Friday, November 20, 2026

Sting in the Tail: Harvest of shame (1996)

The Sting in the Tail column from the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard

Harvest of shame

Let us celebrate. It is a bumper harvest. Let us dance, sing, compose poems and make love. Oops, sorry. Bit of a time lapse there. We don’t live in socialism, we still live in capitalism.

The Herald (13 September) tells us “Record harvest bad news for farmers, merchants and exporters.” “Britain is likely to end up with some two million tonnes of surplus wheat and over 900,000 tonnes of barley, according to Trevor Harriman, Dalgety Agriculture’s commercial manager.”

The Herald goes on to report that grain prices will fall and Harriman as saying “unlike last year it is difficult to see where the surplus will go”.

All this gloom about a bumper harvest could only happen in capitalism, where food is produced for profit and not human need. This madness is reported with no reference to the millions throughout the world who are malnourished, nor the thousands dying of starvation.

There's not a lot of singing and dancing at harvest time today, is there?


Taking a leak

The news that there had been a radioactive leak into the Pentland Firth from Dounreay had a spokesman for the UK Atomic Research Authority saying:
“At 8am on Saturday morning equipment detected a very small amount of radioactivity in the cooling system. There followed a precautionary gradual shutdown of the plant ” (Herald, 30 September).
The closure might seem a bit drastic if we are to believe the “nuclear expert” writing in the previous week’s issue of Professional Engineering. He claimed that regular exposure to nuclear radioactivity can prevent cancer, and daily doses of the stuff should be part of a healthy lifestyle.
"I believe that one day radiation will become part of our daily exercise regime with a device on the gym treadmill to give us a daily dose."
On reflection it is just as well they shut down the plant. The “nuclear expert" is none other than John Graham, vice president of British Nuclear Fuels’s US subsidiary.


Fascination with himself

Paddy Ashdown, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, had been pontificating about the “most fascinating fact in politics”. Is it about the existence of classes, the exploitation of the working class or the economic cause of world hunger and war? No way. It’s about whether he and Blair will end up in the same political party.
"The most fascinating fact about British politics today is that Kenneth Clarke is closer to Paddy Ashdown than to Michael Portillo, and Paddy Ashdown is closer to Tony Blair than Tony Blair is to Dennis Skinner. In the end that fact will have to assert itself I do not say we will end up in the same party we probably won't—but it is the most fascinating fact in politics today ” (Observer, 22 September).
Only a self-absorbed egomaniac like Ashdown could come up with this “fascinating nonsense”.


Economic illusions

One of the most widely-held illusions about capitalism is that if your employer is making big profits it means that you will gain increased wages and greater security of employment.

If the recent record profits of banks accompanied by slashing cuts in staff numbers has not already awakened workers to this illusion perhaps the latest proposals by British Airways will.

In March this year, BA reported pretax profits of £585 million, up from £327 million in the corresponding period last year. So what is their response to this bonanza?
“About 600 British Airways cabin crew based at Glasgow, Manchester and Birmingham are being asked to accept pay cuts of up to 40% as the airline seeks to build its record £585 million profit of last year’’(Herald, 27 September).
BA has also confirmed that it intends shedding 5,000 or more jobs over the next 18 months, and announced the closure of its contract ground handling business at Heathrow which means a loss of 750 jobs.

“Well done, thy good and faithful servant—go forth and multiply!”


The Chloroform Factory

There is a silly debate going on about schools in the Labour Party. It is about what school to send your kid to. It is a phoney debate. Most of them will end their kids to the best one going.

Inside capitalism everything is for sale. Food, clothing, housing and of course education is as good or as bad as you can afford. Workers are not educated in school—they are chloroformed to accept the property rights and national prejudices of their ruling class. Every primary school in Britain teaches the kids the words of “God Save The Queen” and “Rule Britannia”, just as every American one teaches “The Star-Spangled Banner”.

Fortunately for socialists many of the products of the chloroform factory soon see through this poisonous patriotism once they go to work in the office, the factory or sign on the dole.

The human faculty of inquiry cannot be completely wiped out by capitalism's chloroform factories. Therein lies the strength of the socialists’ alternative.


Progress

In so-called primitive societies the elders of the kin group were revered. Their experience of the past was valued. They knew the best hunting grounds, and in later societies the best time to plant seeds and even inside industrial society the best way to perform mechanical skills.

Inside capitalism today the old are despised. In a rapidly changing society the old come to be seen as a burden. They are looked upon as foolish, weak and exploitable.

Every other day we read of the cruelty the old worker has to endure. In the Herald (13 September) we read of a “catalogue of abusive behaviour towards elderly patients” in Glasgow’s Victoria Infirmary'. A story that could be repeated in every city in the modern world.

