Thursday, November 19, 2026

World View: Ravages of competition (1996)

From the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard

The Group of Lisbon is a group mainly of academics from North America. Europe and Japan who are concerned about where the world is heading. In their manifesto called Limits to Competition they describe how capitalism is becoming globalised in that it is not just the raw materials of industrial products that now come from other countries but also their manufactured parts, so that more and more finished goods are "made in the world” rather "made in Britain" or "made in France" or wherever.

This global capitalism that is emerging they see as the same unregulated competitive capitalism that used to exist in individual countries in the 19th century but which (according to them) national states eventually succeeded in taming.

But who, they ask, is to do this on the world level? There is no world government and national governments all see their role, not as to try to regulate and control global capitalism, but to adapt to it and make their countries as acceptable as possible for global business to operate in and from. Being competitive on world markets has become the overriding aim and the dominant ideology to which everything else must be subordinated.

This relentless pursuit of "competitiveness” is leading, say the Group of Lisbon, to growing inequality, misery and chaos, even in those areas best placed to win in the battle of competition (North America, Western Europe, East Asia). Here the welfare state is being dismantled because the taxes to pay for it are undermining the competitiveness of business corporations; education, science, culture and everything else are becoming more and more subordinated to the needs of global business for a flexible labour force, lower costs, and research into methods of lowering costs even further.

As to the losers (apart from a few big cities where the local élites live, Africa, Latin America, most of Asia, even Russia) and of course where there is competition there must be losers, they are being left to rot and to descend even further into famines, disease, massacres and mass movements of populations.

Not a pretty picture, but an accurate one. As well-meaning people the Group of Lisbon want to do something to stop this. What they propose is that governments, the UN and its agencies, international Non-Governmental Organisations (such as Oxfam and Amnesty) and even the multinational corporations should pool their knowledge and administrative skills to draw up and implement a programme that aims to properly meet the basic needs (food, housing, water, energy) of every human being on the planet within a generation, i.e. by the year 2020.

They are right about two things. That global capitalism is leading humanity to disaster, and that humanity does have the knowledge and resources to end world poverty, hunger and disease within a generation. Where they go wrong is in imagining that this could be done within the framework of capitalism. For they are not against capitalism; they only pronounce themselves against unregulated competitive capitalism and want to setup world institutions to try to regulate it.

What they overlook is that competition and the pursuit of "competitiveness’’ are built-in to the economic system that is capitalism. Capitalism is based on the means for producing wealth being run by business firms which compete against each other to make profits. Merely to stay in the race for profits, let alone to win and expand in size, businesses must keep their costs down — which is what being ‘‘competitive’’ means. This is an essential part of capitalism, not some aberration of ruthless business leaders or the short-sighted politicians who follow them. You can’t have capitalism without it.

To get rid of the curse of “competitiveness’’ you have to get rid of capitalism.
Adam Buick

No comments: