Thursday, November 19, 2026

Beating the (hot) air (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

Recently at Mount Melleray in Ireland there occurred a Social Study Conference. Reverend clerics and gentlemen who drank wine with them deliberated at some length on the "conditions of our times.” The "ordinary citizen” was quite unaware that these pious gentlemen were lending oratorical grace to his whims and vices; pre-occupied at the bench, the loom, or just wandering in the shade of the "dole,” he made no comment—nor was he expected to. Even our feathered friends in the trees around the quiet precincts of the famous Mount occupied themselves without distraction, inured as they are to the fatuity that is the stock-in-trade of such Social Study Conferences.

We would like to claim that this Conference discovered some means of eradicating even one of the evils which speaker after speaker dealt with to the point of monotony. Unfortunately it was not to be, and the only thing we learned from this august assembly of self-appointed national-saviours was that "the national morale is very low’’—which is exactly what Paddy Murphy said (in East-Side vernacular) the week before the conference!

Conferences of this nature, however, are useful in one respect, they provide material for the leader writers in the local Press, and the conscious reader of such papers can find an interesting diversion from the usual X-word puzzle; the idea being to rule out a sheet of paper under two headings, "Nonsense” and "Hypocrisy,” apportioning points in order of merit between the conference itself and the leader writer’s comments on same.

We regret that we are unable to donate a prize for a points win in either section by one or other of the parties; if such were available, however, we should without hesitation present it to the leader writer in the Evening Mail (Dublin) for his little gem under the title "Beating the Air” (9/8/57). We gave him few marks in the "Hypocrisy” section as we were obliged to concede the overwhelming superiority of the conference in that domain; but in the "Nonsense” section he was a winner all the way as witness:—
“This country is in greater need now of a leader of vision and energy than ever before in her history. Unhappily there does not seem to be anyone rising up now who seem likely to attain the stature of such men as O’Connell, Parnell, Kevin O’Higgins and one or two others of recent times.”
This poor belated exponent of the "personality cult,” with his clarion for an Irish Fuhrer! A leader of vision, indeed! An Irish Lenin or Stalin? Or could it be a Hitler or Franco? Our school history books are a monotonous chronicle of such "men of vision,” and yet we have conditions that cause naive leader writers to cry from amidst the chaos for a repeat performance. De Valera was to the majority of the Irish people (and still is to a diminishing few) just such a “Leader of Vision.” It is a vision, however, limited by the confines of our economic system.

We can compare such “vision” with the products of electric bulb manufacturers: each may lay claims to the quality of their particular product, “Mazda gives brighter light,” “Osram give longer life,” “Sunshine adds brightness to lightness,” and so on. To a limited extent such claims may bear substantiation, but exposed to the exigencies created by a “short-circuit,” it matters not one iota which bulb we use—the light goes out. And so with our “leaders,” moulded and mandated to serve capitalism, they move within the stage to which they are confined. To a limited degree they may lay claim to this or that “virtue,” but capitalism contains its inevitable “short-circuits,” and when these occur it matters not what persons or parties occupy the parliamentary “socket"—the light of the “visionaries” goes out, and the masses are faced with blackness indeed!

Ireland, like every other country, has had a superabundance of leaders and visionaries. We can see their names immortalised on street designation plates and architectural edifices throughout the length and breadth of the country: and yet remains the scarce alleviated misery and terrible poverty of the working class in this pathetic island—the vision of whose denizens it would appear is to shake the dust of their native heath from their feet and find a place where:—
“ They say there is food and work for all 
“ And the sun shines always there.”
The owners of the super-automobiles that clutter up the pavements outside the luxury hotels are not devoid of “vision,” nor the means of implementing same. They have shown us “How you can buy Killarney"— by buying it! Often they are as “foreign” as the fine cars they ride in, but, paradoxically, it is they who can claim Ireland as THEIR country—literally!

But let us return to the grand humour of our leader writer and his “Beating the Air.” An old joke this time, to be sure, but always one to make us laugh:

“WE need someone to preach the gospel of work and self-reliance.” This surely qualifies for the Rip Van-Winkle comment of the season! We defy its author to give us one example of a newly-appointed government Minister, Social Study Conference, or Employer’s Federation meeting which has not preached TO THE WORKERS about the benefits of hard work!

The Minister for Social Welfare in the late Coalition Government, a certain Mr. Norton, Leader and Visionary of the reformist Irish Labour Party, for example, had hardly donned the robes of Ministerial office before there issued forth from his lips the time-dishonoured cry: “The workers must work harder . . . increased production . . . more exports ’’—though, incidentally, he had been known to declare that “Under our present social system (that is capitalism) greater production means a lower wage for the worker and higher profit for the owners of industry.” (Labour News, 29/1/38).

It would appear that the Irish workers believed Mr. Norton, the Minister for Social Welfare, and not Mr. Norton the aspiring politician of yesterday, for they did indeed work harder; so hard, in fact, that between the time Mr. Norton made his first statement and his later Ministerial announcement they (the workers) increased the over-all volume of production by nearly thirty per cent. (Mr. Costello, In the Dail, 20/7/49). Yet, according to the cost of living figures published by the International Labour Office (Feb. 1949), the REAL WAGES OF THE WORKING CLASS IN EIRE HAD ACTUALLY DROPPED BELOW THE 1937 level! Taxable profits, on the other hand, had risen during the same period from £6,592,000 to £19,640,322! AU of which goes to prove the benefits of harder work—to the capitalists!

The Evening Mail article continues to advise us that the underlying motif at the Mount Melleray Conference appeared to be the need to “revitalise the people,” and comments that there is a great need to “awaken them (the people) to a sense of the realities of the national position as it is today and the grim prospects for the not-so-distant future if we do not pull ourselves together quickly.”

With this, of course, we can have no quarrel; the economic position is indeed grim, and the need for us (the people) to do something about it is truly pressing. What should we do? Tinker with the effects of capitalism? Hold conferences and deliberate on the evils which capitalism creates?

We would suggest to our fellow-working men and women that they should band together with their class-comrades of the working class everywhere, for the ending of the basic cause of all our economic problems—capitalism. Let us by all means be “men of vision”—the vision of a war-less, wage-less, class-less world. In a word, a Socialist World.
Richard Montague

No comments: