that much maligned figure in the 1970s and 1980s: the left-wing Labour Party activist. During this period of political history, the tabloid press had the scent of blood in its nostrils at the notion that student radicals and 'bedsit revolutionaries' were infiltrating the Labour Party up and down the country in order to deselect such sedate centrist characters as Reg Prentice and Bob Mellish. There's no denying that Trotskyists were sending their members into the Labour Party during this time - the Militant Tendency being the best known example - but Jenkins - and most of the people interviewed in his book - represented a longstanding Labour Left tradition rooted in left-wing reformism and such single issues as nuclear disarmament and anti-apartheid.

Len Holmes was one such left-wing local activist, and he said the following about his father:
". . . I was born in Wandsworth and my father, Johnny Holmes, was a well-known leader of the unemployed workers’ movement between the wars. He was a great character but no one would employ him and so with seven children and my mother dying of cancer we had hard times. My wife was born not far away in Wimbledon.

. . .  You mentioned your father?

"Yes, Johnny Holmes was well known as a pacifist in Wandsworth between the wars. During the First World War he drank a lot of water before medical examinations and was always rejected because this increased the pulse rate. He was a street-corner orator and he fought a parliamentary election in Wandsworth as an independent although he eventually joined the Labour Party. He was a friend of Saklatvala who held Battersea briefly for the Communist Party and at one time was a member of the Socialist Party of Great Britain. He was put in Wandsworth Prison for six weeks after leading a demonstration against Wandsworth workhouse. He marched into the institution and demanded that the inmates be fed proper food instead of pigswill. Once he lead a 50,000 strong demonstration of the unemployed to the Cenotaph. He was stopped by the police because he had a banner which read: For those who are dead and not forgotten and for those who are here and are forgotten. My father brushed the police aside saying that they would fight their way there if necessary and he successfully led the demonstration to Whitehall. However the demonstration was broken up there by mounted police and my
father was kicked in the head. He was injured quite badly but eventually recovered and was soon attacking the Royal Family from a soapbox on the corner of Magdalen Road. My father wanted clean sheets and bed linen for the workhouse inmates and porridge and bacon and eggs for breakfast. When he was taken to Wandsworth Prison there were demonstrations outside every night with singing of the Red Flag until the authorities removed him to Brixton. When he came out there were several thousand unemployed to meet him and they marched all the way to our house in Wandsworth.

Quite apart from the fact that there was no money for it, my father did not believe in paying rent to private landlords and was always being taken to court for non-payment. He accumulated £500 in arrears and never paid it. He argued his own case and the landlord said he wished my father was on his side. He was a very clever man. He studied what the magistrate had said on other occasions and quoted him. Once he was offered a job on condition that he changed his politics but he would have nothing to do with capitalism. He was an ardent socialist and knew all the leaders of those days, Lansbury, Greenwood and Bevin but he became a bit disillusioned with the Labour Party. They were not nearly socialist enough for him." (pages 54-56.)
I can't find any record of his father standing as an independent candidate in Wandsworth at a parliamentary election, and I have to wonder how plausible it could have been that a long term unemployed man could have raised the money for an election deposit in the interwar years. It would have been a substantial sum of money. Maybe Len Holmes misremembered. It happens.

The second mention of Johnny Holmes is in Harry Wicks' posthumous memoir 'Keeping My Head: The Memoirs of a British Bolshevik'. Published in 1992 by the independent Trotskyist publisher Socialist Platform, 'Keeping My Head' is a very readable account of Wicks political journey from his teenage political awakening in Battersea in South London just after the end of World War One to the YCL sending him to the Lenin School in Moscow in the 1920s to his central involvement in the earliest days of the British Trotskyist movement.

As a Battersea boy, Wicks encountered members and ex-members of the SPGB. One of those was Johnny Holmes. As he recalls:
Unemployed agitation in the years of 1918 and 1919 emphasised the indignation felt by the ex-servicemen at the conditions they met on their homecoming. The long dole queues and the paltry demobilisation payments never matched the politicians’ promises. The old comrades’ association was most vociferous in its demands for mass protest. When the short-lived postwar boom ended inSeptember 1920 the unemployed agitation discarded its ‘No charity, give us justice’ image, and took on amore aggressive tone. From all over the country, local unemployed committees and associations met in conference and launched the National Unemployed Workers Movement with the demand for ‘Work or Full Maintenance’.From the first, Battersea’s NUWM became widely known, a constituent part of the local labour movement. Hunger marches from all parts of the country found shelter and sustenance ready for them at Latchmere Baths. A Battersea contingent were always marching in the London demonstrations, which in those days all too frequently ended with a police baton charge. 
A host of speakers and agitators sustained the ceaseless campaign at the local guardians for outdoor relief. The memory of one or two is vivid to this day. Johnny Holmes was one such agitator. A short, rather tubby man with a sunshine face, he was on and off unemployed platforms for a decade. His early training as a speaker had been in the SPGB. In his pocket, he always carried a scrapbook of newspaper cuttings which functioned as his speaker’s notes. Many still remember the meetings he addressed during the 1921 miners’ lockout. Johnny talked on the income of the Duke of Northumberland, a big coal owner. Thirty bob a minute was his income, as much as a miner received for three days’ work at the coalface. He had an infectious smile, as though he was laughing at his own speech:

