Thursday, November 19, 2026

Speakers cornered (1996)

The A Word in Your Ear column from the November 1996 issue of the Socialist Standard

'And don’t forget, this is your chance to have your say. The People’s Voice. Okay, we have a call now from Eric from Amersham.” 

“Hello . . . hello? Am I on?”

“Yes, Eric. Now what do you want to say?”

“Am I on The People's Voice!"

“Now get a move on Eric or I’ll have to cut you off.”

“Hello . . . yes, it was about aliens coming to earth.”

“Oh yes . .  . seen one have you, Eric?” 

“Yes . . . well, not exactly. It was my wife. She was on her way home last Friday . . . she was going to do a bit of late-night shopping in Tesco. . . she always does on a Friday, see?”


“And?”
“And these aliens abducted her.”

“They abducted her! Tell us about it, Eric.”

“Well . . .”

“Did they . . . er . . . was sex involved, Eric?”

“Oh no . . . they just talked to her in an alien language about the need for proportional representation. You see, they reckoned that . . . “

“Okay, thanks for that, Eric. Well, there we are, Eric’s wife was snatched by aliens who had their way with her. Give us a call if you can beat that. Whatever you want to say, the airwaves are yours . . . and it’s Melanie from Middlesbrough calling. What’s on your mind, Mel?”

“Europe.”

“What about it?”

“I’m opposed to it.”

“Why’s that, Mel?”

“There’s too many of them.”

“That’s a very interesting point, Melanie. You know, I sometimes think that we’d have been better off staying on our own with our old friends from Australia and New Zealand. We knew who we were dealing with then, eh Melanie? I mean, did we really fight two world wars to be pushed around by a gang of krauts? Telling us what shape our bananas have to be and interfering with our laws. You know, it’s a persuasive argument you put, Melanie.”

“I just think there’s too many.”

“Well, thanks for your call, Melanie. And that’s what it’s all about. The People’s Voice, Tell everyone else what you think. Who do we have next? Ah, John .. . “ 

“You mentioned earlier in the programme that the Labour Party has abandoned socialism.”

“That’s right, John. And about time too, some people are saying. I mean, do we really need all this old talk about bosses and workers? Haven’t we grown out of all that?”

“Well, I think that socialism is as relevant now as ever it was.”

“Oh, so you’d like us to live like the Russians did for years? You must be the last man on earth who believes in that, John.”

“But I don’t. Russia was never socialist. It was state . . . “

“Well, they called themselves socialist.” 

“And I could call myself superman, it wouldn’t mean I could fly.”

“A bit of a comedian, eh John? Okay then, so tell me why you want the labour Party to go back to its old socialist ways.”

“I don’t.”

“Now, make your mind up, John. You said . . . “

“I said socialism is relevant now. Because a socialist society would be one where we produce solely for use and not for profit. When did the Labour Party ever advocate that?”

“Well, they called themselves socialists, didn't they?”

“ What did I say about superman? The old GDR . . . East Germany . . . used to call itself the German Democratic Republic. But it certainly wasn’t democratic. The Labour Party might have called itself socialist . . . Tony Blair still says he’s a socialist . . . but it has never ever stood for the abolition of production for profit.” 

“You don’t like Blair, eh John?”

“I don’t give a damn about him. I want to talk about socialism.”

“So, John wants to see Labour move to the left.”

“No, I do not. I want to seek workers rejecting all the parties of capitalism, including Labour, and organising democratically for a new way of running society. A society without markets, money, wages . . . “

“You’ve got some pretty wild ideas there, John.”

“Well, the so-called sane ones have all been tried and we’ve still got the same social problems as always existed under capitalism. If we want to remove the problems we have to remove their cause.”

 “Mmmn . . . you’re obviously a bit of a thinker, John . . . “

“Anyone can understand . . . “

“Tell me, John, what do you think about those aliens snatching Eric’s wife and taking her with them so that they can have their way with her? Can we really believe that things like that happen? Come on, John, tell us your view. After all, this is The People's Voice. Your chance to say exactly what you think.”
Steve Coleman

1 comment:

Imposs1904 said...

I wonder if it was John from Harlesden?