Monday, November 16, 2026

Thatcher: the last Briton (1988)

From the November 1988 issue of the Socialist Standard

"Europe: open for business"
This is the frankly utilitarian, not to say cynical, slogan adopted by the Department of Trade and Industry for its campaign to publicise the so-called Single European Market that is supposed to come into existence in 1992.

Wisely, from their own point of view, this campaign is directed primarily at business people since it would be difficult to interest ordinary wage and salary earners in something that is so obviously irrelevant to our daily lives. We don't export and we don't import. and the only markets we are involved in are the labour market in which we sell our mental and physical energies, and the supermarket where we buy our weekly supplies. All the same, we are obliged to make some attempt to follow what the bosses are up to.

As its name suggests, the European Common Market is an economic and trading arrangement between a number of European states, twelve at present, including Britain and Ireland. It was set up under the Treaty of Rome signed in 1957. which was modified last year by a new Treaty known, for some reason, as the Single European Act.

The original treaty provided for the establishment of a "European Economic Community" (to give the Common Market its somewhat grandiose official title) which would be something more than a mere free trade area in which commodities could circulate free from customs duties and import quotas. It was to be a single economic area in which capital and professional services, as well as goods, could circulate unhindered, not just by customs restrictions but also by other barriers such as those arising from different technical standards and from collecting taxes at frontier posts. The 1987 Single European Act essentially only changed the decision-making procedures so as to make it easier to achieve this goal by the end of 1992.

Customs restrictions between the Common Market countries have long since been removed (since 1968 in fact) and a common external tariff against outside goods has been erected. Customs posts still exist, of course, but they are concerned either with commodities coming into the Common Market from outside or with checking that incoming goods conform to a country's technical standards or with collecting taxes or checking that they have been paid.

The mere abolition of customs duties and quotas between Common Market countries has proved insufficient to ensure the free flow of commodities between them. The member countries still found ways of protecting their home markets from competition even from other member countries. Germany, for instance, used its "purity law” on beer to keep out imports of beer from other Common Market countries on the grounds that they contained banned chemicals and additives (as indeed they did. and as does most German beer produced for consumption outside Germany). The European Court of Justice struck this down as contrary to the Treaty of Rome, as it has done in many similar cases involving nearly all the Common Market countries (Italy over pasta, Britain over UHT milk and so on).

The way in which national technical standards present a barrier to the free flow of commodities is explained in one of the Department of Trade and Industry's factsheets for businesspeople:
Most Member States have their own standards and laws which are important in setting quality and safety requirements for goods sold in their national home market National standards can be a serious barrier to trade when different standards apply in other Member States; or often a bigger obstacle when Member States do not recognise each others' arrangements for testing and certifying products to ensure that they meet national or EC standards.

These 'technical' barriers fragment the market and add to costs by forcing producers to modify their products, or by subjecting them to different national testing and certification procedures. if they wish to sell them in other Member States. All too often the effect is to discourage firms from seeking orders in other parts of the Community National technical barriers will be progressively eliminated as the single market is completed. By then any product which can be sold in the Member State in which it is produced will be freely marketable in other parts of the EC. unimpeded by different national standards and testing and certification practices (DTI Single Market Factsheet 2).
So this is what all the fuss is about, achieving by the end of 1992. besides the completion of the free movement of capital (some Common Market countries still impose exchange control restrictions) and professional services (it is still not possible for all professional people who have qualified in one country to practise freely in the other countries). the removal of the barrier to the free movement of commodities represented by national technical standards. From the end of 1992 health, safety and other technical standards will either be European or mutually acceptable. At the same time ways of collecting and checking on the payment of taxes other than by physically stopping lorries at frontier posts will be found. And. by pure coincidence, the Channel Tunnel linking Britain physically to the rest of Europe, is due to open in 1993.

What then? Some European politicians want to go on to an Economic and Monetary Union, involving a common European currency (which already exists for some accounting purposes) and a European Central Bank. Others want to go even further and look forward to the emergence of a federal United States of Europe. Mrs Thatcher is vehemently opposed to both. In a radio interview with Jimmy Young in July, she said that the first would "never come in my life-time, and I hope never at all". As to the second, it was simply "not possible":
It is not possible to have a United States of Europe. What is possible is for the 12 countries of Europe to work more closely together on things we would do better together, so that we can trade better together
(Independent, 28 July 1988). 
Actually, apart from the narrow-minded British nationalist prejudice that is typical of her attitudes, Thatcher's view of Europe does correspond more accurately to what the Common Market is in practice and to what the Treaty of Rome meant it to be. Despite what she says however, it would be quite possible to have a United States of Europe if the governments and public opinions of the member countries were to agree to this. But this would require a new. political treaty going way beyond the essentially economic aims of the 1957 Treaty that set up the Common Market. It is true that a directly-elected European Parliament (the next elections are due in June), a European Court of Justice making binding decisions and a European civil service headed by an embryo executive composed of politicians already exist, but their powers, such as they are, do not extend beyond the strictly economic field defined by the Treaty of Rome.

The prospect of the disappearance of the kind of petty nationalism peddled by Thatcher and her equivalents in the other European countries is a welcome one, but that does not mean that we socialists are in favour of a federal European State. Certainly we are non-nationalists and we do want to see a world without frontiers, but a single European State would represent the emergence of another capitalist superpower to vie with imperialist America and state capitalist Russia for the domination of the world. This in no way corresponds to the sort of world we want to see established where there would be no states and no national frontiers but, instead, a single democratic World Community based on the common ownership of the Earth's resources, natural and industrial.
Adam Buick

No comments: