Thursday, November 19, 2026

Labour conference the worst ever (1957)

From the November 1957 issue of the Socialist Standard

J. Campbell's remark at the Labour conference that “Public ownership of the means of production, distribution and exchange is the rich red blood of Socialism,” turned out to be only a blush on his own cheek, or perhaps an erstwhile twinkle in Bevan’s eye. Labourites have always used the above quoted formula—which they misrepresented as Socialism—as proof of the great dividing line between them and the old political parties. Like the Equator, it is an imaginary fine. What the conference this year did do was to wipe out all the old familiar landmarks from the political map, leaving only an arid waste of as yet uncharted opportunism.

Morrison and Bevan
Morrison, from the conference floor, regurgitated a sickly past by pleading for full-blooded nationalisation instead of the new programme, “Industry and Society” (The Shareholders’ State). Yet how different it all was a few conferences back. Then Morrison was on the platform, rebuking delegates who were demanding more full-blooded nationalisation, telling them: “There should be no nationalisation for the sake of nationalisation.” And that “Nationalisation is not an end in itself, but merely a means to an end”; although what the end was he never explained. Then it was Bevan who foamed from the floor for more and yet more nationalisation, and declared: "Socialism could only come through the old hard agony of public ownership and control.” But time marches on and now Bevan sat with the stuffed shirts, cheek by jowl with Gaitskell, whom he once ailed a “a desiccated calculating machine.” And while “the old, hard agony of public ownership” was being ditched in favour of “Industry and Society,” he sat mute.

A Vote-catching Conference
The conference itself was merely a dummy run for the General Election. Delegates were shamelessly told that nationalisation as a vote winning proposition no longer payed dividends. In fact, it was booming a vote loser, and Labour leaders would sooner forgo nine-tenths of some alleged nationalisation principle than one-tenth of their polling prospects. Nationalisation had proved an unpalatable carrot to many of the electors and a more synthetic morsel had been cooked by the party chefs in the hope of stimulating the sluggish appetites of the voters.

The New “Socialism”
It was therefore the task of the Platform, a la Aladdin, to offer “New Socialism” for old. As there were no Socialists at the conference—new or old—the offer was accepted to the tune of 5,382,000 to 1,442,000 on a card vote. Thus, the rubber stamped approval of the big unions once again set its seal on yet another document.

As a piece of nonsense literature, “Industry and Society” ranks with “Alice Through the Looking Glass.” In fact, the "Red Queen” herself could have fittingly presided over such a conference. This New Socialism is however neither Socialism nor new, in that its proposition is the investment of. government funds in private industries. British governments have since the time of Disraeli bought shares for the Government in the Suez Canal Company, undertaken either indirectly through public utilities or even directly, investments in private concerns. Today these investments are enormous and cover a very wide range of industries. A fact probably unknown to many Labourites. The old Fabians believed that by progressively steepened taxation they could invest in state industry outside of private capitalist concerns. Even they never dreamed that their Fabian “Socialism” would be realised by investing inside of capitalist concerns. Nor did they ever imagine using the Stock Exchange and capital market as social instruments for the emancipation of the vast majority.

A future Labour Government will then devote insurance funds to buying shares in selected industries. They might, of course, be content to be merely sleeping partners or rentiers. But if in certain concerns the level of efficiency falls and we may add also the rate of exploitation, then the government as considerable shareholders might demand reorganisation, or even in certain circumstances take over. So if management fail to crack the whip sufficiently. Big Brother will be watching. No doubt the Labour Party see this as one means of getting a greater intensity of effort from the workers. It would seem that the Labour Party, having exploited the workers politically, proposes to assist in their economic exploitation to the greatest possible extent.

No doubt government share buying will help to expand business and profits, while the sway of unpaid labour accruing to the government might help to lighten the burden of capitalist taxation in the running of the capitalist state. Perhaps the New Socialism will be interpreted—from each according to his capacity to each according to his shares.

