Programmes which show irreverence and hostility towards politicians and over-blown celebrities are usually both welcome and popular. It is therefore not surprising that the return of the newsroom-based satire Drop The Dead Donkey (Channel Four, Tuesdays 10 PM) has been widely welcomed. There are other reasons for this too. of course. It is — on occasion — bitingly funny and most of the journalists are portrayed as being witty cynics who refuse to take crap from anyone. No wonder, then, that the TV reviewers give it such a good press. It encapsulates many of the attitudes they too wish to be associated with — wackiness, over-the-top or 'larger-than-life' behaviour, together with independence of thought. Whether this is in any way an accurate depiction of journalists is rather more open to question. but any doubts on this front are usually forgiven or overlooked on the strength of the programme's satirical content.
Indeed it is undoubtedly true that any programme that can so systematically and humorously take apart the inconsistencies, prejudices and vanities of those who claim to rule in our name is not a bad thing. Last-minute scripting and filming also ensure a high degree of contemporary news-related material. But this is not a programme that is above criticism. There is an all-pervading air of cynicism throughout Drop The Dead Donkey which partly mirrors but also reinforces popular prejudices about politics and society in general. And the feed lines for the next sarcastic remark are usually all too apparent and cumbersome. The journalists at Globelink News don't have proper conversations — their sentences generally fall into only two categories: those of the witty remark or observation, and the feed line to the next one. The overall effect of this can be tiresome.
No Flipping
While their subject matter is not identical, Drop The Dead Donkey can be usefully compared and contrasted with the US TV chat show parody The Larry Sanders Show (BBC2, Mondays. Wednesdays and Fridays. 11.15 PM). Like Drop The Dead Donkey, Larry Sanders can be an exceptionally funny programme. However, its distinguishing characteristic is its convincing bid for realism. Where Drop The Dead Donkey seems contrived, The Larry Sanders Show is eminently lifelike. with subtle and beautifully crafted hints of parody and satire. So carefully scripted and magnificently acted is it. in fact, that many are those who have sat through considerable portions of an episode under the impression that it is a fly-on-the-wall documentary about a slightly unbalanced chat show host and his relationships with the overstressed minions who are paid to do his dirty work and pander to his every neurosis. That most episodes of the programme also include one or several real life chat-show guests makes it all the more believable, as are the shameless attempts by the fictional guests to plug their latest book, film or show. Such has been the cult success of Larry Sanders that US showbiz stars — from Roseanne Barr to Danny de Vito — have been queuing up to appear on it as themselves, even at the risk of occasionally looking slightly ridiculous amid the eccentric goings-on.
Without question, Garry Shandling — who plays the role of Sanders and produces the programme as well — has a superb talent. At the risk of using an oxymoron, there can be few actors in the history of television that have developed a character as convincingly insincere as Sanders is. The false Osmond- like grin and crinkly-eyed twinkle which appears every time he is introduced to some second-rate or obsequious guest brings to mind a long line of chat show and game show hosts stretching back decades.
One of the programme's overriding messages would appear to be that the higher up the media ladder someone ascends. and the more they are labelled a ‘star’, the more likely they are to become detached, insular, self-obsessed and insecure. The ways in which these traits manifest themselves — most particularly in Sanders and his crap sidekick Hank Kingsley — is the real focus of the programme. In comparison to Sanders himself, most of his long-suffering staff on the show appear straightforward enough — it is coping with the various ‘star’ egos on parade and with their personal and monetary requirements which causes them big problems, turning them into nurse-maids for neurotics.
The Larry Sanders Show is particularly unusual in that it is so effortlessly able to combine comedy with acute realism. The fact that it is an American show makes it all the more unusual still — the comedy programmes which can be guaranteed to be contrived and unrealistic are often the ones from the US. The fact that such a distorted and perverse culture as that which dominates America could have come up with a marvellous parody of one of its own most notable institutions — the chat show — is heartening indeed.
In the US Larry Sanders is shown on an American equivalent of Channel Four, and because of its realistic use of language and swear-words it may be a long while before it makes it to anything close to prime time here. If you have the energy left after a hard day's wage slavery, however, it is well worth staying up to watch, and — despite some of the merits of Drop The Dead Donkey — has no worthy competitor for the role of best lampoon of the media world from anywhere else.
Dave Perrin
.jpg)
1 comment:
Drop The Dead Donkey really hasn't aged well. In retrospect, it was really overrated.
. . . and, yet, I watched it every week.
Post a Comment