We do not know whether the present rumblings of trade depression will turn into something really big and nasty, or whether—like several other post-war scares—the storm will be mild and short. Perhaps, like the textile slump of the early nineteen fifties, or the motor car slump of two years ago, it will be limited in its effect and duration.
The really significant thing is that nobody can be really sure about it until it happens. It simply is not true, as the Labour and Tory Parties both claim to believe, that capitalism is now under effective control, so that its ups and downs can be foreseen and controlled, and its evil effects of depression ironed out or wafted away.
You Wanted Lower Prices: You May Get Them
Certain it is that economists, politicians and business men are worried, not about the bank rate and the high prices associated with inflation, but about the low prices of raw materials. They have all pretended that the only thing needed to make this country a veritable paradise was falling prices, but now that there is a possibility of this happening they are scared.
Under the heading "Commodity Price Falls Point to Trade Slump," the Daily Mail City column has published gloomy comments on the bleak outlook for business:—
"Not for a long time in the climate of post-war conditions have prices of basic materials used in manufacturing industry been lower than they are now.
“The decline during September ranged up to 5.1 per cent, in raw wool, 6.9 per cent in copper, and 6.4 per cent in rubber.
"Cotton fell 1.7 per cent., linseed oil 5.9 per cent., and lead 2.3 per cent., whale oil showing a drop of 7.7 per cent, and sulphur 5.4 per cent”—(Daily Mail, 11/10/57.)
If you have been thinking that lower prices are what you want, you may now be going to get them, but before you rejoice, read on:—
“Shrinking prices reduces the purchasing power of countries which produce the commodities, reduces their capacity to import, curtails orders to exporting countries, brings inventory and stock losses to manufacturers and spreads business depression and financial difficulties.
"Commodities are falling because suppliers have caught up with demand and even exceeding it as in base metals and the process is spreading.
"Consumer markets have been unable to absorb all the finished products because the prices are more than people can pay without continuous inflation and depreciation of money.
"Factories must turn out more goods for the money or, if people cannot buy, there will be less work and a trade slump."
Raw material production has got dangerously ahead of market demand, as it did in the years before the great slump of the nineteen thirties. So prices are falling, but the defenders of capitalism do not know whether this is good or bad, whether to lament or rejoice. For only one day after the Daily Mail’s City Editor had penned his words of gloom the same newspaper’s leader writer was taking the opposite view. He reported, under the heading "A Bit of Gammon," that the National Farmers' Union was "seriously perturbed about the fall in prices" of bacon, and regarded it as a threat "to the economics of production"; but instead of approving this attitude on the part of the farmers, the leader writer (who apparently does not read his own City column) wrote :—
"This is the first time, even in this era of crazy economics, that we have been told that a drop in prices harms the housewife. We always thought she suffered when prices rose, but we must have been mistaken.”—(Daily Mail, 12/10/57.)
He went on:—
"Bacon is being over-produced and, under competition, prices have fallen. That in itself is a good thing. It is what the Government want”
In the meantime if the City Editor has a word with the leader writer, the latter may learn, to his astonishment, that though the Government may have been saying that it wanted lower prices, it will soon get very worried indeed if prices go on falling.
Is there no hope that the catastrophe of falling prices may be averted?
The Financial Times (11th October, 1957) says that business men are anxiously awaiting news that the "expected improvement in industrial activity in the U.S.” (which has so far failed to appear) will turn up and save them by putting up raw material prices again and mop up some of the surplus. The Manchester Guardian (9/10/57) sees reason for hope at the other end, in the destruction of some of the accumulated stocks, for Australia has just had the happy event of a failure of her wheat harvest through drought. "Now drought has so affected the prospects for this year’s crop in Australia that it seems all the Australian carry-over is likely to be needed for home and export commitments to be met in the next twelve months.” Only a few months ago the Australian Wheat Board was anxiously wondering what to do with all the wheat surplus it could not sell. The wool crop, too, has been damaged by drought.
There is yet another ray of hope. Now that the Russians have got ahead in the lunatic moonbeam race, every country that feels the patriotic need to keep up with the Russians must go in for the same in a big way. According to the Daily Sketch (7/10/57) we could have our own British satellite bowling round the earth at a cost of a mere £500 million; think how much tin and copper and rubber and oil and lead might be wasted on building and launching it and thus send up prices again.
Of course, this and the other forms of waste that help to keep capitalism going might, but for the crazy social system, be used to get rid of the poverty of masses of the world’s population, the undernourishment and the slums. If it cost the Russians £500 million, that would have gone a long way to remove the shocking slums of Moscow and other Russian cities. The Daily Mail talks about crazy economics. Of course, it is crazy that people should have to be glad that capitalism manages to waste so much of the wealth it produces, and glad that a harvest failure in Australia may help to prevent factory unemployment in England.
But capitalism is crazy like that all the time—though not half so crazy as that about 24 million British workers, who ought to be voting to end capitalism and achieve Socialism, actually voted (as Tory, Labour, Liberal and Communist supporters) for capitalism at the last general election in 1955.