Of course, one effect of government share buying could be to enhance the share values of the concerns involved, and at the same time depreciate gilt edged securities. What is more important is the fact that concerns in which some future Labour Government proposes to invest will be known as “socialised sectors” and government participation in exploitation announced as a further step towards the Socialist Commonwealth. In such sectors workers will be told they are not merely working for capitalists but their own government, and hence failure to respond to productivity drives, it will be said, will be a blow to the government and indirectly a blow to themselves, and no doubt the “Socialist” employers will add their voices to such appeals. And if the workers strike in these “ socialised sectors ” they may well be told that they are striking against the government—a Labour Government; and such action may well turn a friendly government into an enemy government.

The Repeal of the Rent Act
The demand for repeal of the Rent Act was a specious effort to seduce from the Tories the so-called middle class voters, who live in houses which will be decontrolled next October and who will be faced with much higher rents and insecurity of tenure, the Labour Party have talked about “reasonable” rents being charged if and when it is returned. Nevertheless, the Labour spokesmen at their conference declined to say what constitutes a reasonable rent. One of them added neither would it be possible to forecast the future cost of house maintenance and repairs. Rents of workers' houses have already gone up, and they will be going up again in the next few months and it is pretty certain from the remarks of Mr. Greenwood that in the Labour Party’s view these higher levels will constitute reasonable rents.

The Labour Party’s proposal to substitute a municipal landlord for a private one does not touch the real crux of the housing problem. As an alternative to Tory property owning democracy they are prepared to offer 100 per cent, mortgages on millions of houses long past their best, or alternatively to exact from tenants heavy contributions to the local authorities for the upkeep of old property.

If housing is one of the main social tragedies of today, then the burden of guilt lies heavy on the Labour Party. It was the Labour Party that continued the War Government’s practice of keeping rents low by rent controls in order to keep wages pegged to a given level. This meant that in view of rising costs rents became uneconomic and thus provided the landlord with sufficient reasons for not carrying out normal maintenance and repairs. This, of course, has greatly aggravated the housing situation. If rents had risen with rising prices the workers, using a favourable economic situation, would have demanded higher wages, and the loss would have had to be borne by manufacturers instead of landlords. But at least landlords would, in their own interests, have sought to maintain their property in reasonable repair. Thus the Labour Party’s policy of low rents in the interest of the manufacturers has had dire consequences on the state of millions of working class dwellings.

Nor did the Labour Government when in office make any serious attempt to deal with the housing problem. Their 250,000 houses a year was so inadequate for housing needs that even the Tories increased it to 300,000 per year. Nor do the Labour Party now propose to make any real contribution to the housing problem. They envisage no scheme of new housing construction to solve housing shortages, rather their propositions are designed to keep up those houses which, as the years go by, are in danger of falling down. And this from a party which has always claimed that it would solve the housing problem, and in 1945, through the mouth of Bevan, said that under a Labour Government there would be no housing problem.

Crossmaa as the Man from the “Pru”
It was left to Mr. Crossman to sell insurance to the delegates as a preliminary to selling it to the electorate. It was another palpable effort to attract sections of the voters who are still under Tory allegiance. The proposal was pensions at half-pay. The employee would be levied 3 per cent of his earnings, and the rest of the contribution would be made by the Government and employer. A man earning £30 a week would contribute more, and so would the State. The Labour Party thus propose to perpetuate permanently the inequalities of the wage system into old-age. Mr. Crossman’s lame excuse that trade unions operate on an acceptance of inequality in wages is an admission that he regards income inequalities as a norm of any social situation.

So countless workers who live on full pay penury now will after fifty years of work and fifty years’ contributions live on half-pay penury. The contributions of workers will, of course, be invested on the best insurance lines in order to secure for the government or governments operating the scheme the highest possible profits. And so the unpaid labour from the hides and carcasses of the workers in their working years will be meagrely redistributed back to them in their non-working years. No doubt if the classic author of all State insurance schemes —the Liberal, David Lloyd George—could have heard Crossman he might have raised his eyebrows in approval. And no doubt if Keir Hardie could have witnessed the progress of his party he would have back-somersaulted in disgust

It might be as well to mention here that one of the chief planks of the Labour Party in the past was non-contributory pension schemes. Pensions should come out of taxation thundered old time Labourites. Their case against the Tories was that contributory schemes were Tory swindles. They are now working the swindle themselves, and so the plank of pensions via taxation becomes sawdust promises.