‘Imagine, 30 shillings each minute of the day. Whatever the Duke was doing, going to bed, eating his bread and cheese or sitting in his bathroom having a sh-sh-sh-shave.’

Each itemisation of the crowded minutes in the Duke’s life brought fresh convulsions of laughter from the crowd.

. . . Another outstanding unemployment speaker in the 1920s was Tom Waller, affectionately known as Workhouse Waller. He too had got his Socialist education from the SPGB. Like his voice, his speeches were strong and rasping. Wage slavery and capitalism were his enemy, a Socialist society his objective. When the local board of guardians said that there was to be no more poor law relief without task work — which meant the workhouse — he was ready with the answer: ‘We enter the workhouse all together.’ (pages 20-21)
Wicks' book also provides a brief biographical note of Holmes in the appendix to the book:
Holmes, Johnny. Ex-SPGB, Secretary of Wandsworth Unemployed Committee and member of Communist Party. Very active in 1921 and 22. See Michael Ward The Unemployed in South West London 1918-23 (draft manuscript), and Red Flag over the Workhouse, Labour and Social History Group, 1980. (page 199)

S.P.G.B. Lecture List For October, 1911. Frederick S. Leigh

Following on from the standalone post for A. Barker, a similar style post for Fred Leigh, another founder member of the SPGB. Again, the details below are from Keith Scholey's unpublished document 'The Founding Members of the Socialist Party of Great Britain'.

Leigh, Frederick S
         Paddington branch. Leigh was an Executive Committee member 1904-6 and spoke for the Party 1904-12. He seems to have had some theatrical aspirations (as would be implied by the somewhat eccentric garb he wore to the 1905 Conference), writing a small play “Wasted Lives” about the 1905 Russian Revolution, which was performed for the Battersea branch on 9 December 1906 (Socialist Standard January 1907). He was lapsed from membership on 28th January 1914.

S.P.G.B. Lecture List For October, 1911. A. Barker

In recent months, when I have posted details of the Pre-World War One monthly lecture list on the blog, I have tried where I can to give some extra information on the listed speakers. That only seems fair when covering a period in the SPGB's history when it was so active and visible in working class politics in London. For example, just looking at the lecture list for the October 1911 issue of the Standard, you have advertised over a hundred meetings in London alone listed with 20 plus speakers.

Sometimes, the added information on the listed speakers is only the basics gleaned from the early SPGB membership records: a speaker's full name; their branch; when they joined the SPGB; if and when (and why) they left the SPGB. Sometimes I'm more fortunate in that there might be a wiki page for a speaker (see R. M. Fox, Frank Dawkins and Tommy Jackson, for example). On other occasions - if a speaker has 'lasted the course' - it might be an obituary in the pages of the Socialist Standard (see J. E. Roe, Alex Anderson and Jack Fitzgerald, for example). Whatever the case - and wherever I can - I try to flesh out the bones of the early history of the SPGB and the Socialist Standard. It's important that that information is readily available for anyone interested in the history of our tradition.

In keeping with that 'mission', posted below is a potted political history of the Socialist Party member, A. Barker, who was a listed speaker in the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard. The words below are not mine. It's from an unpublished document entitled 'The Founding Members of the Socialist Party of Great Britain', which was written by Keith Scholey a number of years ago. Keith was an excellent archivist and historian of the Party - he is no longer a member - and this document was an attempt to provide as much background as possible on the founding members of the SPGB. If I can get his permission, I may post the full document on the blog.

Barker, A
Tooting branch. Barker was very active for the Party before the First World War, being a public speaker in 1909-14 and serving on the 1906-7 and 1908-9 Executive Committees. At a local level he served as Tooting branch secretary in 1905-6 and was a local election candidate for Tooting Ward, Wandsworth in 1906 and again in 1909. He had previously been a local election candidate for the SDF in 1903. Barker probably left the Party during the First World War, rejoining on 16th June 1927. He was again most active, for example being nominated as the prospective Parliamentary candidate for North Battersea in the 1929 election (in the event however the deposit could not be raised to contest the seat). Barker finally lapsed on 25th June 1943.