What further proof is needed that capitalism is not geared to serving human welfare than the way it treats the very old and other vulnerable groups?

Living in the real world (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard
Socialism is the only answer to the problems which capitalism inevitably generates — and what problems they are! Despite all the rubbish we hear these days about the so-called defeat of socialism and about how a victorious capitalism provides plenty for all, the number of workers suffering under capitalism in one way or another is actually on the increase.
The number of people in the world living in absolute poverty has grown, not declined, in the last 25 years. 1.3 billion people, more than a fifth of the human race, live in absolute poverty, lacking access to basic necessities such as food and clean drinking water. One-third of the world’s children are undernourished, and 12.2 million of them die before the age of five every year, 95 percent of them from poverty-related illnesses. Over 400 armed conflicts have occurred since the end of the Second World War. These have caused the deaths of over 20 million people directly and an estimated one and a half million indirectly. Total world military spending stands at around $750 billion a year – equivalent to the annual incomes of the poorest half of the world’s people.

In Britain, 3.7 million children – one in five – now live in families dependent on Income Support, or on less than this. There are six million people, who live in uninsulated homes, with inadequate heating systems, who cannot afford to be warm. An estimated half-million of people are homeless. Out of the 66 main causes of death for men, 62 are more common in social classes IV and V. In women 64 out of 70 are more common in these social classes. In recent years increased poverty and unemployment have been responsible for the return of tuberculosis as an important disease.

Even many of those whose standard of living, as measured by an increase in their disposable monetary income, do not consider themselves to be living in an improving world. In two separate opinion polls in 1995 60 percent of people replied “worse” to the question “do you think that the kind of world that today’s children will inherit will be better or worse than the kind of world that children of your generation inherited, or about the same?” An Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare – which takes into account such other factors as inequality, crime, environmental degradation, insecurity, the decline of public services, as well as disposable income – has been falling since the mid 1970s and by 1990 was almost back to its 1950 level.

All these facts and figures – and many more – together with their sources are to be found in The Politics of the Real World published in February by Earthscan (price: £6.99). This book was prepared by a coalition of campaigning charities, including Oxfam, Friends of the Earth, Save the Children, Christian Aid and the World Wide Fund for Nature, calling itself the Real World Coalition.

Campaigning Charities
One feature of political life (in the broadest sense) in recent decades has been the rise of the campaigning charity. In the past charities were mainly religious bodies handing out donations from the guilty rich to the deserving poor who were supposed to be grateful and not ask for more. Now, with a relaxation of the rules by the Charity Commissioners, charities tend to see themselves just as much as pressure groups campaigning and lobbying on behalf of their beneficiaries as bodies providing help. They have become, while continuing their basic charity work, single-issue, reformist organisations.

One of the main reasons for this was the failure of the Labour Party to do much to help the “underprivileged” and the “disadvantaged”. At one time Labour had a global strategy of trying to improve social conditions for the destitute, the sick, the handicapped, the unemployed, the old by means of social reform legislation. But when in power they found that they had to give priority instead to profits and profit-making, since the capitalist system (which, as the government, they had assumed responsibility for managing) runs on profits.

The Wilson and Callaghan Labour governments of the 60s and 70s all ended up cutting back, not expanding, social welfare provisions. As a result, many of those concerned with such problems withdrew from working through the Labour Party to try to tackle them and moved instead to working through charities, which they eventually turned into the campaigning organisations they are today.

This represented a step back from Labour’s global reformism to a mere single-issue reformism. Now, apparently, many of those in the charities have come to realise that each of them cannot solve in isolation the problem they target and that these problems are interconnected and require a global approach.

The Real World Coalition is an attempt to overcome the limitations of each charity being a single-issue campaign group. The result is a surprisingly perceptive analysis of how the main problems charities are concerned about – “Third World poverty, relative deprivation in Britain and environmental damage” – are interlinked and have a common cause. This, however, is not followed up when it comes to proposing a solution.

The indictment
The common cause of the various problems is identified as “the dominant intellectual model of economic and social progress” of “the unquestioned pursuit of economic growth”, “based on the expansion of market forces”. This “model” is mercilessly criticised.
“As we approach the new century, it has become increasingly clear that the model of economic and social progress which has dominated the second half of the present one no longer works. The problems of environmental degradation, global poverty and domestic inequality have begun to threaten, even to overwhelm, the gains which have been made . . . The failure of the model lies not just in the existence of these problems, or even their increase. It lies in the way in which current patterns of economic growth, based on the expansion of market forces, are themselves their cause. The model is ultimately self-defeating” (P. 117).

“There is now little sign – indeed, increasingly, little pretence – that such problems will be either eradicated or repaired by further application of the model’s prescriptions. On the contrary: what has now become clear is that further economic development on the pattern of the past will continue to exacerbate these problems. For they are not, as supposed, symptoms of the model’s failure, but of its success“(pp. 10-11).

“The international regime of free trade, capital mobility and market deregulation acts as a constant pressure on social and environmental standards. Combined with the now rapid processes of technological change, increasing international competition forces companies and governments to seek ways of cutting costs. This is having a direct effect not just on wages but on the conditions and security of employment, as firms look for maximum flexibility and productivity from their employees – in white collar occupations as well as blue collar ones. Moreover global competition acts as a downward pressure on employment protection, social security and consumer protection standards, as arguments over the European Social Charter have demonstrated. Environmental policies which are seen to raise costs – even if this is only in the short term – similarly become more difficult to defend. Taxation and public spending themselves come to be regarded as costs, raising prices and driving away foreign investment, and are therefore to be reduced” (p. 57).

“The crucial realisation is that these outcomes are not incidental by-products of market forces, but central, predictable consequences of them” (p. 119).
Back to Square One
It might be thought that anyone making such an analysis would go on to conclude that what is required is the complete abolition of the world market system. This, however, is far from being the case. All the Real World Coalition offers is . . . “the social regulation of trade”, “regulating markets for the general good”, “a gradual, agreed, managed shift in international economic relations”: “It is not markets themselves to which we take exception, but the abdication of democratic decision making to the socially and environmentally damaging outcomes of overall market forces. Markets are essential. But they must be shaped in the interests of society, not vice versa” (pp. 119-20).

This, the Real World Coalition go on, requires 
“governments with the mandate and power to influence and constrain market forces to generate the chosen outcomes. To do this governments have many tools at their disposal: law, taxation, public expenditure, incentive, persuasion”.
This is just the classic reformist recipe of government intervention to try to constrain the market system to work for the common good. Precisely the recipe which failed when Labour tried it and whose failure led to the rise of the campaign charities.

The fact is that capitalism cannot be reformed so as to serve the common good. In suggesting that it can the Real World Coalition has merely gone back to where the Labour Party was thirty or so years ago. This makes it much more radical than the Labour Party is today, but just as wrong.

The flaw in their analysis is to see the “model” they criticise merely as a set of ideas that has been freely adopted and which can be abandoned by a similar act of will if those in power can be persuaded to do so. The model of “unquestioned economic growth” is indeed a set of ideas, but it is more than this: it is a set of ideas that reflects and corresponds to the capitalist economic system.

Capitalism is an economic system of capital accumulation out of profits. This is its dynamic. Profits are made by competing firms which, in order to remain competitive, have to re-invest most of them in new, more productive machinery and equipment. The result is the accumulation of a greater and greater stock of productive equipment used to make profits, or capital. This is the reason for “the unquestioned economic growth” that the Real World Coalition attacks as the cause of the problems its member charities seek to solve. But it is not an accident. It is the very essence of capitalism. Economic growth and capital accumulation are the same thing; capitalism is the system of capital accumulation.

That “the dominant intellectual model” is dominant is not accident. It is in fact a reflection of the logic of capitalism and is not something that can be changed by a mere decision of those running the system to adopt a new model. It is the intellectual model which the system demands those who manage it to adhere to.

In this sense it is that it is those who adhere to it who are the ones living in the real world – the existing real world of capitalism. And that it is the campaigning charities, who imagine that things could be different within the capitalist world market system, who are not.

To stop the “dominant intellectual model” being applied means getting rid of the system of blind economic growth of which it is but an ideological reflection. This requires, not tinkering through legislation and taxes, but a revolution in the basis of society which would make the productive resources of the world the common heritage of all humanity instead of the exclusive property of individuals, corporations and governments. On this basis, a different “model” would emerge, that of organising the production and distribution of wealth to meet human needs.
Adam Buick

Free trade, profits and the environment (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard
Capitalism is, first and foremost, a system in which the making of profits overrides every other consideration — including damage to our environment. Socialists have been pointing this out for a long time now, yet most of those involved in environmental issues still think you can have capitalism without its problems.
The environmental movement present us with such devastating evidence of the effects of the profit system that it is surprising they fail to touch upon the root cause of the problems they highlight. This is nowhere more striking than in their attacks against the current global trading system which they blame for many social and environmental problems.

World trade has certainly been “liberalised” in many areas in the past forty or fifty years. “Distortions” of the free market price of goods, such as tariffs (which force importers to increase the price of goods), import quotas (restrictions on the amount a state will import) and export subsidies (selling exports at a deliberately low price) have all been cut back. Environmentalists are right to point out that this leaves little or no room for restrictions on the exchange of goods produced by environmentally or socially damaging means. Still, capitalism never left much room for considering the harmful consequences of the production methods used, such as causing pollution or paying low wages, when trade was more restricted. Their call for restricting trade to somehow prevent these harmful consequences overlooks the profit-driven motives that have shaped the current world trading system.

Multinationals
It is not hard to see the benefits of free trade to the hugely powerful transnational corporations. These now account for one third of global output and their global annual sales have reached 4.8 trillion dollars (which is, incidentally, greater than the total level of international trade). The largest 100 multinational corporations alone control about one-third of all foreign direct investment. The world trading system can be seen as having adapted itself to meet their needs, particularly in the last forty or fifty years.

There was, in the aftermath of the Second World War, an especially concerted effort by the US and Europe to establish freer world-wide trade. The liberalisation of capital and goods markets was an integral part of their strategy, and had indeed been a key war aim given the autarkic regional trading blocs pre-war Germany and Japan had built up.

The USA and Britain agreed to start cutting down on tariffs in 1944 as part of the famous Bretton Woods agreements. Further measures were then taken such as in 1949 when 30 percent of European trade was freed from restrictions.

Capitalism Since 1945 (edited by P. Armstrong, 1991) takes up the story:
“The reduction of tariff barriers after the formation of the EEC in 1958 increased trade by the order of 25-35%. Within EFTj4, (the free trade zone formed by seven of the non-EEC European countries, including at that time the United Kingdom) lower barriers resulted in extra imports of around 10-15% for the countries concerned . . .

"Very high rates of tariff covering about 7% of goods in the United States and United Kingdom almost disappeared, and the proportion of trade (excluding agriculture and fuels) which attracted tariffs of 15 per cent or less rose from 54% to 85% in the USA, from 37% to 85% in the United Kingdom and from 71% to 97% for the EEC. "
World trade grew by an average of 8.7 percent between 1963-72. This growth then slowed sharply from 1973 (it averaged 3.8 percent per year from 1973-88).

In 1973 the Trilateral Commission was founded, to continue the work of building what Holly Sklar in her book Trilateralism (1980) called the “new economic order”.

The Trilateral Commission, she wrote, “planned and encouraged an utter restructuring of the world’s political and economic agenda with much of its new power arrangements built to favour transnational corporate activity.”

The objectives of the Commission were evident in their various reports and policy documents such as this call for the lifting of restrictions on capital mobility made in their publication Towards a Regenerated Economic System, “countries that want economic development would be well-advised to welcome foreign firms on appropriate terms”.

You do not need a degree in economics to work out what was meant by “appropriate” in this context. It is made abundantly clear in the following statement by David Rockcrfeller, one of the leading US politicians and business representatives on the Trilateral Commission: 
"international bankers, corporations, and investors have little need for tariffs and other trade barriers. Their interest lies in finding the most efficient, profitable, productive, and convenient spot for their investment".
George Ball, Under-secretary of State for Economic Affairs in the Kennedy Administration and a director of Lehman brothers Kuhn Loeb, a large investment house, told the British National Committee of the International Chamber of Commerce in 1967:
“In these twenty postwar years, we have come to recognise in action, though not always in words, that the political boundaries of nation-states are too narrow and constituted to define the scope and activities of modern business".
No place for environmentalism
GATT (now called the World Trade Organisations WTO), an institution which has been the focus of much hostility from environmentalists, also had an important role in the move towards trade liberalisation:
"Six rounds of General Agreements on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) negotiations, from 1947 to 1967, for example, brought tariffs on all dutiable US imports downfrom their 1932 high of 59.0% to 9.9% in 1970 n (Capitalism Since 1945).
GATT was founded after the Second World War as an institution to regulate world trade. The original GATT articles contained the basic free trade principles that were gradually put into practice: 
"Article One establishes the rule of 'Most Favoured Nation ’— one country cannot discriminate between domestic products and ‘like products’ imported from another GATT country. 'Like products' were defined in 1971 to be limited to consideration of product characteristics; does not allow consideration of how product is produced or harvested" (Lori Wallach in The Case Against Free Trade, Earth Island Press, 1993).
Environmentalists had hoped that Article 20, which allowed “measures necessary to protect human, animal and plant health or life”, would permit exceptions to the above principles in the case of environmental protection. The well-publicised tuna-dolphin ease, in which the Mexican government appealed against the US Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, put the hopes of environmentalists to the test. Wallach records what happened:
“In August 1991, a three-person, secret GATT dispute panel in Geneva ruled that the (1972 act) was an illegal barrier to trade because it restricts importing tuna into the United States that are caught using techniques that kill large numbers of dolphins”.
This was one of many such judgements that put paid to the environmentalists’ misplaced faith in international law to protect the environment. As Ralph Nader put it, “GATT and NAFTA set out rules limiting countries’ ability to exclude imports on the basis of labour, human rights, or environmental conditions in the country of production”. The Agreements allow one country to challenge as infringing trade another country's environmental, health or safety laws. They therefore have the effect of “harmonising” environmental and safely standards, a euphemism for bringing those states with more stringent regulations down to the level of the least stringent. In other words, the law could only be relied upon when it worked in the other direction.