The Labour Conference touched a new low on old age pensions. Crossman deplored the abject poverty of countless old age pensioners living on £2 per week. He proposed to raise them from abject poverty to mere poverty by raising the pension to £3 per week in the happy event of the Labour Party coming to power. According to someone at the conference, £3 per week was the decently human minimum on which old people could live. To talk of £3 per week as a decent human minimum is perhaps one of the most indecent things said at an indecent conference.

Bevan and the Bomb
It was fitting that the H-bomb provided the one big explosion at the conference. And even more fitting that Bevan should detonate the Executive's policy, which is to retain it under a Labour Government. Bevan was then jeered and booed as an idol with feet of clay by his old followers with heads of clay. Mr. Bevan has revealed to an admiring world that he has all the essential qualities of a great statesman; i.e., he can be all things to all men. Thus he supported the last war, and subsequently other military adventures, yet contrived to spread the illusion he was an anti-militarist. He helped to pilot the greatest of all armament programmes through the House of Commons, and yet many came to accept him as a man of peace. He supported the dropping of the atom bomb, and now the retention of the H-bomb. Nevertheless, at New Delhi he appeared to give the impression that he was against the H-bomb. He said just before the Christmas Island tests; “I wish to heaven Britain would rise to her moral stature by surrendering her hydrogen-bomb experiment. I can see no good purpose in Britain arming herself with that useless weapon.” (Daily Express, 4/10/57). As a statesman, however, he can always correct an interpretation by someone who only reads the lines of his speeches and not in between them.

And so the long line of rabble rousers who have passed into statesmen must now include Mr. Bevan. Like his compatriot Lloyd George, he has a silver tongue and a quicksilver mind. Unfettered by theory and unattached to any principle, he may serve as a pliable instrument for British Foreign Policy. And perhaps the “ i ” in Bevin will be replaced by an “ a ” as the greatest of Labour Foreign Secretaries.

No doubt after the Suez debacle and the tough time ahead in international affairs, a strong man and not a weak one like Eden must be found. Bevan, with his emotional oratory and power to persuade many people, seems to be the best strong man in sight This may account for his sudden and dramatic build up in the Press. Even his political opponents, whom he once called “vermin,” find him highly acceptable. Thus has the idol of the left become the darling of the right.

Bevan is, of course, the spokesman of the Labour policy to continue the Anglo-American axis— an axis which constitutes two hydrogen-bomb powers against one. It is true “Bevanites” and others can point to the sinister implications of such a policy. But would the banning of the H-bomb provide the basis of a peaceful solution in the real world of capitalism? If British capitalism decided to forgo the H-bomb as a bargaining factor in international politics, then American and Russian capitalism would go it alone, and with a lack of restraint that might well convert the cold war to boiling point. It would also mean that America would retreat to splendid but savage isolation and the cutting of her commitments with N.A.T.O. Moreover, the withdrawal of her economic support for Britain could have disastrous effects on the British economy. Emotionally minded leftists have yet to learn there are no alternatives under capitalism, at least no worthwhile ones.

Perhaps Kruschev in his little talk with Bevan suggested that Russia would prefer Britain with a H-bomb rather than without one.

Cousins, the T.G.W.U. chief, talked hysterically about the H-bomb. He said "he had a six-year-old daughter, and he would not compromise with anyone on the future of that girl.” But Mr. Cousins belongs to a party whose support of wars and armaments have not hesitated to compromise the future of countless six-year-old daughters and sons. Are atom bombs, rockets and 1000 bomber raids any less a compromise in substance with the lives and futures of any human being? Nevertheless, although from the Bevanites viewpoint his heart was in the right place, his million union votes went to the wrong place; i.e., in support of the executive.

The Labour Party at its conference sought to expunge its murky past, but only to foreshadow an even blacker future.
Ted Wilmott

No comments: