Socialism will mean suicide
Dear Editors,
Out of curiosity, I bought the current issue of Socialist Standard, and I want to make you aware of my observations.
There is no such thing as a "capitalist class" or a "working class". Everyone who has a job is by definition a worker. For example you would probably describe Lord Hanson or Ian Vallance as being "capitalist class" or élite—but they work incredibly hard and the companies that they manage provide thousands of jobs and pay huge amounts of corporation tax which is paid to the revenue and should theoretically be used to benefit our society. Expressions such as "lower class", “upper class", and "master class" are put about as propaganda by idiotic hotheads who want to instil the belief that society is more divided than it really is. I know plenty of people for example, who work as gamekeepers. cooks, grooms, and cleaners—and most of them are a good deal more fulfilled and happy than their wealthy employers. If I was to suggest to any of them that they were "lower class" to their face— they would smack me one— and they would be right to do so.
It is deeply insulting and presumptuous to pigeonhole people with a class tag.
If you handed the resources for producing and distributing wealth to your version of the "working class", they would misuse and abuse them—because it is human nature to be greedy and most of them are uneducated twits. But that is not to say that it is their fault. Easily the most important challenge that we face is to (attempt) to educate everyone properly. If I were Prime Minister tomorrow, this would be my first priority. I would have the vast majority of our present teachers fired—and only rehire new ones after they had passed the most vigorous and searching exams. But they would be paid highly, probably in line with the pay received by top city types. I cannot overstress this point . . . the root of most of our problems is a poor education.
All of us have a responsibility to look after people who are very young, old, ill or disadvantaged through disability or ill-health. But nobody else is owed a living. Everyone should be rewarded according to how much they are prepared to contribute to society. Nobody is prohibited from buying shares on the stock market, and everyone who has a job should push their seniors for shareholdings—however small they may be—in the companies in which they work. If they waste their pay packets in the pub at the weekend—then they are idiots for doing so. The point is that we have to stop people being irresponsible . . . I repeat, we have to educate them. It is that simple.
The world as envisaged in your magazine would be a dirty, dark, morbid, bland, dreary, depressing nightmare. There would be no enterprise, and worst of all—creativity and imagination would evaporate because incentive would disappear. Black markets would thrive amid unfettered drug abuse, and suicide would soar through chronic depression (I promise).
So forget real socialism— better to push for the return of Lady T? I hope you will print this to try and provoke the kind of discussion which in your ideal world, would probably be illegal
Simon Ropner
London EC4
Reply:
It is good to see that you are sufficiently curious to investigate ideas that you don’t agree with and have taken the time to write to us, although you appear not have fully understood what we stand for.
We define a member of the working class as someone who has to work to survive, and a capitalist as someone who doesn't have to. True, there are many members of the less than 5 percent minority capitalist class who choose to work and there are workers who survive on the dole without working. You are confusing higher-paid workers with members of the capitalist class, who own the means of production through stocks and shares and direct ownership and do not have to work to live. Some of these high-paid executives occupy a grey area in terms of which class they belong to. Some may well be knocking on the door of the capitalist class and may be given the key of the door. We argue that capitalism is based on a two-class system, not that every human being fits neatly into one class or the other. Our case is based on the fact that capitalism is unable to deal with major problems such as war, hunger, bad housing and pollution because it is the cause of these problems.
It will not be us—the Socialist Party—who will be handing the resources for producing and distributing wealth to the working class; the working class (as defined above, i.e. most people) will decide when they have had enough of capitalism and will themselves take democratic action to get rid of it by taking resources over and administering them democratically. so abolishing the division of society into classes.
You describe most of the working class as "uneducated twits" but who do you suppose plans and produces all the wealth of society today? And how could this be done by people who don’t know what they are doing? The fact is that people like us (and probably you) run society from top to bottom but at the moment we don’t do it in our own interest but for the benefit of ponces like Lord Hanson and Ian Vallance who may well work hard but not at producing anything useful, only at working out how to screw more profit out of us and how to swindle their fellow capitalists (you seem to forget that Lord Hanson in particular made his money as an asset-stripper).
Capitalism is an inefficient system which does not benefit people as a whole. The need for profit prevents full production being achieved. Capitalism is an unpredictable system; it is a snakes-and-ladders world where, whether you are worker or capitalist, you can’t be sure what the new day will bring; unemployment for the worker or bankruptcy for the capitalist. Despite centuries of accumulated wisdom, technical knowledge and medical breakthroughs we cannot make use of these developments unless there is a profit in it for someone. We know what the problems are and we know that there are sufficient resources to deal with them but capitalism says: no, not without a profit. With all this knowledge and natural and human resources, millions, indeed billions, not only suffer deprivation but are prevented from applying their physical and mental energies to produce what is necessary to allow them to lead a satisfying life.
You are saying that it is "human nature" to be greedy, although you seem to be implying this only applies to the working class, and that they would still be greedy even after your education programme. The question of educating people "properly" is not really an issue. In a socialist society people will get the best education that is possible, but if there are some who for any reason (such as a particular educational institution failing them) do not attain the educational development that they had hoped for they will not be disadvantaged by society, but will still be socially equal and would still be able to improve their education throughout their lives if they so wish. The education that workers will receive under capitalism is something different. It does not prepare people for producing wealth for mutual benefit but teaches them that capitalism is the best of all possible worlds and. to prepare them to compete with each other for jobs.
You say that everyone should be rewarded according to how much they are prepared to contribute to society. But who is going to do the rewarding? And what do the capitalist class contribute to society? They don't have to work so will they be rewarded? Today if they choose not to work they will still be rewarded by their ownership of the means of production.
Of course workers are prohibited from buying substantial numbers of shares—because they haven’t got the money. Some may well be able to buy a few thousand pounds-worth but that will only make a marginal difference to their lives. Nearly every able-bodied and many less-able people will have something to contribute to socialist society. Even children may want to join in the productive process. We can see nothing wrong with them assisting in non-dangerous jobs between schooling, which could be extended over many more years and be interspersed with working periods.
What would be the incentive in socialism? In fact, what is socialism? We don’t necessarily expect you to agree with it but for the purposes of debate it is important that you comprehend our definition. There won’t be any markets in socialism, black or otherwise. Money will be redundant and there won't be exchange in the sense that it is applied to commodities today. (Of course, people may occasionally want to swap personal goods with each other, though if you have some item that you no longer require then you could take it to a storehouse where it could be taken by someone who could later make use of it.)
There won’t be a government to tell people what to do or think and free discussion, far from being illegal as in your rather limited imagination, will be a key feature of how people administer their own affairs.
Socialism means, as we said above the common ownership of productive resources and their democratic control by all the people; this will allow them to be used to turn out what people need, so that inadequate housing, education, health-care, transport systems, pollution control and all the other problems caused by the profit system can become things of the past.
What will be the incentive? Well, to build a better world, to produce what is needed and. on the individual level, to do something really useful and creative.
Editors

No comments:
Post a Comment