S.P.G.B. Lecture List For October. (1911)

Party News from the October 1911 issue of the Socialist Standard




Blogger's Note:
Once again, I don't have enough room in the label section to include all the listed speakers, so some brief information on some of the speakers missing from the sidebar.
  • A. Bays is possibly the member listed as W. Bays' in the early Party membership records, who was a member of the Stoke Newington Branch of the SPGB. He joined the SPGB in May 1910. No date is given for when - or why - he left.
  • H. Cooper was H.J. Cooper. He joined Earlsfield Branch of the SPGB in September 1908, and his membership was lapsed in December 1915.
  • F. Dawkins was a member of the Romford Branch of the SPGB, joining in August 1905. His wiki page goes into extensive detail on his background and on his political journey from Methodism (and the ILP) to Marxism (and the SPGB). Later in life he was a parliamentary candidate for the Labour Party in the Hampstead constituency at the 1929 General Election.
  • R. Fox was R. M. Fox. He joined the SPGB in Tottenham in September 1906. Better known after he left the SPGB, his 1937 autobiography, Smoky Crusade, sticks the boot into his old SPGB comrades. I should post the offending excerpts from his book on the blog some time.
  • J. Halls was John H. Halls, who joined Paddington Branch of the SPGB in June 1907 (a Mrs Eleanor B. Halls joined Paddington Branch in July 1907). A regular writer and translator for the Socialist Standard in the Edwardian period, he eventually resigned his membership when he moved abroad (Paris).
  • A. Hoskyns was Ambrose Hoskyns. He joined the Islington Branch of the SPGB in August 1910. He was an occasional writer for the Socialist Standard in the Pre-War 1914 period. There are no details of when he left the SPGB. A flavour of his writing (and the early history of the SPGB) is contained within his April 1911 article, 'The Attempted Suppression of Free Speech in Islington'.
  • A. Jacobs was Alf Jacobs. There is more detailed background on him in this feature which appeared in the September 1954 issue of the Socialist Standard.
  • H. Joy was a member of the Tooting Branch of the SPGB. They joined the SPGB in October 1907.
  • C. Parker was a member of West Ham Branch. Joined the SPGB in May 1906, and was lapsed from membership in October 1929.
  • F. J. Rourke was a member of the Tottenham Branch, originally joining the SPGB in June 1909. Their membership was lapsed in February 1914. ("Moved away".)
  • F. W. Stearn was a member of the Tottenham Branch. There were actually two 'F. Stearn's in the branch at the time - possibly father and son - so I don't know which one was a listed speaker for this month.

The Crisis: Wilson's lame explanation (1975)

From the October 1975 issue of the Socialist Standard

On August 20th Harold Wilson made his long-awaited broadcast to the nation informing us of what his government proposed to do about the economic difficulties in which “our country” finds itself. It was an emotional appeal for us all to accept sacrifices, accompanied by the threat of what would happen if we did not. To be more specific, wage workers were told that they could no longer “get for themselves such a pay increase as to enable them to escape the rigours of inflation” and that “the limit on pay settlements is £6 a week”.

The whole harangue was preceded by what purported to be an explanation of the causes of our economic difficulties — an explanation which appeared to exonerate the government from all blame. No doubt, at the speed of the spoken word, the reasons given sounded plausible enough to most of those who listened.

Let us however examine more closely these “causes” which Wilson claimed to be known to us all. He gave three. First:
The whole industrial world faces the most virulent trade and employment depression since the thirties.
This is like saying that you are going to be out of work because there are not enough jobs to go round — and explains exactly nothing. It has, however, the built-in suggestion that trade depressions and unemployment are like cosmic disturbances, for which politicians cannot be held responsible. In fact later in his speech Wilson likened the situation to “the fact that the world has been knocked off its axis by a universal recession”. The second reason given was:
Industry’s failure over the past 20 years to invest in industry, new plant, machinery, factory buildings, industrial modernisation . . .
Presumably Wilson was referring to British industry : yet in West Germany where, due to war-time destruction of factories and plant, large investment and modernization were essential, there is more unemployment than in Britain. As a reason for our present difficulties this second cause seems suspect, to say the least — apart from the fact that every worker knows that more efficient production is aimed at reducing the labour force. And so we come to the third reason:
. . . the effect of inflation on industry’s ability to provide jobs for those established in industry, jobs for school-leavers . . . this year it has been almost entirely internal prices and costs, including pay, which have aggravated inflation . . .
Here the workers are intended to feel partly to blame for having “aggravated” inflation. But you cannot aggravate something which is not already there. So what causes inflation? We are not told.

