Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Letter: A Reader defends the Liberal Party (1957)

Letter to the Editors from the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

A Reader defends the Liberal Party

Finchley Road, London, N.W.2.

The Secretary, S.P.G.B.

Dear Sir,—Some months ago I wrote to you asking for an explanation of certain statements made about Marxism in the pamphlet Socialist Comment. I never received a reply, although when I sent for “Questions of the Day” it was quickly sent. I will not assume that you are only interested in spreading your ideas and not caring to answer questions on them, but that an administrative hitch was the reason for your silence. I am now writing to ask you why you have deliberately distorted the facts about the Liberal Party in the booklet “Questions of the Day.” As a Liberal I deeply resent the allegation made against the Liberal Party. First, you have deliberately tried to convey the impression that the Liberal Party is composed of capitalists of the High Tory calibre. Nothing could be further than the truth. It is not clever to give accounts of nineteenth century Whig and so-called Liberal administration and then point to the Liberals of today. It is a cheap trick and is completely misleading. The nineteenth century Liberals were in some measure more enlightened than the Tories. This does not mean to say that the present-day Liberal Party follows their doctrines. Far from it; we only accept that which is good; e.g., Repeal of the Com Laws. But why go back in history? Surely it is only the present that counts? But even if you must delve back into the past, at least be honest. Nothing is said about the great Liberal social reforms at the beginning of the twentieth century, and nothing about our Free Trade ideas.

Liberalism is identified with laissez-faire. But not, and this point must be stressed, of the 19th century variety. The Government should merely supervise industry, nationalising only public utilities, and keeping a sharp eye on restrictive practices, inflation, etc. In that way the evils of unfettered capitalism and the evils of bureaucratic Socialism can be avoided.

I am not asking you to share my beliefs [it would be futile in any case] but only to present them in a fair way.
Yours faithfully,
Brian M. Levy.


Reply.
We cannot trace our correspondent’s earlier letter. We certainly have no wish to avoid answering questions, and if he will repeat them a reply will be forthcoming.

The letter goes on make charges about the contents of the S.P.G.B. pamphlet Questions of the Day, but the charges are quite unfounded. It is true that the chapter on the Liberal Party deals to a considerable extent with the actions of that party in the nineteenth century, but it also deals with the programme of the Liberal Party at the 1950 General Election—about which our correspondent says nothing.

Our correspondent asks "Why go back in history?" This would, of course, be a legitimate point for the present-day Liberal Party to make if in fact that party repudiated the policies and actions of the Liberal Party and Liberal governments in the past. Until such repudiation is forthcoming and while the Liberal Party goes on chiming continuity with its own past, it will continue to be pertinent for us to expose what those Liberals were and what they did. And our correspondent does not give any evidence at all of any distortion on our part.

Our correspondent does name one of the "great social reforms” of the Liberal past and explicitly approves it—the repeal of the Com Laws and the support for Free Trade. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Free Trade movement was one conducted by the Liberal factory owners for the purpose of getting cheap food and consequently low wages.

As regards the present-day activities of the Liberals, one of their main concerns is to promote schemes of profit-sharing. This is dealt with in our pamphlet, where it is pointed out that the Liberal aim is to get the workers to work harder and thus secure "increased profits,” out of which increase the workers are to receive a share. Yet our correspondent writes indignantly at our charge that the Liberal Party is, as it always was, a party of capitalism.

His last point is equally revealing. He claims that the Liberal Party is in favour of nationalising certain industries. As nationalisation is State capitalism and does not serve the interests of the working class, this too, clearly demonstrates the capitalist character of the Liberal Party.
Editorial Committee.

1 comment:

Imposs1904 said...

The Questions of the Day pamphlet referred to in the letter from Brian Levy is the 1953 edition (the third edition of this pamphlet).

Unfortunately this particular edition is not on the SPGB website. Only the 1978 edition is available.