The move towards free trade can be clearly seen as an outcome of the drive for profits, as companies increasingly operate on a global basis and expect to be able to import and export goods at their free market price.

The anti-free trade lobby are right to point to the conflict between the drive towards free trade and environmental and social needs. After all, if the purpose of free trade is to increase profits, such a conclusion is quite predictable. As Larry Elliott puts it, writing in the Guardian (27 May):
“In reality, globalisation . . . represents the final triumph of capital over labour, since the corollary of the deregulation of finance is the shackling of trade unions. It means the national governments are left powerless in the face of multinationals who will relocate at the first whiff of interventionist policies."
Environmentalists do not usually dispute that the drive for profit underlies the move towards free trade. What they want instead is a “fairer” system of world trade in which environmental and social needs are taken into account. For example, Wallach refers to a “Group of 250” NGOs who wrote a letter to the US government, calling for sanctions to ensure compliance with regulations, funding for their enforcement, taxes and duties on environmentally damaging practices and so on.

In other words, they unreasonably expected that the goal of increasing profitability (which is what GAIT, the WTO and NAFTA are all about) can be compromised under the profit-system. But it can’t. The profit system demands a trading system that allows profits to be maximised. To protect the environment it is the whole global profit system itself that must go.
Dan Greenwood

Greasy Pole: Jobseekers and the retired (1996)

The Greasy Pole column from the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard

Both on the same day, two decisions were taken by this year's Labour Party conference which were—how do we put this in a publication designed for quiet family reading?—somewhat inconsistent. First there was the pledge to ban the ownership and possession of some handguns. This was Labour’s reaction to Dunblane; the conference heard an impressive speech from the organiser of the Dunblane Snowdrop petition (who happens to be a life-long supporter of the Conservative Party). After that Tony Blair and the leadership composed their faces into suitably pious expressions and the conference stood in silent tribute to the children killed in the massacre.

Well that’s right and proper, isn’t it? It’s right that a party which is pretty certain it will be running the country in a few months’ time should be concerned about mass murder and the grief and anguish it leaves in its wake. But what’s this? On the same day the delegates wept about Dunblane they also voted in favour of Britain keeping the Trident missile. And what else is Trident, if not a weapon designed to wipe out lots of people, apart from laying waste to huge areas and leaving much of it uninhabitable for a very long time? A bit worse, in other words, than a handgun.

Votes
Except that when we look at it more closely we can see a disreputable consistency about these two decisions. Making handguns illegal—and getting a Tory to come to urge you to do it in an emotional speech—is likely to win votes. Promising to ban Trident—or any other nuclear weapon—is likely to lose them. As Labour’s shadow defence secretary David Clark put it: ’’British people won’t elect a government that they do not trust with the defence of our country." And getting elected as the government is what Labour is basically concerned with and this year, as the prospect of electoral victory looms closer and closer, the conference was in no mood to put any obstacle in the way. No mood to miss exploiting any chance to win a few votes, even over a poignant tragedy like Dunblane.

Buck stops here
This was the setting for Blair's craftily composed speech on the Tuesday, when he made his pledges for a “new age of achievement" (as if we haven’t heard that before) on education, crime, employment, handguns . . .  And said, in case anyone had any doubts on the issue, that he would be responsible for getting Labour’s programme to work, for a "great, radical, reforming" experience for us all. The buck, he said, would stop with him.

Perhaps this impressed enough people to make it worthwhile. If so, they were people with seriously defective memories because if Blair meant what he said he would be unique among prime ministers. Political leaders are not famous for standing up and confessing that they have made a mess of things or that their promises were false or that they are not in control of the situation. Quite simply, when reality comes home and their election pledges are exposed they try to pass the buck. Like Attlee blaming the dominance of American capitalism just after the war. Like Wilson and the gnomes of Zurich. And always, whatever other excuses they make, they blame workers who are allegedly bringing the economy to its knees through extravagant and irresponsible wage claims, strikes, restrictive practices and so on.