So much for explanations which explain nothing. It is distressing that, as far as we can tell, such arguments can be accepted by the majority of the electorate. It is, however, understandable. Politicians have never informed the public of the true nature of the economic system which they try to administer. We do not learn about it at school or from the “mass media”. But at least we can take a hard look at what politicians such as Wilson tell us and see the worthlessness of their so-called explanations. It is then up to the workers to find their own explanations from an understanding of the nature of the capitalist economic system of production.

Let us then go back to Wilson’s three "causes”. Why in fact is there a trade depression in the “whole industrial world”? What is immediately apparent is that these countries have produced more commodities than they can sell at a profit. This is what “trade depression” means. But why should this be so? Capitalists, whether they control private companies or nationalized industries, employ the physical and mental abilities of wage-workers to produce commodities (or processed materials). The primary aim is to sell such commodities at a profit. This profit represents the difference between the value of the work provided by wage-workers and the wages they are paid. Employers know this only too well. The effort to restrain wage increases, the introduction of better machinery, the stream-lining of production methods, are all intended to reduce the “wage bill” and increase the margin of profit.

It follows therefore that the working class as a whole are not paid enough to buy back the goods they have produced. The “export drives” typical of all industrialized countries are evidence of this need to sell abroad the surplus which workers in the country of origin cannot afford to purchase. Likewise, in spite of what Wilson says, the bulk of profits are reinvested in industry — to produce more and more commodities in the hope that by price undercutting such goods can be sold abroad. But, like taking in each other’s washing, it is a futile endeavour when all countries are trying to do the same thing. The surplus car production at the present time is perhaps the most evident example of this. America, Europe and Japan are all fighting to sell their cars to each other — to the extent of “dumping” cars abroad at less than their internal prices.

It is true that, in part, export of commodities is required to provide the money to purchase food and raw materials not sufficiently available in the exporting country. But, globally, there is an excess of commodities, including food, over and above the purchasing power of the working class. This is what shows a world-wide trade depression to have other causes than interference from outer space. It is due to, in Marx’s phrase, “disproportion of production” which is inherent in capitalism.

That is not the end of the story. The “crisis of over-production” leads to a slowing down, or even halting, of production. Capitalists will not for long continue production of what they cannot sell, even at a reduced margin of profit. Reduction of production means unemployment. The ability of workers to buy back what they have produced is further curtailed. Production is reduced still further and unemployment increases.

This is the explanation of the nature of “the virulent trade and employment depression” which Wilson might have given. But then, having promised to administer capitalism better than Heath, he can hardly be expected to tell the electorate that trade depressions are endemic in the capitalist system. The electorate might want to change the system for one which produces commodities for distribution rather than sale at a profit.

What is really behind Mr. Wilson’s second “reason” for our economic difficulties: British industrial inefficiency? The explanation is to be found in what has been written above. British capitalism can only survive if it can export wealth. To do this, foreign competitors must be under-cut, or better value for money offered. By the more efficient processes outlined by Wilson in his speech industrial wage bills can be reduced, goods can be exported at lower prices while still maintaining the previous margin of profit. Some countries can, however, compete more successfully because labour is cheaper, and this is why “wage restraint” is so important to the employer. This leads on to the third of Wilson’s “reasons” in his reference to pay aggravating inflation. Industry’s concern about pay increases is not that they aggravate inflation but because they make it more difficult to sell products at a competitive price while still maintaining the customary margin of profit.

But this still does not explain the inflation which is “aggravated” and which largely caused, in the first place, the demands for higher wages. This kind of inflation — the devaluation of the pound — has been caused by the excessive printing of paper money by the Bank of England on the authority of successive governments since the war. No mention of this was made in Mr. Wilson’s speech. But he is not the only one to keep quiet about the effects of government monetary policy, both here and abroad, on the rate of inflation. In November 1974 Enoch Powell was complaining that:
. . . little attention had been given (in the press) to the epoch-making conclusions of the European Economic Community Countries’ finance ministers on measures to tackle inflation. To restore the general stability in the value of money they agreed that they should follow the principle ‘that increases in the supply of money should be cut back to the same level as the real growth in gross national product’, plus whatever might be accepted for the time being as the permissible rate of inflation, namely 4 per cent next year.
(The Times, 4th November 1974)
Our economic difficulties are not, as Wilson implies, a “bolt from the blue” but a direct result of the operation of a capitalist economy. When the electorate understands this it may seriously examine the case for establishing an alternative economic system based on production for use rather than production for sale, that is, Socialism as we mean it and not as Labour politicians use the word to conceal state capitalism.
John Moore