Iron Chancellor
To some extent, in spite of Blair’s bluster about where the buck stops, the Labour Party arc getting in a sort of pre-emptive strike. In the person of Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown they are already warning us, before Blair has even got to the doorstep of Number Ten. that life in the new age of achievement might be hard for some. Certainly all those wishy-washy Labour veterans who cut their political teeth on the idea that a Labour government would spend their way out of unemployment, slums, deficient medical services, got short shrift from Brown. Labour’s chancellor-to-be told the conference his policies will be " . . . costed, hard headed." There will be "iron discipline . . . no magic wand solutions by cooking the books. . . no wish-list spending solutions . . .”

This must have gone down a treat in the City; it attracted the sobriquet Iron Chancellor and comparisons with Denis Healey, the last Labour chancellor to carry such a message to their conference (with the difference that he was actually in charge of the Treasury at the time). At the 1976 conference Healey told the delegates that he brought news from the battlefront the government were applying for a loan from the IMF and there must be " . . . very painful cuts in public expenditure . . . sticking to the pay policy . . .” Healey then proceeded to impose those policies right up to the infamous Winter of Discontent and the Tory victory in 1979.

Unnecessary
But Brown should be wary of the comparisons. The original Iron Chancellor—Bismarck—got the sack and Healey admitted, years after the event, that the crisis in the mid-1970s was more a matter of the ‘‘experts’’ in the Treasury getting it wrong. ". . . In a sense," he wrote in his memoirs The Time of My Life, "The whole affair was unnecessary. The Treasury had grossly overestimated the PSBR, which would have fallen with the IMF’s limit without any of the measures they prescribed.” Unnecessary? All those cuts? All that pressure on living standards? All those speeches condemning workers who tried to resist?

Labour is gearing itself up now to be the next government their conference, said Gordon Brown, was “the launch pad for the General Election." How will he describe next year’s event when, if Labour win, the pledges will have been subjected to a rather more rigorous examination than they got from the nervous delegates of 1996—the examination of reality and the actual experience behind the fine words? Watch this space.
Ivan

Capitalism's democratic dictatorship (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard
One of the main things which was supposed to have distinguished the countries of western Europe from those in the old Soviet state capitalist empire was that, in the west, there exists something called 'democracy'. This so-called democracy is a farce. The idea that you can have democracy and the private ownership of the means of communication is a nonsense.
Maurice Saatchi and Peter Gummer have both been given a part in the machinery of government of the United Kingdom for the rest of their lives. How did these men achieve their permanent incorporation into the vital organ of British “democracy”, the House of Lords, without the endorsement of the electorate? They got there because they are captains of a lie factory that performs a service for the political party that currently oversees British capitalism. That is to say, they employer numbers of “educated” and “artistic” people to blend truth and lies in whatever proportion they calculate is most effective in misleading the public.

Just before they achieved their political stardom, Saatchi and Gummer offered for public display a sample of the qualities that make such men great: they – doubtless after many serious meetings, and assisted by numerous specialists in the advertising art – placed a pair of “demonic” eyes across the ubiquitously-smiling gob of the Right Honourable Tony Blair MP.

Of course there was uproar among the Blair career-support team and the great Labour machine that hones those aspects of truth that best suits Labour’s purpose was quick to cry “foul” and accuse the defilers of the Blair innocence of an abuse of democracy.

Socialists have no illusions about the democratic credentials of the politicians of the Left, the Right or the Centre. What the capitalist class, and the political parties that serve that class, call democracy is a contrived form of consensus in which the political parties conspire to ensure that the maximum number of people accept a system of law which guarantees a minority class in society the legal right to own and control the means of life of the great majority. To achieve and maintain that system of Law – and the Order that ensures the right of that minority to exploit and impoverish the majority – capitalism must have political control of the state machine.

A vital part of the process that maintains the illusion of democratic choice is the power to confine political knowledge – and, thus, political options – to those parties whose policies are firmly rooted in an acceptance of capitalism.

Human Nature
From a tender age the child is nurtured in the belief that the way we live under capitalism is as natural as the seasons and that the ongoing problems of poverty, unemployment, insecurity, crime and wars are as inevitable as the vagaries of climate. It is not unreasonable for people to believe that life could not be otherwise since these problems, while they are sometimes less acute, are always part of life irrespective of the political party holding the reins of government.

Another great instrument of social conditioning is religion and its contention that humans suffer from basic defects in our nature. “Human Nature”, therefore, according to religion, is inimical to the patterns of social co-operation which a rational alternative to capitalism would require. Capitalism expresses its gratitude by granting a privileged position in education and in the media to those churches that establish a “moral” basis for its heinous system of organised plunder.

The control of education and the moral blandishments of a property-based religious morality have proved vital in creating the illusion of freedom and democracy while limiting choice to those parties that put forward various formula – for running capitalism. The opportunity of participating in the election of a new government is extended to the citizen about a dozen times during an average lifetime. All the parties which currently have the financial ability to field enough candidates to form a government are wholly agreed about one thing: they all intend to retain capitalism and they will have a monopoly of space in the press and time on the electronic media to promote their support of that system.

Effectively, the air time on radio and television that is devoted to the political, economic and social problems of society, not only during, but between elections, is given only to parties that support capitalism. Not only the traditional party political broadcasts but news, magazine and discussion programmes, give exposure to politicians, many of whom become instantly recognisable figures. Some even become media clowns or participants as celebrities in quiz shows. The whole political conspiracy is wrapped in a package of infamous “guidelines” which the broadcasters use to deny discussion or promotion of alternative ways of organising the way we live.

When it comes to elections, choice is governed by information and knowledge and, since the allegedly democratic parties have ensured that the public have information about, and knowledge of, the present system and the politicians offering themselves to run this system capitalism goes unchallenged. Like Henry Ford’s Model T, which was available in any colour providing it was black, current “democratic” practice is to allow us the widest possible choice as long as it is capitalism.

Media-created celebrities
Of course capitalist politicians and the people to whom capitalism entrusts the control of news and information will hotly dispute this. Quite rightly, they will point out that any political party that wishes to field a minimum of fifty candidates in a general election will be allowed the minimum of air time in order to make a party election broadcast and, of course, the amount of broadcasting time will increase in accordance with the number of candidates above that figure. This is an arrangement agreed between the major parties and the various broadcasters over the years – no hint of an, even, nominal independent body to formulate and oversee it. In fact, if an organisation can deposit about £260,000 it may get the same number of party election broadcasts as do the major political parties.

Additional to this latter sum of money, if the organisation putting up the maximum number of candidates was to offer a serious election challenge it would need many millions of pounds to spend on advertising, promotion, wages, transport and the like, much of which the major parties get free of charge from the media and, even then, it would have no guarantee that its message would get exposure on the numerous other programmes which pay fees to those politicians who are invited to offer the views of their party.

So the truth is that the democratic machinery is available to all shades of opinion – if they can afford it. Even then, a party stating a case for an alternative way of running society would be disadvantaged, for capitalist politics, its parties and its media, are not based on rational examination of ideas but on the performance of media celebrities.

Generating lies
Perhaps the greatest impediment to the rational discussion of ideas is the lies, misinformation and confusion which the media generates on an almost daily basis about possible alternatives to capitalism. We could fill this journal with examples of misrepresentation by newspapers, magazines, radio and TV stations. The big networks, like the BBC, lay down certain fundamental areas of misrepresentation to which newscasters and political correspondents must adhere.

An examples of this emerged in 1989 when this writer challenged BBC Northern Ireland concerning its West African correspondent’s reference to “the Marxist government of Angola”. To anyone with the remotest knowledge of Marxism this was pure nonsense: not only is “Marxist government” a contradiction-in-terms but to suggest that the government of Angola was interested in establishing a government that could in any way reflect the socialist vision of Marx is either monumental ignorance or deliberate fabrication.

After several letters and a number of telephone calls, a Mr Paul Robinson replied for the BBC:
“Your letter has been passed to me for reply. 

After checking with the World Service at Bush House in London I can confirm that it is BBC policy to use the terminology “the Marxist government of Angola” and as such we must adhere to that policy”.
This, then, is the much-vaunted “democracy” that capitalism offers:
  • Ideas that are not backed by vast sums of money are barred to consideration.
  • Choice is effectively limited to that of politicians within the dictatorship of capital.
  • The media deliberately distorts facts in such a way as to make difficult the presentation of a case for an alternative form of social organisation.
Looking at the dictatorship of capital over democracy emphasises the difficulties that confront us in the struggle for a sane world. But there is one heartening thought: unlike the parties of capitalism whose purpose is a permanent struggle, to gain power and, when power has been lost, struggle to regain it, our purpose is to make that initial breakthrough which will finally overcome the ability of capitalism’s political agents to lie, confuse and misinform.

Unlike Members of Parliament elected to service capitalism, socialist delegates will not be observing parliament’s meaningless rituals. When there is a majority of socialist delegates there will be no Queen’s Speech, no White Papers nor any of the other shams that pass for democracy today. Just the historic announcement that capitalism has been abolished and that, henceforth, real participative democracy in the administration of social affairs, at local, regional and world levels, will obtain.
Richard Montague

World View: When liberty means slavery (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard

When "communism" collapsed and Russia pulled its troops out of Afghanistan in 1989, and the US stopped backing the Mujahideen (Islamic fighters) against the stooge government in Kabul, a similar pattern emerged as in Somalia. Billions of dollars' worth of weaponry were left behind by the superpowers and the country split up into various factions vying for power.

One faction that emerged hoping to fill the political vacuum were the Taliban. The Taliban (students) were initially the refugees, many of them Mujahideen, who fled to north Pakistan to escape the Soviet régime back home. In 1994, having spent several years undergoing a thorough brainwashing in the Madrasas (religious schools) in the refugee camps of Pakistan, they emerged as a new type of fundamentalism.

Seeing in these religious schools a source of recruits for an army that could possibly be taken back into Afghanistan, a one-eyed mullah, Mohammed Omar Akhund, summoned the faithful to a new holy war.

As the Taliban set off into western Afghanistan in 1994 their numbers swelled to 10,000, their morale and comradeship only matched by the training they had achieved, and the weapons and logistics they had been provided with.

As they steadily advanced towards Kabul, taking, en route, the Silk Gorge which the soviets had tried in vain for years to seize with serious loss of life, through towns and villages, they left behind their calling card -Islamic shariah law, the strictest form of Sunni orthodoxy.

Under shariah the limbs of thieves have been amputated (usually an arm or a foot). Drinkers are lashed and adulterers are stoned to death. Men are forced to grow beards and women made to cover their faces with the burka. TVs have been outlawed along with laughter and singing, girls schools closed and women forbidden to work.

With less resistance than anticipated, Kabul fell to the Taliban on 27 September and with it the five faction government that had been in power for five years. A UN base was overrun and Najibullah, the former president of the Soviet puppet regime who had taken cover there, was shot and hung outside the presidential palace along with his brother and two aides.

Ousted president Rabbani fled north with what forces his warlord minister of defence Masood could muster, fearing less an old enemy, General Rashid Dostum, a heavily armed northern warlord. than Kabul's new occupiers.

Oil-rich Central Asia
One week before Kabul fell, US diplomats were observed visiting Taliban headquarters. That the Taliban loathe the Shiites of Iran—America’s favourite enemies—as “deviants from Islam”— is reason enough, it would seem, for the US interest. For obvious reasons, though, any support would have to be strictly covert lest women voters be upset in the US.

That the Russian rulers are biting their nails, afraid that an Afghan conflict might spread to their oil-rich former empire in Central Asia, where Russia still has a monopoly on oil production, is another reason why the US might want to stoke the proverbial fire.

But at what cost? Would the Russian rulers once again give support to Iran, in an attempt to thwart Taliban ambitions, as they had done when the US backed the Mujahideen against the Russian invasion of Afghanistan?

At the same time, Central Asian states are afraid that the Russian rulers will use the opportunity to reassert Russian presence in the area to protect vital pipeline routes and its own internal security.

And where does Pakistan stand in all this—the first country to recognise the Taliban as the official government? There have been claims that Pakistan actually trained the Taliban. These rumours have been strenuously denied, but Pakistan denied the well-established fact that its intelligence services, the ISI, were training the Mujahideen.

It seems likely that as well as desiring Afghanistan to be a compliant client state, the Pakistan rulers were only too happy to see the Taliban leave their country. The Taliban’s fundamentalism could only have been a destabilising factor in a country where Islam does not have the same hold on the people as in Iran—and which has a woman prime minister.

Trade route
Apart from Pakistan or the US, who else has financed the Taliban? Evidence has emerged that the Taliban were taking a 10 percent slice of the £50 million poppy cultivation industry and providing safe passage for the heroin exporters. Afghanistan does, after all, provide 50 percent of the world’s heroin, an industry the Taliban won’t be able to afford able to outlaw, no matter how much they denounce western corruption and decadence.

Furthermore, with the commercially-important silk road blocked for so long by bandits, where else were powerful businesses to look to have this opened than to the Taliban?

One thing is certain, Afghanistan is far from the stability the Taliban claim to have ushered in. The Taliban, to the indigenous population, are as welcome as the plague. General Dostum still holds six key northern provinces rich in mineral wealth, and he has a hefty arsenal — the legacy of the soviet withdrawal — with which to defend them.

To the west lies a hostile Iran and to the north a nervous Russia fearing further Islamic influence. It seems another US-created Frankenstein monster is up and walking, made from the remnants of discarded foreign policy from bygone years. They have appeared in Korea and Cambodia, the Middle East and across Africa as well as in Latin America. As if the world’s working class had not seen enough of the horror show that is capitalism.

We can only hope that, as in the movies, these monsters are banished by ordinary people all over the world acting in their own interests—as socialists, taking control of the planet they inhabit and their own destiny.
John Bissett