Utopian & Scientific Socialism (1975)

From the October 1975 issue of the Socialist Standard

It is essential for workers to have at least a basic understanding of capitalism before they can hope to become useful in the struggle for Socialism. Whilst one man cannot hope to know everything about society today, he can acquaint himself with the fundamentals. Unfortunately today most workers accept the prevailing ideas of the ruling class and the confused outlook that results from them. When many workers hear the Socialist case for the first time they are apt to dismiss it as utopian or an impossible dream. Socialism is however a materialist conception, that is an idea which has sprung directly from the real conditions and relations in society. Socialism as yet is an idea only but one which is based upon knowledge of the real world and not upon an ideal or religious feeling. The Christian ideas that “Christ died for our sins” or “Christ lives to save” are idealistic and have no basis in fact. (It would take a mist- enveloped religious mind to explain how Christ can be both dead and alive). The Socialist idea that capitalist society is divided into two different classes with mutually opposing interests is a fact. But it is one which the ruling class and their propagandists are always trying to obscure, talking instead of the “National Interest” and playing down class interests. Naturally the ruling class, being in a privileged position, want capitalism to continue ad infinitum, so that they can keep reaping-in the surplus-value produced for them by the working class.

Capitalism will remain as long as the majority of the working class want it to remain and allow it. Historically speaking capitalism is relatively new (about two hundred years) but already it has outlived its useful life. Whilst it was the necessary step for society to develop its productive forces and social production, it is essentially an anarchic and anti-social system. All past private-property societies have resulted in the exploitation of one class by another, but under capitalism it has taken a particular form, i.e. the wage-slave. The worker, owning virtually nothing of the means of life, must sell his abilities to the owners of capital for a wage. He is “free” to approach any potential employer for work, and the employer is free to employ him or not as the case may be.

Capitalist industries are geared to produce vast numbers of commodities which must be sold at a profit if they are to remain in business. That great organ of capitalist ideology the Daily Telegraph (14th June 1975) summed up the purpose of capitalist production very neatly:
Offices and factories will not be built unless it pays people to do so. In the same way there will be no investment in industry unless it is expected to produce a reasonable profit.
The aforesaid profit of course comes from the unpaid labour extracted from the working class at the point of production, and not from the shifting of sums of money by financial wizards from one industry to the next. When the worker goes home at the end of the week he leaves behind him his labour, now embodied in commodities with a certain value. The value of the wage which he takes home is invariably less than the value of the labour he leaves with his employer. The “reasonable profit” of the Daily Telegraph is created by human labour applied to materials; and from the capitalist point of view the larger the profit, the more “reasonable” the investment.

The London Brick Company Ltd. recently announced half yearly profits of about £5m., £2m. higher than expected, and immediately became a more “reasonable” proposition. It is worth pointing out that the housing problem is no less severe because of the profits of the London Brick Company, and for certain types of bricks there is now a three-month waiting period. On the other hand the capitalists are steering well clear of the Norton-Villiers concern at the time of writing because it looks like folding or at least severely curtailing production. Slumps and booms are as natural to capitalism as waves on the sea. At the moment there is a worldwide recession affecting many industries (but not all), and this is because the workers as a class have produced too many commodities for the world market. Because it is no longer profitable to employ them many workers will be laid off or put on short time, and they must suffer the hardships. The very goods that they alone have produced are denied them because they have produced too many! Booms, slumps and unemployment are inherent characteristics of capitalist society because the purpose behind production is the accumulation of profit and not the satisfaction of human needs.

With the abolition of private property (either state or individually owned) there will no longer be any classes in society, and for the first time production can be geared to the needs of society generally and not to the profit motive. All the paraphernalia of capitalism, i.e. money, wages, banks, insurance, armies, police etc., will cease to exist as the reason for their existence disappears. In the opinion of the writer, the only conceivable use for money in Socialist society would be as museum-pieces to show how backward previous societies had been.
Tony D'Arcy


Blogger's Note:
The following quotation from Karl Marx accompanied this article:
". . .  a man who has not understood the present state of society may be expected to understand still less the movement which is tending to overthrow it and the literary expression of this revolutionary movement".
Karl Marx, letter to P. V. Annekov, 28th December 1846.